Re: [VOTE] UIMA-DUCC 3.0.0 RC4 - updating overview doc, uima v3 use?

[Marshall Schor <ms...@schor.com>]

I see from the release notes that this version of DUCC supports uima v2 and v3.

I see from the build that it appears to include uima-as version 2.10.2,
which in turn, includes the jars for a version of uima v2.
I don't think jars for uima v3 are included?

Does the documentation need to be expanded for using uima v3, for instance,
saying that using uima-as with v3 is not (yet) supported, so you need to
do x-y-z ??? (run ducc without uima-as?).

Reading the Chapter 1 DUCC Overview, it seems this might need updating in the
following senses:

1) talking about the new "pull" model

2) talking about running without ActiveMQ (?)

3) talking about running without UIMA-AS (?)

4) talking about Cassandra - the fact that it's bundled, and what it's used for

5) talking about how to choose (for a new DUCC user) among the various
"styles" - e.g., advice on when to use various configurations
(with or without ActiveMQ, UIMA-AS, etc.).  

  I'm wondering if these have evolved over time, since this chapter was first
written

The (?) means I'm not sure these are correct.

-Marshall

Re: [VOTE] UIMA-DUCC 3.0.0 RC4 - updating overview doc, uima v3 use?

[Eddie Epstein <ea...@gmail.com>]

Marshall,
The overview will indicate support for UIMAv2 and UIMAv3 versions. Use of
Cassandra has been described since version 2.1. Non-UIMA-AS services have
been supported and described since the initial release. Although work has
been done to formalize the pull-service mechanism used by DUCC jobs, it is
not as fully supported as UIMA-AS services and is not yet documented. I
agree that it should be documented in the near future release.
Eddie

On Sat, Mar 16, 2019 at 10:19 AM Marshall Schor <ms...@schor.com> wrote:

> I see from the release notes that this version of DUCC supports uima v2
> and v3.
>
> I see from the build that it appears to include uima-as version 2.10.2,
> which in turn, includes the jars for a version of uima v2.
> I don't think jars for uima v3 are included?
>
> Does the documentation need to be expanded for using uima v3, for instance,
> saying that using uima-as with v3 is not (yet) supported, so you need to
> do x-y-z ??? (run ducc without uima-as?).
>
> Reading the Chapter 1 DUCC Overview, it seems this might need updating in
> the
> following senses:
>
> 1) talking about the new "pull" model
>
> 2) talking about running without ActiveMQ (?)
>
> 3) talking about running without UIMA-AS (?)
>
> 4) talking about Cassandra - the fact that it's bundled, and what it's
> used for
>
> 5) talking about how to choose (for a new DUCC user) among the various
> "styles" - e.g., advice on when to use various configurations
> (with or without ActiveMQ, UIMA-AS, etc.).
>
>   I'm wondering if these have evolved over time, since this chapter was
> first
> written
>
> The (?) means I'm not sure these are correct.
>
> -Marshall
>
>
>