You are viewing a plain text version of this content. The canonical link for it is here.
Posted to dev@knox.apache.org by Kevin Minder <ke...@hortonworks.com> on 2013/03/21 14:10:01 UTC
[DISCUSS] Bulk import of Jira issues
Hi Everyone,
We don't have our Jira setup yet but in preparation I would like to
discuss if we should bulk import the Jira issues from the Hortonworks
Jira. Below I have a list of the currently filed issues. Personally I
would like to import them in an effort to move everything into the public.
Kevin.
BUG-4336 Gateway starts even if incorrect master password entered
BUG-4335 Support finer grain control over what is included in the URL
rewrite
BUG-4334 Prepare Maven project structure for Apache submission
BUG-4333 Support horizontal scalability of gateway via clustering
BUG-4332 Provide option to have gateway behave transparently
BUG-4331 Prepare for Apache submission
BUG-4330 Support translation of cluster internal hostnames to
external hostnames
BUG-4329 Smart load balancing among gateway cluster intances
BUG-4328 Ensure that all cluster topology details are rewritten for
Oozie REST APIs
BUG-4327 Prevent Shiro rememberMe cookie from being returned
BUG-4326 Cluster topology must not be exposed in datanode redirect
query parameters
BUG-4325 Clean up i18n logging and any System.out or printStackTrace
usages
BUG-4324 Parse and convert Hadoop config files to Gateway cluster
topology
BUG-4323 Clean up usage and help output from server command line
BUG-4322 Support HUE interacting with a Hadoop cluster via the Gateway
BUG-4321 Add support for Oozie REST APIs
BUG-4320 Change gateway URLs to match service URLs as closely as possible
BUG-4319 Integrate execution of open source governance scanning into
release build
BUG-4318 Verify LDAP over SSL
BUG-4317 Convert from service lookup pattern to dependency injection
pattern where possible
BUG-4316 Authentication failure via Shiro/LDAP/BasicAuth doesn't
produce diagnostic output when misconfigured
BUG-4315 Investigate OpenID/OAuth as identity federation/SSO mechanism
BUG-4314 Cluster topology discovery and synchronization via Ambari
BUG-4313 Integrate hadoop-auth maven module as authentication provider
BUG-4312 Verify authentication via Active Directory using LDAP
BUG-4311 Provide support for hosting Jersey services for the purposes
of protocol mediation of non-REST services
BUG-4310 Allow plug-ins to be loaded by adding JARs to bin directory
(or similar)
BUG-4309 Create lifecycle scripts for gateway server
BUG-4308 Limit HTTP basic auth chalenges to HTTPS
BUG-4307 Provide option to have gateway automatically follow WebHDFS
redirects
BUG-4306 Access Kerberos secured Hadoop cluster via gateway using
basic auth credentials
BUG-4305 Support federation/SSO using external tokens (MS Azure)
BUG-4304 Access Kerberos secured Hadoop cluster via gateway using SPNEGO
BUG-4303 Support HTTPS gateway endpoints
BUG-4302 Generate audit log of all gateway activity
BUG-4301 Invoke HDFS via gateway using hadoop CLI and FileSystem API
BUG-4300 Utilize hadoop.auth cookie to prevent re-authentication for
every request
BUG-4299 Administrative REST API
BUG-4298 Misleading logging output when files in
{GATEWAY_HOME}/deployments changed
BUG-4297 IdentityAssertionHttpServletRequestWrapper should only be
used when required by the service
BUG-4296 Error message resulting from invalid deployment file are not
diagnostic
BUG-4295 Several very inefficient implementation of InputStream and
ServletInputStream need to be rewritten
BUG-4294 Improved test coverage for invalid request/response bodies
BUG-4293 Clean up APIs and SPIs to follow either Fluent or Bean style
consistently.
Re: [DISCUSS] Bulk import of Jira issues
Posted by Alan Gates <ga...@hortonworks.com>.
I have a couple of concerns about this:
1) I'm not sure how those outside of Hortonworks are supposed to evaluate this. If they can't see the contents of those bugs how can they vote? We could provide a raw dump for them to look at I supposed, but that seems painful.
2) Was the git history maintained during the import to Apache? If so, then I see some value in the JIRA import since the two can still be correlated. If not, then the value seems dubious since people won't be able to look back and see what source changes relate to what JIRAs.
Alan.
On Mar 21, 2013, at 6:10 AM, Kevin Minder wrote:
> Hi Everyone,
> We don't have our Jira setup yet but in preparation I would like to discuss if we should bulk import the Jira issues from the Hortonworks Jira. Below I have a list of the currently filed issues. Personally I would like to import them in an effort to move everything into the public.
> Kevin.
>
> BUG-4336 Gateway starts even if incorrect master password entered
> BUG-4335 Support finer grain control over what is included in the URL rewrite
> BUG-4334 Prepare Maven project structure for Apache submission
> BUG-4333 Support horizontal scalability of gateway via clustering
> BUG-4332 Provide option to have gateway behave transparently
> BUG-4331 Prepare for Apache submission
> BUG-4330 Support translation of cluster internal hostnames to external hostnames
> BUG-4329 Smart load balancing among gateway cluster intances
> BUG-4328 Ensure that all cluster topology details are rewritten for Oozie REST APIs
> BUG-4327 Prevent Shiro rememberMe cookie from being returned
> BUG-4326 Cluster topology must not be exposed in datanode redirect query parameters
> BUG-4325 Clean up i18n logging and any System.out or printStackTrace usages
> BUG-4324 Parse and convert Hadoop config files to Gateway cluster topology
> BUG-4323 Clean up usage and help output from server command line
> BUG-4322 Support HUE interacting with a Hadoop cluster via the Gateway
> BUG-4321 Add support for Oozie REST APIs
> BUG-4320 Change gateway URLs to match service URLs as closely as possible
> BUG-4319 Integrate execution of open source governance scanning into release build
> BUG-4318 Verify LDAP over SSL
> BUG-4317 Convert from service lookup pattern to dependency injection pattern where possible
> BUG-4316 Authentication failure via Shiro/LDAP/BasicAuth doesn't produce diagnostic output when misconfigured
> BUG-4315 Investigate OpenID/OAuth as identity federation/SSO mechanism
> BUG-4314 Cluster topology discovery and synchronization via Ambari
> BUG-4313 Integrate hadoop-auth maven module as authentication provider
> BUG-4312 Verify authentication via Active Directory using LDAP
> BUG-4311 Provide support for hosting Jersey services for the purposes of protocol mediation of non-REST services
> BUG-4310 Allow plug-ins to be loaded by adding JARs to bin directory (or similar)
> BUG-4309 Create lifecycle scripts for gateway server
> BUG-4308 Limit HTTP basic auth chalenges to HTTPS
> BUG-4307 Provide option to have gateway automatically follow WebHDFS redirects
> BUG-4306 Access Kerberos secured Hadoop cluster via gateway using basic auth credentials
> BUG-4305 Support federation/SSO using external tokens (MS Azure)
> BUG-4304 Access Kerberos secured Hadoop cluster via gateway using SPNEGO
> BUG-4303 Support HTTPS gateway endpoints
> BUG-4302 Generate audit log of all gateway activity
> BUG-4301 Invoke HDFS via gateway using hadoop CLI and FileSystem API
> BUG-4300 Utilize hadoop.auth cookie to prevent re-authentication for every request
> BUG-4299 Administrative REST API
> BUG-4298 Misleading logging output when files in {GATEWAY_HOME}/deployments changed
> BUG-4297 IdentityAssertionHttpServletRequestWrapper should only be used when required by the service
> BUG-4296 Error message resulting from invalid deployment file are not diagnostic
> BUG-4295 Several very inefficient implementation of InputStream and ServletInputStream need to be rewritten
> BUG-4294 Improved test coverage for invalid request/response bodies
> BUG-4293 Clean up APIs and SPIs to follow either Fluent or Bean style consistently.
Re: [DISCUSS] Bulk import of Jira issues
Posted by "Mattmann, Chris A (388J)" <ch...@jpl.nasa.gov>.
Hey Kevin,
Awesome, great thoughts.
We had to deal with this when we moved OODT from JPL to Apache, even after.
1+ years after I still had an internal JIRA with over 200+ unresolved
issues.
I moved them 1 by 1 (not kidding!) to Apache. It sucked. I closed many
along
the way that I knew we wouldn't deal with at the ASF, and that were dating
back to like 2007.
So, it's really up to you here. If all of the below make sense to work on
Apache Knox (incubating), I say, bring em' over! Helps to decommission
existing
work internally (e.g., at Hortonworks) that's separate from the Apache
stuff.
+1.
Cheers,
Chris
On 3/21/13 6:10 AM, "Kevin Minder" <ke...@hortonworks.com> wrote:
>Hi Everyone,
>We don't have our Jira setup yet but in preparation I would like to
>discuss if we should bulk import the Jira issues from the Hortonworks
>Jira. Below I have a list of the currently filed issues. Personally I
>would like to import them in an effort to move everything into the public.
>Kevin.
>
>BUG-4336 Gateway starts even if incorrect master password entered
>BUG-4335 Support finer grain control over what is included in the URL
>rewrite
>BUG-4334 Prepare Maven project structure for Apache submission
>BUG-4333 Support horizontal scalability of gateway via clustering
>BUG-4332 Provide option to have gateway behave transparently
>BUG-4331 Prepare for Apache submission
>BUG-4330 Support translation of cluster internal hostnames to
>external hostnames
>BUG-4329 Smart load balancing among gateway cluster intances
>BUG-4328 Ensure that all cluster topology details are rewritten for
>Oozie REST APIs
>BUG-4327 Prevent Shiro rememberMe cookie from being returned
>BUG-4326 Cluster topology must not be exposed in datanode redirect
>query parameters
>BUG-4325 Clean up i18n logging and any System.out or printStackTrace
>usages
>BUG-4324 Parse and convert Hadoop config files to Gateway cluster
>topology
>BUG-4323 Clean up usage and help output from server command line
>BUG-4322 Support HUE interacting with a Hadoop cluster via the Gateway
>BUG-4321 Add support for Oozie REST APIs
>BUG-4320 Change gateway URLs to match service URLs as closely as
>possible
>BUG-4319 Integrate execution of open source governance scanning into
>release build
>BUG-4318 Verify LDAP over SSL
>BUG-4317 Convert from service lookup pattern to dependency injection
>pattern where possible
>BUG-4316 Authentication failure via Shiro/LDAP/BasicAuth doesn't
>produce diagnostic output when misconfigured
>BUG-4315 Investigate OpenID/OAuth as identity federation/SSO mechanism
>BUG-4314 Cluster topology discovery and synchronization via Ambari
>BUG-4313 Integrate hadoop-auth maven module as authentication provider
>BUG-4312 Verify authentication via Active Directory using LDAP
>BUG-4311 Provide support for hosting Jersey services for the purposes
>of protocol mediation of non-REST services
>BUG-4310 Allow plug-ins to be loaded by adding JARs to bin directory
>(or similar)
>BUG-4309 Create lifecycle scripts for gateway server
>BUG-4308 Limit HTTP basic auth chalenges to HTTPS
>BUG-4307 Provide option to have gateway automatically follow WebHDFS
>redirects
>BUG-4306 Access Kerberos secured Hadoop cluster via gateway using
>basic auth credentials
>BUG-4305 Support federation/SSO using external tokens (MS Azure)
>BUG-4304 Access Kerberos secured Hadoop cluster via gateway using
>SPNEGO
>BUG-4303 Support HTTPS gateway endpoints
>BUG-4302 Generate audit log of all gateway activity
>BUG-4301 Invoke HDFS via gateway using hadoop CLI and FileSystem API
>BUG-4300 Utilize hadoop.auth cookie to prevent re-authentication for
>every request
>BUG-4299 Administrative REST API
>BUG-4298 Misleading logging output when files in
>{GATEWAY_HOME}/deployments changed
>BUG-4297 IdentityAssertionHttpServletRequestWrapper should only be
>used when required by the service
>BUG-4296 Error message resulting from invalid deployment file are not
>diagnostic
>BUG-4295 Several very inefficient implementation of InputStream and
>ServletInputStream need to be rewritten
>BUG-4294 Improved test coverage for invalid request/response bodies
>BUG-4293 Clean up APIs and SPIs to follow either Fluent or Bean style
>consistently.