You are viewing a plain text version of this content. The canonical link for it is here.
Posted to users@spamassassin.apache.org by Charles Gregory <cg...@hwcn.org> on 2004/03/09 17:08:06 UTC
Re: [spa] Re: Opinions About SPF
On Tue, 9 Mar 2004, Alex van den Bogaerdt wrote:
> On Tue, Mar 09, 2004 at 12:10:28PM +0100, Martin Carpenter wrote:
> > I don't personally have anything new to add to the debate, but I did like
> > this comment from Rob Slade in the latest Risks digest
> > (http://catless.ncl.ac.uk/Risks/23.26.html#subj4):
> > ...
> > In fact, most of these antispam technologies fail in the
> > face of the problem of spam nets set up by viruses.
> > infected machines could use the micropayment "wallet" on
> > the infected machine, thus creating ..... a real cost.
>
> Wow. You mean finally the owners^Wpeople paying the bill have
> an incentive to either install a firewall theirselves or pay
> someone to do this for them.
Wow, yeah, this could mean that we go back to the original concept of the
internet as merely a tool for big business, with the little 'poor' people
squeezed out by costs and/or the fear of costs they cannot control.
And just wait until people figure out that all they have to do is *bail
out* on an ISP that tries to bill them, so then the ISP's will be eating
the costs, because they won't be able to afford legal costs to go after
their clients, and there will go the little ISP's, and eventually any
semblance of competition in the service provider field, as only the large
providers, like the phone companies will invest in legal action against
clients who bail.
But I'm sure we can count on the phone company to keep our internet
service reliable and fairly priced....... Riiiiiiiight.
> No more nigerian scam coming from a2000.nl/chello.nl , unless
> the proud owner of that super-de-luxe cable connection is willing
> to pay for the spam it routes.
And isn't it just too bad if the user of that computer system got caught
by a fresh virus, in between his anti-virus program updates, never knew
that his anti-virus was circumvented/disabled by the clever virus and that
he was actually unprotected *and* spamming for a month......
And if that user is a poor commmunity organization with NO extra budget,
and loses its internet access because of it, well we don't care about the
masses do we?
Of course, I'm slightly less sympathetic to the people who can fork out
$45 a month for access but can't cough up the same amount *once* for
decent virus prevention. Maybe your idea would have some merit with cable
modems. But hey, wait, technically it is ALREADY IN PLACE. Most high speed
services actually have bandwidth limits. If the moron who doesn't protect
his cable modem exceeds that, he *will* pay.......
> I like this idea, a lot.
As a side note, please refer to a previous rant of mine on how computer
stores sell 'complete' computer packages without a decent anti-virus
built-in, and no education as to the 'risks' of running without one.
You want to push for fundamental change? Go for something realistic and
support FREE fully updated virus-checkers like CLAMAV and make sure it
works on Windows, then get computer stores the world over to include them
in their 'packages' as a compulsory item. Why not make a FREE anti-virus
fire-wall system for ISP's? How easy it would be to filter/firewall
viruses for the ignorant customers if the majority of anti-virus companies
weren't charging ridiculous 'per user' fees to ISP's?
Hurray for CLAMAV!
- Charles
Re: [spa] Re: Opinions About SPF
Posted by Alex van den Bogaerdt <al...@ergens.op.het.net>.
Warning: RANT.
On Tue, Mar 09, 2004 at 11:08:06AM -0500, Charles Gregory wrote:
> > No more nigerian scam coming from a2000.nl/chello.nl , unless
> > the proud owner of that super-de-luxe cable connection is willing
> > to pay for the spam it routes.
>
> And isn't it just too bad if the user of that computer system got caught
> by a fresh virus, in between his anti-virus program updates, never knew
> that his anti-virus was circumvented/disabled by the clever virus and that
> he was actually unprotected *and* spamming for a month......
You seem to use the same arguments as I do. At least we agree on that.
The user does not know or does not care. Send the bill. He will know
and he will care. Here we seem to disagree.
> And if that user is a poor commmunity organization with NO extra budget,
> and loses its internet access because of it, well we don't care about the
> masses do we?
People without the necessary skills are not allowed to drive.
People without the necessary skills are not allowed to fly.
People without the necessary skills are not allowed to operate heavy equipment.
Why should I care about people without the necessary skills to run
a computer? Hey, they can hire personnel. That doesn't need to be
full time. Poor community organizations can try and find volunteers.
People should think about this _before_ operating a computer. If they
are unable to either gain the necessary knowledge themselves or hire
it from someone else, that is enough reason to not use a computer.
The fact is: These kind of people (well, most of them) run their
computers without even trying to be secure. These kind of computers
are being contaminated by a virus. These kind of computers are spam
relays. These kind of spam relays send _me_ spam.
I don't care *at*all* if they are aware of the problem. If _they_ are
the problem, I do _not_ want to suffer from _their_ problem. Disconnect,
then send a bill, reconnect when the damage is payed for.
And perhaps it is a good thing if ISPs are stuck with the bill. They
only care about money. When we are able to shift costs to them instead
of paying bandwidth, server capacity and such ourselves, maybe they
start fixing the problem. Many ISPs don't know or don't care about
virus and spam. See my 2nd paragraph and replace "user" by "ISP".
If chello and similar would be proactive and responsive, this mailing
list would probably not even exist in the first place. Sigh, even the
people at MS understand there is a problem.
Alex
--
begin sig
http://www.googlism.com/index.htm?ism=alex+van+den+bogaerdt&type=1
This message was produced without any <iframe tags