You are viewing a plain text version of this content. The canonical link for it is here.
Posted to fop-commits@xmlgraphics.apache.org by je...@apache.org on 2009/02/06 17:27:14 UTC
svn commit: r741616 - in
/xmlgraphics/fop/branches/Temp_AreaTreeNewDesign/src/documentation:
content/xdocs/trunk/intermediate.xml
resources/images/if-architecture-overview.png
Author: jeremias
Date: Fri Feb 6 16:27:13 2009
New Revision: 741616
URL: http://svn.apache.org/viewvc?rev=741616&view=rev
Log:
Updated intermediate format documentation.
Added:
xmlgraphics/fop/branches/Temp_AreaTreeNewDesign/src/documentation/resources/images/if-architecture-overview.png (with props)
Modified:
xmlgraphics/fop/branches/Temp_AreaTreeNewDesign/src/documentation/content/xdocs/trunk/intermediate.xml
Modified: xmlgraphics/fop/branches/Temp_AreaTreeNewDesign/src/documentation/content/xdocs/trunk/intermediate.xml
URL: http://svn.apache.org/viewvc/xmlgraphics/fop/branches/Temp_AreaTreeNewDesign/src/documentation/content/xdocs/trunk/intermediate.xml?rev=741616&r1=741615&r2=741616&view=diff
==============================================================================
--- xmlgraphics/fop/branches/Temp_AreaTreeNewDesign/src/documentation/content/xdocs/trunk/intermediate.xml (original)
+++ xmlgraphics/fop/branches/Temp_AreaTreeNewDesign/src/documentation/content/xdocs/trunk/intermediate.xml Fri Feb 6 16:27:13 2009
@@ -24,16 +24,24 @@
</header>
<body>
<note>
- Please note that the intermediate format is an <strong>advanced feature</strong> and can be ignored by most
- users of Apache FOP.
+ Please note that the intermediate formats described here are
+ <strong>advanced features</strong> and can be ignored by most users of Apache FOP.
</note>
<section id="introduction">
<title>Introduction</title>
<p>
- The intermediate format (IF) is a proprietary XML format that represents the area tree
- generated by the layout engine. The area tree is conceptually defined in the
+ Apache FOP now provides two different so-called intermediate formats. The first one
+ (let's call it the area tree XML format) is basically a 1:1 XML representation of the FOP's
+ area tree generated by the layout engine. The area tree is conceptually defined in the
<a href="http://www.w3.org/TR/2001/REC-xsl-20011015/slice1.html#section-N742-Formatting">XSL-FO specification in chapter 1.1.2</a>.
- The IF can be generated through the area tree XML Renderer (the XMLRenderer).
+ Even though the area tree is mentioned in the XSL-FO specification, this part is not
+ standardized. Therefore, the area tree XML format is a FOP-proprietary XML file format.
+ The area tree XML can be generated through the area tree XML Renderer (the XMLRenderer).
+ </p>
+ <p>
+ The second intermediate format (which we shall it exactly that: the intermediate format)
+ is a recent addition which tries to meet a slightly different set of goals. It is highly
+ optimized for speed.
</p>
<p>
The intermediate format can be used to generate intermediate documents that are modified
@@ -43,31 +51,78 @@
to a single output file.
</p>
</section>
+ <section id="which-if">
+ <title>Which Intermediate Format to choose?</title>
+ <p>
+ There are two formats to choose from, so the question which format to choose is obvious.
+ Here's a list of strengths and use cases for both formats:
+ </p>
+ <section id="strengths-at">
+ <title>Area Tree XML (AT XML)</title>
+ <ul>
+ <li>1:1 representation of FOP's area tree in XML.</li>
+ <li>Contains more structure information than the new intermediate format.</li>
+ <li>Used in FOP's layout engine test suite for regression testing.</li>
+ </ul>
+ </section>
+ <section id="strengths-if">
+ <title>Intermediate Format (IF)</title>
+ <ul>
+ <li>Highly optimized for speed.</li>
+ <li>Smaller XML files.</li>
+ <li>Easier to post-process.</li>
+ <li>XML Schema is available.</li>
+ <li>
+ Recommended for use cases where documents are formatted concurrently and later
+ concatenated to a single print job.
+ </li>
+ </ul>
+ </section>
+ <p>
+ Both formats have their use cases. You will need to choose for yourself which format is
+ suitable for your use case.
+ </p>
+ <p>
+ More technical information about the two formats can be found on the
+ <a href="http://wiki.apache.org/xmlgraphics-fop/AreaTreeIntermediateXml/NewDesign">FOP Wiki</a>.
+ </p>
+ </section>
+ <section id="architecture">
+ <title>Architectural Overview</title>
+ <figure src="images/if-architecture-overview.png"
+ alt="Diagram with an architectural overview over the intermediate formats"/>
+ </section>
<section id="usage">
- <title>Usage of the Intermediate Format</title>
+ <title>Usage of the Area Tree XML format (AT XML)</title>
+ <p>
+ As already mentioned, the area tree XML format is generated by using the
+ <strong>XMLRenderer</strong> (MIME type: <strong>application/X-fop-areatree</strong>).
+ So, you basically set the right MIME type for the output format and process your FO files
+ as if you would create a PDF file.
+ </p>
+ <p>
+ However, there is an important detail to consider: The
+ various Renderers don't all use the same font sources. To be able to create the right
+ area tree for the ultimate output file, you need to create the area tree XML file using
+ the right font setup. This is achieved by telling the XMLRenderer to mimic another
+ renderer. This is done by calling the XMLRenderer's mimicRenderer() method with an
+ instance of the ultimate target renderer as the single parameter. This has a consequence:
+ An area tree XML file rendered with the Java2DRenderer may not look as expected when it
+ was actually generated for the PDF renderer. For renderers that use the same font setup,
+ this restriction does not apply (PDF and PS, for example). Generating the area tree XML
+ format file is the first step.
+ </p>
<p>
- As already mentioned, the IF is generated by using the <strong>XMLRenderer</strong> (MIME type:
- <strong>application/X-fop-areatree</strong>). So, you basically set the right MIME type for
- the output format and process your FO files as if you would create a PDF file. However, there
- is an important detail to consider: The various Renderers don't all use the same font sources.
- To be able to create the right area tree for the ultimate output file, you need to create
- the IF file using the right font setup. This is achieved by telling the XMLRenderer to mimic
- another renderer. This is done by calling the XMLRenderer's mimicRenderer() method with an
- instance of the ultimate target renderer as the single parameter. This has a consequence: An
- IF file rendered with the Java2DRenderer may not look as expected when it was actually generated
- for the PDF renderer. For renderers that use the same font setup, this restriction does not
- apply (PDF and PS, for example). Generating the intermediate format file is the first step.
- </p>
- <p>
- The second step is to reparse the IF file using the <strong>AreaTreeParser</strong> which is
- found in the org.apache.fop.area package. The pages retrieved from the IF file are added to an
- AreaTreeModel instance from where they are normally rendered using one of the available Renderer
- implementations. You can find examples for the IF processing in the
- <a href="http://svn.apache.org/viewcvs.cgi/xmlgraphics/fop/trunk/examples/embedding/java/embedding/intermediate/"><code>examples/embedding</code></a>
- directory in the FOP distribution
+ The second step is to reparse the file using the <strong>AreaTreeParser</strong> which is
+ found in the org.apache.fop.area package. The pages retrieved from the area tree XML file
+ are added to an AreaTreeModel instance from where they are normally rendered using one of
+ the available Renderer implementations. You can find examples for the area tree XML
+ processing in the
+ <a href="http://svn.apache.org/viewvc/xmlgraphics/fop/trunk/examples/embedding/java/embedding/intermediate/"><code>examples/embedding</code></a>
+ directory in the FOP distribution.
</p>
<p>
- The basic pattern to parse the IF format looks like this:
+ The basic pattern to parse the area tree XML format looks like this:
</p>
<source><![CDATA[
FopFactory fopFactory = FopFactory.newInstance();
@@ -84,7 +139,7 @@
AreaTreeModel treeModel = new RenderPagesModel(userAgent,
MimeConstants.MIME_PDF, fontInfo, out);
- //Parse the IF file into the area tree
+ //Parse the area tree file into the area tree
AreaTreeParser parser = new AreaTreeParser();
Source src = new StreamSource(myIFFile);
parser.parse(src, treeModel, userAgent);
@@ -95,7 +150,7 @@
out.close();
}]]></source>
<p>
- This example simply reads an IF file and renders it to a PDF file. Please note, that in normal
+ This example simply reads an area tree file and renders it to a PDF file. Please note, that in normal
FOP operation you're shielded from having to instantiate the FontInfo object yourself. This
is normally a task of the AreaTreeHandler which is not present in this scenario. The same
applies to the AreaTreeModel instance, in this case an instance of a subclass called
@@ -105,7 +160,7 @@
is now finished.
</p>
<p>
- The intermediate format can also be used from the <a href="running.html#standalone-start">command-line</a>
+ The area tree XML format can also be used from the <a href="running.html#standalone-start">command-line</a>
by using the "-atin" parameter for specifying the area tree XML as input file. You can also
specify a "mimic renderer" by inserting a MIME type between "-at" and the output file.
</p>
@@ -113,8 +168,8 @@
<title>Concatenating Documents</title>
<p>
This initial example is obviously not very useful. It would be faster to create the PDF file
- directly. As the <a href="http://svn.apache.org/repos/asf/xmlgraphics/fop/trunk/examples/embedding/java/embedding/intermediate/ExampleConcat.java">ExampleConcat.java</a>
- example shows you can easily parse multiple IF files in a row and add the parsed pages to the
+ directly. As the <a href="http://svn.apache.org/repos/asf/xmlgraphics/fop/trunk/examples/embedding/java/embedding/atxml/ExampleConcat.java">ExampleConcat.java</a>
+ example shows you can easily parse multiple area tree files in a row and add the parsed pages to the
same AreaTreeModel instance which essentially concatenates all the input document to one single
output document.
</p>
@@ -122,18 +177,22 @@
<section id="modifying">
<title>Modifying Documents</title>
<p>
- One of the most important use cases for the intermediate format is obviously modifying the area
+ One of the most important use cases for this format is obviously modifying the area
tree XML before finally rendering it to the target format. You can easily use XSLT to process
- the IF file according to your needs. Please note, that we will currently not formally describe
- the intermediate format. You need to have a good understanding its structure so you don't
+ the AT XML file according to your needs. Please note, that we will currently not formally describe
+ the area tree XML format. You need to have a good understanding its structure so you don't
create any non-parseable files. We may add an XML Schema and more detailed documentation at a
later time. You're invited to help us with that.
</p>
+ <note>
+ The area tree XML format is sensitive to changes in whitespace. If you're not careful,
+ the modified file may not render correctly.
+ </note>
</section>
<section id="advanced">
<title>Advanced Use</title>
<p>
- The generation of the intermediate format as well as it parsing process has been designed to allow
+ The generation of the area tree format as well as it parsing process has been designed to allow
for maximum flexibility and optimization. Please note that you can call <code>setTransformerHandler()</code> on
XMLRenderer to give the XMLRenderer your own TransformerHandler instance in case you would like to
do custom serialization (to a W3C DOM, for example) and/or to directly modify the area tree using
@@ -142,5 +201,134 @@
</p>
</section>
</section>
+ <section id="usage-if">
+ <title>Usage of the Intermediate Format (IF)</title>
+ <p>
+ The Intermediate Format (IF) is generated by the <strong>IFSerializer</strong>
+ (MIME type: <strong>application/X-fop-intermediate-format</strong>).
+ So, you basically set the right MIME type for the output format and process your FO files
+ as if you would create a PDF file.
+ </p>
+ <p>
+ The IFSerializer is an implementation of the <strong>IFDocumentHandler</strong> and
+ <strong>IFPainter</strong> interfaces. The <strong>IFRenderer</strong> class is responsible
+ for converting FOP's area tree into calls against these two interfaces.
+ </p>
+ <ul>
+ <li>
+ IFDocumentHandler: This interface is used on the document-level and defines the
+ overall structure of the Intermediate Format.
+ </li>
+ <li>
+ IFPainter: This interface is used to generate graphical page content like text, images
+ and borders.
+ </li>
+ </ul>
+ <p>
+ As with the AT XML, there is an important detail to consider: The various output
+ implementations don't all use the same font sources. To be able
+ to create the right IF for the ultimate output file, you need to create the IF file using
+ the right font setup. This is achieved by telling the IFRenderer (responsible for
+ converting the area tree into calls to the IFDocumentHandler and IFPainter interfaces)
+ to mimic another renderer. This is done by calling the IFSerializer's
+ mimicDocumentHandler() method with an instance of the ultimate target document handler
+ as the single parameter. This has a consequence: An IF file rendered with the
+ Java2DDocumentHandler may not look as expected when it was actually generated for the PDF
+ implementation. For implementations that use the same font setup,
+ this restriction does not apply (PDF and PS, for example). Generating the Intermediate
+ Format file is the first step.
+ </p>
+ <p>
+ The second step is to reparse the file using the <strong>IFParser</strong> which is
+ found in the org.apache.fop.render.intermediate package. The IFParser simply takes an
+ IFDocumentHandler instance against which it generates the appropriate calls. The IFParser
+ is implemented as a SAX ContentHandler so you're free to choose the method for
+ post-processing the IF file(s). You can use XSLT or write SAX- or DOM-based code to
+ manipulate the contents. You can find examples for the Intermediate Format
+ processing in the
+ <a href="http://svn.apache.org/viewvc/xmlgraphics/fop/trunk/examples/embedding/java/embedding/intermediate/"><code>examples/embedding</code></a>
+ directory in the FOP distribution.
+ </p>
+ <p>
+ The basic pattern to parse the intermediate format looks like this:
+ </p>
+ <source><![CDATA[
+FopFactory fopFactory = FopFactory.newInstance();
+
+// Setup output
+OutputStream out = new java.io.FileOutputStream(pdffile);
+out = new java.io.BufferedOutputStream(out);
+try {
+ //Setup user agent
+ FOUserAgent userAgent = fopFactory.newFOUserAgent();
+
+ //Create IFDocumentHandler instance
+ IFDocumentHandler targetHandler;
+ String mime = MimeConstants.MIME_PDF;
+ targetHandler = fopFactory.getRendererFactory().createDocumentHandler(
+ userAgent, mime);
+
+ //Setup fonts
+ IFUtil.setupFonts(targetHandler);
+
+ //Tell the target handler where to write the PDF to
+ targetHandler.setResult(new StreamResult(pdffile));
+
+ //Parse the IF file
+ IFParser parser = new IFParser();
+ Source src = new StreamSource(myIFFile);
+ parser.parse(src, targetHandler, userAgent);
+
+} finally {
+ out.close();
+}]]></source>
+ <p>
+ This example simply reads an intermediate file and renders it to a PDF file. Here
+ IFParser.parse() is used, but you can also just get a SAX ContentHandler by using the
+ IFParser.getContentHandler() method.
+ </p>
+ <section id="concat-if">
+ <title>Concatenating Documents</title>
+ <p>
+ This initial example is obviously not very useful. It would be faster to create the PDF file
+ directly (without the intermediate step). As the
+ <a href="http://svn.apache.org/repos/asf/xmlgraphics/fop/trunk/examples/embedding/java/embedding/intermediate/ExampleConcat.java">ExampleConcat.java</a>
+ example shows you can easily parse multiple intermediate files in a row and use the
+ IFConcatenator class to concatenate page sequences from multiple source files to a single
+ output file. This particular example does the concatenation on the level of the
+ IFDocumentHandler interface. You could also do this in XSLT or using SAX on the XML level.
+ Whatever suits your process best.
+ </p>
+ </section>
+ <section id="modifying-if">
+ <title>Modifying Documents</title>
+ <p>
+ One of the most important use cases for this format is obviously modifying the
+ intermediate format before finally rendering it to the target format. You can easily use
+ XSLT to process the IF file according to your needs.
+ </p>
+ <p>
+ There is an XML Schema (located under
+ <a href="http://svn.apache.org/viewvc/xmlgraphics/fop/trunk/src/documentation/intermediate-format-ng/">src/documentation/intermediate-format-ng</a>)
+ that helps you verify that your modified content is correct.
+ </p>
+ <p>
+ For certain output formats there's a caveat: Formats like AFP and PCL do not support
+ arbitrary transformations on the IF's "viewport" and "g" elements. Possible are
+ only rotations in 90 degree steps and translations.
+ </p>
+ </section>
+ <section id="advanced-if">
+ <title>Advanced Use</title>
+ <p>
+ The generation of the intermediate format as well as it parsing process has been
+ designed to allow for maximum flexibility and optimization. So rather than just passing
+ in a StreamResult to IFSerializer's setResult() method, you can also use a SAXResult
+ or a DOMResult. And as you've already seen , the IFParser on the other side allows you
+ to retrieve a ContentHandler instance where you can manually send SAX events to to
+ start the parsing process (see <code>getContentHandler()</code>).
+ </p>
+ </section>
+ </section>
</body>
</document>
Added: xmlgraphics/fop/branches/Temp_AreaTreeNewDesign/src/documentation/resources/images/if-architecture-overview.png
URL: http://svn.apache.org/viewvc/xmlgraphics/fop/branches/Temp_AreaTreeNewDesign/src/documentation/resources/images/if-architecture-overview.png?rev=741616&view=auto
==============================================================================
Binary file - no diff available.
Propchange: xmlgraphics/fop/branches/Temp_AreaTreeNewDesign/src/documentation/resources/images/if-architecture-overview.png
------------------------------------------------------------------------------
svn:mime-type = image/png
---------------------------------------------------------------------
To unsubscribe, e-mail: fop-commits-unsubscribe@xmlgraphics.apache.org
For additional commands, e-mail: fop-commits-help@xmlgraphics.apache.org
Re: svn commit: r741616 - in /xmlgraphics/fop/branches/Temp_AreaTreeNewDesign/src/documentation:
content/xdocs/trunk/intermediate.xml resources/images/if-architecture-overview.png
Posted by Vincent Hennebert <vh...@gmail.com>.
Jeremias Maerki wrote:
> On 11.02.2009 13:07:12 Vincent Hennebert wrote:
>> Jeremias Maerki wrote:
>>> On 10.02.2009 13:22:01 Vincent Hennebert wrote:
>>>> Hi Jeremias,
>>>>
>>>> A few suggestions:
>>>>
>> <snip/>
>>>>> <section id="introduction">
>>>>> <title>Introduction</title>
>>>>> <p>
>>>>> - The intermediate format (IF) is a proprietary XML format that represents the area tree
>>>>> - generated by the layout engine. The area tree is conceptually defined in the
>>>>> + Apache FOP now provides two different so-called intermediate formats. The first one
>>>>> + (let's call it the area tree XML format) is basically a 1:1 XML representation of the FOP's
>>>>> + area tree generated by the layout engine. The area tree is conceptually defined in the
>>>>> <a href="http://www.w3.org/TR/2001/REC-xsl-20011015/slice1.html#section-N742-Formatting">XSL-FO specification in chapter 1.1.2</a>.
>>>>> - The IF can be generated through the area tree XML Renderer (the XMLRenderer).
>>>> Renaming this class into AreaTreeRenderer or AreaTreeXMLRenderer will
>>>> probably allow to avoid confusion in the future.
>>> -1 to that. Will break backwards-compatibility for those who are using
>>> this renderer directly. It would break at least two pieces of software I
>>> have.
>> Breaking backwards-compatibility because of an important change in an
>> API is a thing, simply have a class renamed is a non-issue if you ask
>> me. It’s just a small search/replace and recompilation.
>
> Ok, then "simply" rename FopFactory to FormattingObjectsProcessorFactory
> and see what the FOP users will tell you.
That has of course nothing to do. We are talking about a change that
would bring some clarification. Admittedly small, but every little
helps.
>> To make things a little bit smoother though, XMLRenderer could be made
>> deprecated with a suggestion to switch to AreaTree[XML]Renderer.
>
> And how would that make the situation any better?
That would give users the time to plan the adaptation of their code.
>>> If you you generate SAX events
>>> (AbstractXMLRenderer.setContentHandler()), working with MIME types isn't
>>> enough.
>> I’m missing the point here?
>
> If you're selecting the XMLRenderer via its MIME type, renaming
> XMLRenderer to anything else is a non-issue because it would be handled
> inside FOP. But if you need to send the AT XML as SAX events somewhere
> you have to instantiate XMLRenderer yourself.
Hmmm. But can’t that be done through the renderer options?
>>> Besides, I don't think that would really improve the whole thing
>>> much. After all, with the new IF, we're not primarily talking about
>>> renderers but something else (IFDocumentHandler/IFPainter).
>> It’s never too obvious. After all, the two sections in the documentation
>> are very similar.
>
> Yes, and there is just no way to make them any more dissimilar. Both are
> XML-based intermediate formats. Both have their use cases. Better to
> keep them close together so people know that there are two and how to
> deal with them.
Which is an additional reason why XMLRenderer could do with a name
change IMO. However, I’ve just seen Chris’ answer, and the majority
decides.
Vincent
Re: svn commit: r741616 - in /xmlgraphics/fop/branches/Temp_AreaTreeNewDesign/src/documentation: content/xdocs/trunk/intermediate.xml resources/images/if-architecture-overview.png
Posted by Jeremias Maerki <de...@jeremias-maerki.ch>.
On 11.02.2009 13:07:12 Vincent Hennebert wrote:
> Jeremias Maerki wrote:
> > On 10.02.2009 13:22:01 Vincent Hennebert wrote:
> >> Hi Jeremias,
> >>
> >> A few suggestions:
> >>
> <snip/>
> >>> <section id="introduction">
> >>> <title>Introduction</title>
> >>> <p>
> >>> - The intermediate format (IF) is a proprietary XML format that represents the area tree
> >>> - generated by the layout engine. The area tree is conceptually defined in the
> >>> + Apache FOP now provides two different so-called intermediate formats. The first one
> >>> + (let's call it the area tree XML format) is basically a 1:1 XML representation of the FOP's
> >>> + area tree generated by the layout engine. The area tree is conceptually defined in the
> >>> <a href="http://www.w3.org/TR/2001/REC-xsl-20011015/slice1.html#section-N742-Formatting">XSL-FO specification in chapter 1.1.2</a>.
> >>> - The IF can be generated through the area tree XML Renderer (the XMLRenderer).
> >> Renaming this class into AreaTreeRenderer or AreaTreeXMLRenderer will
> >> probably allow to avoid confusion in the future.
> >
> > -1 to that. Will break backwards-compatibility for those who are using
> > this renderer directly. It would break at least two pieces of software I
> > have.
>
> Breaking backwards-compatibility because of an important change in an
> API is a thing, simply have a class renamed is a non-issue if you ask
> me. It’s just a small search/replace and recompilation.
Ok, then "simply" rename FopFactory to FormattingObjectsProcessorFactory
and see what the FOP users will tell you.
> To make things a little bit smoother though, XMLRenderer could be made
> deprecated with a suggestion to switch to AreaTree[XML]Renderer.
And how would that make the situation any better?
>
> > If you you generate SAX events
> > (AbstractXMLRenderer.setContentHandler()), working with MIME types isn't
> > enough.
>
> I’m missing the point here?
If you're selecting the XMLRenderer via its MIME type, renaming
XMLRenderer to anything else is a non-issue because it would be handled
inside FOP. But if you need to send the AT XML as SAX events somewhere
you have to instantiate XMLRenderer yourself.
>
> > Besides, I don't think that would really improve the whole thing
> > much. After all, with the new IF, we're not primarily talking about
> > renderers but something else (IFDocumentHandler/IFPainter).
>
> It’s never too obvious. After all, the two sections in the documentation
> are very similar.
Yes, and there is just no way to make them any more dissimilar. Both are
XML-based intermediate formats. Both have their use cases. Better to
keep them close together so people know that there are two and how to
deal with them.
Jeremias Maerki
Re: svn commit: r741616 - in /xmlgraphics/fop/branches/Temp_AreaTreeNewDesign/src/documentation:
content/xdocs/trunk/intermediate.xml resources/images/if-architecture-overview.png
Posted by Chris Bowditch <bo...@hotmail.com>.
Vincent Hennebert wrote:
Hi Vincent,
> Jeremias Maerki wrote:
>
>>On 10.02.2009 13:22:01 Vincent Hennebert wrote:
>>
>>>Hi Jeremias,
>>>
>>>A few suggestions:
>>>
>
> <snip/>
>
>>>> <section id="introduction">
>>>> <title>Introduction</title>
>>>> <p>
>>>>- The intermediate format (IF) is a proprietary XML format that represents the area tree
>>>>- generated by the layout engine. The area tree is conceptually defined in the
>>>>+ Apache FOP now provides two different so-called intermediate formats. The first one
>>>>+ (let's call it the area tree XML format) is basically a 1:1 XML representation of the FOP's
>>>>+ area tree generated by the layout engine. The area tree is conceptually defined in the
>>>> <a href="http://www.w3.org/TR/2001/REC-xsl-20011015/slice1.html#section-N742-Formatting">XSL-FO specification in chapter 1.1.2</a>.
>>>>- The IF can be generated through the area tree XML Renderer (the XMLRenderer).
>>>
>>>Renaming this class into AreaTreeRenderer or AreaTreeXMLRenderer will
>>>probably allow to avoid confusion in the future.
>>
>>-1 to that. Will break backwards-compatibility for those who are using
>>this renderer directly. It would break at least two pieces of software I
>>have.
>
>
> Breaking backwards-compatibility because of an important change in an
> API is a thing, simply have a class renamed is a non-issue if you ask
> me. It’s just a small search/replace and recompilation.
> To make things a little bit smoother though, XMLRenderer could be made
> deprecated with a suggestion to switch to AreaTree[XML]Renderer.
I'm sorry I agree with Jeremias here. The AreaTreeRenderer is part of
the user facing API if you work with the Intermediate Format as many
folks do. The reasons you state (about the meaning of the class not
being clear enough) aren't good enough IMO to warrant breaking backwards
compatibility.
-1 to this change.
<snip/>
Chris
Re: svn commit: r741616 - in /xmlgraphics/fop/branches/Temp_AreaTreeNewDesign/src/documentation:
content/xdocs/trunk/intermediate.xml resources/images/if-architecture-overview.png
Posted by Vincent Hennebert <vh...@gmail.com>.
Jeremias Maerki wrote:
> On 10.02.2009 13:22:01 Vincent Hennebert wrote:
>> Hi Jeremias,
>>
>> A few suggestions:
>>
<snip/>
>>> <section id="introduction">
>>> <title>Introduction</title>
>>> <p>
>>> - The intermediate format (IF) is a proprietary XML format that represents the area tree
>>> - generated by the layout engine. The area tree is conceptually defined in the
>>> + Apache FOP now provides two different so-called intermediate formats. The first one
>>> + (let's call it the area tree XML format) is basically a 1:1 XML representation of the FOP's
>>> + area tree generated by the layout engine. The area tree is conceptually defined in the
>>> <a href="http://www.w3.org/TR/2001/REC-xsl-20011015/slice1.html#section-N742-Formatting">XSL-FO specification in chapter 1.1.2</a>.
>>> - The IF can be generated through the area tree XML Renderer (the XMLRenderer).
>> Renaming this class into AreaTreeRenderer or AreaTreeXMLRenderer will
>> probably allow to avoid confusion in the future.
>
> -1 to that. Will break backwards-compatibility for those who are using
> this renderer directly. It would break at least two pieces of software I
> have.
Breaking backwards-compatibility because of an important change in an
API is a thing, simply have a class renamed is a non-issue if you ask
me. It’s just a small search/replace and recompilation.
To make things a little bit smoother though, XMLRenderer could be made
deprecated with a suggestion to switch to AreaTree[XML]Renderer.
> If you you generate SAX events
> (AbstractXMLRenderer.setContentHandler()), working with MIME types isn't
> enough.
I’m missing the point here?
> Besides, I don't think that would really improve the whole thing
> much. After all, with the new IF, we're not primarily talking about
> renderers but something else (IFDocumentHandler/IFPainter).
It’s never too obvious. After all, the two sections in the documentation
are very similar.
Vincent
Re: svn commit: r741616 - in /xmlgraphics/fop/branches/Temp_AreaTreeNewDesign/src/documentation: content/xdocs/trunk/intermediate.xml resources/images/if-architecture-overview.png
Posted by Jeremias Maerki <de...@jeremias-maerki.ch>.
On 10.02.2009 13:22:01 Vincent Hennebert wrote:
> Hi Jeremias,
>
> A few suggestions:
>
> > Author: jeremias
> > Date: Fri Feb 6 16:27:13 2009
> > New Revision: 741616
> >
> > URL: http://svn.apache.org/viewvc?rev=741616&view=rev
> > Log:
> > Updated intermediate format documentation.
> >
> > Added:
> > xmlgraphics/fop/branches/Temp_AreaTreeNewDesign/src/documentation/resources/images/if-architecture-overview.png (with props)
>
> What software did you use to produce this image? You may want to also
> commit the source file, so that others can edit it if necessary.
Inkscape. I'll add the original file shortly.
>
> <snip/>
> > <section id="introduction">
> > <title>Introduction</title>
> > <p>
> > - The intermediate format (IF) is a proprietary XML format that represents the area tree
> > - generated by the layout engine. The area tree is conceptually defined in the
> > + Apache FOP now provides two different so-called intermediate formats. The first one
> > + (let's call it the area tree XML format) is basically a 1:1 XML representation of the FOP's
> > + area tree generated by the layout engine. The area tree is conceptually defined in the
> > <a href="http://www.w3.org/TR/2001/REC-xsl-20011015/slice1.html#section-N742-Formatting">XSL-FO specification in chapter 1.1.2</a>.
> > - The IF can be generated through the area tree XML Renderer (the XMLRenderer).
>
> Renaming this class into AreaTreeRenderer or AreaTreeXMLRenderer will
> probably allow to avoid confusion in the future.
-1 to that. Will break backwards-compatibility for those who are using
this renderer directly. It would break at least two pieces of software I
have. If you you generate SAX events
(AbstractXMLRenderer.setContentHandler()), working with MIME types isn't
enough. Besides, I don't think that would really improve the whole thing
much. After all, with the new IF, we're not primarily talking about
renderers but something else (IFDocumentHandler/IFPainter).
> <snip/>
>
> Vincent
Jeremias Maerki
Re: svn commit: r741616 - in /xmlgraphics/fop/branches/Temp_AreaTreeNewDesign/src/documentation:
content/xdocs/trunk/intermediate.xml resources/images/if-architecture-overview.png
Posted by Vincent Hennebert <vh...@gmail.com>.
Hi Jeremias,
A few suggestions:
> Author: jeremias
> Date: Fri Feb 6 16:27:13 2009
> New Revision: 741616
>
> URL: http://svn.apache.org/viewvc?rev=741616&view=rev
> Log:
> Updated intermediate format documentation.
>
> Added:
> xmlgraphics/fop/branches/Temp_AreaTreeNewDesign/src/documentation/resources/images/if-architecture-overview.png (with props)
What software did you use to produce this image? You may want to also
commit the source file, so that others can edit it if necessary.
<snip/>
> <section id="introduction">
> <title>Introduction</title>
> <p>
> - The intermediate format (IF) is a proprietary XML format that represents the area tree
> - generated by the layout engine. The area tree is conceptually defined in the
> + Apache FOP now provides two different so-called intermediate formats. The first one
> + (let's call it the area tree XML format) is basically a 1:1 XML representation of the FOP's
> + area tree generated by the layout engine. The area tree is conceptually defined in the
> <a href="http://www.w3.org/TR/2001/REC-xsl-20011015/slice1.html#section-N742-Formatting">XSL-FO specification in chapter 1.1.2</a>.
> - The IF can be generated through the area tree XML Renderer (the XMLRenderer).
Renaming this class into AreaTreeRenderer or AreaTreeXMLRenderer will
probably allow to avoid confusion in the future.
<snip/>
Vincent