You are viewing a plain text version of this content. The canonical link for it is here.
Posted to general@jakarta.apache.org by "Craig R. McClanahan" <cm...@mytownnet.com> on 1999/07/07 01:16:44 UTC

Re: Java1.1 or Java2?

Greg Wilkins wrote:

> Another question for the list!
> What is the target platform of Jakarta projects?
> Will we make the jump to Java2 or ignore it a keep 1.1 alive?
>
> I think the benefits of containers and weak references far
> outweigh backward compatibility ????
>

There is at least one place that 1.1 compatibility is critically
important ... Java2 on Linux systems is not yet ready for prime time
(although pre-v2 is a lot better than pre-v1 was), so a move to Java2 now
would leave that platform behind.

James has mentioned at other times that this is why the Servlet API
itself has not yet taken advantage of the new Java2 features
(collections, iterators, and so on).  This is true even in the 2.2 API
that is out for public review at the moment.

>
> --
> Greg Wilkins<gr...@mortbay.com>          GB  Phone: +44-(0)171-4394045
> Mort Bay Consulting Australia and UK.    Mbl Phone: +44-(0)7775534369
> http://www.mortbay.com                   AU  Phone: +61-(0)299772395
>

Craig McClanahan



Re: Java1.1 or Java2?

Posted by Lawrence Pit <lo...@cable.a2000.nl>.
> There is at least one place that 1.1 compatibility is critically
> important ... Java2 on Linux systems is not yet ready for prime time
> (although pre-v2 is a lot better than pre-v1 was), so a move to Java2 now
> would leave that platform behind.

I'll bet it's released before Jakarta sees it's first release. ;)

> James has mentioned at other times that this is why the Servlet API
> itself has not yet taken advantage of the new Java2 features
> (collections, iterators, and so on).  This is true even in the 2.2 API
> that is out for public review at the moment.

If Java2 classes are used (or RMI, which is inevitable if 2.2 is going to be
implemented) then it will not work with Microsoft's JVM. But who cares,
right? Also, I wonder how soon companies like IBM, Supercede, etc. etc. will
fully support Java2.

I suggest sticking to 1.1 for the moment, like the Servlet API does, and
when Java2 becomes mainstream do the switch. Things like weak references,
unsynchronized HashMap's etc. are ways to optimize code, but imo it's better
to optimize the architecture, design and testability for the moment than to
optimize code.

Lawrence Pit


Re: Java1.1 or Java2?

Posted by Robert Loren <me...@worldnet.att.net>.
Here ya go, if you'd like:
http://java.sun.com/beans/infobus/#DOWNLOAD_COLLECTIONS
Rob

Tom Clarke wrote:

> I won't get into how frustrating it is that collections cannot be
> retrofitted to 1.1.
>
> Having said this, weblogic comes with com.sun.java.util.collections.* which
> are the same classes if in a different package name. I don't know if these
> are generally available.
>


Re: Java1.1 or Java2?

Posted by Tom Clarke <tc...@agency.com>.
I won't get into how frustrating it is that collections cannot be
retrofitted to 1.1.

Having said this, weblogic comes with com.sun.java.util.collections.* which
are the same classes if in a different package name. I don't know if these
are generally available.

Tom


Tom Clarke
Senior Technical Consultant
AGENCY.COM
V 212.358.2798

----- Original Message -----
From: Preston L. Bannister <pr...@home.com>
To: <ge...@jakarta.apache.org>
Sent: Tuesday, July 06, 1999 7:29 PM
Subject: RE: Java1.1 or Java2?


> From: Craig McClanahan [mailto:cmcclanahan@mytownnet.com]
> > There is at least one place that 1.1 compatibility is critically
> > important ... Java2 on Linux systems is not yet ready for prime time
> > (although pre-v2 is a lot better than pre-v1 was), so a move to Java2
now
> > would leave that platform behind.
>
> Java on IBM OS/390 is also 1.1 (don't know the ETA for 1.2).
> Another big platform (if in an entirely different sense...).
>
>
> ---------------------------------------------------------------------
> To unsubscribe, e-mail: general-unsubscribe@jakarta.apache.org
> For additional commands, e-mail: general-help@jakarta.apache.org
>
>


RE: Java1.1 or Java2?

Posted by "Preston L. Bannister" <pr...@home.com>.
From: Craig McClanahan [mailto:cmcclanahan@mytownnet.com]
> There is at least one place that 1.1 compatibility is critically
> important ... Java2 on Linux systems is not yet ready for prime time
> (although pre-v2 is a lot better than pre-v1 was), so a move to Java2 now
> would leave that platform behind.

Java on IBM OS/390 is also 1.1 (don't know the ETA for 1.2).
Another big platform (if in an entirely different sense...).