Regexps (was Re: [VOTE] - Entry level JSDK 1.4 in Cocoon 2.2)

[Ugo Cei <u....@cbim.it>]

Alan wrote:
> * Ugo Cei <u....@cbim.it> [2004-03-03 08:15]:
>>Probably just the fact that we'd ship one less JAR file.
>     That was my point.
> 
> (Though a change would break sitemaps depending on ORO specific patterns,
>     if there is such a thing.)

At the cost of breaking some sitemaps, and since it's more or less clear 
that we're going to require JDK 1.4 for 2.2, I'll probably propose to 
drop Jakarta ORO in favour of the JDK's package (unless it's seriously 
broken) ... travel light.

		Ugo

Re: Regexps (was Re: [VOTE] - Entry level JSDK 1.4 in Cocoon 2.2)

[Ugo Cei <u....@cbim.it>]

Vadim Gritsenko wrote:

> IIRC, ORO is not used by sitemap. Rather, CForms has direct dependecies 
> on ORO.

Might be worthwile checking if 1.4 regexps are good enough for the task.

> PS I heard that 1.4.0 regexp was not good:
> http://marc.theaimsgroup.com/?l=jakarta-regexp-user&m=106588023307749&w=2

Oh, well, since "1.4.1 fixes most bugs", we can mandate 1.4.1 or even 
1.4.2 ;-).

	Ugo

Re: Regexps (was Re: [VOTE] - Entry level JSDK 1.4 in Cocoon 2.2)

[Vadim Gritsenko <va...@reverycodes.com>]

Ugo Cei wrote:

> Alan wrote:
>
>> * Ugo Cei <u....@cbim.it> [2004-03-03 08:15]:
>>
>>> Probably just the fact that we'd ship one less JAR file.
>>
>>     That was my point.
>>
>> (Though a change would break sitemaps depending on ORO specific 
>> patterns,
>>     if there is such a thing.)
>
>
> At the cost of breaking some sitemaps, and since it's more or less 
> clear that we're going to require JDK 1.4 for 2.2, I'll probably 
> propose to drop Jakarta ORO in favour of the JDK's package (unless 
> it's seriously broken) ... travel light.


IIRC, ORO is not used by sitemap. Rather, CForms has direct dependecies 
on ORO.

PS I heard that 1.4.0 regexp was not good:
http://marc.theaimsgroup.com/?l=jakarta-regexp-user&m=106588023307749&w=2

Vadim