You are viewing a plain text version of this content. The canonical link for it is here.
Posted to c-dev@xerces.apache.org by Christoffer Dam Bruun <cb...@systematic.dk> on 2001/08/29 17:35:49 UTC
RE: compilation with inlined desctuctor fails on AIX 4.2, xlC 3 r
ev.1
Hi Peiyong,
Is there a reason why inline is not specified in the class XXX ?
It seems that it would be more safe to just always put "inline" into the
class
declaration instead of reordering the functions.
/Christoffer
Compiler output for the failing files:
xlC_r -qnotempinc -D_THREAD_SAFE -c -O -DXML_USE_NATIVE_TRANSCODER
-DXML_USE_INM
EM_MESSAGELOADER -DAPP_NO_THREADS -DXML_USE_NO_THREADS
-I/home/kfat/nightly/in
clude -o /home/kfat/nightly/obj/AIX/XMLUri.o XMLUri.cpp
"/home/kfat/nightly/include/util/XMLUri.hpp", line 498.29: 1540-241: (S)
"XMLUri
::getScheme() const" was declared with external linkage and called or
defined be
fore being declared as inline.
"/home/kfat/nightly/include/util/XMLUri.hpp", line 498.1: 1540-377: (I)
"XMLUri:
:getScheme() const" is declared on line 152 of
"/home/kfat/nightly/include/util/
XMLUri.hpp".
"/home/kfat/nightly/include/util/XMLUri.hpp", line 503.29: 1540-241: (S)
"XMLUri
::getUserInfo() const" was declared with external linkage and called or
defined
before being declared as inline.
"/home/kfat/nightly/include/util/XMLUri.hpp", line 503.1: 1540-377: (I)
"XMLUri:
:getUserInfo() const" is declared on line 159 of
"/home/kfat/nightly/include/uti
l/XMLUri.hpp".
"/home/kfat/nightly/include/util/XMLUri.hpp", line 508.29: 1540-241: (S)
"XMLUri
::getHost() const" was declared with external linkage and called or defined
befo
re being declared as inline.
"/home/kfat/nightly/include/util/XMLUri.hpp", line 508.1: 1540-377: (I)
"XMLUri:
:getHost() const" is declared on line 167 of
"/home/kfat/nightly/include/util/XM
LUri.hpp".
"/home/kfat/nightly/include/util/XMLUri.hpp", line 518.29: 1540-241: (S)
"XMLUri
::getPath() const" was declared with external linkage and called or defined
befo
re being declared as inline.
"/home/kfat/nightly/include/util/XMLUri.hpp", line 518.1: 1540-377: (I)
"XMLUri:
:getPath() const" is declared on line 182 of
"/home/kfat/nightly/include/util/XM
LUri.hpp".
"/home/kfat/nightly/include/util/XMLUri.hpp", line 523.29: 1540-241: (S)
"XMLUri
::getQueryString() const" was declared with external linkage and called or
defin
ed before being declared as inline.
"/home/kfat/nightly/include/util/XMLUri.hpp", line 523.1: 1540-377: (I)
"XMLUri:
:getQueryString() const" is declared on line 191 of
"/home/kfat/nightly/include/
util/XMLUri.hpp".
"/home/kfat/nightly/include/util/XMLUri.hpp", line 528.29: 1540-241: (S)
"XMLUri
::getFragment() const" was declared with external linkage and called or
defined
before being declared as inline.
"/home/kfat/nightly/include/util/XMLUri.hpp", line 528.1: 1540-377: (I)
"XMLUri:
:getFragment() const" is declared on line 200 of
"/home/kfat/nightly/include/uti
l/XMLUri.hpp".
gmake[1]: *** [XMLUri.o] Error 1
gmake[1]: Leaving directory `/home/kfat/nightly/src/util'
xlC_r -qnotempinc -D_THREAD_SAFE -c -O -DXML_USE_NATIVE_TRANSCODER
-DXML_USE_INM
EM_MESSAGELOADER -DAPP_NO_THREADS -DXML_USE_NO_THREADS
-I/home/kfat/nightly/in
clude -o /home/kfat/nightly/obj/AIX/XMLScanner2.o XMLScanner2.cpp
"/home/kfat/nightly/include/validators/common/ContentSpecNode.hpp", line
372.38:
1540-241: (S) "ContentSpecNode::getElement() const" was declared with
external
linkage and called or defined before being declared as inline.
"/home/kfat/nightly/include/validators/common/ContentSpecNode.hpp", line
372.1:
1540-377: (I) "ContentSpecNode::getElement() const" is declared on line 182
of "
/home/kfat/nightly/include/validators/common/ContentSpecNode.hpp".
"/home/kfat/nightly/include/validators/common/ContentSpecNode.hpp", line
382.48:
1540-241: (S) "ContentSpecNode::getFirst() const" was declared with
external li
nkage and called or defined before being declared as inline.
"/home/kfat/nightly/include/validators/common/ContentSpecNode.hpp", line
382.1:
1540-377: (I) "ContentSpecNode::getFirst() const" is declared on line 184 of
"/h
ome/kfat/nightly/include/validators/common/ContentSpecNode.hpp".
"/home/kfat/nightly/include/validators/common/ContentSpecNode.hpp", line
392.48:
1540-241: (S) "ContentSpecNode::getSecond() const" was declared with
external l
inkage and called or defined before being declared as inline.
"/home/kfat/nightly/include/validators/common/ContentSpecNode.hpp", line
392.1:
1540-377: (I) "ContentSpecNode::getSecond() const" is declared on line 186
of "/
home/kfat/nightly/include/validators/common/ContentSpecNode.hpp".
"/home/kfat/nightly/include/validators/common/ContentSpecNode.hpp", line
397.52:
1540-241: (S) "ContentSpecNode::getType() const" was declared with external
lin
kage and called or defined before being declared as inline.
"/home/kfat/nightly/include/validators/common/ContentSpecNode.hpp", line
397.1:
1540-377: (I) "ContentSpecNode::getType() const" is declared on line 187 of
"/ho
me/kfat/nightly/include/validators/common/ContentSpecNode.hpp".
"/home/kfat/nightly/include/validators/common/ContentSpecNode.hpp", line
416.38:
1540-241: (S) "ContentSpecNode::getMinOccurs() const" was declared with
externa
l linkage and called or defined before being declared as inline.
"/home/kfat/nightly/include/validators/common/ContentSpecNode.hpp", line
416.1:
1540-377: (I) "ContentSpecNode::getMinOccurs() const" is declared on line
190 of
"/home/kfat/nightly/include/validators/common/ContentSpecNode.hpp".
"/home/kfat/nightly/include/validators/common/ContentSpecNode.hpp", line
421.38:
1540-241: (S) "ContentSpecNode::getMaxOccurs() const" was declared with
externa
l linkage and called or defined before being declared as inline.
"/home/kfat/nightly/include/validators/common/ContentSpecNode.hpp", line
421.1:
1540-377: (I) "ContentSpecNode::getMaxOccurs() const" is declared on line
191 of
"/home/kfat/nightly/include/validators/common/ContentSpecNode.hpp".
gmake[1]: *** [XMLScanner2.o] Error 1
gmake[1]: Leaving directory `/home/kfat/nightly/src/internal'
xlC_r -qnotempinc -D_THREAD_SAFE -c -O -DXML_USE_NATIVE_TRANSCODER
-DXML_USE_INM
EM_MESSAGELOADER -DAPP_NO_THREADS -DXML_USE_NO_THREADS
-I/home/kfat/nightly/in
clude -o /home/kfat/nightly/obj/AIX/DatatypeValidatorFactory.o
DatatypeValidato
rFactory.cpp
"/home/kfat/nightly/include/validators/datatype/ListDatatypeValidator.hpp",
line
326.36: 1540-241: (S) "ListDatatypeValidator::setContent(const
XMLCh*const)" wa
s declared with external linkage and called or defined before being declared
as
inline.
"/home/kfat/nightly/include/validators/datatype/ListDatatypeValidator.hpp",
line
326.1: 1540-377: (I) "ListDatatypeValidator::setContent(const XMLCh*const)"
is
declared on line 201 of
"/home/kfat/nightly/include/validators/datatype/ListData
typeValidator.hpp".
"/home/kfat/nightly/include/util/XMLDouble.hpp", line 205.24: 1540-241: (S)
"XML
Double::cleanUp()" was declared with external linkage and called or defined
befo
re being declared as inline.
"/home/kfat/nightly/include/util/XMLDouble.hpp", line 205.1: 1540-377: (I)
"XMLD
ouble::cleanUp()" is declared on line 157 of
"/home/kfat/nightly/include/util/XM
LDouble.hpp".
"/home/kfat/nightly/include/util/XMLFloat.hpp", line 195.23: 1540-241: (S)
"XMLF
loat::cleanUp()" was declared with external linkage and called or defined
before
being declared as inline.
"/home/kfat/nightly/include/util/XMLFloat.hpp", line 195.1: 1540-377: (I)
"XMLFl
oat::cleanUp()" is declared on line 152 of
"/home/kfat/nightly/include/util/XMLF
loat.hpp".
"/home/kfat/nightly/include/util/XMLUri.hpp", line 498.29: 1540-241: (S)
"XMLUri
::getScheme() const" was declared with external linkage and called or
defined be
fore being declared as inline.
"/home/kfat/nightly/include/util/XMLUri.hpp", line 498.1: 1540-377: (I)
"XMLUri:
:getScheme() const" is declared on line 152 of
"/home/kfat/nightly/include/util/
XMLUri.hpp".
"/home/kfat/nightly/include/util/XMLUri.hpp", line 503.29: 1540-241: (S)
"XMLUri
::getUserInfo() const" was declared with external linkage and called or
defined
before being declared as inline.
"/home/kfat/nightly/include/util/XMLUri.hpp", line 503.1: 1540-377: (I)
"XMLUri:
:getUserInfo() const" is declared on line 159 of
"/home/kfat/nightly/include/uti
l/XMLUri.hpp".
"/home/kfat/nightly/include/util/XMLUri.hpp", line 508.29: 1540-241: (S)
"XMLUri
::getHost() const" was declared with external linkage and called or defined
befo
re being declared as inline.
"/home/kfat/nightly/include/util/XMLUri.hpp", line 508.1: 1540-377: (I)
"XMLUri:
:getHost() const" is declared on line 167 of
"/home/kfat/nightly/include/util/XM
LUri.hpp".
"/home/kfat/nightly/include/util/XMLUri.hpp", line 518.29: 1540-241: (S)
"XMLUri
::getPath() const" was declared with external linkage and called or defined
befo
re being declared as inline.
"/home/kfat/nightly/include/util/XMLUri.hpp", line 518.1: 1540-377: (I)
"XMLUri:
:getPath() const" is declared on line 182 of
"/home/kfat/nightly/include/util/XM
LUri.hpp".
"/home/kfat/nightly/include/util/XMLUri.hpp", line 523.29: 1540-241: (S)
"XMLUri
::getQueryString() const" was declared with external linkage and called or
defin
ed before being declared as inline.
"/home/kfat/nightly/include/util/XMLUri.hpp", line 523.1: 1540-377: (I)
"XMLUri:
:getQueryString() const" is declared on line 191 of
"/home/kfat/nightly/include/
util/XMLUri.hpp".
"/home/kfat/nightly/include/util/XMLUri.hpp", line 528.29: 1540-241: (S)
"XMLUri
::getFragment() const" was declared with external linkage and called or
defined
before being declared as inline.
"/home/kfat/nightly/include/util/XMLUri.hpp", line 528.1: 1540-377: (I)
"XMLUri:
:getFragment() const" is declared on line 200 of
"/home/kfat/nightly/include/uti
l/XMLUri.hpp".
gmake[2]: *** [DatatypeValidatorFactory.o] Error 1
gmake[2]: Leaving directory `/home/kfat/nightly/src/validators/datatype'
> -----Original Message-----
> From: peiyongz@ca.ibm.com [mailto:peiyongz@ca.ibm.com]
> Sent: 29. august 2001 17:11
> To: xerces-c-dev@xml.apache.org
> Subject: RE: compilation with inlined desctuctor fails on AIX
> 4.2, xlC 3
> r ev.1
>
>
> Christoffer,
>
> Great!
> But for the sake of consistency, we may go with
> the re-order-caller-callee solution, could you send us the
> error message (before you add 'inline' into the class construct)
> on the following files? thanks.
>
> "/home/kfat/nightly/include/util/XMLUri.hpp"
> "/home/kfat/nightly/include/validators/datatype/ListDatatypeVa
> lidator.hpp",
>
> "/home/kfat/nightly/include/util/XMLDouble.hpp",
> "/home/kfat/nightly/include/util/XMLFloat.hpp",
>
>
> Regards,
>
> Peiyong Zhang
> ____________________________________________
> XML Parsers Development
> IBM Toronto Laboratory email: peiyongz@ca.ibm.com
> Phone: (416)448-4088; Fax: (416)448-4414; T/L: 778-4088
>
>
>
> Christoffer Dam Bruun <cb...@systematic.dk> on 08/29/2001 10:20:47 AM
>
> Please respond to xerces-c-dev@xml.apache.org
>
> To: "'xerces-c-dev@xml.apache.org'" <xe...@xml.apache.org>
> cc:
> Subject: RE: compilation with inlined desctuctor fails on
> AIX 4.2, xlC 3 r
> ev.1
>
>
> Hi,
>
> It works if the inline declaration is made inside the class XXX {...}
> construct.
> We have successfully compiled all the source.
>
> /Christoffer
>
> > -----Original Message-----
> > From: peiyongz@ca.ibm.com [mailto:peiyongz@ca.ibm.com]
> > Sent: 28. august 2001 23:12
> > To: xerces-c-dev@xml.apache.org
> > Subject: Re: compilation with inlined desctuctor fails on AIX
> > 4.2, xlC 3
> > rev.1
> >
> >
> > Christoffer,
> >
> > In your last mail you mentioned the compilation error on inline
> > function
> > and suggest the two solutions
> >
> > 1) move A::~A() up before A::amethod()
> > 2) not declare A::~A() inline
> >
> > For sure, they work fine for classes with relative simple
> > interdependency
> > among methods, while for more complicated classes it could be
> > a maintenance
> > burden.
> >
> > Could we add the keyword 'inline' to those methods in the
> > class body to
> > notify the compiler that they are inline?
> >
> > class A {
> > A *left, *right;
> > A() {left=0, left=0;};
> > void amethod();
> > ***inline*** ~A();
> > };
> >
> >
> > It your compiler accepts that, it might eliminate the
> > importance of the
> > method order
> > (which is in fact **UNnecessary** to most other compilers),
> could you
> > have a test?
> >
> > Regards,
> >
> > Peiyong Zhang
> > ____________________________________________
> > XML Parsers Development
> > IBM Toronto Laboratory email: peiyongz@ca.ibm.com
> > Phone: (416)448-4088; Fax: (416)448-4414; T/L: 778-4088
> >
> >
> >
> > Christoffer Dam Bruun <cb...@systematic.dk> on 08/21/2001 09:03:05 AM
> >
> > Please respond to xerces-c-dev@xml.apache.org
> >
> > To: xerces-c-dev@xml.apache.org
> > cc:
> > Subject: compilation with inlined desctuctor fails on AIX
> > 4.2, xlC 3 rev.1
> >
> >
> > Hi,
> >
> > We are trying to compile Xerces 1.5.1 src on AIX and have run
> > into some
> > compilation problems
> > makefiels generated with:
> > runConfigure -paix -cxlc -xxlC -rnone
> >
> > It appears that xlC will not accept that the following construct:
> >
> > class A {
> > A *left, *right;
> > A() {left=0, left=0;};
> > void amethod();
> > ~A();
> > };
> >
> > inline void A::amethod()
> > {
> > if (right)
> > delete right; // This calls the A destruct'er that is
> > later declared
> > inline
> > }
> >
> > inline A::~A()
> > {
> > if (left)
> > delete left;
> > if (right)
> > delete right;
> > }
> >
> > If one tries to compile:
> >
> > [/home/kfat] xlC -c a.cpp
> > "a.cpp", line 14.11: 1540-241: (S) "A::~A()" was declared
> > with external
> > linkage
> > and called or defined before being declared as inline.
> > "a.cpp", line 14.1: 1540-377: (I) "A::~A()" is declared on line 5 of
> > "a.cpp".
> >
> > Even if we try to compile with "-qnoinline" it still fails
> > with the same
> > error msg.
> >
> > We have found 2 solutions:
> > 1) move A::~A() up before A::amethod()
> > 2) not declare A::~A() inline
> >
> > Know, what has this to do with Xerces :-)
> >
> > We have encountered the above problem in the following files:
> > ContentSpecNode.hpp
> > StringDatatypeValidator.hpp
> > DecimalDatatypeValidator.hpp
> > HexBinaryDatatypeValidator.hpp
> > Base64BinaryDatatypeValidator.hpp
> > NOTATIONDatatypeValidator.hpp
> > QNameDatatypeValidator.hpp
> > ListDatatypeValidator.hpp
> > UnionDatatypeValidator.hpp
> >
> > Are we the only ones having problems compiling on AIX ?
> >
> > Regards
> > Christoffer Bruun
> > email: cb@systematic.dk
> > tlf: 89432000
> >
> > ---
> > Ed is the standard text editor.
> > If you use ed, you are on the path to redemption, the
> > so-calleds "visual" editors have been placed here by ed to tempt the
> > faithless. DO NOT GIVE IN!!! THE MIGHTY ED HAS SPOKEN!!!
> >
> >
> >
> ---------------------------------------------------------------------
> > To unsubscribe, e-mail: xerces-c-dev-unsubscribe@xml.apache.org
> > For additional commands, e-mail: xerces-c-dev-help@xml.apache.org
> >
> >
> >
> >
> >
> >
> ---------------------------------------------------------------------
> > To unsubscribe, e-mail: xerces-c-dev-unsubscribe@xml.apache.org
> > For additional commands, e-mail: xerces-c-dev-help@xml.apache.org
> >
>
> ---------------------------------------------------------------------
> To unsubscribe, e-mail: xerces-c-dev-unsubscribe@xml.apache.org
> For additional commands, e-mail: xerces-c-dev-help@xml.apache.org
>
>
>
>
>
> ---------------------------------------------------------------------
> To unsubscribe, e-mail: xerces-c-dev-unsubscribe@xml.apache.org
> For additional commands, e-mail: xerces-c-dev-help@xml.apache.org
>
---------------------------------------------------------------------
To unsubscribe, e-mail: xerces-c-dev-unsubscribe@xml.apache.org
For additional commands, e-mail: xerces-c-dev-help@xml.apache.org