You are viewing a plain text version of this content. The canonical link for it is here.
Posted to users@spamassassin.apache.org by Per Jessen <pe...@computer.org> on 2008/11/02 19:29:33 UTC
Re: Problems with the email adress of our company
Greg Troxel wrote:
> Asking someone to change their domain name to match an SA rule seems
> a bit extreme to me! Why not propose that de establish a gmbh 2nd
> level for companies, and make him rss.gmbh.de?
>
> FROM_DOMAIN_NOVOWEL was logged for only 3 messages here yesterday,
> of
> 1.3 million logged as scoring 7.0 and higher. All 3 were fps:
>
> privatehealthmgmt.com
> umdnj-secure.com (twice)
>
> (That second one had a long consonant string to the left of the @
> sign.)
>
> It is perhaps extreme, but even if the rule is fixed not to FP, I
> suspect (but have no data) there will be lingering trouble from older
> installations. From the business point of view one has to weigh the
> cost of FPs and the cost of changing the name. I would probably
> change names, since it really isn't that hard.
>>From the business point of view, one also has to consider the cost
involved in changing all the stationery, website, businesscards,
brochures, etc etc etc ...
/Per Jessen, Zürich
Re: Problems with the email adress of our company
Posted by mouss <mo...@netoyen.net>.
Kelson wrote:
> Per Jessen wrote:
>> I guess it's a matter of opinion, but an email address is a significant
>> part of a corporate identity - you don't go around changing it ad-hoc,
>> and you certainly try to avoid having one domain in your email-address
>> and another on your brochures and businesscards.
>
> Exactly. That sort of thing would train users to expect your company's
> email to come from multiple and/or unfamiliar domains, such that they
> will be less likely to notice phishing attempts that claim to be your
> company but come from other domains.
>
<devil advocate=yes>
- how many users would see the address part in
From: joe at rssgmbh <jo...@otherdomain.example>
- and regarding phishing, those users who "will be less likely to
notice" will never notice anyway, whatever you do.
- if your marketers decide to use beepornot.com instead of
Beep-or-not.com, don't come crying that it is blocked because it
contains "porn".
</devil>
I do understand the trademark/name/identity/IP/... issues, and I do
understand that OP should not be forced to play such games, but if he
has no other way to get his mail delivered to his recipients, then he
can ask his boss/mgmt/mktg/president/... whether it's acceptable to play
these games in order to get mail out.
Re: Problems with the email adress of our company
Posted by Kelson <ke...@speed.net>.
Per Jessen wrote:
> I guess it's a matter of opinion, but an email address is a significant
> part of a corporate identity - you don't go around changing it ad-hoc,
> and you certainly try to avoid having one domain in your email-address
> and another on your brochures and businesscards.
Exactly. That sort of thing would train users to expect your company's
email to come from multiple and/or unfamiliar domains, such that they
will be less likely to notice phishing attempts that claim to be your
company but come from other domains.
--
Kelson Vibber
SpeedGate Communications <www.speed.net>
Re: Problems with the email adress of our company
Posted by Per Jessen <pe...@computer.org>.
mouss wrote:
> Per Jessen wrote:
>>
>>>>From the business point of view, one also has to consider the cost
>> involved in changing all the stationery, website, businesscards,
>> brochures, etc etc etc ...
>>
>
> it is not necessary to change these. a second domain name that points
> to the "primary" one is enough (how about
> RemoteSensingSolutions.com?).
I guess it's a matter of opinion, but an email address is a significant
part of a corporate identity - you don't go around changing it ad-hoc,
and you certainly try to avoid having one domain in your email-address
and another on your brochures and businesscards.
/Per Jessen, Zürich
Re: Problems with the email adress of our company
Posted by mouss <mo...@netoyen.net>.
Per Jessen wrote:
> Greg Troxel wrote:
>
>> Asking someone to change their domain name to match an SA rule seems
>> a bit extreme to me! Why not propose that de establish a gmbh 2nd
>> level for companies, and make him rss.gmbh.de?
>>
>> FROM_DOMAIN_NOVOWEL was logged for only 3 messages here yesterday,
>> of
>> 1.3 million logged as scoring 7.0 and higher. All 3 were fps:
>>
>> privatehealthmgmt.com
>> umdnj-secure.com (twice)
>>
>> (That second one had a long consonant string to the left of the @
>> sign.)
>>
>> It is perhaps extreme, but even if the rule is fixed not to FP, I
>> suspect (but have no data) there will be lingering trouble from older
>> installations. From the business point of view one has to weigh the
>> cost of FPs and the cost of changing the name. I would probably
>> change names, since it really isn't that hard.
>
>>>From the business point of view, one also has to consider the cost
> involved in changing all the stationery, website, businesscards,
> brochures, etc etc etc ...
>
it is not necessary to change these. a second domain name that points to
the "primary" one is enough (how about RemoteSensingSolutions.com?).
not ideal, but may be needed since even if the scores are fixed in SA,
many sites won't update, and let's not speak about sites using
proprietray technos that have similar rules (such rules come "naturally"
after you received spam with unpronounceable names...).