You are viewing a plain text version of this content. The canonical link for it is here.
Posted to users@spamassassin.apache.org by Robert Müller <rm...@thinxsolutions.com> on 2008/05/07 00:01:02 UTC

typo in 20_vbounce.cf?

Hi all,
as I'm facing raising amount of bounces on my mailserver in the last 2 
months, I tried to use the vbounce ruleset to identify the ones caused 
by UBE faking the sender address.
This was generally successful, but surprisingly there are a lot of 
UBE-bounces which are not recognized by vbounce.
After digging a little bit into this (I'm not a SA-expert), it showed 
that the body-rule " __HAVE_BOUNCE_RELAYS" is giving a "1", but often no 
header rule "__BOUNCE*" seems to give a hit.
One of the most likely rules to be IMHO true is the 
"__BOUNCE_FROM_DAEMON" one, but this one nearly never gives a hit. 
Looking at the regexp in this line, the "+" after the \S seems not to be 
correct from my point of view, I would suggest a "*" here, as it is in 
"__BOUNCE_RPATH_MD".
So for testing purposes I modified the line
old:
header __BOUNCE_FROM_DAEMON   From =~ 
/(?:(?:daemon|deamon|majordomo|postmaster|virus|scanner|devnull|automated-response|SMTP.gateway|mailadmin|mailmaster|surfcontrol|You_Got_Spammed)\S+\@|<>)/i

to new:
header __BOUNCE_FROM_DAEMON   From =~ 
/(?:(?:daemon|deamon|majordomo|postmaster|virus|scanner|devnull|automated-response|SMTP.gateway|mailadmin|mailmaster|surfcontrol|You_Got_Spammed)\S*\@|<>)/i

and now, also the bounces formerly not recognized are correctly identified.
Can someone confirm that this is a "typo"? Or have I misunderstood 
something?

THX,
Robert

Re: typo in 20_vbounce.cf?

Posted by Robert Müller <rm...@thinxsolutions.com>.
Sorry for missing the most important part of the information in the body 
- I fully agree with you.
On the other side, I learned at school to carefully read all parts of 
the document - seems also to be true :-)

Robert

Jari Fredriksson schrieb:
>> doh!
>> I guess if I read the subject line that would have helped.
>>     
>
> You are not alone with this ;D It's a good practise to include all data in the body of the message, and not to refer to the subject. I once learned that in school and it seems to be true..
>
> jarif
>
>
>
>   
>> On May 7, 2008, at 11:15 AM, JP Kelly wrote:
>>
>>     
>>> where is this line found?
>>>
>>> On May 6, 2008, at 3:01 PM, Robert Müller wrote:
>>>
>>>       
>>>> So for testing purposes I modified the line
>>>> old:
>>>> header __BOUNCE_FROM_DAEMON   From =~
>>>> /(?:(?:daemon|deamon|
>>>> majordomo|postmaster|virus|scanner|devnull|automated-response|
>>>> SMTP.gateway|mailadmin|mailmaster|surfcontrol|You_Got_Spammed)\S+\@|
>>>> <>)/i 
>>>>
>>>> to new:
>>>> header __BOUNCE_FROM_DAEMON   From =~
>>>> /(?:(?:daemon|deamon|
>>>> majordomo|postmaster|virus|scanner|devnull|automated-response|
>>>> SMTP.gateway|mailadmin|mailmaster|surfcontrol|You_Got_Spammed)\S*\@|
>>>> <>)/i 
>>>>         
>
>   


Re: typo in 20_vbounce.cf?

Posted by Jari Fredriksson <ja...@iki.fi>.
> doh!
> I guess if I read the subject line that would have helped.

You are not alone with this ;D It's a good practise to include all data in the body of the message, and not to refer to the subject. I once learned that in school and it seems to be true..

jarif



> 
> On May 7, 2008, at 11:15 AM, JP Kelly wrote:
> 
>> where is this line found?
>> 
>> On May 6, 2008, at 3:01 PM, Robert Müller wrote:
>> 
>>> So for testing purposes I modified the line
>>> old:
>>> header __BOUNCE_FROM_DAEMON   From =~
>>> /(?:(?:daemon|deamon|
>>> majordomo|postmaster|virus|scanner|devnull|automated-response|
>>> SMTP.gateway|mailadmin|mailmaster|surfcontrol|You_Got_Spammed)\S+\@|
>>> <>)/i 
>>> 
>>> to new:
>>> header __BOUNCE_FROM_DAEMON   From =~
>>> /(?:(?:daemon|deamon|
>>> majordomo|postmaster|virus|scanner|devnull|automated-response|
>>> SMTP.gateway|mailadmin|mailmaster|surfcontrol|You_Got_Spammed)\S*\@|
>>> <>)/i 

Re: typo in 20_vbounce.cf?

Posted by JP Kelly <li...@jpkvideo.net>.
doh!
I guess if I read the subject line that would have helped.

On May 7, 2008, at 11:15 AM, JP Kelly wrote:

> where is this line found?
>
> On May 6, 2008, at 3:01 PM, Robert Müller wrote:
>
>> So for testing purposes I modified the line
>> old:
>> header __BOUNCE_FROM_DAEMON   From =~ /(?:(?:daemon|deamon| 
>> majordomo|postmaster|virus|scanner|devnull|automated-response| 
>> SMTP.gateway|mailadmin|mailmaster|surfcontrol|You_Got_Spammed)\S+\@| 
>> <>)/i
>>
>> to new:
>> header __BOUNCE_FROM_DAEMON   From =~ /(?:(?:daemon|deamon| 
>> majordomo|postmaster|virus|scanner|devnull|automated-response| 
>> SMTP.gateway|mailadmin|mailmaster|surfcontrol|You_Got_Spammed)\S*\@| 
>> <>)/i
>


Re: typo in 20_vbounce.cf?

Posted by JP Kelly <li...@jpkvideo.net>.
where is this line found?

On May 6, 2008, at 3:01 PM, Robert Müller wrote:

> So for testing purposes I modified the line
> old:
> header __BOUNCE_FROM_DAEMON   From =~ /(?:(?:daemon|deamon|majordomo| 
> postmaster|virus|scanner|devnull|automated-response|SMTP.gateway| 
> mailadmin|mailmaster|surfcontrol|You_Got_Spammed)\S+\@|<>)/i
>
> to new:
> header __BOUNCE_FROM_DAEMON   From =~ /(?:(?:daemon|deamon|majordomo| 
> postmaster|virus|scanner|devnull|automated-response|SMTP.gateway| 
> mailadmin|mailmaster|surfcontrol|You_Got_Spammed)\S*\@|<>)/i