You are viewing a plain text version of this content. The canonical link for it is here.
Posted to dev@avalon.apache.org by Paul Hammant <pa...@yahoo.com> on 2001/06/04 13:50:42 UTC

[ Was "Off Topic...", now: ] Avalon become OS.

> >2) GPL code can be modified by a business or org and kept secret, provided
> the code is not
> >distributed out again.
> 
> neither may the binary. RSN it will even become difficult to allow people
> to use software without giving them access to sourcecode. So if you have a
> GPLed http server then anyone who visits your site has to have access to
> source of server. RMS got miffed that service providers were using GPL code
> but not recontributing changes ;)

Blimey.
 
> >3) Modifications to GPL code (like other OSS licenses) must be republished. 
> 
> Not all OSS or Free software licenses mandate republishing. (ie Apache).

To a point.  If you change an apache class then yes, but if you extend or use it then replication
is not necessary.
 
> >4) GPL likes Xerces because Xerces implements a W3C interface (approved).
> The linking of the
> >Xerces classes is achieved through a factory that *could* have multiple
> implementations (somthing
> >the GPL likes very much).  If you import any org.apache.* class (and other
> utilities under many
> >other OSI approved licenses) you are in breach of GPL.
> 
> Actually xerces may not be used by GPL app even though it goes through a PD
> interface. The exception is only allowed when it is considered hosted
> component.

>From what I have read, you can use Xerces in a GPL app, but not distribute it.  This is because
the W3C licensed SAX API allows multiple implementations.  As such the person running a GPL app
could choose to run Xerces instead of a GPL approved parser.  The point being that as long as the
GPL app is not compiled against, or distributed with Xerces, it's not in breach.

Would JDK 1.4's parser?  Yes, as it's part of the JDK and hence appowed as part of the "operating
system" or "hosted environment" concessions.  Weird.  Sun have a far more closed license than
Apache, yet pass the GPL compatability test on the basis that they are providing it as part of the
JDK.

Wat too about Apache licensed software if Sun included it in the JDK?

> >Avalon
> >======
> >
> >This leads us neatly on to Avalon, If Avalon's interfaces were declared
> "Operating system", then
> >they would be granted the same excepmtion as JDK classes would (they are a
> commercial license). 
> >People are going to object here, citing examples like not file system
> implemented in Avalon....
> >
> >It is my opinion that OS is where we should head....
> 
> The problem is that almost all of Avalon is involved with hosted components
> and thus all of it would have be BSDL or X11 licensed. This would involve
> convincing all Avalon committers, the PMC and the Board. Feel free to try ;)

Never, I am very happy with the terms of the Apache license.  What I am peed off about is that the
FSF maintains some "Any color you like as long as it is black" attidude to (we'll say) 20 fine OSI
approved licenses.

If we declare Avalon to be an operating system, we might, without any further changes to terms and
conditions or licenses, be compatible with the GPL becase of it's "get out of jail" clause for
such layers in a computing environment.

Not so you say - Avalon is definately not an OS.  True, but then neither is Java.  Without much of
stretch of thinking, we should be able to determine that no Java code at all can possibly be
compatible with the GPL.  Ahh, but the GPL zealots say that there is Kaffe/Classpath to allow
compatiblity with GPL (multiple implementations).  That's great but those are massively
imcomplete.  There is not Swing or other heavier APIs, and any work that they have done is so
close to the orginal art of Sun et al, that copyright infringement is probably an issue.

GPL is completely insane for toolkits, services and APIs. Its only patronised by people that are
new to the "cause" of open source, or those too proud to admin they have made the wrong choice of
open source license (the second half of that is paraphrasing your comments Peter (entirely valid)
during the spat with the JBoss people late last year).

Anyway, I really think by a process of declaration and gap filling we could grant Avalon the
status of operating system, at least to the level that the JDK has been.  ApacheOS is born. 
Avalon plus beaucoup de hosted services. We have Cocoon, Locomotive, FTP, James.  In the wings are
others, plus some of your glimmers like DNS and mine like Jesktop.

All we have to do is define a feature gap, with the already loose definition of operating system
in mind.

Regards,

- Paul H

____________________________________________________________
Do You Yahoo!?
Get your free @yahoo.co.uk address at http://mail.yahoo.co.uk
or your free @yahoo.ie address at http://mail.yahoo.ie

---------------------------------------------------------------------
To unsubscribe, e-mail: avalon-dev-unsubscribe@jakarta.apache.org
For additional commands, e-mail: avalon-dev-help@jakarta.apache.org


Re: [ Was "Off Topic...", now: ] Avalon become OS.

Posted by Berin Loritsch <bl...@apache.org>.
Paul Hammant wrote:
> 
> Berin : Do you want me to email you the subject of this thread?  If yes, just since Saturday?

Please.  Since Saturday should be fine.
> 
> ---
> 
> > >GPL is completely insane for toolkits, services and APIs. Its only
> > patronised by people that are
> > >new to the "cause" of open source, or those too proud to admin they have
> > made the wrong choice of
> > >open source license (the second half of that is paraphrasing your comments
> > Peter (entirely valid)
> > >during the spat with the JBoss people late last year).
> >
> > You have to realize that when the GPL was born there was a very good reason
> > for making the choices it made. I agree 100% with those decisions at that
> > time. GPL serves the users at the expense of developers. In current times
> > there is still some reasons to use GPL. Mainly if a company does not want
> > to release code only to have market-savy competitiors repackage and resell it.
> 
> That's a good point - release as GPL to open it, but stifle commercial competitors use.  A spolier
> of sorts.
> 
> > The other reason a lot of new comers use GPL is because of advertising
> > (they believe GPL==opensource) and they don't really understand
> > implications and actually believe some of the rhetoric spouted by 'anarhy r
> > us' type peeps.
> 
> That's what I meant by "new to the cause".  You put it better though.
> 
>  [ Avalon == ApacheOS (phase 1) ]
> 
> > It is definetly something I have played with as an idea. One of the main
> > reasons I ended up getting involved with Ant was to play with idea of an
> > ant init system (first process in *nix systems) and also to rebuild my
> > cron/job/at server. I am also involved with Isolate JSR (basically fork for
> > java) which should be a step in right direction.
> 
> Can we go down the gap route?  i.e. where does Avalon on top of J2SE on top of host OS (or BIOS or
> other) not fill the requisites for OS definition.
> 
> Incidentally, Peter, you're spot on for pushing Ant down the Avalon road (as long as it remains
> multimodal).
> 
> Regards,
> 
> - Paul H
> 
> ____________________________________________________________
> Do You Yahoo!?
> Get your free @yahoo.co.uk address at http://mail.yahoo.co.uk
> or your free @yahoo.ie address at http://mail.yahoo.ie
> 
> ---------------------------------------------------------------------
> To unsubscribe, e-mail: avalon-dev-unsubscribe@jakarta.apache.org
> For additional commands, e-mail: avalon-dev-help@jakarta.apache.org

---------------------------------------------------------------------
To unsubscribe, e-mail: avalon-dev-unsubscribe@jakarta.apache.org
For additional commands, e-mail: avalon-dev-help@jakarta.apache.org


Re: [ Was "Off Topic...", now: ] Avalon become OS.

Posted by Paul Hammant <pa...@yahoo.com>.
Berin : Do you want me to email you the subject of this thread?  If yes, just since Saturday?

---

> >GPL is completely insane for toolkits, services and APIs. Its only
> patronised by people that are
> >new to the "cause" of open source, or those too proud to admin they have
> made the wrong choice of
> >open source license (the second half of that is paraphrasing your comments
> Peter (entirely valid)
> >during the spat with the JBoss people late last year).
> 
> You have to realize that when the GPL was born there was a very good reason
> for making the choices it made. I agree 100% with those decisions at that
> time. GPL serves the users at the expense of developers. In current times
> there is still some reasons to use GPL. Mainly if a company does not want
> to release code only to have market-savy competitiors repackage and resell it.

That's a good point - release as GPL to open it, but stifle commercial competitors use.  A spolier
of sorts.
 
> The other reason a lot of new comers use GPL is because of advertising
> (they believe GPL==opensource) and they don't really understand
> implications and actually believe some of the rhetoric spouted by 'anarhy r
> us' type peeps. 

That's what I meant by "new to the cause".  You put it better though.
 
 [ Avalon == ApacheOS (phase 1) ]

> It is definetly something I have played with as an idea. One of the main
> reasons I ended up getting involved with Ant was to play with idea of an
> ant init system (first process in *nix systems) and also to rebuild my
> cron/job/at server. I am also involved with Isolate JSR (basically fork for
> java) which should be a step in right direction.

Can we go down the gap route?  i.e. where does Avalon on top of J2SE on top of host OS (or BIOS or
other) not fill the requisites for OS definition.

Incidentally, Peter, you're spot on for pushing Ant down the Avalon road (as long as it remains
multimodal).

Regards,

- Paul H

____________________________________________________________
Do You Yahoo!?
Get your free @yahoo.co.uk address at http://mail.yahoo.co.uk
or your free @yahoo.ie address at http://mail.yahoo.ie

---------------------------------------------------------------------
To unsubscribe, e-mail: avalon-dev-unsubscribe@jakarta.apache.org
For additional commands, e-mail: avalon-dev-help@jakarta.apache.org


Re: [ Was "Off Topic...", now: ] Avalon become OS.

Posted by Peter Donald <do...@apache.org>.
At 12:50 PM 6/4/01 +0100, Paul Hammant wrote:
>> >3) Modifications to GPL code (like other OSS licenses) must be
republished. 
>> 
>> Not all OSS or Free software licenses mandate republishing. (ie Apache).
>
>To a point.  If you change an apache class then yes, but if you extend or
use it then replication
>is not necessary.

not sure what you mean. If you modify apache classes there is no license
clause that forces you to publish it. You can keep it private and sell it
as part of a "valued-added" product (ie Oracle did that with Apache
webserver and jserv I believe).

>> >4) GPL likes Xerces because Xerces implements a W3C interface (approved).
>> The linking of the
>> >Xerces classes is achieved through a factory that *could* have multiple
>> implementations (somthing
>> >the GPL likes very much).  If you import any org.apache.* class (and other
>> utilities under many
>> >other OSI approved licenses) you are in breach of GPL.
>> 
>> Actually xerces may not be used by GPL app even though it goes through a PD
>> interface. The exception is only allowed when it is considered hosted
>> component.
>
>>>From what I have read, you can use Xerces in a GPL app, but not
distribute it.  This is because
>the W3C licensed SAX API allows multiple implementations.  As such the
person running a GPL app
>could choose to run Xerces instead of a GPL approved parser.  The point
being that as long as the
>GPL app is not compiled against, or distributed with Xerces, it's not in
breach.

okay - that works for me ;)

>Would JDK 1.4's parser?  Yes, as it's part of the JDK and hence appowed as
part of the "operating
>system" or "hosted environment" concessions.  Weird.  Sun have a far more
closed license than
>Apache, yet pass the GPL compatability test on the basis that they are
providing it as part of the
>JDK.

;)

>Never, I am very happy with the terms of the Apache license.  What I am
peed off about is that the
>FSF maintains some "Any color you like as long as it is black" attidude to
(we'll say) 20 fine OSI
>approved licenses.

They are persistent ;) Maybe not completely coherent (LGPL interpretation
seems to vary depending on what project you are talking about).

>GPL is completely insane for toolkits, services and APIs. Its only
patronised by people that are
>new to the "cause" of open source, or those too proud to admin they have
made the wrong choice of
>open source license (the second half of that is paraphrasing your comments
Peter (entirely valid)
>during the spat with the JBoss people late last year).

You have to realize that when the GPL was born there was a very good reason
for making the choices it made. I agree 100% with those decisions at that
time. GPL serves the users at the expense of developers. In current times
there is still some reasons to use GPL. Mainly if a company does not want
to release code only to have market-savy competitiors repackage and resell it.

The other reason a lot of new comers use GPL is because of advertising
(they believe GPL==opensource) and they don't really understand
implications and actually believe some of the rhetoric spouted by 'anarhy r
us' type peeps. 

>Anyway, I really think by a process of declaration and gap filling we
could grant Avalon the
>status of operating system, at least to the level that the JDK has been.
ApacheOS is born. 
>Avalon plus beaucoup de hosted services. We have Cocoon, Locomotive, FTP,
James.  In the wings are
>others, plus some of your glimmers like DNS and mine like Jesktop.

It is definetly something I have played with as an idea. One of the main
reasons I ended up getting involved with Ant was to play with idea of an
ant init system (first process in *nix systems) and also to rebuild my
cron/job/at server. I am also involved with Isolate JSR (basically fork for
java) which should be a step in right direction.


Cheers,

Pete

*-----------------------------------------------------*
| "Faced with the choice between changing one's mind, |
| and proving that there is no need to do so - almost |
| everyone gets busy on the proof."                   |
|              - John Kenneth Galbraith               |
*-----------------------------------------------------*


---------------------------------------------------------------------
To unsubscribe, e-mail: avalon-dev-unsubscribe@jakarta.apache.org
For additional commands, e-mail: avalon-dev-help@jakarta.apache.org