You are viewing a plain text version of this content. The canonical link for it is here.
Posted to users@solr.apache.org by solr <fr...@rodland.no> on 2022/10/26 08:55:07 UTC
Bug in copyfield when using maxChars (SOLR 9)
Hi
We’ve stumbled upon something that seems like a bug. The behaviour is changed since solr 8.11
If we setup copyfield with maxChars, this is “remembered” for all other copyField-operations (at least for the same source field).
From schema.xml:
<field name="searchablefield" type="text" indexed="true" stored="true" multiValued="true"/>
<field name="genteaser" type="text" indexed="false" stored="true"/>
Input doc:
body:“On a brighter note, they have a phone number to call if you are interested in volunteering. You can call 860 - 690 - 4300 ext 2. (there are a lot of forms to fill out, and they are asking for info on when the babies are due) There was a lady in here yesterday asking how to volunteer. She is 2 - 3 months pregnant and wants to get her hands dirty. She says her husband will be home at the time, but can't drive, so she wants to be able to help out. So I told her the names of the people who are in charge, and also pointed her in the direction of a site where she can make an appointment to drop off some pre - packaged meals. I'll let you know what I hear from them when I do. One day I had not posted because all I was going to do was complain about how the morning sickness is wearing me out! Then I thought, I can make this an uplifting post, so I'll share with you about my friend Jackie, who I met in high school, who went through this 2 years ago with her first baby, Samuel."
search with qf=searchablefield for q=“Samuel"
HIT (OK)
<copyField source="body" dest="genteaser" />
<copyField source="body" dest="searchablefield"/>
HIT (OK)
<copyField source="body" dest="searchablefield" maxChars="3000000"/>
<copyField source="body" dest="genteaser" maxChars="300"/>
NT HIT (as expected)
<copyField source="body" dest="searchablefield" maxChars="300"/>
<copyField source="body" dest="genteaser" maxChars="300”/>
NO HIT (BUG):
<copyField source="body" dest="genteaser" maxChars="300"/>
<copyField source="body" dest="searchablefield" maxChars="300000”/>
NO HIT (BUG):
<copyField source="body" dest="genteaser" maxChars="300"/>
<copyField source="body" dest="searchablefield"/>
We also clearly see this behaviour when viewing the documents.
Fredrik
--
Fredrik Rødland
Cell: +47 99 21 98 17
Maisen Pedersens vei 1 Twitter: @fredrikr
NO-1363 Høvik, NORWAY flickr:
http://www.flickr.com/fmmr/
http://rodland.no about.me http://about.me/fmr
Re: Bug in copyfield when using maxChars (SOLR 9)
Posted by Kevin Risden <kr...@apache.org>.
Thanks Fredrik for creating https://issues.apache.org/jira/browse/SOLR-16502
and providing an easy to reproduce test case. I just put a PR up to fix
this.
For those looking for a great bug report this is an awesome example.
Kevin Risden
On Wed, Oct 26, 2022 at 6:14 AM solr <fr...@rodland.no> wrote:
> Hi
>
> We’ve stumbled upon something that seems like a bug. The behaviour is
> changed since solr 8.11
>
> If we setup copyfield with maxChars, this is “remembered” for all other
> copyField-operations (at least for the same source field).
>
> From schema.xml:
> <field name="searchablefield" type="text" indexed="true" stored="true"
> multiValued="true"/>
> <field name="genteaser" type="text" indexed="false" stored="true"/>
>
> Input doc:
> body:“On a brighter note, they have a phone number to call if you are
> interested in volunteering. You can call 860 - 690 - 4300 ext 2. (there
> are a lot of forms to fill out, and they are asking for info on when the
> babies are due) There was a lady in here yesterday asking how to
> volunteer. She is 2 - 3 months pregnant and wants to get her hands dirty.
> She says her husband will be home at the time, but can't drive, so she
> wants to be able to help out. So I told her the names of the people who
> are in charge, and also pointed her in the direction of a site where she
> can make an appointment to drop off some pre - packaged meals. I'll let
> you know what I hear from them when I do. One day I had not posted because
> all I was going to do was complain about how the morning sickness is
> wearing me out! Then I thought, I can make this an uplifting post, so I'll
> share with you about my friend Jackie, who I met in high school, who went
> through this 2 years ago with her first baby, Samuel."
>
>
> search with qf=searchablefield for q=“Samuel"
>
> HIT (OK)
> <copyField source="body" dest="genteaser" />
> <copyField source="body" dest="searchablefield"/>
>
> HIT (OK)
> <copyField source="body" dest="searchablefield" maxChars="3000000"/>
> <copyField source="body" dest="genteaser" maxChars="300"/>
>
> NT HIT (as expected)
> <copyField source="body" dest="searchablefield" maxChars="300"/>
> <copyField source="body" dest="genteaser" maxChars="300”/>
>
> NO HIT (BUG):
> <copyField source="body" dest="genteaser" maxChars="300"/>
> <copyField source="body" dest="searchablefield" maxChars="300000”/>
>
> NO HIT (BUG):
> <copyField source="body" dest="genteaser" maxChars="300"/>
> <copyField source="body" dest="searchablefield"/>
>
>
> We also clearly see this behaviour when viewing the documents.
>
> Fredrik
>
>
> --
>
> Fredrik Rødland
> Cell: +47 99 21 98 17
> Maisen Pedersens vei 1 Twitter: @fredrikr
> NO-1363 Høvik, NORWAY flickr:
> http://www.flickr.com/fmmr/
> http://rodland.no about.me http://about.me/fmr
>
>