Re: mod isapi

[Eduardo Franco <ed...@pulso.com.br>]

I think the better question would be: Since when I can't use mod_isapi under
Linux?

If I can compile it as a shared object... why not use it?!

I perfect use case for this would be:

I've a product for WIN + IIS it's a ISAPI extension/filter, now I've to
por it to Linux + Apache... to don't split my product into two components...
I decided to port the ISAPI extension/filter to linux and run it on mod_isapi
+ mod_filter (module I'd created to emulate the ISAPI filter).

Now it's just one Project for two plataforms... it's wonderful to manage!
:)

Ok! I'm a lunatic... but it save me a lot of time... But try it out with
gcc + Windows... you'll see the same error. It's a problem o language standard
not OS specific!

And the signature of the function in mod_isapi.h is different from the ISAPI
specification! Wich require a return type of int!

Best,

Eduardo Franco

>On Mon, 14 Jul 2003, Eduardo Franco wrote:
>
>> When I was trying to compile an ISAPI extendion under linux (with gcc
2.9.6
>> and apache 2.4.43, using the mod_isapi) I got the following error message.
>I
>> was mixing C++ with C (using extern "C" directive).
>>
>> /usr/src/apache/httpd-2.0.39/modules/arch/win32/mod_isapi.h:77: ISO C++
>> forbids declaration of
>> `PFN_GETEXTENSIONVERSION' with no type
>
>Since when can you use mod_isapi on Linux?  It's in modules/arch/win32/
>because it's only intended for use on Windows platforms.
>
>--Cliff
>

Re: mod isapi

[Eduardo Franco <ed...@pulso.com.br>]

Hi Bill!

I have to thank you and the people who worked in that module for the great
job! I'll wait for the next release!

Just another thing....

I was just wondering if there's any effort to create a module that emulate
the behaviour of the ISAPI filter. I had created a simple module, but it's
not fully implemented... it just emulate the SF_NOTIFY_PREPROC_HEADERS
event... the only one that I was using.

If there's anyone already working in anything similar, and need some help
with that, it would be nice to help!

Best,

--
Eduardo Franco

On Tuesday, July 15, 2003 4:23 PM [GMT-3:00=CET],
William A. Rowe, Jr. <wr...@rowe-clan.net> wrote:

> Eduardo,
>
>   thank you for making my day yesterday with your post :-)  And your
> great retort to Cliff ;->  I specifically redesigned isapi for
> exactly the case you are describing.
>
>   Yes, that's a problem, I'll commit a patch as soon as I am sure I'm
> happy with the choice of return type, later this afternoon.
>
> Bill

Re: mod isapi

[Cliff Woolley <jw...@virginia.edu>]

On Tue, 15 Jul 2003, William A. Rowe, Jr. wrote:

>   thank you for making my day yesterday with your post :-)  And your
> great retort to Cliff ;->  I specifically redesigned isapi for exactly the
> case you are describing.

/me grins ;)

Hey, if it works, it works... that was just news to me.  :-)

Re: mod isapi

["William A. Rowe, Jr." <wr...@rowe-clan.net>]

Eduardo,

  thank you for making my day yesterday with your post :-)  And your
great retort to Cliff ;->  I specifically redesigned isapi for exactly the
case you are describing.

  Yes, that's a problem, I'll commit a patch as soon as I am sure I'm
happy with the choice of return type, later this afternoon.

Bill



At 07:02 PM 7/14/2003, Eduardo Franco wrote:
>I think the better question would be: Since when I can't use mod_isapi under
>Linux?
>
>If I can compile it as a shared object... why not use it?!
>
>I perfect use case for this would be:
>
>I've a product for WIN + IIS it's a ISAPI extension/filter, now I've to
>por it to Linux + Apache... to don't split my product into two components...
>I decided to port the ISAPI extension/filter to linux and run it on mod_isapi
>+ mod_filter (module I'd created to emulate the ISAPI filter).
>
>Now it's just one Project for two plataforms... it's wonderful to manage!
>:)
>
>Ok! I'm a lunatic... but it save me a lot of time... But try it out with
>gcc + Windows... you'll see the same error. It's a problem o language standard
>not OS specific!
>
>And the signature of the function in mod_isapi.h is different from the ISAPI
>specification! Wich require a return type of int!
>
>Best,
>
>Eduardo Franco
>
>>On Mon, 14 Jul 2003, Eduardo Franco wrote:
>>
>>> When I was trying to compile an ISAPI extendion under linux (with gcc
>2.9.6
>>> and apache 2.4.43, using the mod_isapi) I got the following error message.
>>I
>>> was mixing C++ with C (using extern "C" directive).
>>>
>>> /usr/src/apache/httpd-2.0.39/modules/arch/win32/mod_isapi.h:77: ISO C++
>>> forbids declaration of
>>> `PFN_GETEXTENSIONVERSION' with no type
>>
>>Since when can you use mod_isapi on Linux?  It's in modules/arch/win32/
>>because it's only intended for use on Windows platforms.
>>
>>--Cliff
>>