You are viewing a plain text version of this content. The canonical link for it is here.
Posted to fop-dev@xmlgraphics.apache.org by "GISBERT Aurélien (DSIT-EX)" <au...@sncf.fr> on 2002/01/25 11:38:42 UTC
Choice of a XSL-Fo processor
I have to do a comparison between the different existing XSL-Fo processors.
I focused on these ones:
-FOP, Apache
-XEP, RenderX
-Antenna House XSL Processor
-PassiveTeX
Could you give me their "good and bad parts"?
Who support them?
What are the aims of each one about the XSL specification?
Finally, is there any other good XSL-Fo processors?
I understood that these 4 XSL-Fo processors were all compliant to the basic
conformance level in the W3C recommendation, and also to some of the objects
and properties of the extended level.
I would like to have your opinions. I have to transform an XML document into
a PDF file, using a specific model of presentation (first page, contents,
headers, titles, ...)
Regards
-----------------------
Aurelien Gisbert
Engineer student in the INSA of Lyon, France
Internee in the SNCF, France (working with Alain Herbuel, in the DSIT-EX
section)
---------------------------------------------------------------------
To unsubscribe, e-mail: fop-dev-unsubscribe@xml.apache.org
For additional commands, email: fop-dev-help@xml.apache.org
Re: Choice of a XSL-Fo processor
Posted by Patrick Andries <pa...@videotron.ca>.
Matt Savino wrote:
>Thanks Betty for filling in some of the blanks. (I was mixing up XEP and
>PassiveTex in a post I made earlier. I forgot XEP is RenderX.)
>
>I just had a couple of questions:
>
>Antenna House is Windows-only right?
>
>Do you think XEP's command line-driven approach would work within a J2EE
>internet application dynamically generating printable reports?
>
I believe XEP has an embeddable version but only for a fee.
>
>Apparently the reason my developer couldn't find an API to XEP is that
>there is none.
>
There is none freely available, but this is what I read this on their
support list some time ago :
«The commercial version of XEP
comes with a fourth document that describes various programming interfaces
available in XEP.
The evaluation version does not include the API documentation: it is meant
to let people assess formatting quality, memory footprint and performance.
In our view, detailed knowledge of API is not necessary for making a
purchase
decision.
Best regards,
Nikolai Grigoriev
RenderX»
---------------------------------------------------------------------
To unsubscribe, e-mail: fop-dev-unsubscribe@xml.apache.org
For additional commands, email: fop-dev-help@xml.apache.org
Re: Choice of a XSL-Fo processor
Posted by Matt Savino <ma...@synergizethis.com>.
Thanks Betty for filling in some of the blanks. (I was mixing up XEP and
PassiveTex in a post I made earlier. I forgot XEP is RenderX.)
I just had a couple of questions:
Antenna House is Windows-only right?
Do you think XEP's command line-driven approach would work within a J2EE
internet application dynamically generating printable reports?
Apparently the reason my developer couldn't find an API to XEP is that
there is none. I'd rather avoid hassling with temp files and calling
command line driven batch processes from within my application if I can
avoid it.
Thanks a lot for all your help.
-Matt
Betty Harvey wrote:
>
> Aurelien:
>
> I recently went through this exercise. I evaluated FOP, XEP and
> AntennaHouse. I didn't evaluate PassiveTex. I started putting together
> analysis sheet together of the different products but haven't completed it
> yet. For commercial projects I think both XEP and Antenna House work very
> well. XEP provided more of the functionality we required (internal and
> external linking and side navigation bar (extension to FO). Although I
> understand that Antenna House will have some of this functionality in the
> next release. However, you have to use a XSLT parser to create the FO
> file first. XEP is command-line driven. Another good feature of XEP and
> FOP is that it created the PDF and doesn't require Distiller. FOP also
> has a side-navigation bar extension.
>
> I liked Antenna Houses graphical user interface for the
> development of the XSL-FO. This is a nice development tool because
> you can see the results without creating a PDF file and opening
> the Reader to see the results. However, to create a PDF file you
> do need Distiller. I used the evaluation version of Antenna House
> recently to print training materials for a training class and I
> was very happy with the results.
>
> I originally created my XSL-FO file to work with XEP. I had
> one to change one attribute in the XSL file to get it to work
> with Antenna House ("fo:page-sequence master-reference" to
> "fo:page-sequence master-name"). I had to do major surgery to
> get it to work with FOP because of the unsupported features.
>
> Bottom line both XEP and Antenna House are good and seem
> very stable. If I get my analysis sheet completed I may post it
> if anyone is interested.
>
> Hope this helps.
>
> Betty
>
> On Fri, 25 Jan 2002, GISBERT Aurélien (DSIT-EX) wrote:
>
> >
> > I have to do a comparison between the different existing XSL-Fo processors.
> > I focused on these ones:
> > -FOP, Apache
> > -XEP, RenderX
> > -Antenna House XSL Processor
> > -PassiveTeX
> >
> > Could you give me their "good and bad parts"?
> > Who support them?
> > What are the aims of each one about the XSL specification?
> > Finally, is there any other good XSL-Fo processors?
> >
> > I understood that these 4 XSL-Fo processors were all compliant to the basic
> > conformance level in the W3C recommendation, and also to some of the objects
> > and properties of the extended level.
> >
> > I would like to have your opinions. I have to transform an XML document into
> > a PDF file, using a specific model of presentation (first page, contents,
> > headers, titles, ...)
> >
> > Regards
> >
> > -----------------------
> > Aurelien Gisbert
> > Engineer student in the INSA of Lyon, France
> > Internee in the SNCF, France (working with Alain Herbuel, in the DSIT-EX
> > section)
> >
> > ---------------------------------------------------------------------
> > To unsubscribe, e-mail: fop-dev-unsubscribe@xml.apache.org
> > For additional commands, email: fop-dev-help@xml.apache.org
> >
>
> ---------------------------------------------------------------------
> To unsubscribe, e-mail: fop-dev-unsubscribe@xml.apache.org
> For additional commands, email: fop-dev-help@xml.apache.org
---------------------------------------------------------------------
To unsubscribe, e-mail: fop-dev-unsubscribe@xml.apache.org
For additional commands, email: fop-dev-help@xml.apache.org
Re: Choice of a XSL-Fo processor
Posted by Betty Harvey <be...@eccnet.com>.
Aurelien:
I recently went through this exercise. I evaluated FOP, XEP and
AntennaHouse. I didn't evaluate PassiveTex. I started putting together
analysis sheet together of the different products but haven't completed it
yet. For commercial projects I think both XEP and Antenna House work very
well. XEP provided more of the functionality we required (internal and
external linking and side navigation bar (extension to FO). Although I
understand that Antenna House will have some of this functionality in the
next release. However, you have to use a XSLT parser to create the FO
file first. XEP is command-line driven. Another good feature of XEP and
FOP is that it created the PDF and doesn't require Distiller. FOP also
has a side-navigation bar extension.
I liked Antenna Houses graphical user interface for the
development of the XSL-FO. This is a nice development tool because
you can see the results without creating a PDF file and opening
the Reader to see the results. However, to create a PDF file you
do need Distiller. I used the evaluation version of Antenna House
recently to print training materials for a training class and I
was very happy with the results.
I originally created my XSL-FO file to work with XEP. I had
one to change one attribute in the XSL file to get it to work
with Antenna House ("fo:page-sequence master-reference" to
"fo:page-sequence master-name"). I had to do major surgery to
get it to work with FOP because of the unsupported features.
Bottom line both XEP and Antenna House are good and seem
very stable. If I get my analysis sheet completed I may post it
if anyone is interested.
Hope this helps.
Betty
On Fri, 25 Jan 2002, GISBERT Aurélien (DSIT-EX) wrote:
>
> I have to do a comparison between the different existing XSL-Fo processors.
> I focused on these ones:
> -FOP, Apache
> -XEP, RenderX
> -Antenna House XSL Processor
> -PassiveTeX
>
> Could you give me their "good and bad parts"?
> Who support them?
> What are the aims of each one about the XSL specification?
> Finally, is there any other good XSL-Fo processors?
>
> I understood that these 4 XSL-Fo processors were all compliant to the basic
> conformance level in the W3C recommendation, and also to some of the objects
> and properties of the extended level.
>
> I would like to have your opinions. I have to transform an XML document into
> a PDF file, using a specific model of presentation (first page, contents,
> headers, titles, ...)
>
> Regards
>
> -----------------------
> Aurelien Gisbert
> Engineer student in the INSA of Lyon, France
> Internee in the SNCF, France (working with Alain Herbuel, in the DSIT-EX
> section)
>
> ---------------------------------------------------------------------
> To unsubscribe, e-mail: fop-dev-unsubscribe@xml.apache.org
> For additional commands, email: fop-dev-help@xml.apache.org
>
---------------------------------------------------------------------
To unsubscribe, e-mail: fop-dev-unsubscribe@xml.apache.org
For additional commands, email: fop-dev-help@xml.apache.org