You are viewing a plain text version of this content. The canonical link for it is here.
Posted to qa@openoffice.apache.org by Ji Yan <ya...@gmail.com> on 2012/05/29 16:24:08 UTC
FYA new defect with tag [From Symphony]
Recently, a few defects(about 70+) opened with tag "[From Symphony]". I'd
like to share with you what we(Symphony test team) are doing and the
meaning of this tag.
In this week, we spent our effort on AOO interoperability testing, by
running sample files(both MS binary and xml file) loading and saving with
AOO. During this test we found there are some bugs exist in AOO but cannot
be reproduced in Symphony, so we filed issues in bugzilla with this tag
"[From Symphony]" to make everyone clear that specific problem only exist
in AOO but not in Symphony.
More and more defects will come out in the feature, if Symphony has no such
issue the tag will be added to identifyits origin.
Thanks & Best Regards, Yan Ji
Re: FYA new defect with tag [From Symphony]
Posted by Yan Ji <ya...@gmail.com>.
Regina,
The sample files generated by various version of MS Office including MS Office 2000, Office XP, Office 2003 and Office 2007. We tried to search issues before file in bugzilla, but keyword or search criteria maybe different, so there might be a few duplicate defects exist but hope not too many.
Thanks & Best Regards, Yan Ji
On May 29, 2012, at 11:24 PM, Regina Henschel wrote:
> Hi Yan Ji,
>
> Ji Yan schrieb:
>> Recently, a few defects(about 70+) opened with tag "[From Symphony]". I'd
>> like to share with you what we(Symphony test team) are doing and the
>> meaning of this tag.
>>
>> In this week, we spent our effort on AOO interoperability testing, by
>> running sample files(both MS binary and xml file) loading and saving with
>> AOO. During this test we found there are some bugs exist in AOO but cannot
>> be reproduced in Symphony, so we filed issues in bugzilla with this tag
>> "[From Symphony]" to make everyone clear that specific problem only exist
>> in AOO but not in Symphony.
>
> Could you please tell, how the files where generated, especially which Microsoft Office version you use to generate the file and which steps needed to generate such a file from scratch. I have got MS Office 2010, but I'm not familiar in using it. There might be differences between an Asian and Europe version of the MS Office suite. Therefore I will try to generate such files by myself.
>
> Have you already searched Bugzilla, whether the problem is already reported, when you report the bug?
>
> Kind regards
> Regina
>
Re: FYA new defect with tag [From Symphony]
Posted by Regina Henschel <rb...@t-online.de>.
Hi Yan Ji,
Ji Yan schrieb:
> Recently, a few defects(about 70+) opened with tag "[From Symphony]". I'd
> like to share with you what we(Symphony test team) are doing and the
> meaning of this tag.
>
> In this week, we spent our effort on AOO interoperability testing, by
> running sample files(both MS binary and xml file) loading and saving with
> AOO. During this test we found there are some bugs exist in AOO but cannot
> be reproduced in Symphony, so we filed issues in bugzilla with this tag
> "[From Symphony]" to make everyone clear that specific problem only exist
> in AOO but not in Symphony.
Could you please tell, how the files where generated, especially which
Microsoft Office version you use to generate the file and which steps
needed to generate such a file from scratch. I have got MS Office 2010,
but I'm not familiar in using it. There might be differences between an
Asian and Europe version of the MS Office suite. Therefore I will try to
generate such files by myself.
Have you already searched Bugzilla, whether the problem is already
reported, when you report the bug?
Kind regards
Regina
Re: FYA new defect with tag [From Symphony]
Posted by Regina Henschel <rb...@t-online.de>.
Hi,
Yong Lin Ma schrieb:
> They exist in AOO 3.4 release code. But has been fixed in Symphony.
Do you will bring this fixes to AOO? Then you should take this issues.
It can be disappointing to do QA on that issues with confirming, seeking
for duplicates, and tracking down the cause, just to notice, that there
is no need to do so.
Kind regards
Regina
>
> On Tue, May 29, 2012 at 10:53 PM, drew jensen
> <dr...@gmail.com> wrote:
>> On Tue, 2012-05-29 at 22:24 +0800, Ji Yan wrote:
>>> Recently, a few defects(about 70+) opened with tag "[From Symphony]". I'd
>>> like to share with you what we(Symphony test team) are doing and the
>>> meaning of this tag.
>>>
>>> In this week, we spent our effort on AOO interoperability testing, by
>>> running sample files(both MS binary and xml file) loading and saving with
>>> AOO. During this test we found there are some bugs exist in AOO but cannot
>>> be reproduced in Symphony, so we filed issues in bugzilla with this tag
>>> "[From Symphony]" to make everyone clear that specific problem only exist
>>> in AOO but not in Symphony.
>>>
>>> More and more defects will come out in the feature, if Symphony has no such
>>> issue the tag will be added to identifyits origin.
>>>
>>> Thanks& Best Regards, Yan Ji
>>
>> Hi,
>>
>> Do you mean they exist in the AOO release code, or in the AOO/Symphany
>> mashup code?
>>
>> Thanks
>>
>> //drew
>>
>>
>>
>
Re: FYA new defect with tag [From Symphony]
Posted by Yong Lin Ma <ma...@apache.org>.
They exist in AOO 3.4 release code. But has been fixed in Symphony.
On Tue, May 29, 2012 at 10:53 PM, drew jensen
<dr...@gmail.com> wrote:
> On Tue, 2012-05-29 at 22:24 +0800, Ji Yan wrote:
>> Recently, a few defects(about 70+) opened with tag "[From Symphony]". I'd
>> like to share with you what we(Symphony test team) are doing and the
>> meaning of this tag.
>>
>> In this week, we spent our effort on AOO interoperability testing, by
>> running sample files(both MS binary and xml file) loading and saving with
>> AOO. During this test we found there are some bugs exist in AOO but cannot
>> be reproduced in Symphony, so we filed issues in bugzilla with this tag
>> "[From Symphony]" to make everyone clear that specific problem only exist
>> in AOO but not in Symphony.
>>
>> More and more defects will come out in the feature, if Symphony has no such
>> issue the tag will be added to identifyits origin.
>>
>> Thanks & Best Regards, Yan Ji
>
> Hi,
>
> Do you mean they exist in the AOO release code, or in the AOO/Symphany
> mashup code?
>
> Thanks
>
> //drew
>
>
>
Re: FYA new defect with tag [From Symphony]
Posted by drew jensen <dr...@gmail.com>.
On Tue, 2012-05-29 at 22:24 +0800, Ji Yan wrote:
> Recently, a few defects(about 70+) opened with tag "[From Symphony]". I'd
> like to share with you what we(Symphony test team) are doing and the
> meaning of this tag.
>
> In this week, we spent our effort on AOO interoperability testing, by
> running sample files(both MS binary and xml file) loading and saving with
> AOO. During this test we found there are some bugs exist in AOO but cannot
> be reproduced in Symphony, so we filed issues in bugzilla with this tag
> "[From Symphony]" to make everyone clear that specific problem only exist
> in AOO but not in Symphony.
>
> More and more defects will come out in the feature, if Symphony has no such
> issue the tag will be added to identifyits origin.
>
> Thanks & Best Regards, Yan Ji
Hi,
Do you mean they exist in the AOO release code, or in the AOO/Symphany
mashup code?
Thanks
//drew
Re: FYA new defect with tag [From Symphony]
Posted by drew jensen <dr...@gmail.com>.
On Tue, 2012-05-29 at 22:24 +0800, Ji Yan wrote:
> Recently, a few defects(about 70+) opened with tag "[From Symphony]". I'd
> like to share with you what we(Symphony test team) are doing and the
> meaning of this tag.
>
> In this week, we spent our effort on AOO interoperability testing, by
> running sample files(both MS binary and xml file) loading and saving with
> AOO. During this test we found there are some bugs exist in AOO but cannot
> be reproduced in Symphony, so we filed issues in bugzilla with this tag
> "[From Symphony]" to make everyone clear that specific problem only exist
> in AOO but not in Symphony.
>
> More and more defects will come out in the feature, if Symphony has no such
> issue the tag will be added to identifyits origin.
>
> Thanks & Best Regards, Yan Ji
Hi,
Do you mean they exist in the AOO release code, or in the AOO/Symphany
mashup code?
Thanks
//drew