[1.5.1] Blockers and Critical issues

[Emmanuel Lecharny <el...@gmail.com>]

Hi guys,

I have done my homeworks and browsed JIRA to harvest the bugs we still
have. The bad news is that we have a lot of them, the good news is
that we only have 2 blockrs and 1 criticals remaining. Here they are :

1.5.1 issues :
------------
2 blockers
4 criticals
48 majors
10 minors
1 trivial

Only 30 are bugs.

_but_ since 1.5.0,
63 fixed issues, out of it :
6 were blockers,
4 were criticals,
33 were majors
18 were minors
and 3 were trivials

Remaining blockers :
--------------------
* [DIRSERVER-832] - Added Attributes are all case sensitive

This issue's title is deceptive... The pb is much wider than simply
case sensitivity. I'm not sure it can be fixed in 1.5.1, if we are to
realease before the end of august. I would suggest a postpone.

* [DIRSERVER-951] - Negated filter on indexed attribute doesn't find
entries without attribute
Not an easy one, but we can expect to fix it for 1.5.1. Anyone ?

Remaining criticals :
---------------------
Out of 4 criticals, we have only 1 bug, otherwise there are 2 tasks
and one improvement.

* [DIRSERVER-928] - Comparator may fail
This is a class which is instanciated 25 times in the code, when we
need a comparator for a specific Attribute. I think we should use a
specific comparator instead of this generic one, because its logic is
broken : if none of the objects implement Comparable, then it ends
with a o1.hashCode() - o2.hashCode(). The pb is that it's not because
o1.hashCode() == o2.hashCode() that both objects are equals...

Remaining majors :
------------------
23 of those guys, if we consider only the bugs. I will create a
commented list tomorrow, but the best would be to check on JIRA.

-- 
Regards,
Cordialement,
Emmanuel Lécharny
www.iktek.com

Re: [1.5.1] Blockers and Critical issues

[Alex Karasulu <ak...@apache.org>]

Hey E!  Thanks for this.


On 8/15/07, Emmanuel Lecharny <el...@gmail.com> wrote:
>
> Hi guys,
>
> I have done my homeworks and browsed JIRA to harvest the bugs we still
> have. The bad news is that we have a lot of them, the good news is
> that we only have 2 blockrs and 1 criticals remaining. Here they are :


I'll start looking at these blocker and critical bugs.

1.5.1 issues :
> ------------
> 2 blockers
> 4 criticals
> 48 majors
> 10 minors
> 1 trivial
>
> Only 30 are bugs.
>
> _but_ since 1.5.0,
> 63 fixed issues, out of it :
> 6 were blockers,
> 4 were criticals,
> 33 were majors
> 18 were minors
> and 3 were trivials
>
> Remaining blockers :
> --------------------
> * [DIRSERVER-832] - Added Attributes are all case sensitive
>
> This issue's title is deceptive... The pb is much wider than simply
> case sensitivity. I'm not sure it can be fixed in 1.5.1, if we are to
> realease before the end of august. I would suggest a postpone.
>
> * [DIRSERVER-951] - Negated filter on indexed attribute doesn't find
> entries without attribute
> Not an easy one, but we can expect to fix it for 1.5.1. Anyone ?
>
> Remaining criticals :
> ---------------------
> Out of 4 criticals, we have only 1 bug, otherwise there are 2 tasks
> and one improvement.
>
> * [DIRSERVER-928] - Comparator may fail
> This is a class which is instanciated 25 times in the code, when we
> need a comparator for a specific Attribute. I think we should use a
> specific comparator instead of this generic one, because its logic is
> broken : if none of the objects implement Comparable, then it ends
> with a o1.hashCode() - o2.hashCode(). The pb is that it's not because
> o1.hashCode() == o2.hashCode() that both objects are equals...
>
> Remaining majors :
> ------------------
> 23 of those guys, if we consider only the bugs. I will create a
> commented list tomorrow, but the best would be to check on JIRA.


Will do.  Putting on the Conan music now to slay the bugs:
http://safehaus.org/~akarasulu/conan.mp3

:-D

Alex