You are viewing a plain text version of this content. The canonical link for it is here.
Posted to dev@subversion.apache.org by Daniel Shahaf <d....@daniel.shahaf.name> on 2017/02/04 16:53:46 UTC
Low level of activity (was: Re: svn commit: r74422 -
/pmc/subversion/reports/201702.txt)
I wrote the following in a thread on private@, but the issue need not be
discussed confidentially:
Daniel Shahaf wrote on Fri, Feb 03, 2017 at 18:05:27 +0000:
> I've noticed that some threads don't happen.
>
> Examples:
>
> - stefan2 solicited reviews of his authz branch. None happened.
>
> - SVN-4670 was filed with a trivial patch. Nothing happened.
>
> What worries me isn't the reduced activity \u2014 that's to be expected \u2014 but
> the complete *lack* of activity around these and other threads. That
> activity level is lower than I would expect, even taking into account
> that we're now mostly volunteer-run.
Cheers,
Daniel
Re: Low level of activity
Posted by Daniel Shahaf <d....@daniel.shahaf.name>.
Branko \u010cibej wrote on Sun, Feb 05, 2017 at 23:30:24 +0100:
> On 05.02.2017 22:22, Branko \u010cibej wrote:
> > On 05.02.2017 22:02, Stefan wrote:
> >> Wouldn't it be possible to also consider getting some
> >> funding/sponsorship/donations?
To elaborate on Brane's reply: the ASF as an organization doesn't fund
development; funding, when present, is expected to be handled directly
between the funders (companies) and fundees (developers being paid).
Nothing stops a consortium of interested parties from pooling their
resources to fund someone's work on feature�X, but that is expected to
happen "out of band", not on any *.apache.org place but directly between
those interested parties and that developer.
Cheers,
Daniel
> >> If enough money gets donated maybe some of the existing committers could
> >> arrange something with their dayjobs (as in being able to work like 20%
> >> on SVN) and therefore be able to contribute more time on SVN than they
> >> can right now?
> >>
> >> Also if some specific features would be put up as examples for
> >> committers who would volunteer to work on a feature, that might be
> >> caught up by companies who are willing to pay for getting the feature
> >> into the subversion core (LuaJIT used that approach, for instance, quite
> >> successfully).
> > The ASF does not accept donations toward any particular project. Whilst
> > we might encourage companies to fund individual developers, we solicit
> > donations for specific features.
>
> I mean "can't solicit" of course.
>
> -- Brane
>
Re: Low level of activity
Posted by Branko Čibej <br...@apache.org>.
On 05.02.2017 22:22, Branko \u010cibej wrote:
> On 05.02.2017 22:02, Stefan wrote:
>> On 2/5/2017 15:45, Stefan Fuhrmann wrote:
>>> On 04.02.2017 17:53, Daniel Shahaf wrote:
>>>> I wrote the following in a thread on private@, but the issue need not be
>>>> discussed confidentially:
>>>>
>>>> Daniel Shahaf wrote on Fri, Feb 03, 2017 at 18:05:27 +0000:
>>>>> I've noticed that some threads don't happen.
>>>>>
>>>>> Examples:
>>>>>
>>>>> - stefan2 solicited reviews of his authz branch. None happened.
>>>>>
>>>>> - SVN-4670 was filed with a trivial patch. Nothing happened.
>>>>>
>>>>> What worries me isn't the reduced activity \u2014 that's to be expected \u2014
>>>>> but
>>>>> the complete *lack* of activity around these and other threads. That
>>>>> activity level is lower than I would expect, even taking into account
>>>>> that we're now mostly volunteer-run.
>>> Since more or less all committers contribute in their
>>> spare time these days, not only the "intensity" of
>>> interaction will go down.
>>>
>>> What we do see instead is that people appear to be
>>> very active for a short period of time - a day or two -
>>> and then become silent for a longer period of time,
>>> maybe for weeks at a time. Those periods of activity
>>> often don't overlap, which makes interaction harder.
>>> The amount of back and forth discussion will probably
>>> go down.
>>>
>>> I think that as a community, we need to adapt our
>>> expectations / communication to that new pattern.
>>> Things that might help:
>>>
>>> * Allow for at least 2 weeks of reaction time for
>>> silent consensus etc.
>>>
>>> * Send an notification post to dev@ before starting
>>> some larger work - people may not follow commits
>>> closely anymore. Not as a vote or anything but simply
>>> to keep people in the loop.
>>>
>>> * "Ping" a thread that you _really_ want feedback on
>>> after 2+ weeks of inactivity.
>>>
>>> None of these need to be codified; they seem like
>>> pretty common sense for a project with much more
>>> asynchronism.
>>>
>>> -- Stefan^2.
>> Wouldn't it be possible to also consider getting some
>> funding/sponsorship/donations?
>>
>> If enough money gets donated maybe some of the existing committers could
>> arrange something with their dayjobs (as in being able to work like 20%
>> on SVN) and therefore be able to contribute more time on SVN than they
>> can right now?
>>
>> Also if some specific features would be put up as examples for
>> committers who would volunteer to work on a feature, that might be
>> caught up by companies who are willing to pay for getting the feature
>> into the subversion core (LuaJIT used that approach, for instance, quite
>> successfully).
> The ASF does not accept donations toward any particular project. Whilst
> we might encourage companies to fund individual developers, we solicit
> donations for specific features.
I mean "can't solicit" of course.
-- Brane
Re: Low level of activity
Posted by Branko Čibej <br...@apache.org>.
On 05.02.2017 22:02, Stefan wrote:
> On 2/5/2017 15:45, Stefan Fuhrmann wrote:
>> On 04.02.2017 17:53, Daniel Shahaf wrote:
>>> I wrote the following in a thread on private@, but the issue need not be
>>> discussed confidentially:
>>>
>>> Daniel Shahaf wrote on Fri, Feb 03, 2017 at 18:05:27 +0000:
>>>> I've noticed that some threads don't happen.
>>>>
>>>> Examples:
>>>>
>>>> - stefan2 solicited reviews of his authz branch. None happened.
>>>>
>>>> - SVN-4670 was filed with a trivial patch. Nothing happened.
>>>>
>>>> What worries me isn't the reduced activity \u2014 that's to be expected \u2014
>>>> but
>>>> the complete *lack* of activity around these and other threads. That
>>>> activity level is lower than I would expect, even taking into account
>>>> that we're now mostly volunteer-run.
>> Since more or less all committers contribute in their
>> spare time these days, not only the "intensity" of
>> interaction will go down.
>>
>> What we do see instead is that people appear to be
>> very active for a short period of time - a day or two -
>> and then become silent for a longer period of time,
>> maybe for weeks at a time. Those periods of activity
>> often don't overlap, which makes interaction harder.
>> The amount of back and forth discussion will probably
>> go down.
>>
>> I think that as a community, we need to adapt our
>> expectations / communication to that new pattern.
>> Things that might help:
>>
>> * Allow for at least 2 weeks of reaction time for
>> silent consensus etc.
>>
>> * Send an notification post to dev@ before starting
>> some larger work - people may not follow commits
>> closely anymore. Not as a vote or anything but simply
>> to keep people in the loop.
>>
>> * "Ping" a thread that you _really_ want feedback on
>> after 2+ weeks of inactivity.
>>
>> None of these need to be codified; they seem like
>> pretty common sense for a project with much more
>> asynchronism.
>>
>> -- Stefan^2.
> Wouldn't it be possible to also consider getting some
> funding/sponsorship/donations?
>
> If enough money gets donated maybe some of the existing committers could
> arrange something with their dayjobs (as in being able to work like 20%
> on SVN) and therefore be able to contribute more time on SVN than they
> can right now?
>
> Also if some specific features would be put up as examples for
> committers who would volunteer to work on a feature, that might be
> caught up by companies who are willing to pay for getting the feature
> into the subversion core (LuaJIT used that approach, for instance, quite
> successfully).
The ASF does not accept donations toward any particular project. Whilst
we might encourage companies to fund individual developers, we solicit
donations for specific features.
-- Brane
Re: Low level of activity
Posted by Stefan <lu...@posteo.de>.
On 2/5/2017 15:45, Stefan Fuhrmann wrote:
> On 04.02.2017 17:53, Daniel Shahaf wrote:
>> I wrote the following in a thread on private@, but the issue need not be
>> discussed confidentially:
>>
>> Daniel Shahaf wrote on Fri, Feb 03, 2017 at 18:05:27 +0000:
>>> I've noticed that some threads don't happen.
>>>
>>> Examples:
>>>
>>> - stefan2 solicited reviews of his authz branch. None happened.
>>>
>>> - SVN-4670 was filed with a trivial patch. Nothing happened.
>>>
>>> What worries me isn't the reduced activity — that's to be expected —
>>> but
>>> the complete *lack* of activity around these and other threads. That
>>> activity level is lower than I would expect, even taking into account
>>> that we're now mostly volunteer-run.
>
> Since more or less all committers contribute in their
> spare time these days, not only the "intensity" of
> interaction will go down.
>
> What we do see instead is that people appear to be
> very active for a short period of time - a day or two -
> and then become silent for a longer period of time,
> maybe for weeks at a time. Those periods of activity
> often don't overlap, which makes interaction harder.
> The amount of back and forth discussion will probably
> go down.
>
> I think that as a community, we need to adapt our
> expectations / communication to that new pattern.
> Things that might help:
>
> * Allow for at least 2 weeks of reaction time for
> silent consensus etc.
>
> * Send an notification post to dev@ before starting
> some larger work - people may not follow commits
> closely anymore. Not as a vote or anything but simply
> to keep people in the loop.
>
> * "Ping" a thread that you _really_ want feedback on
> after 2+ weeks of inactivity.
>
> None of these need to be codified; they seem like
> pretty common sense for a project with much more
> asynchronism.
>
> -- Stefan^2.
Wouldn't it be possible to also consider getting some
funding/sponsorship/donations?
If enough money gets donated maybe some of the existing committers could
arrange something with their dayjobs (as in being able to work like 20%
on SVN) and therefore be able to contribute more time on SVN than they
can right now?
Also if some specific features would be put up as examples for
committers who would volunteer to work on a feature, that might be
caught up by companies who are willing to pay for getting the feature
into the subversion core (LuaJIT used that approach, for instance, quite
successfully).
Regards,
Stefan
Re: Low level of activity
Posted by Stefan Fuhrmann <st...@apache.org>.
On 04.02.2017 17:53, Daniel Shahaf wrote:
> I wrote the following in a thread on private@, but the issue need not be
> discussed confidentially:
>
> Daniel Shahaf wrote on Fri, Feb 03, 2017 at 18:05:27 +0000:
>> I've noticed that some threads don't happen.
>>
>> Examples:
>>
>> - stefan2 solicited reviews of his authz branch. None happened.
>>
>> - SVN-4670 was filed with a trivial patch. Nothing happened.
>>
>> What worries me isn't the reduced activity \u2014 that's to be expected \u2014 but
>> the complete *lack* of activity around these and other threads. That
>> activity level is lower than I would expect, even taking into account
>> that we're now mostly volunteer-run.
Since more or less all committers contribute in their
spare time these days, not only the "intensity" of
interaction will go down.
What we do see instead is that people appear to be
very active for a short period of time - a day or two -
and then become silent for a longer period of time,
maybe for weeks at a time. Those periods of activity
often don't overlap, which makes interaction harder.
The amount of back and forth discussion will probably
go down.
I think that as a community, we need to adapt our
expectations / communication to that new pattern.
Things that might help:
* Allow for at least 2 weeks of reaction time for
silent consensus etc.
* Send an notification post to dev@ before starting
some larger work - people may not follow commits
closely anymore. Not as a vote or anything but simply
to keep people in the loop.
* "Ping" a thread that you _really_ want feedback on
after 2+ weeks of inactivity.
None of these need to be codified; they seem like
pretty common sense for a project with much more
asynchronism.
-- Stefan^2.
Re: Low level of activity
Posted by Garance A Drosehn <dr...@rpi.edu>.
On 6 Feb 2017, at 3:58, Stefan Sperling wrote:
> On Sun, Feb 05, 2017 at 07:21:21PM +0000, Daniel Shahaf wrote:
>> Stefan Sperling wrote on Sat, Feb 04, 2017 at 20:03:36 +0100:
>>> You may have gotten used to a level of activity which was made
>>> possible by several full-time employment positions [...]
>>
>> Just to be clear, I wasn't comparing our activity level of today
>> to our activity level a few years ago; I was comparing our activity
>> level of today to other volunteer-run projects.
>
> Which other projects? At this point, any other project with more
> than 5 very active developers is way beyond our ballpark.
You also have to look at those volunteers in those projects. For
awhile I was quite active contributing to FreeBSD, but that's at
least partially because RPI was willing to pay my salary for
improvements to lpr/lpd. They weren't paying me to work *on*
FreeBSD, but I could improve lpr/lpd on RPI's time (because RPI
depends a lot on those programs), and then do all the "contribute
to FreeBSD" work on my own time.
(note that RPI doesn't use FreeBSD in any production services,
but I was building FreeBSD's lpr/lpd on other platforms, and
then adding extra features to that)
So this project would be helped if there were companies who found
there was some significant feature that they needed in subversion,
even though they aren't paying anyone *to* work on it. So there
may be less activity in subversion simply because it's "good
enough" for what most companies use it for.
--
Garance Alistair Drosehn = drosih@rpi.edu
Senior Systems Programmer or gad@FreeBSD.org
Rensselaer Polytechnic Institute; Troy, NY; USA
Re: Low level of activity (was: Re: svn commit: r74422 -
/pmc/subversion/reports/201702.txt)
Posted by Stefan Sperling <st...@elego.de>.
On Sun, Feb 05, 2017 at 07:21:21PM +0000, Daniel Shahaf wrote:
> Stefan Sperling wrote on Sat, Feb 04, 2017 at 20:03:36 +0100:
> > You may have gotten used to a level of activity which was made possible
> > by several full-time employment positions [...]
>
> Just to be clear, I wasn't comparing our activity level of today to our
> activity level a few years ago; I was comparing our activity level of
> today to other volunteer-run projects.
Which other projects? At this point, any other project with more than
5 very active developers is way beyond our ballpark.
Re: Low level of activity (was: Re: svn commit: r74422 -
/pmc/subversion/reports/201702.txt)
Posted by Daniel Shahaf <d....@daniel.shahaf.name>.
Stefan Sperling wrote on Sat, Feb 04, 2017 at 20:03:36 +0100:
> You may have gotten used to a level of activity which was made possible
> by several full-time employment positions [...]
Just to be clear, I wasn't comparing our activity level of today to our
activity level a few years ago; I was comparing our activity level of
today to other volunteer-run projects.
Re: Low level of activity (was: Re: svn commit: r74422 -
/pmc/subversion/reports/201702.txt)
Posted by Stefan Sperling <st...@elego.de>.
On Sat, Feb 04, 2017 at 04:53:46PM +0000, Daniel Shahaf wrote:
> I wrote the following in a thread on private@, but the issue need not be
> discussed confidentially:
>
> Daniel Shahaf wrote on Fri, Feb 03, 2017 at 18:05:27 +0000:
> > I've noticed that some threads don't happen.
> >
> > Examples:
> >
> > - stefan2 solicited reviews of his authz branch. None happened.
> >
> > - SVN-4670 was filed with a trivial patch. Nothing happened.
> >
> > What worries me isn't the reduced activity \u2014 that's to be expected \u2014 but
> > the complete *lack* of activity around these and other threads. That
> > activity level is lower than I would expect, even taking into account
> > that we're now mostly volunteer-run.
>
> Cheers,
>
> Daniel
Well, I suppose people simply have their priorities.
You may have gotten used to a level of activity which was made possible
by several full-time employment positions with a lot of creative freedom.
Nowadays, as far as I know, we're all volunteers, with paid development
being a rare exception. I don't think this is a real problem. It's simply
what happens when people have less time to spend on this project, and
when those who get funding can't choose to do whatever they want but get
funded for specific things (as was the case with funding I got for working
on the conflict resolver, for example -- which BTW is over since Jan 31st).
What we can do is keep asking each other for help, and take all the help
we can get :)