You are viewing a plain text version of this content. The canonical link for it is here.
Posted to user@guacamole.apache.org by Jason Keltz <ja...@yorku.ca> on 2025/12/05 15:40:08 UTC
guacamole on RHEL10 with RDP
Hi.
We use Apache Guacamole to allow our users to access various servers and workstations remotely using RDP. For RDP on our Linux systems, we use XRDP+XorgXRDP. All of our Linux systems run RHEL8 (well, Rocky 8). RHEL8 is out of full support mode now, so it's time to move on. RHEL9 will be out of full support in May 2027, and since the upgrade process is extremely lengthy, I want to skip right to RHEL10. However, there's a big problem - Red Hat has removed xorg support from the distribution, and we're left with just Wayland. That's all fine - Wayland is maturing - but XRDP doesn't yet support Wayland. We need to find a solution with RHEL10. We need to be able to maintain users ability to run GNOME remotely, cut and paste from local to remote system, maintain disconnected sessions so that users don't lose their session after disconnected. I don't think the solution is so easy.
I understand that GNOME now includes built in RDP support, but from what I understand, it has to be configured for each user, each user has a separate password for it, and I believe (thought I could be wrong) that it's meant for users to connect to an existing local session remotely. Most users are accessing our systems remotely without having a local session open.
I was looking into solutions — possibly an RDP or VNC server that supports Wayland. I see there's something called "wayvnc", but it doesn't support GNOME, and for consistency, I'd really like the users to be able to access their similar environment remotely.
If anyone has any suggestions, I'd really love to hear them.
Jason.
Re: guacamole on RHEL10 with RDP
Posted by Jason Keltz <ja...@yorku.ca>.
Hi Nick,
Just to clarify in case my message wasn't clear - you do configure an rdp username and password on the system, and then you add that to guac username/password fields instead of $GUAC_USERNAME/$GUAC_PASSWORD... so when you select the host In guac, it does have to pass the username and password in, but now you're just starting at GDM on the host. So they are using the RDP auth mechanism - just not the way that I'm used to it being used. I wonder if anyone has managed to work around that, or whether that's possible. It's a pity that RHEL10 did away with optional Xorg support.
Jason.
________________________________
From: Nick Couchman <vn...@apache.org>
Sent: Friday, December 5, 2025 1:43 PM
To: user@guacamole.apache.org <us...@guacamole.apache.org>
Subject: Re: guacamole on RHEL10 with RDP
On Fri, Dec 5, 2025 at 1:39 PM Jason Keltz <ja...@yorku.ca> wrote:
>
> I can respond to a few of my own questions...
>
> I installed a RHEL10 system for testing, and discovered that I can enable multi-user support with GNOME RDP, and users can use their regular username and password to login.
>
> Disadvantages: 1) After logging into Guac, and selecting a host, the user gets the GDM screen where they have to re-enter their username and password! It doesn't look like you can pass in the username and password from guac as I've always done with XRDP. This is super unintuitive for users who have just been logging into guac, and then clicking through to various hosts without having to re-enter their username and password each time. 2) It doesn't look like sound works. 3) I had to use guac 1.6.0 on my test host, guac 1.5.5 does not work (but I haven't been able to upgrade to 1.6.0 on my main host due to a bug). Not sure about performance yet. Still would love to hear from people with other solutions.
>
Jason,
Thanks for responding back with this information. Just a couple of
quick thoughts:
* Regarding credential pass-through, this might be something to ask on
the Gnome mailing list or forum, or perhaps ask Red Hat if you have a
support agreement with them, as I would expect this impacts RDP
clients other than Guacamole - that is, you probably can't run
xfreerdp or Microsoft Remote Desktop Client and access a RHEL10 system
running multi-user mode and expect credential pass-through to work
from those clients, either.
* Regarding the issue with Guacamole 1.5.5 not working with Gnome RDP
- my understanding is that Gnome RDP actually requires the GFX
Pipeline (formerly RemoteFX) to function properly, and that was only
implemented in Guacamole 1.6.0 as part of the reworking of the
rendering engine.
-Nick
---------------------------------------------------------------------
To unsubscribe, e-mail: user-unsubscribe@guacamole.apache.org
For additional commands, e-mail: user-help@guacamole.apache.org
Re: guacamole on RHEL10 with RDP
Posted by Nick Couchman <vn...@apache.org>.
On Fri, Dec 5, 2025 at 1:39 PM Jason Keltz <ja...@yorku.ca> wrote:
>
> I can respond to a few of my own questions...
>
> I installed a RHEL10 system for testing, and discovered that I can enable multi-user support with GNOME RDP, and users can use their regular username and password to login.
>
> Disadvantages: 1) After logging into Guac, and selecting a host, the user gets the GDM screen where they have to re-enter their username and password! It doesn't look like you can pass in the username and password from guac as I've always done with XRDP. This is super unintuitive for users who have just been logging into guac, and then clicking through to various hosts without having to re-enter their username and password each time. 2) It doesn't look like sound works. 3) I had to use guac 1.6.0 on my test host, guac 1.5.5 does not work (but I haven't been able to upgrade to 1.6.0 on my main host due to a bug). Not sure about performance yet. Still would love to hear from people with other solutions.
>
Jason,
Thanks for responding back with this information. Just a couple of
quick thoughts:
* Regarding credential pass-through, this might be something to ask on
the Gnome mailing list or forum, or perhaps ask Red Hat if you have a
support agreement with them, as I would expect this impacts RDP
clients other than Guacamole - that is, you probably can't run
xfreerdp or Microsoft Remote Desktop Client and access a RHEL10 system
running multi-user mode and expect credential pass-through to work
from those clients, either.
* Regarding the issue with Guacamole 1.5.5 not working with Gnome RDP
- my understanding is that Gnome RDP actually requires the GFX
Pipeline (formerly RemoteFX) to function properly, and that was only
implemented in Guacamole 1.6.0 as part of the reworking of the
rendering engine.
-Nick
---------------------------------------------------------------------
To unsubscribe, e-mail: user-unsubscribe@guacamole.apache.org
For additional commands, e-mail: user-help@guacamole.apache.org
Re: guacamole on RHEL10 with RDP
Posted by Jason Keltz <ja...@yorku.ca>.
I can respond to a few of my own questions...
I installed a RHEL10 system for testing, and discovered that I can enable multi-user support with GNOME RDP, and users can use their regular username and password to login.
Disadvantages: 1) After logging into Guac, and selecting a host, the user gets the GDM screen where they have to re-enter their username and password! It doesn't look like you can pass in the username and password from guac as I've always done with XRDP. This is super unintuitive for users who have just been logging into guac, and then clicking through to various hosts without having to re-enter their username and password each time. 2) It doesn't look like sound works. 3) I had to use guac 1.6.0 on my test host, guac 1.5.5 does not work (but I haven't been able to upgrade to 1.6.0 on my main host due to a bug). Not sure about performance yet. Still would love to hear from people with other solutions.
Jason.
Jason Keltz
Computer Development Manager
Department of Electrical Engineering and Computer Science
York University
Toronto, Ontario Canada
Tel: (416) 736-2100 x. 33570
Fax: (416) 736-5872
________________________________
From: Jason Keltz <ja...@yorku.ca>
Sent: Friday, December 5, 2025 10:40 AM
To: user <us...@guacamole.apache.org>
Subject: guacamole on RHEL10 with RDP
Hi.
We use Apache Guacamole to allow our users to access various servers and workstations remotely using RDP. For RDP on our Linux systems, we use XRDP+XorgXRDP. All of our Linux systems run RHEL8 (well, Rocky 8). RHEL8 is out of full support mode now, so it's time to move on. RHEL9 will be out of full support in May 2027, and since the upgrade process is extremely lengthy, I want to skip right to RHEL10. However, there's a big problem - Red Hat has removed xorg support from the distribution, and we're left with just Wayland. That's all fine - Wayland is maturing - but XRDP doesn't yet support Wayland. We need to find a solution with RHEL10. We need to be able to maintain users ability to run GNOME remotely, cut and paste from local to remote system, maintain disconnected sessions so that users don't lose their session after disconnected. I don't think the solution is so easy.
I understand that GNOME now includes built in RDP support, but from what I understand, it has to be configured for each user, each user has a separate password for it, and I believe (thought I could be wrong) that it's meant for users to connect to an existing local session remotely. Most users are accessing our systems remotely without having a local session open.
I was looking into solutions — possibly an RDP or VNC server that supports Wayland. I see there's something called "wayvnc", but it doesn't support GNOME, and for consistency, I'd really like the users to be able to access their similar environment remotely.
If anyone has any suggestions, I'd really love to hear them.
Jason.