You are viewing a plain text version of this content. The canonical link for it is here.
Posted to users@subversion.apache.org by Kalin KOZHUHAROV <ka...@thinrope.net> on 2005/08/22 16:22:47 UTC

Books on subverison [was Re: Need SVN -> VSS converter]

William Nagel wrote:
> Actually, I have considered publishing in a more "fixed" resource:
> 
> http://www.amazon.com/exec/obidos/tg/detail/-/0131855182/ref=ase_williamnageln-20/104-1760436-5604716?v=glance&s=books
> 
> I wrote that post off the top of my head, but much of the info in  there 
> is conveyed in a similar manner in my book.

Now, I understand why you have the style to write such posts "off the 
top of your head" :-)

I have recently read "Pragmatic Version Control Using Subversion" and I 
found that a very good starter for somebody with almost no knowledge of 
subversion (and little CVS experience). It helped me fill those spots 
left blank when I had to jump head-first into moving a few big VSS 
projects into subversion. The only down-side was missing new features 
(locking!) as the book is written for svn-1.1.1 apparently.

So, now I am into the position to manage a few svn repos for a few teams 
and I am trying to get "everything unsder subversion" as server setting 
and $HOME dirs. So far, with the on-line subversion book, this ML and 
#svn irc, I kind of manage it. But a good book is a good book, will have 
to check it.

So may be you (or somebody else) could try to differentiate "Subversion 
Version Control" from the (contetns of the) on-line "Version Control 
with Subversion" and probably "Pragmatic Version Control Using Subversion"?

Did we miss another book?
Has anybody read all/many books on subversion? It will be a very good 
resource to compare them, not to rate them, but to say what is specific 
and good/missing in every book.

As a start:

ISBN: 0974514063 (2005-02-01, 224 pages)
Pragmatic Version Control Using Subversion by Mike Mason
= very good for no experience users/future admins
= read it as one whole story
+ good style, fun to read
- not that great as a reference ( I just prefer grep-ing/google-ing)
- a bit outdated, subversion-1.1.1 (no locking discussed)
! Probably best to read this book _before_ ever trying to play with 
subversion
.


ISBN: 0131855182 (2005-05-16, 368 pages)
Subversion Version Control : Using the Subversion Version Control System 
in Development Projects by William Nagel
.

ISBN: 1590592905 (2004-11-15, 336 pages)
Practical Subversion by Garrett Rooney
.


ISBN: 0596004486 (2004-07-22, 304 pages)
Version Control with Subversion by C. Michael Pilato, et.al.
! Available on-line, may be the best reference as of today
.


You get my idea of "format" :-) Feel free to change it, but please stick 
with a format for easy post processing.
I might try to compile a web page out of that (if permission to include 
the comments posted here is granted) depending on the interest.

Authors, don't be shy and sell your works. People always need good books!

Kalin.

-- 
|[ ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ ]|
+-> http://ThinRope.net/ <-+
|[ ______________________ ]|

---------------------------------------------------------------------
To unsubscribe, e-mail: users-unsubscribe@subversion.tigris.org
For additional commands, e-mail: users-help@subversion.tigris.org

Re: Books on subverison [was Re: Need SVN -> VSS converter]

Posted by Ben Collins-Sussman <su...@collab.net>.
The list of all known SVN books is on the 'links' page:

     http://subversion.tigris.org/project_links.html

And (long ago) I wrote a review of Garrett Rooney's book, "Practical  
Subversion":

     http://www.amazon.com/exec/obidos/tg/detail/-/1590592905/ 
qid=1124731958/sr=8-1/ref=pd_bbs_1/104-0398232-0795901? 
v=glance&s=books&n=507846



---------------------------------------------------------------------
To unsubscribe, e-mail: users-unsubscribe@subversion.tigris.org
For additional commands, e-mail: users-help@subversion.tigris.org

Re: Books on subverison [was Re: Need SVN -> VSS converter]

Posted by William Nagel <bi...@stagelogic.com>.
On Aug 22, 2005, at 11:22 AM, Kalin KOZHUHAROV wrote:

> William Nagel wrote:
>
>> Actually, I have considered publishing in a more "fixed" resource:
>> http://www.amazon.com/exec/obidos/tg/detail/-/0131855182/ 
>> ref=ase_williamnageln-20/104-1760436-5604716?v=glance&s=books
>> I wrote that post off the top of my head, but much of the info in   
>> there is conveyed in a similar manner in my book.
>>
>
> Now, I understand why you have the style to write such posts "off  
> the top of your head" :-)
>
> I have recently read "Pragmatic Version Control Using Subversion"  
> and I found that a very good starter for somebody with almost no  
> knowledge of subversion (and little CVS experience). It helped me  
> fill those spots left blank when I had to jump head-first into  
> moving a few big VSS projects into subversion. The only down-side  
> was missing new features (locking!) as the book is written for  
> svn-1.1.1 apparently.

As far as I know, that's a problem with all current print books on  
Subversion (including my own).

>
> So, now I am into the position to manage a few svn repos for a few  
> teams and I am trying to get "everything unsder subversion" as  
> server setting and $HOME dirs. So far, with the on-line subversion  
> book, this ML and #svn irc, I kind of manage it. But a good book is  
> a good book, will have to check it.
>
> So may be you (or somebody else) could try to differentiate  
> "Subversion Version Control" from the (contetns of the) on-line  
> "Version Control with Subversion" and probably "Pragmatic Version  
> Control Using Subversion"?

I'll give it a shot.

>
> Did we miss another book?
> Has anybody read all/many books on subversion? It will be a very  
> good resource to compare them, not to rate them, but to say what is  
> specific and good/missing in every book.
>
> As a start:
>
> ISBN: 0974514063 (2005-02-01, 224 pages)
> Pragmatic Version Control Using Subversion by Mike Mason
> = very good for no experience users/future admins
> = read it as one whole story
> + good style, fun to read
> - not that great as a reference ( I just prefer grep-ing/google-ing)
> - a bit outdated, subversion-1.1.1 (no locking discussed)
> ! Probably best to read this book _before_ ever trying to play with  
> subversion
> .

I haven't read Mike's book so I can't comment.

>
>
> ISBN: 0131855182 (2005-05-16, 368 pages)
> Subversion Version Control : Using the Subversion Version Control  
> System in Development Projects by William Nagel
> .

+ Covers both the technical aspects of how to use Subversion and the  
fuzzier topics of how to make use of Subversion as a part of the  
whole development process
+ Includes case studies of real-world projects that use Subversion
+ Contains examples for extending Subversion with hook scripts, as  
well as tips on how to create your own hook scripts to fit a specific  
need
+ Published under the Open Publication License.  Although a PDF is  
not yet available for download, it will be freely available in the  
future.
- Although it's a fairly technical book, it is not as comprehensive  
as the O'Reilly book when it comes to the specific technicalities of  
using Subversion.
- Some sections, such as the hook scripts chapter assume a reasonably  
technical background in shell scripts as well as some familiarity  
with Perl and/or Python.  Those with no background in scripting may  
not be able to get as much from these sections of the book.
- The book contains a lot of suggestions for things you can do to fit  
Subversion into your development process, but many (though definitely  
not all) of those suggestions do not have accompanying technical  
examples.
- The title of the book is really, really long

>
> ISBN: 1590592905 (2004-11-15, 336 pages)
> Practical Subversion by Garrett Rooney
> .

I haven't read this one either.

>
>
> ISBN: 0596004486 (2004-07-22, 304 pages)
> Version Control with Subversion by C. Michael Pilato, et.al.
> ! Available on-line, may be the best reference as of today
> .

+ A very comprehensive technical reference.  Good solid information.   
The online version is kept very up-to-date and has much information  
that isn't available yet in the print books that are available (such  
as info specific to version 1.2)
+ Written by several of the core Subversion developers who know SVN  
better than just about anyone else.
- Works better as a reference book than it does as a way to learn  
Subversion.  People with no version control background may feel very  
overwhelmed if they start with this book.

>
>
> You get my idea of "format" :-) Feel free to change it, but please  
> stick with a format for easy post processing.
> I might try to compile a web page out of that (if permission to  
> include the comments posted here is granted) depending on the  
> interest.
>
> Authors, don't be shy and sell your works. People always need good  
> books!

Well, that's what I've got.  I tried to be objective about my own  
book.  I'm going to be the last person to claim that it's perfect,  
but I also won't claim that I completely lack bias. ;-)

-Bill

>
> Kalin.
>
> -- 
> |[ ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ ]|
> +-> http://ThinRope.net/ <-+
> |[ ______________________ ]|
>


---------------------------------------------------------------------
To unsubscribe, e-mail: users-unsubscribe@subversion.tigris.org
For additional commands, e-mail: users-help@subversion.tigris.org