You are viewing a plain text version of this content. The canonical link for it is here.
Posted to dev@cloudstack.apache.org by Animesh Chaturvedi <an...@citrix.com> on 2013/05/30 00:19:53 UTC

[DISCUSS] Baremetal and UCS UI when to check in

As you may recall we had disabled Baremetal in 4.1 and master because of blocker issues. Frank unfortunately has been tied up with $dayjob responsibilities and now plans  to start fixing baremetal issues the following week. 

Jessica Wang had been working on the UI for baremetal and UCS but given that the feature is disabled she is not sure how / when to check it in. I see the following options

1) Add the UI support when we enable and fix baremetal 
2) Add the UI support now, keep it disabled and enable it later when Frank re-enables the feature


The UI changes that will be made are:
- Baremetal: add Screen for Baremetal DHCP server and Baremetal PXE Server
- UCS:
	- Screen to add UCS Manager to Zone
	- Blades: List blades for the selected UCS Manager
	- Screen to associate blades to service profiles for that UCS Manager

IMHO option 1 is preferred since that ensures UI comes in when the feature is working and integration tested. Please share your thoughts.


Thanks
Animesh

Re: [DISCUSS] Baremetal and UCS UI when to check in

Posted by Wido den Hollander <wi...@widodh.nl>.
On 05/30/2013 10:33 PM, Chip Childers wrote:
> On Wed, May 29, 2013 at 10:19:53PM +0000, Animesh Chaturvedi wrote:
>>
>> As you may recall we had disabled Baremetal in 4.1 and master because of blocker issues. Frank unfortunately has been tied up with $dayjob responsibilities and now plans  to start fixing baremetal issues the following week.
>>
>> Jessica Wang had been working on the UI for baremetal and UCS but given that the feature is disabled she is not sure how / when to check it in. I see the following options
>>
>> 1) Add the UI support when we enable and fix baremetal
>> 2) Add the UI support now, keep it disabled and enable it later when Frank re-enables the feature
>>
>>
>> The UI changes that will be made are:
>> - Baremetal: add Screen for Baremetal DHCP server and Baremetal PXE Server
>> - UCS:
>> 	- Screen to add UCS Manager to Zone
>> 	- Blades: List blades for the selected UCS Manager
>> 	- Screen to associate blades to service profiles for that UCS Manager
>>
>> IMHO option 1 is preferred since that ensures UI comes in when the feature is working and integration tested. Please share your thoughts.
>>
>>
>> Thanks
>> Animesh
>>
>
> It seems silly to have it in the UI, but not in the underlying code.
>

+1 It should be the other way around. Code first, UI later or at the 
same time.

Having "dead" UI options would also confuse people.

Wido

> BTW - is there any progress on getting the tests requested by David when
> he veto'ed the merge?
>
> -chip
>


RE: [DISCUSS] Baremetal and UCS UI when to check in

Posted by Animesh Chaturvedi <an...@citrix.com>.

> -----Original Message-----
> From: Chip Childers [mailto:chip.childers@sungard.com]
> Sent: Thursday, May 30, 2013 1:34 PM
> To: dev@cloudstack.apache.org
> Subject: Re: [DISCUSS] Baremetal and UCS UI when to check in
> 
> On Wed, May 29, 2013 at 10:19:53PM +0000, Animesh Chaturvedi wrote:
> >
> > As you may recall we had disabled Baremetal in 4.1 and master because
> of blocker issues. Frank unfortunately has been tied up with $dayjob
> responsibilities and now plans  to start fixing baremetal issues the
> following week.
> >
> > Jessica Wang had been working on the UI for baremetal and UCS but
> > given that the feature is disabled she is not sure how / when to check
> > it in. I see the following options
> >
> > 1) Add the UI support when we enable and fix baremetal
> > 2) Add the UI support now, keep it disabled and enable it later when
> > Frank re-enables the feature
> >
> >
> > The UI changes that will be made are:
> > - Baremetal: add Screen for Baremetal DHCP server and Baremetal PXE
> > Server
> > - UCS:
> > 	- Screen to add UCS Manager to Zone
> > 	- Blades: List blades for the selected UCS Manager
> > 	- Screen to associate blades to service profiles for that UCS
> Manager
> >
> > IMHO option 1 is preferred since that ensures UI comes in when the
> feature is working and integration tested. Please share your thoughts.
> >
> >
> > Thanks
> > Animesh
> >
> 
> It seems silly to have it in the UI, but not in the underlying code.
> 
> BTW - is there any progress on getting the tests requested by David when
> he veto'ed the merge?
[Animesh>] Frank has not started working on it yet, but yes the tests are the precondition for enabling
> 
> -chip

Re: [DISCUSS] Baremetal and UCS UI when to check in

Posted by Chip Childers <ch...@sungard.com>.
On Wed, May 29, 2013 at 10:19:53PM +0000, Animesh Chaturvedi wrote:
> 
> As you may recall we had disabled Baremetal in 4.1 and master because of blocker issues. Frank unfortunately has been tied up with $dayjob responsibilities and now plans  to start fixing baremetal issues the following week. 
> 
> Jessica Wang had been working on the UI for baremetal and UCS but given that the feature is disabled she is not sure how / when to check it in. I see the following options
> 
> 1) Add the UI support when we enable and fix baremetal 
> 2) Add the UI support now, keep it disabled and enable it later when Frank re-enables the feature
> 
> 
> The UI changes that will be made are:
> - Baremetal: add Screen for Baremetal DHCP server and Baremetal PXE Server
> - UCS:
> 	- Screen to add UCS Manager to Zone
> 	- Blades: List blades for the selected UCS Manager
> 	- Screen to associate blades to service profiles for that UCS Manager
> 
> IMHO option 1 is preferred since that ensures UI comes in when the feature is working and integration tested. Please share your thoughts.
> 
> 
> Thanks
> Animesh
>

It seems silly to have it in the UI, but not in the underlying code.

BTW - is there any progress on getting the tests requested by David when
he veto'ed the merge?

-chip

RE: [DISCUSS] Baremetal and UCS UI when to check in

Posted by Animesh Chaturvedi <an...@citrix.com>.

> -----Original Message-----
> From: Prasanna Santhanam [mailto:tsp@apache.org]
> Sent: Wednesday, May 29, 2013 10:07 PM
> To: dev@cloudstack.apache.org
> Subject: Re: [DISCUSS] Baremetal and UCS UI when to check in
> 
> On Wed, May 29, 2013 at 10:19:53PM +0000, Animesh Chaturvedi wrote:
> >
> > As you may recall we had disabled Baremetal in 4.1 and master because
> > of blocker issues. Frank unfortunately has been tied up with $dayjob
> > responsibilities and now plans  to start fixing baremetal issues the
> > following week.
> >
> > Jessica Wang had been working on the UI for baremetal and UCS but
> > given that the feature is disabled she is not sure how / when to check
> > it in. I see the following options
> >
> > 1) Add the UI support when we enable and fix baremetal
> > 2) Add the UI support now, keep it disabled and enable it later when
> > Frank re-enables the feature
> >
> >
> > The UI changes that will be made are:
> > - Baremetal: add Screen for Baremetal DHCP server and Baremetal PXE
> > Server
> > - UCS:
> > 	- Screen to add UCS Manager to Zone
> > 	- Blades: List blades for the selected UCS Manager
> > 	- Screen to associate blades to service profiles for that UCS
> Manager
> >
> > IMHO option 1 is preferred since that ensures UI comes in when the
> > feature is working and integration tested. Please share your thoughts.
> 
> +1 - not sure why this is DISCUSS, since that seems the logical thing
> to do. Have the UI come in when the feature is enabled and working.
> 
> 
[Animesh>] It seems logical to me too, but since feature was disabled I did not want to assume.

> --
> Prasanna.,
> 
> ------------------------
> Powered by BigRock.com


Re: [DISCUSS] Baremetal and UCS UI when to check in

Posted by Prasanna Santhanam <ts...@apache.org>.
On Wed, May 29, 2013 at 10:19:53PM +0000, Animesh Chaturvedi wrote:
> 
> As you may recall we had disabled Baremetal in 4.1 and master
> because of blocker issues. Frank unfortunately has been tied up with
> $dayjob responsibilities and now plans  to start fixing baremetal
> issues the following week. 
> 
> Jessica Wang had been working on the UI for baremetal and UCS but
> given that the feature is disabled she is not sure how / when to
> check it in. I see the following options
> 
> 1) Add the UI support when we enable and fix baremetal 
> 2) Add the UI support now, keep it disabled and enable it later when Frank re-enables the feature
> 
> 
> The UI changes that will be made are:
> - Baremetal: add Screen for Baremetal DHCP server and Baremetal PXE Server
> - UCS:
> 	- Screen to add UCS Manager to Zone
> 	- Blades: List blades for the selected UCS Manager
> 	- Screen to associate blades to service profiles for that UCS Manager
> 
> IMHO option 1 is preferred since that ensures UI comes in when the
> feature is working and integration tested. Please share your
> thoughts.

+1 - not sure why this is DISCUSS, since that seems the logical thing
to do. Have the UI come in when the feature is enabled and working.


-- 
Prasanna.,

------------------------
Powered by BigRock.com