You are viewing a plain text version of this content. The canonical link for it is here.
Posted to dev@forrest.apache.org by Sjur Moshagen <sj...@mac.com> on 2015/11/23 13:46:33 UTC
Title element content in v2 docs
Hello all,
I just noticed a discrepancy between the dtd and the actual rendering in the default (and possibly all) skins for the title element. The DTD says:
title
Element name title
Content model ( #PCDATA | strong | em | code | sub | sup | a | br | img | icon | acronym | map ) *
Attributes
id type: ID
class type: CDATA
xml:lang type: NMTOKEN
Used inside header | section
I then tried to add an img element inside title, but it is removed during the transformations to html. It is there in the intermediate xml:
<title>
<icon src="images/Beta-Stamp.png" height="30"/>
OSX
</title>
Question:
Does this mean that it never has been added to the html rendering (ie various skins/default html transform), or that it really should not be part of the content model for the title element? The same question is valid also for the remaining title subelements.
Grateful for feedback.
Sjur
Re: Title element content in v2 docs
Posted by Sjur Moshagen <sj...@mac.com>.
Thanks for the research and feedback. It seems those elements have been added to the dtd, but without the corresponding changes to the skinning transformations. I’ll have a look at that.
Sjur
> 25. nov. 2015 kl. 00:11 skrev David Crossley <cr...@apache.org>:
>
> I did some net archaeology:
>
> This was initially added to document-v11 DTD around 2003-03-20,
> i gather as part of the alignment with xhtml at the time.
> Soon after, the DTD changes since Forrest-0.4 were removed
> and the new document-v12 was commenced in CVS on 2003-04-24:
> http://marc.info/?l=forrest-dev&m=105115903415487
> which did contain a comment about it.
>
> The comment is also listed at the end of our example documents, e.g.:
> http://forrest.apache.org/dtdx/document-v20.html#changes-12
> viz:
> "doc-v12 enhances doc-v11 by relaxing various restrictions that were found to be unnecessary.
> * Links ((link|jump|fork) and inline elements (br|img|icon|acronym) are allowed inside title.
> * ..."
>
> -David
>
> Sjur Moshagen wrote:
>> Hello all,
>>
>> I just noticed a discrepancy between the dtd and the actual rendering in the default (and possibly all) skins for the title element. The DTD says:
>>
>> title
>> Element name title
>> Content model ( #PCDATA | strong | em | code | sub | sup | a | br | img | icon | acronym | map ) *
>> Attributes
>> id type: ID
>> class type: CDATA
>> xml:lang type: NMTOKEN
>> Used inside header | section
>>
>> I then tried to add an img element inside title, but it is removed during the transformations to html. It is there in the intermediate xml:
>>
>> <title>
>> <icon src="images/Beta-Stamp.png" height="30"/>
>> OSX
>> </title>
>>
>> Question:
>>
>> Does this mean that it never has been added to the html rendering (ie various skins/default html transform), or that it really should not be part of the content model for the title element? The same question is valid also for the remaining title subelements.
>>
>> Grateful for feedback.
>>
>> Sjur
>>
>>
Re: Title element content in v2 docs
Posted by David Crossley <cr...@apache.org>.
I did some net archaeology:
This was initially added to document-v11 DTD around 2003-03-20,
i gather as part of the alignment with xhtml at the time.
Soon after, the DTD changes since Forrest-0.4 were removed
and the new document-v12 was commenced in CVS on 2003-04-24:
http://marc.info/?l=forrest-dev&m=105115903415487
which did contain a comment about it.
The comment is also listed at the end of our example documents, e.g.:
http://forrest.apache.org/dtdx/document-v20.html#changes-12
viz:
"doc-v12 enhances doc-v11 by relaxing various restrictions that were found to be unnecessary.
* Links ((link|jump|fork) and inline elements (br|img|icon|acronym) are allowed inside title.
* ..."
-David
Sjur Moshagen wrote:
> Hello all,
>
> I just noticed a discrepancy between the dtd and the actual rendering in the default (and possibly all) skins for the title element. The DTD says:
>
> title
> Element name title
> Content model ( #PCDATA | strong | em | code | sub | sup | a | br | img | icon | acronym | map ) *
> Attributes
> id type: ID
> class type: CDATA
> xml:lang type: NMTOKEN
> Used inside header | section
>
> I then tried to add an img element inside title, but it is removed during the transformations to html. It is there in the intermediate xml:
>
> <title>
> <icon src="images/Beta-Stamp.png" height="30"/>
> OSX
> </title>
>
> Question:
>
> Does this mean that it never has been added to the html rendering (ie various skins/default html transform), or that it really should not be part of the content model for the title element? The same question is valid also for the remaining title subelements.
>
> Grateful for feedback.
>
> Sjur
>
>