You are viewing a plain text version of this content. The canonical link for it is here.
Posted to dev@cocoon.apache.org by Christofer Dutz <ch...@c-ware.de> on 2024/08/20 09:39:55 UTC

[VOTE] Move Apache Cocoon into the Apache Attic

Hi all,

given that there is not enough remaining activity in the Apache Cocoon project, we would like to start a vote on moving Apache Cocoon into the Apache Attic.

Please vote:

  *   +1 if you are in favor
  *   0 if you are indifferent about it
  *   -1 if you are not in favor, but please provide reasoning

I think given the low activity here, we should keep the vote open for a full week.

Chris

Re: AW: AW: [RESULT] [VOTE] Move Apache Cocoon into the Apache Attic

Posted by Cédric Damioli <cd...@apache.org>.
Oops, I forgot it ...
I wanted first to properly inform users@ but did not find the time to do 
it, and then forgot it.
I'll try to do it asap.

Cédric


Le 17/12/2024 à 18:35, Arnout Engelen a écrit :
> Anyone?
>
> On 2024/09/28 14:31:37 Christofer Dutz wrote:
>> Sooo … who’s adding the resolution to the next board meeting’s agenda?
>>
>> Chris
>>
>> Von: Christofer Dutz <ch...@c-ware.de>
>> Datum: Samstag, 14. September 2024 um 11:01
>> An: dev@cocoon.apache.org <de...@cocoon.apache.org>
>> Betreff: AW: AW: [RESULT] [VOTE] Move Apache Cocoon into the Apache Attic
>> Well, I guess this is sort of the issue we are facing here. There are some people that like and still use cocoon and would like others to clean up stuff.
>> But so far, I have not really heard anyone actually willing to do the work. If there’s nobody willing to do the work, then the project can’t continue.
>> That’s as simple as it can get.
>>
>> I did the work to clean up the build, to make building releasing etc. simpler in the hope that would re-engage people, but it seems that did not work.
>>
>> I thought I had heard from one of the PMC members that he also maintains a private fork. But that might have been me mixing up things.
>>
>> Chris
>>
>> Von: insight49@gmail.com <in...@gmail.com>
>> Datum: Freitag, 13. September 2024 um 17:46
>> An: dev@cocoon.apache.org <de...@cocoon.apache.org>
>> Betreff: Re: AW: [RESULT] [VOTE] Move Apache Cocoon into the Apache Attic
>>
>> Dspace (prior to version 7) used Cocoon 2.2, and enhanced its functionality, for instance, integration with Lucene SOLR. Look for the XMLUI section available from:
>>
>> https://github.com/DSpace/DSpace/releases/tag/dspace-6.4
>>
>> Release Notes:
>>
>> https://wiki.lyrasis.org/display/DSDOC6x
>>
>> I always continued to use Cocoon version 2.1x, and am hoping to use LLMs to help me refactor some of its code. I am not a JAVA developer. There were a few old code samples many (many years) ago adding some java classes, which I believe were never fully integrated into 2.13.
>>
>> I still love 2.1x, and would like to see better html parser cleanup than jsoup/niko, hardening security issues, and wow, if the python integrator package could ever be upgraded, that would tie in nicely with the wide use of python language.
>>
>> Cocoon pipelines are awesome.
>>
>> Dan
>>
>> ========================
>>
>>
>> On 2024-09-13 8:15 a.m., Cédric Damioli wrote:
>> Do you think there exist "multiple" forks ?
>> I'm now aware of Gabriel's but are there any others ?
>>
>> Cédric
>> Le 13/09/2024 à 15:58, Christofer Dutz a écrit :
>> It does seem as if multiple people claimed to still be using Cocoon, but maintaining their own forks.
>> Why not bring exactly this back to the upstream project and join forces in maintaining it?
>>
>> Chris
>>
>> Von: Cédric Damioli <cd...@apache.org>
>> Datum: Donnerstag, 12. September 2024 um 19:31
>> An: dev@cocoon.apache.org<ma...@cocoon.apache.org> <de...@cocoon.apache.org>
>> Betreff: Re: [RESULT] [VOTE] Move Apache Cocoon into the Apache Attic
>> Hi,
>>
>> Sadly, there's not enough motivated individuals to keep the project running as is.
>> When we ran a poll 10 months ago, very few people actually volunteered to help keeping Cocoon 2.3 alive, and the reality of these past 10 months is that nobody has barely done anything to move forward.
>>
>> Anyway, now that the Attic vote has passed, we have to move forward with the due process.
>>
>> Cédric
>> Le 11/09/2024 à 13:27, Gabriel Gruber a écrit :
>>>> Can you explain why you didn't via https://github.com/apache/cocoon ?
>> Hmm, good question actually. I wasn’t aware that the PR functionality was actually really used to add enhancements to the project and I always felt a little bit lost with the formal/administrative rules to get patches to the project, without being an official committer.
>>
>> Anyway I would be willing to add all necessary changes to make cocoon compatible with spring 5+ in a PR
>>
>> Cheerio,
>> Gabriel
>>
>>
>> From: Torsten Curdt <tc...@apache.org>
>> Date: Wednesday, 11. September 2024 at 10:59
>> To: dev@cocoon.apache.org<ma...@cocoon.apache.org> <de...@cocoon.apache.org>
>> Subject: Re: [RESULT] [VOTE] Move Apache Cocoon into the Apache Attic
>> It is sad, to let such a powerful project die. Having said that, we are using it still in production and trying to apply security patches on our own fork to make it compatible with newer versions of spring and java.
>>
>> If the project would continue on github, I can just stress again that I would be very happy to participate and share all our patches.
>>
>> Can you explain why you didn't via https://github.com/apache/cocoon ?
>>
>> Just trying to understand whether github would really make a difference.
>>
>> While I am still +1 for the attic (because I don't see anyone working on Cocoon in any form),
>> it feels a little sad if there are individually maintained forks that could as well be part of the project.
>>
>> cheers,
>> Torsten
>>
>>
>>


Re: AW: AW: [RESULT] [VOTE] Move Apache Cocoon into the Apache Attic

Posted by Arnout Engelen <en...@apache.org>.
Anyone?

On 2024/09/28 14:31:37 Christofer Dutz wrote:
> Sooo … who’s adding the resolution to the next board meeting’s agenda?
> 
> Chris
> 
> Von: Christofer Dutz <ch...@c-ware.de>
> Datum: Samstag, 14. September 2024 um 11:01
> An: dev@cocoon.apache.org <de...@cocoon.apache.org>
> Betreff: AW: AW: [RESULT] [VOTE] Move Apache Cocoon into the Apache Attic
> Well, I guess this is sort of the issue we are facing here. There are some people that like and still use cocoon and would like others to clean up stuff.
> But so far, I have not really heard anyone actually willing to do the work. If there’s nobody willing to do the work, then the project can’t continue.
> That’s as simple as it can get.
> 
> I did the work to clean up the build, to make building releasing etc. simpler in the hope that would re-engage people, but it seems that did not work.
> 
> I thought I had heard from one of the PMC members that he also maintains a private fork. But that might have been me mixing up things.
> 
> Chris
> 
> Von: insight49@gmail.com <in...@gmail.com>
> Datum: Freitag, 13. September 2024 um 17:46
> An: dev@cocoon.apache.org <de...@cocoon.apache.org>
> Betreff: Re: AW: [RESULT] [VOTE] Move Apache Cocoon into the Apache Attic
> 
> Dspace (prior to version 7) used Cocoon 2.2, and enhanced its functionality, for instance, integration with Lucene SOLR. Look for the XMLUI section available from:
> 
> https://github.com/DSpace/DSpace/releases/tag/dspace-6.4
> 
> Release Notes:
> 
> https://wiki.lyrasis.org/display/DSDOC6x
> 
> I always continued to use Cocoon version 2.1x, and am hoping to use LLMs to help me refactor some of its code. I am not a JAVA developer. There were a few old code samples many (many years) ago adding some java classes, which I believe were never fully integrated into 2.13.
> 
> I still love 2.1x, and would like to see better html parser cleanup than jsoup/niko, hardening security issues, and wow, if the python integrator package could ever be upgraded, that would tie in nicely with the wide use of python language.
> 
> Cocoon pipelines are awesome.
> 
> Dan
> 
> ========================
> 
> 
> On 2024-09-13 8:15 a.m., Cédric Damioli wrote:
> Do you think there exist "multiple" forks ?
> I'm now aware of Gabriel's but are there any others ?
> 
> Cédric
> Le 13/09/2024 à 15:58, Christofer Dutz a écrit :
> It does seem as if multiple people claimed to still be using Cocoon, but maintaining their own forks.
> Why not bring exactly this back to the upstream project and join forces in maintaining it?
> 
> Chris
> 
> Von: Cédric Damioli <cd...@apache.org>
> Datum: Donnerstag, 12. September 2024 um 19:31
> An: dev@cocoon.apache.org<ma...@cocoon.apache.org> <de...@cocoon.apache.org>
> Betreff: Re: [RESULT] [VOTE] Move Apache Cocoon into the Apache Attic
> Hi,
> 
> Sadly, there's not enough motivated individuals to keep the project running as is.
> When we ran a poll 10 months ago, very few people actually volunteered to help keeping Cocoon 2.3 alive, and the reality of these past 10 months is that nobody has barely done anything to move forward.
> 
> Anyway, now that the Attic vote has passed, we have to move forward with the due process.
> 
> Cédric
> Le 11/09/2024 à 13:27, Gabriel Gruber a écrit :
> >> Can you explain why you didn't via https://github.com/apache/cocoon ?
> 
> Hmm, good question actually. I wasn’t aware that the PR functionality was actually really used to add enhancements to the project and I always felt a little bit lost with the formal/administrative rules to get patches to the project, without being an official committer.
> 
> Anyway I would be willing to add all necessary changes to make cocoon compatible with spring 5+ in a PR
> 
> Cheerio,
> Gabriel
> 
> 
> From: Torsten Curdt <tc...@apache.org>
> Date: Wednesday, 11. September 2024 at 10:59
> To: dev@cocoon.apache.org<ma...@cocoon.apache.org> <de...@cocoon.apache.org>
> Subject: Re: [RESULT] [VOTE] Move Apache Cocoon into the Apache Attic
> It is sad, to let such a powerful project die. Having said that, we are using it still in production and trying to apply security patches on our own fork to make it compatible with newer versions of spring and java.
> 
> If the project would continue on github, I can just stress again that I would be very happy to participate and share all our patches.
> 
> Can you explain why you didn't via https://github.com/apache/cocoon ?
> 
> Just trying to understand whether github would really make a difference.
> 
> While I am still +1 for the attic (because I don't see anyone working on Cocoon in any form),
> it feels a little sad if there are individually maintained forks that could as well be part of the project.
> 
> cheers,
> Torsten
> 
> 
> 

AW: AW: [RESULT] [VOTE] Move Apache Cocoon into the Apache Attic

Posted by Christofer Dutz <ch...@c-ware.de>.
Sooo … who’s adding the resolution to the next board meeting’s agenda?

Chris

Von: Christofer Dutz <ch...@c-ware.de>
Datum: Samstag, 14. September 2024 um 11:01
An: dev@cocoon.apache.org <de...@cocoon.apache.org>
Betreff: AW: AW: [RESULT] [VOTE] Move Apache Cocoon into the Apache Attic
Well, I guess this is sort of the issue we are facing here. There are some people that like and still use cocoon and would like others to clean up stuff.
But so far, I have not really heard anyone actually willing to do the work. If there’s nobody willing to do the work, then the project can’t continue.
That’s as simple as it can get.

I did the work to clean up the build, to make building releasing etc. simpler in the hope that would re-engage people, but it seems that did not work.

I thought I had heard from one of the PMC members that he also maintains a private fork. But that might have been me mixing up things.

Chris

Von: insight49@gmail.com <in...@gmail.com>
Datum: Freitag, 13. September 2024 um 17:46
An: dev@cocoon.apache.org <de...@cocoon.apache.org>
Betreff: Re: AW: [RESULT] [VOTE] Move Apache Cocoon into the Apache Attic

Dspace (prior to version 7) used Cocoon 2.2, and enhanced its functionality, for instance, integration with Lucene SOLR. Look for the XMLUI section available from:

https://github.com/DSpace/DSpace/releases/tag/dspace-6.4

Release Notes:

https://wiki.lyrasis.org/display/DSDOC6x

I always continued to use Cocoon version 2.1x, and am hoping to use LLMs to help me refactor some of its code. I am not a JAVA developer. There were a few old code samples many (many years) ago adding some java classes, which I believe were never fully integrated into 2.13.

I still love 2.1x, and would like to see better html parser cleanup than jsoup/niko, hardening security issues, and wow, if the python integrator package could ever be upgraded, that would tie in nicely with the wide use of python language.

Cocoon pipelines are awesome.

Dan

========================


On 2024-09-13 8:15 a.m., Cédric Damioli wrote:
Do you think there exist "multiple" forks ?
I'm now aware of Gabriel's but are there any others ?

Cédric
Le 13/09/2024 à 15:58, Christofer Dutz a écrit :
It does seem as if multiple people claimed to still be using Cocoon, but maintaining their own forks.
Why not bring exactly this back to the upstream project and join forces in maintaining it?

Chris

Von: Cédric Damioli <cd...@apache.org>
Datum: Donnerstag, 12. September 2024 um 19:31
An: dev@cocoon.apache.org<ma...@cocoon.apache.org> <de...@cocoon.apache.org>
Betreff: Re: [RESULT] [VOTE] Move Apache Cocoon into the Apache Attic
Hi,

Sadly, there's not enough motivated individuals to keep the project running as is.
When we ran a poll 10 months ago, very few people actually volunteered to help keeping Cocoon 2.3 alive, and the reality of these past 10 months is that nobody has barely done anything to move forward.

Anyway, now that the Attic vote has passed, we have to move forward with the due process.

Cédric
Le 11/09/2024 à 13:27, Gabriel Gruber a écrit :
>> Can you explain why you didn't via https://github.com/apache/cocoon ?

Hmm, good question actually. I wasn’t aware that the PR functionality was actually really used to add enhancements to the project and I always felt a little bit lost with the formal/administrative rules to get patches to the project, without being an official committer.

Anyway I would be willing to add all necessary changes to make cocoon compatible with spring 5+ in a PR

Cheerio,
Gabriel


From: Torsten Curdt <tc...@apache.org>
Date: Wednesday, 11. September 2024 at 10:59
To: dev@cocoon.apache.org<ma...@cocoon.apache.org> <de...@cocoon.apache.org>
Subject: Re: [RESULT] [VOTE] Move Apache Cocoon into the Apache Attic
It is sad, to let such a powerful project die. Having said that, we are using it still in production and trying to apply security patches on our own fork to make it compatible with newer versions of spring and java.

If the project would continue on github, I can just stress again that I would be very happy to participate and share all our patches.

Can you explain why you didn't via https://github.com/apache/cocoon ?

Just trying to understand whether github would really make a difference.

While I am still +1 for the attic (because I don't see anyone working on Cocoon in any form),
it feels a little sad if there are individually maintained forks that could as well be part of the project.

cheers,
Torsten



AW: AW: [RESULT] [VOTE] Move Apache Cocoon into the Apache Attic

Posted by Christofer Dutz <ch...@c-ware.de>.
Well, I guess this is sort of the issue we are facing here. There are some people that like and still use cocoon and would like others to clean up stuff.
But so far, I have not really heard anyone actually willing to do the work. If there’s nobody willing to do the work, then the project can’t continue.
That’s as simple as it can get.

I did the work to clean up the build, to make building releasing etc. simpler in the hope that would re-engage people, but it seems that did not work.

I thought I had heard from one of the PMC members that he also maintains a private fork. But that might have been me mixing up things.

Chris

Von: insight49@gmail.com <in...@gmail.com>
Datum: Freitag, 13. September 2024 um 17:46
An: dev@cocoon.apache.org <de...@cocoon.apache.org>
Betreff: Re: AW: [RESULT] [VOTE] Move Apache Cocoon into the Apache Attic

Dspace (prior to version 7) used Cocoon 2.2, and enhanced its functionality, for instance, integration with Lucene SOLR. Look for the XMLUI section available from:

https://github.com/DSpace/DSpace/releases/tag/dspace-6.4

Release Notes:

https://wiki.lyrasis.org/display/DSDOC6x

I always continued to use Cocoon version 2.1x, and am hoping to use LLMs to help me refactor some of its code. I am not a JAVA developer. There were a few old code samples many (many years) ago adding some java classes, which I believe were never fully integrated into 2.13.

I still love 2.1x, and would like to see better html parser cleanup than jsoup/niko, hardening security issues, and wow, if the python integrator package could ever be upgraded, that would tie in nicely with the wide use of python language.

Cocoon pipelines are awesome.

Dan

========================


On 2024-09-13 8:15 a.m., Cédric Damioli wrote:
Do you think there exist "multiple" forks ?
I'm now aware of Gabriel's but are there any others ?

Cédric
Le 13/09/2024 à 15:58, Christofer Dutz a écrit :
It does seem as if multiple people claimed to still be using Cocoon, but maintaining their own forks.
Why not bring exactly this back to the upstream project and join forces in maintaining it?

Chris

Von: Cédric Damioli <cd...@apache.org>
Datum: Donnerstag, 12. September 2024 um 19:31
An: dev@cocoon.apache.org<ma...@cocoon.apache.org> <de...@cocoon.apache.org>
Betreff: Re: [RESULT] [VOTE] Move Apache Cocoon into the Apache Attic
Hi,

Sadly, there's not enough motivated individuals to keep the project running as is.
When we ran a poll 10 months ago, very few people actually volunteered to help keeping Cocoon 2.3 alive, and the reality of these past 10 months is that nobody has barely done anything to move forward.

Anyway, now that the Attic vote has passed, we have to move forward with the due process.

Cédric
Le 11/09/2024 à 13:27, Gabriel Gruber a écrit :
>> Can you explain why you didn't via https://github.com/apache/cocoon ?

Hmm, good question actually. I wasn’t aware that the PR functionality was actually really used to add enhancements to the project and I always felt a little bit lost with the formal/administrative rules to get patches to the project, without being an official committer.

Anyway I would be willing to add all necessary changes to make cocoon compatible with spring 5+ in a PR

Cheerio,
Gabriel


From: Torsten Curdt <tc...@apache.org>
Date: Wednesday, 11. September 2024 at 10:59
To: dev@cocoon.apache.org<ma...@cocoon.apache.org> <de...@cocoon.apache.org>
Subject: Re: [RESULT] [VOTE] Move Apache Cocoon into the Apache Attic
It is sad, to let such a powerful project die. Having said that, we are using it still in production and trying to apply security patches on our own fork to make it compatible with newer versions of spring and java.

If the project would continue on github, I can just stress again that I would be very happy to participate and share all our patches.

Can you explain why you didn't via https://github.com/apache/cocoon ?

Just trying to understand whether github would really make a difference.

While I am still +1 for the attic (because I don't see anyone working on Cocoon in any form),
it feels a little sad if there are individually maintained forks that could as well be part of the project.

cheers,
Torsten



Re: AW: [RESULT] [VOTE] Move Apache Cocoon into the Apache Attic

Posted by "insight49@gmail.com" <in...@gmail.com>.
Dspace (prior to version 7) used Cocoon 2.2, and enhanced its 
functionality, for instance, integration with Lucene SOLR. Look for the 
XMLUI section available from:

https://github.com/DSpace/DSpace/releases/tag/dspace-6.4

Release Notes:

https://wiki.lyrasis.org/display/DSDOC6x

I always continued to use Cocoon version 2.1x, and am hoping to use LLMs 
to help me refactor some of its code. I am not a JAVA developer. There 
were a few old code samples many (many years) ago adding some java 
classes, which I believe were never fully integrated into 2.13.

I still love 2.1x, and would like to see better html parser cleanup than 
jsoup/niko, hardening security issues, and wow, if the python integrator 
package could ever be upgraded, that would tie in nicely with the wide 
use of python language.

Cocoon pipelines are awesome.

Dan

========================


On 2024-09-13 8:15 a.m., Cédric Damioli wrote:
> Do you think there exist "multiple" forks ?
> I'm now aware of Gabriel's but are there any others ?
>
> Cédric
>
> Le 13/09/2024 à 15:58, Christofer Dutz a écrit :
>>
>> It does seem as if multiple people claimed to still be using Cocoon, 
>> but maintaining their own forks.
>>
>> Why not bring exactly this back to the upstream project and join 
>> forces in maintaining it?
>>
>> Chris
>>
>> *Von: *Cédric Damioli <cd...@apache.org>
>> *Datum: *Donnerstag, 12. September 2024 um 19:31
>> *An: *dev@cocoon.apache.org <de...@cocoon.apache.org>
>> *Betreff: *Re: [RESULT] [VOTE] Move Apache Cocoon into the Apache Attic
>>
>> Hi,
>>
>> Sadly, there's not enough motivated individuals to keep the project 
>> running as is.
>> When we ran a poll 10 months ago, very few people actually 
>> volunteered to help keeping Cocoon 2.3 alive, and the reality of 
>> these past 10 months is that nobody has barely done anything to move 
>> forward.
>>
>> Anyway, now that the Attic vote has passed, we have to move forward 
>> with the due process.
>>
>> Cédric
>>
>> Le 11/09/2024 à 13:27, Gabriel Gruber a écrit :
>>
>>     >> Can you explain why you didn't via
>>     https://github.com/apache/cocoon ?
>>
>>     Hmm, good question actually. I wasn’t aware that the PR
>>     functionality was actually really used to add enhancements to the
>>     project and I always felt a little bit lost with the
>>     formal/administrative rules to get patches to the project,
>>     without being an official committer.
>>
>>     Anyway I would be willing to add all necessary changes to make
>>     cocoon compatible with spring 5+ in a PR
>>
>>     Cheerio,
>>
>>     Gabriel
>>
>>     *From: *Torsten Curdt <tc...@apache.org> <ma...@apache.org>
>>     *Date: *Wednesday, 11. September 2024 at 10:59
>>     *To: *dev@cocoon.apache.org <de...@cocoon.apache.org>
>>     <ma...@cocoon.apache.org>
>>     *Subject: *Re: [RESULT] [VOTE] Move Apache Cocoon into the Apache
>>     Attic
>>
>>         It is sad, to let such a powerful project die. Having said
>>         that, we are using it still in production and trying to apply
>>         security patches on our own fork to make it compatible with
>>         newer versions of spring and java.
>>
>>         If the project would continue on github, I can just stress
>>         again that I would be very happy to participate and share all
>>         our patches.
>>
>>
>>     Can you explain why you didn't via https://github.com/apache/cocoon ?
>>
>>     Just trying to understand whether github would really make a
>>     difference.
>>
>>     While I am still +1 for the attic (because I don't see anyone
>>     working on Cocoon in any form),
>>     it feels a little sad if there are individually maintained forks
>>     that could as well be part of the project.
>>
>>     cheers,
>>     Torsten
>>
>

Re: AW: [RESULT] [VOTE] Move Apache Cocoon into the Apache Attic

Posted by Cédric Damioli <cd...@apache.org>.
Do you think there exist "multiple" forks ?
I'm now aware of Gabriel's but are there any others ?

Cédric

Le 13/09/2024 à 15:58, Christofer Dutz a écrit :
>
> It does seem as if multiple people claimed to still be using Cocoon, 
> but maintaining their own forks.
>
> Why not bring exactly this back to the upstream project and join 
> forces in maintaining it?
>
> Chris
>
> *Von: *Cédric Damioli <cd...@apache.org>
> *Datum: *Donnerstag, 12. September 2024 um 19:31
> *An: *dev@cocoon.apache.org <de...@cocoon.apache.org>
> *Betreff: *Re: [RESULT] [VOTE] Move Apache Cocoon into the Apache Attic
>
> Hi,
>
> Sadly, there's not enough motivated individuals to keep the project 
> running as is.
> When we ran a poll 10 months ago, very few people actually volunteered 
> to help keeping Cocoon 2.3 alive, and the reality of these past 10 
> months is that nobody has barely done anything to move forward.
>
> Anyway, now that the Attic vote has passed, we have to move forward 
> with the due process.
>
> Cédric
>
> Le 11/09/2024 à 13:27, Gabriel Gruber a écrit :
>
>     >> Can you explain why you didn't via https://github.com/apache/cocoon ?
>
>     Hmm, good question actually. I wasn’t aware that the PR
>     functionality was actually really used to add enhancements to the
>     project and I always felt a little bit lost with the
>     formal/administrative rules to get patches to the project, without
>     being an official committer.
>
>     Anyway I would be willing to add all necessary changes to make
>     cocoon compatible with spring 5+ in a PR
>
>     Cheerio,
>
>     Gabriel
>
>     *From: *Torsten Curdt <tc...@apache.org> <ma...@apache.org>
>     *Date: *Wednesday, 11. September 2024 at 10:59
>     *To: *dev@cocoon.apache.org <de...@cocoon.apache.org>
>     <ma...@cocoon.apache.org>
>     *Subject: *Re: [RESULT] [VOTE] Move Apache Cocoon into the Apache
>     Attic
>
>         It is sad, to let such a powerful project die. Having said
>         that, we are using it still in production and trying to apply
>         security patches on our own fork to make it compatible with
>         newer versions of spring and java.
>
>         If the project would continue on github, I can just stress
>         again that I would be very happy to participate and share all
>         our patches.
>
>
>     Can you explain why you didn't via https://github.com/apache/cocoon ?
>
>     Just trying to understand whether github would really make a
>     difference.
>
>     While I am still +1 for the attic (because I don't see anyone
>     working on Cocoon in any form),
>     it feels a little sad if there are individually maintained forks
>     that could as well be part of the project.
>
>     cheers,
>     Torsten
>

AW: [RESULT] [VOTE] Move Apache Cocoon into the Apache Attic

Posted by Christofer Dutz <ch...@c-ware.de>.
It does seem as if multiple people claimed to still be using Cocoon, but maintaining their own forks.
Why not bring exactly this back to the upstream project and join forces in maintaining it?

Chris

Von: Cédric Damioli <cd...@apache.org>
Datum: Donnerstag, 12. September 2024 um 19:31
An: dev@cocoon.apache.org <de...@cocoon.apache.org>
Betreff: Re: [RESULT] [VOTE] Move Apache Cocoon into the Apache Attic
Hi,

Sadly, there's not enough motivated individuals to keep the project running as is.
When we ran a poll 10 months ago, very few people actually volunteered to help keeping Cocoon 2.3 alive, and the reality of these past 10 months is that nobody has barely done anything to move forward.

Anyway, now that the Attic vote has passed, we have to move forward with the due process.

Cédric

Le 11/09/2024 à 13:27, Gabriel Gruber a écrit :
>> Can you explain why you didn't via https://github.com/apache/cocoon ?

Hmm, good question actually. I wasn’t aware that the PR functionality was actually really used to add enhancements to the project and I always felt a little bit lost with the formal/administrative rules to get patches to the project, without being an official committer.

Anyway I would be willing to add all necessary changes to make cocoon compatible with spring 5+ in a PR

Cheerio,
Gabriel


From: Torsten Curdt <tc...@apache.org>
Date: Wednesday, 11. September 2024 at 10:59
To: dev@cocoon.apache.org<ma...@cocoon.apache.org> <de...@cocoon.apache.org>
Subject: Re: [RESULT] [VOTE] Move Apache Cocoon into the Apache Attic
It is sad, to let such a powerful project die. Having said that, we are using it still in production and trying to apply security patches on our own fork to make it compatible with newer versions of spring and java.

If the project would continue on github, I can just stress again that I would be very happy to participate and share all our patches.

Can you explain why you didn't via https://github.com/apache/cocoon ?

Just trying to understand whether github would really make a difference.

While I am still +1 for the attic (because I don't see anyone working on Cocoon in any form),
it feels a little sad if there are individually maintained forks that could as well be part of the project.

cheers,
Torsten


Re: [RESULT] [VOTE] Move Apache Cocoon into the Apache Attic

Posted by Cédric Damioli <cd...@apache.org>.
Hi,

Sadly, there's not enough motivated individuals to keep the project 
running as is.
When we ran a poll 10 months ago, very few people actually volunteered 
to help keeping Cocoon 2.3 alive, and the reality of these past 10 
months is that nobody has barely done anything to move forward.

Anyway, now that the Attic vote has passed, we have to move forward with 
the due process.

Cédric


Le 11/09/2024 à 13:27, Gabriel Gruber a écrit :
>
> >> Can you explain why you didn't via https://github.com/apache/cocoon ?
>
> Hmm, good question actually. I wasn’t aware that the PR functionality 
> was actually really used to add enhancements to the project and I 
> always felt a little bit lost with the formal/administrative rules to 
> get patches to the project, without being an official committer.
>
> Anyway I would be willing to add all necessary changes to make cocoon 
> compatible with spring 5+ in a PR
>
> Cheerio,
>
> Gabriel
>
> *From: *Torsten Curdt <tc...@apache.org>
> *Date: *Wednesday, 11. September 2024 at 10:59
> *To: *dev@cocoon.apache.org <de...@cocoon.apache.org>
> *Subject: *Re: [RESULT] [VOTE] Move Apache Cocoon into the Apache Attic
>
>     It is sad, to let such a powerful project die. Having said that,
>     we are using it still in production and trying to apply security
>     patches on our own fork to make it compatible with newer versions
>     of spring and java.
>
>     If the project would continue on github, I can just stress again
>     that I would be very happy to participate and share all our patches.
>
>
> Can you explain why you didn't via https://github.com/apache/cocoon ?
>
> Just trying to understand whether github would really make a difference.
>
> While I am still +1 for the attic (because I don't see anyone working 
> on Cocoon in any form),
> it feels a little sad if there are individually maintained forks that 
> could as well be part of the project.
>
> cheers,
> Torsten
>

Re: [RESULT] [VOTE] Move Apache Cocoon into the Apache Attic

Posted by Gabriel Gruber <ga...@workflow.at>.
>> Can you explain why you didn't via https://github.com/apache/cocoon ?

Hmm, good question actually. I wasn’t aware that the PR functionality was actually really used to add enhancements to the project and I always felt a little bit lost with the formal/administrative rules to get patches to the project, without being an official committer.

Anyway I would be willing to add all necessary changes to make cocoon compatible with spring 5+ in a PR

Cheerio,
Gabriel


From: Torsten Curdt <tc...@apache.org>
Date: Wednesday, 11. September 2024 at 10:59
To: dev@cocoon.apache.org <de...@cocoon.apache.org>
Subject: Re: [RESULT] [VOTE] Move Apache Cocoon into the Apache Attic
It is sad, to let such a powerful project die. Having said that, we are using it still in production and trying to apply security patches on our own fork to make it compatible with newer versions of spring and java.

If the project would continue on github, I can just stress again that I would be very happy to participate and share all our patches.

Can you explain why you didn't via https://github.com/apache/cocoon ?

Just trying to understand whether github would really make a difference.

While I am still +1 for the attic (because I don't see anyone working on Cocoon in any form),
it feels a little sad if there are individually maintained forks that could as well be part of the project.

cheers,
Torsten

Re: [RESULT] [VOTE] Move Apache Cocoon into the Apache Attic

Posted by Torsten Curdt <tc...@apache.org>.
> It is sad, to let such a powerful project die. Having said that, we are
> using it still in production and trying to apply security patches on our
> own fork to make it compatible with newer versions of spring and java.
>
> If the project would continue on github, I can just stress again that I
> would be very happy to participate and share all our patches.
>

Can you explain why you didn't via https://github.com/apache/cocoon ?

Just trying to understand whether github would really make a difference.

While I am still +1 for the attic (because I don't see anyone working on
Cocoon in any form),
it feels a little sad if there are individually maintained forks that could
as well be part of the project.

cheers,
Torsten

Re: [RESULT] [VOTE] Move Apache Cocoon into the Apache Attic

Posted by Gabriel Gruber <ga...@workflow.at>.
Hello,

first of all thanks to Chris and his honesty to declare that the needed power and energy is just not enough to continue with the project.

It is sad, to let such a powerful project die. Having said that, we are using it still in production and trying to apply security patches on our own fork to make it compatible with newer versions of spring and java.

If the project would continue on github, I can just stress again that I would be very happy to participate and share all our patches.

Anyway, thank you all for your effort and maybe someone should try to just quickly describe what it practically means for cocoon. (documentation, soucecode, releases, jira project)

There is a page describing the general process

https://attic.apache.org/#:~:text=The%20Apache%20Attic%20was%20created,Attic%20Project%20%5B...%5D

Thanks
Gabriel
________________________________
From: Rich Bowen <rb...@apache.org>
Sent: Tuesday, September 10, 2024 7:04:47 PM
To: dev@cocoon.apache.org <de...@cocoon.apache.org>
Subject: Re: [RESULT] [VOTE] Move Apache Cocoon into the Apache Attic



On 2024/08/29 15:12:33 Cédric Damioli wrote:
> Hi Chris,
>
> I saw in the last board's meeting notes than Rich wanted to pursue
> another roll call. Am I wrong here ?
> That's why I didn't vote on this thread in the first place.

Yeah, sorry to make this confusing. That was not my intent. The vote for attic seems to be pretty definitive, and I don't wish to interfere with the will of the project. I'd only ask that you be sure to announce it loudly on your dev/user lists, so that it doesn't come as a surprise.

--Rich

Re: [RESULT] [VOTE] Move Apache Cocoon into the Apache Attic

Posted by Rich Bowen <rb...@apache.org>.

On 2024/08/29 15:12:33 Cédric Damioli wrote:
> Hi Chris,
> 
> I saw in the last board's meeting notes than Rich wanted to pursue 
> another roll call. Am I wrong here ?
> That's why I didn't vote on this thread in the first place.

Yeah, sorry to make this confusing. That was not my intent. The vote for attic seems to be pretty definitive, and I don't wish to interfere with the will of the project. I'd only ask that you be sure to announce it loudly on your dev/user lists, so that it doesn't come as a surprise.

--Rich

Re: [RESULT] [VOTE] Move Apache Cocoon into the Apache Attic

Posted by Cédric Damioli <cd...@apache.org>.
Hi Chris,

I saw in the last board's meeting notes than Rich wanted to pursue 
another roll call. Am I wrong here ?
That's why I didn't vote on this thread in the first place.

I'm also sad to act the end of this great project but as you said, it's 
probably time to let it go ...

Cédric


Le 29/08/2024 à 13:02, Christofer Dutz a écrit :
>
> So, the vote passes with 4 binding +1 votes and no other votes.
>
> I guess the next step would be for the PMC Chair do add an attic 
> resolution to the next month’s board agenda.
>
> Apache Cocoon was the one project that brought me to Apache, even if 
> it took a loooong long time for me to really get involved.
>
> It’s a little sad to see it go, but I guess there’s a time for 
> everything and the time for XML has long time passed.
>
> Thanks to all of you.
>
> Chris
>
> *Von: *Jörg Heinicke <jo...@gmx.de>
> *Datum: *Donnerstag, 22. August 2024 um 09:52
> *An: *dev@cocoon.apache.org <de...@cocoon.apache.org>
> *Betreff: *Re: [VOTE] Move Apache Cocoon into the Apache Attic
>
> +1
>
> Joerg
>
> PS: I already gave my +1 two days ago, but my message might be stuck
> somewhere.
>
>
> On 20.08.24 11:39, Christofer Dutz wrote:
> > Hi all,
> >
> > given that there is not enough remaining activity in the Apache Cocoon
> > project, we would like to start a vote on moving Apache Cocoon into the
> > Apache Attic.
> >
> > Please vote:
> >
> >   * +1 if you are in favor
> >   * 0 if you are indifferent about it
> >   * -1 if you are not in favor, but please provide reasoning
> >
> > I think given the low activity here, we should keep the vote open for a
> > full week.
> >
> > Chris
> >
>

[RESULT] [VOTE] Move Apache Cocoon into the Apache Attic

Posted by Christofer Dutz <ch...@c-ware.de>.
So, the vote passes with 4 binding +1 votes and no other votes.

I guess the next step would be for the PMC Chair do add an attic resolution to the next month’s board agenda.

Apache Cocoon was the one project that brought me to Apache, even if it took a loooong long time for me to really get involved.
It’s a little sad to see it go, but I guess there’s a time for everything and the time for XML has long time passed.

Thanks to all of you.

Chris

Von: Jörg Heinicke <jo...@gmx.de>
Datum: Donnerstag, 22. August 2024 um 09:52
An: dev@cocoon.apache.org <de...@cocoon.apache.org>
Betreff: Re: [VOTE] Move Apache Cocoon into the Apache Attic
+1

Joerg

PS: I already gave my +1 two days ago, but my message might be stuck
somewhere.


On 20.08.24 11:39, Christofer Dutz wrote:
> Hi all,
>
> given that there is not enough remaining activity in the Apache Cocoon
> project, we would like to start a vote on moving Apache Cocoon into the
> Apache Attic.
>
> Please vote:
>
>   * +1 if you are in favor
>   * 0 if you are indifferent about it
>   * -1 if you are not in favor, but please provide reasoning
>
> I think given the low activity here, we should keep the vote open for a
> full week.
>
> Chris
>

Re: [VOTE] Move Apache Cocoon into the Apache Attic

Posted by Jörg Heinicke <jo...@gmx.de>.
+1

Joerg

PS: I already gave my +1 two days ago, but my message might be stuck
somewhere.


On 20.08.24 11:39, Christofer Dutz wrote:
> Hi all,
>
> given that there is not enough remaining activity in the Apache Cocoon
> project, we would like to start a vote on moving Apache Cocoon into the
> Apache Attic.
>
> Please vote:
>
>   * +1 if you are in favor
>   * 0 if you are indifferent about it
>   * -1 if you are not in favor, but please provide reasoning
>
> I think given the low activity here, we should keep the vote open for a
> full week.
>
> Chris
>

Re: [VOTE] Move Apache Cocoon into the Apache Attic

Posted by Torsten Curdt <tc...@apache.org>.
+1 sad but about time


 given that there is not enough remaining activity in the Apache Cocoon
> project, we would like to start a vote on moving Apache Cocoon into the
> Apache Attic.
>
>
>
> Please vote:
>
>    - +1 if you are in favor
>    - 0 if you are indifferent about it
>    - -1 if you are not in favor, but please provide reasoning
>
>
>
> I think given the low activity here, we should keep the vote open for a
> full week.
>
>
>
> Chris
>

AW: [VOTE] Move Apache Cocoon into the Apache Attic

Posted by Christofer Dutz <ch...@c-ware.de>.
Here’s my +1 (binding)

Chris

Von: Christofer Dutz <ch...@c-ware.de>
Datum: Dienstag, 20. August 2024 um 11:40
An: dev@cocoon.apache.org <de...@cocoon.apache.org>
Betreff: [VOTE] Move Apache Cocoon into the Apache Attic
Hi all,

given that there is not enough remaining activity in the Apache Cocoon project, we would like to start a vote on moving Apache Cocoon into the Apache Attic.

Please vote:

  *   +1 if you are in favor
  *   0 if you are indifferent about it
  *   -1 if you are not in favor, but please provide reasoning

I think given the low activity here, we should keep the vote open for a full week.

Chris

Re: [VOTE] Move Apache Cocoon into the Apache Attic

Posted by Francesco Chicchiriccò <il...@apache.org>.
On 20/08/24 11:39, Christofer Dutz wrote:
>
> Hi all,
>
> given that there is not enough remaining activity in the Apache Cocoon project, we would like to start a vote on moving Apache Cocoon into the Apache Attic.
>
> Please vote:
>
>   * +1 if you are in favor
>   * 0 if you are indifferent about it
>   * -1 if you are not in favor, but please provide reasoning
>
> I think given the low activity here, we should keep the vote open for a full week.
>
+1
Regards.

-- 
Francesco Chicchiriccò

Tirasa - Open Source Excellence
http://www.tirasa.net/

Member at The Apache Software Foundation
Syncope, Cocoon, Olingo, CXF, OpenJPA, PonyMail
http://home.apache.org/~ilgrosso/

Re: [VOTE] Move Apache Cocoon into the Apache Attic

Posted by Jörg Heinicke <jo...@gmx.de>.
+1

Regards,
Joerg

On 20.08.24 11:39, Christofer Dutz wrote:
> Hi all,
>
> given that there is not enough remaining activity in the Apache Cocoon
> project, we would like to start a vote on moving Apache Cocoon into the
> Apache Attic.
>
> Please vote:
>
>   * +1 if you are in favor
>   * 0 if you are indifferent about it
>   * -1 if you are not in favor, but please provide reasoning
>
> I think given the low activity here, we should keep the vote open for a
> full week.
>
> Chris
>