You are viewing a plain text version of this content. The canonical link for it is here.
Posted to dev@openoffice.apache.org by Yuzhen Fan <fa...@gmail.com> on 2014/01/17 13:27:16 UTC
[QA][Test Report] Weekly Status Update as of 20140117
Hi All,
We started doing the AOO 4.1 Function Verification test(FVT), here is the
weekly update (1/13 - 1/17):
*Test execution:*
1. New feature testing on comments/Annotations on text ranges - Ongoing
Bugs found: (red one is critical)
Bug 124030 - Failed to open ODT file exported from AOO with
comment/annotation in original docx file (fix submitted by Oliver, will
verify with next build)
Bug 124028 - Highlight of commented/annotated text range gets lost when
export as PDF by AOO
Bug 124027 - The list numbers/bullets in comment/annotation get lost when
import .docx file to AOO
2. Improved feature testing on In-place editing of Input Fields - Complete
Bugs found:
Bug 123827- [Accessibility][IA2]Focus value of Field function type list
can't be identified in writer
Bug 123828 - [Accessibility]Tab Key can't travel in input field dialogue in
writer
Bug 123825 - The content change when importing .docx with “Date" field
Bug 123826 - The content lost when importing .docx with “Fill-in" field
3. Existing feature on 3 APP testing - Ongoing
We have assigned 287 text executions to about 5 volunteers, and completed
about 13.8% in execution (150 test executions done). We are far from and
tight to finish feature FVT before Feb 13 with current resource. I have
sent 2nd call for volunteers in community.
Total Not Run Passed Failed Blocked Completed [%]
Debian Linux 64bit 56 7 36 10 3 87.5
MacOS X 209 185 15 9 0 8.13
Redhat Linux 32bit 69 67 0 2 0 2.90
Redhat Linux 64bit 222 219 3 0 0 1.35
Ubuntu Linux 64bit 167 165 2 0 0 1.20
Windows 7 180 125 38 17 2 31.67
Windows 8 182 169 11 2 0 7.14
Total 1085 937 105 40 5 13.8
*Defect summary:* see above bug lists in Test execution
*Issues & quality highlight:*
1. We have execution gap in FVT test as lack volunteers in testing, have
sent the 2nd call for volunteers
2. Build for Mac 64bit is not available in buildbot and dev snapshot
3. Build for Linux is not available in dev snapshot
*Volunteer status: *
1. No new volunteers(total 5 so far) on FVT execution work, 2 person(Edwin
and Liu Ping) ask for more as they have completed their assignment
*Plan for next week:*
1. Continue to do FVT test on Mac, Linux and Windows
2. Continue to do testing on comments/Annotations on text ranges
3. Summarize high priority issues in Bugzilla
Thanks you all for effort this week, let's continue and make progress next
week!
Regards,
Yu Zhen
Re: [QA][Test Report] Weekly Status Update as of 20140117
Posted by Oliver-Rainer Wittmann <or...@googlemail.com>.
Hi,
Thanks for report.
I have some comments/questions - see inline below.
On 17.01.2014 13:27, Yuzhen Fan wrote:
> Hi All,
> We started doing the AOO 4.1 Function Verification test(FVT), here is the
> weekly update (1/13 - 1/17):
>
> *Test execution:*
> 1. New feature testing on comments/Annotations on text ranges - Ongoing
> Bugs found: (red one is critical)
> Bug 124030 - Failed to open ODT file exported from AOO with
> comment/annotation in original docx file (fix submitted by Oliver, will
> verify with next build)
This one is already fixed.
> Bug 124028 - Highlight of commented/annotated text range gets lost when
> export as PDF by AOO
An improvement/change to the PDF export is needed. Currently,
comments/annotations are exported as "PDF Sticky Notes" which do not
offer the feature to be applied to a text range. Instead it would make
sense to export such comments/annotations as "PDF Highlight Text". For
this deeper knowledge on the PDF file format is needed.
> Bug 124027 - The list numbers/bullets in comment/annotation get lost when
> import .docx file to AOO
This issue is not related to the improvement "comments/annotations on
text ranges".
>
> 2. Improved feature testing on In-place editing of Input Fields - Complete
> Bugs found:
> Bug 123827- [Accessibility][IA2]Focus value of Field function type list
> can't be identified in writer
> Bug 123828 - [Accessibility]Tab Key can't travel in input field dialogue in
> writer
> Bug 123825 - The content change when importing .docx with “Date" field
This issue has been closed approx. two weeks ago as NOT_AN_ISSUE.
Why is it nevertheless reported here?
> Bug 123826 - The content lost when importing .docx with “Fill-in" field
This issue is not related to the improvement "in-place editing of Input
Fields". It had been reported two weeks ago that it already occurs in
released version 4.0.1 (today, I confirmed that it reproducible also in
OOo 3.2.0 and OOo 3.3.0).
Why is it reported in context of the improvement "in-place editing of
Input Fields"?
>
> 3. Existing feature on 3 APP testing - Ongoing
> We have assigned 287 text executions to about 5 volunteers, and completed
> about 13.8% in execution (150 test executions done). We are far from and
> tight to finish feature FVT before Feb 13 with current resource. I have
> sent 2nd call for volunteers in community.
>
>
> Total Not Run Passed Failed Blocked Completed [%]
> Debian Linux 64bit 56 7 36 10 3 87.5
> MacOS X 209 185 15 9 0 8.13
> Redhat Linux 32bit 69 67 0 2 0 2.90
> Redhat Linux 64bit 222 219 3 0 0 1.35
> Ubuntu Linux 64bit 167 165 2 0 0 1.20
> Windows 7 180 125 38 17 2 31.67
> Windows 8 182 169 11 2 0 7.14
> Total 1085 937 105 40 5 13.8
>
> *Defect summary:* see above bug lists in Test execution
>
> *Issues & quality highlight:*
> 1. We have execution gap in FVT test as lack volunteers in testing, have
> sent the 2nd call for volunteers
> 2. Build for Mac 64bit is not available in buildbot and dev snapshot
> 3. Build for Linux is not available in dev snapshot
There are Linux 32bit deb-packages available on the snapshot - see
http://ci.apache.org/projects/openoffice/#linsnap
Best regards, Oliver.
>
> *Volunteer status: *
> 1. No new volunteers(total 5 so far) on FVT execution work, 2 person(Edwin
> and Liu Ping) ask for more as they have completed their assignment
>
> *Plan for next week:*
> 1. Continue to do FVT test on Mac, Linux and Windows
> 2. Continue to do testing on comments/Annotations on text ranges
> 3. Summarize high priority issues in Bugzilla
>
> Thanks you all for effort this week, let's continue and make progress next
> week!
>
> Regards,
> Yu Zhen
>
---------------------------------------------------------------------
To unsubscribe, e-mail: qa-unsubscribe@openoffice.apache.org
For additional commands, e-mail: qa-help@openoffice.apache.org
Re: [QA][Test Report] Weekly Status Update as of 20140117
Posted by Oliver-Rainer Wittmann <or...@googlemail.com>.
Hi,
Thanks for report.
I have some comments/questions - see inline below.
On 17.01.2014 13:27, Yuzhen Fan wrote:
> Hi All,
> We started doing the AOO 4.1 Function Verification test(FVT), here is the
> weekly update (1/13 - 1/17):
>
> *Test execution:*
> 1. New feature testing on comments/Annotations on text ranges - Ongoing
> Bugs found: (red one is critical)
> Bug 124030 - Failed to open ODT file exported from AOO with
> comment/annotation in original docx file (fix submitted by Oliver, will
> verify with next build)
This one is already fixed.
> Bug 124028 - Highlight of commented/annotated text range gets lost when
> export as PDF by AOO
An improvement/change to the PDF export is needed. Currently,
comments/annotations are exported as "PDF Sticky Notes" which do not
offer the feature to be applied to a text range. Instead it would make
sense to export such comments/annotations as "PDF Highlight Text". For
this deeper knowledge on the PDF file format is needed.
> Bug 124027 - The list numbers/bullets in comment/annotation get lost when
> import .docx file to AOO
This issue is not related to the improvement "comments/annotations on
text ranges".
>
> 2. Improved feature testing on In-place editing of Input Fields - Complete
> Bugs found:
> Bug 123827- [Accessibility][IA2]Focus value of Field function type list
> can't be identified in writer
> Bug 123828 - [Accessibility]Tab Key can't travel in input field dialogue in
> writer
> Bug 123825 - The content change when importing .docx with “Date" field
This issue has been closed approx. two weeks ago as NOT_AN_ISSUE.
Why is it nevertheless reported here?
> Bug 123826 - The content lost when importing .docx with “Fill-in" field
This issue is not related to the improvement "in-place editing of Input
Fields". It had been reported two weeks ago that it already occurs in
released version 4.0.1 (today, I confirmed that it reproducible also in
OOo 3.2.0 and OOo 3.3.0).
Why is it reported in context of the improvement "in-place editing of
Input Fields"?
>
> 3. Existing feature on 3 APP testing - Ongoing
> We have assigned 287 text executions to about 5 volunteers, and completed
> about 13.8% in execution (150 test executions done). We are far from and
> tight to finish feature FVT before Feb 13 with current resource. I have
> sent 2nd call for volunteers in community.
>
>
> Total Not Run Passed Failed Blocked Completed [%]
> Debian Linux 64bit 56 7 36 10 3 87.5
> MacOS X 209 185 15 9 0 8.13
> Redhat Linux 32bit 69 67 0 2 0 2.90
> Redhat Linux 64bit 222 219 3 0 0 1.35
> Ubuntu Linux 64bit 167 165 2 0 0 1.20
> Windows 7 180 125 38 17 2 31.67
> Windows 8 182 169 11 2 0 7.14
> Total 1085 937 105 40 5 13.8
>
> *Defect summary:* see above bug lists in Test execution
>
> *Issues & quality highlight:*
> 1. We have execution gap in FVT test as lack volunteers in testing, have
> sent the 2nd call for volunteers
> 2. Build for Mac 64bit is not available in buildbot and dev snapshot
> 3. Build for Linux is not available in dev snapshot
There are Linux 32bit deb-packages available on the snapshot - see
http://ci.apache.org/projects/openoffice/#linsnap
Best regards, Oliver.
>
> *Volunteer status: *
> 1. No new volunteers(total 5 so far) on FVT execution work, 2 person(Edwin
> and Liu Ping) ask for more as they have completed their assignment
>
> *Plan for next week:*
> 1. Continue to do FVT test on Mac, Linux and Windows
> 2. Continue to do testing on comments/Annotations on text ranges
> 3. Summarize high priority issues in Bugzilla
>
> Thanks you all for effort this week, let's continue and make progress next
> week!
>
> Regards,
> Yu Zhen
>
---------------------------------------------------------------------
To unsubscribe, e-mail: dev-unsubscribe@openoffice.apache.org
For additional commands, e-mail: dev-help@openoffice.apache.org
Re: [QA][Test Report] Weekly Status Update as of 20140117
Posted by Edwin Sharp <el...@mail-page.com>.
IMHO the word "volunteer" deters people and must be replaced with a more enticing term.
Regarding point 2 - there's a volunteer hiding in every bug reporter...
On Fri, Jan 17, 2014, at 16:12, Rob Weir wrote:
> On Fri, Jan 17, 2014 at 7:58 AM, Edwin Sharp <el...@mail-page.com> wrote:
> > 85,083,221 downloads and only 5 volunteers???
> >
>
> It is a strange thing, but we seem to attract many more testers 1-week
> before we release. But not so many volunteers 2 months before
> release.
>
> Three sources of more help:
>
> 1) Explain to existing volunteers that it is important to test now,
> early. The later we wait the harder it will be. Just because we are
> having a beta does not mean we don't also need to test. Beta is
> supplement to testing, not a replacement for testing.
>
> 2) See if there are any volunteers in other areas, dev, documentation,
> marketing, support, etc., who can help.
>
> 3) A public call for new volunteers
>
> Regards,
>
> -Rob
>
> > On Fri, Jan 17, 2014, at 14:27, Yuzhen Fan wrote:
> >> Hi All,
> >> We started doing the AOO 4.1 Function Verification test(FVT), here is the
> >> weekly update (1/13 - 1/17):
> >>
> >> *Test execution:*
> >> 1. New feature testing on comments/Annotations on text ranges - Ongoing
> >> Bugs found: (red one is critical)
> >> Bug 124030 - Failed to open ODT file exported from AOO with
> >> comment/annotation in original docx file (fix submitted by Oliver, will
> >> verify with next build)
> >> Bug 124028 - Highlight of commented/annotated text range gets lost when
> >> export as PDF by AOO
> >> Bug 124027 - The list numbers/bullets in comment/annotation get lost when
> >> import .docx file to AOO
> >>
> >> 2. Improved feature testing on In-place editing of Input Fields - Complete
> >> Bugs found:
> >> Bug 123827- [Accessibility][IA2]Focus value of Field function type list
> >> can't be identified in writer
> >> Bug 123828 - [Accessibility]Tab Key can't travel in input field dialogue in
> >> writer
> >> Bug 123825 - The content change when importing .docx with “Date" field
> >> Bug 123826 - The content lost when importing .docx with “Fill-in" field
> >>
> >> 3. Existing feature on 3 APP testing - Ongoing
> >> We have assigned 287 text executions to about 5 volunteers, and completed
> >> about 13.8% in execution (150 test executions done). We are far from and
> >> tight to finish feature FVT before Feb 13 with current resource. I have
> >> sent 2nd call for volunteers in community.
> >>
> >>
> >> Total Not Run Passed Failed Blocked Completed [%]
> >> Debian Linux 64bit 56 7 36 10 3 87.5
> >> MacOS X 209 185 15 9 0 8.13
> >> Redhat Linux 32bit 69 67 0 2 0 2.90
> >> Redhat Linux 64bit 222 219 3 0 0 1.35
> >> Ubuntu Linux 64bit 167 165 2 0 0 1.20
> >> Windows 7 180 125 38 17 2 31.67
> >> Windows 8 182 169 11 2 0 7.14
> >> Total 1085 937 105 40 5 13.8
> >>
> >> *Defect summary:* see above bug lists in Test execution
> >>
> >> *Issues & quality highlight:*
> >> 1. We have execution gap in FVT test as lack volunteers in testing, have
> >> sent the 2nd call for volunteers
> >> 2. Build for Mac 64bit is not available in buildbot and dev snapshot
> >> 3. Build for Linux is not available in dev snapshot
> >>
> >> *Volunteer status: *
> >> 1. No new volunteers(total 5 so far) on FVT execution work, 2 person(Edwin
> >> and Liu Ping) ask for more as they have completed their assignment
> >>
> >> *Plan for next week:*
> >> 1. Continue to do FVT test on Mac, Linux and Windows
> >> 2. Continue to do testing on comments/Annotations on text ranges
> >> 3. Summarize high priority issues in Bugzilla
> >>
> >> Thanks you all for effort this week, let's continue and make progress next
> >> week!
> >>
> >> Regards,
> >> Yu Zhen
> >
> > ---------------------------------------------------------------------
> > To unsubscribe, e-mail: qa-unsubscribe@openoffice.apache.org
> > For additional commands, e-mail: qa-help@openoffice.apache.org
> >
>
> ---------------------------------------------------------------------
> To unsubscribe, e-mail: qa-unsubscribe@openoffice.apache.org
> For additional commands, e-mail: qa-help@openoffice.apache.org
>
---------------------------------------------------------------------
To unsubscribe, e-mail: qa-unsubscribe@openoffice.apache.org
For additional commands, e-mail: qa-help@openoffice.apache.org
Re: [QA][Test Report] Weekly Status Update as of 20140117
Posted by Rob Weir <ro...@apache.org>.
On Fri, Jan 17, 2014 at 7:58 AM, Edwin Sharp <el...@mail-page.com> wrote:
> 85,083,221 downloads and only 5 volunteers???
>
It is a strange thing, but we seem to attract many more testers 1-week
before we release. But not so many volunteers 2 months before
release.
Three sources of more help:
1) Explain to existing volunteers that it is important to test now,
early. The later we wait the harder it will be. Just because we are
having a beta does not mean we don't also need to test. Beta is
supplement to testing, not a replacement for testing.
2) See if there are any volunteers in other areas, dev, documentation,
marketing, support, etc., who can help.
3) A public call for new volunteers
Regards,
-Rob
> On Fri, Jan 17, 2014, at 14:27, Yuzhen Fan wrote:
>> Hi All,
>> We started doing the AOO 4.1 Function Verification test(FVT), here is the
>> weekly update (1/13 - 1/17):
>>
>> *Test execution:*
>> 1. New feature testing on comments/Annotations on text ranges - Ongoing
>> Bugs found: (red one is critical)
>> Bug 124030 - Failed to open ODT file exported from AOO with
>> comment/annotation in original docx file (fix submitted by Oliver, will
>> verify with next build)
>> Bug 124028 - Highlight of commented/annotated text range gets lost when
>> export as PDF by AOO
>> Bug 124027 - The list numbers/bullets in comment/annotation get lost when
>> import .docx file to AOO
>>
>> 2. Improved feature testing on In-place editing of Input Fields - Complete
>> Bugs found:
>> Bug 123827- [Accessibility][IA2]Focus value of Field function type list
>> can't be identified in writer
>> Bug 123828 - [Accessibility]Tab Key can't travel in input field dialogue in
>> writer
>> Bug 123825 - The content change when importing .docx with “Date" field
>> Bug 123826 - The content lost when importing .docx with “Fill-in" field
>>
>> 3. Existing feature on 3 APP testing - Ongoing
>> We have assigned 287 text executions to about 5 volunteers, and completed
>> about 13.8% in execution (150 test executions done). We are far from and
>> tight to finish feature FVT before Feb 13 with current resource. I have
>> sent 2nd call for volunteers in community.
>>
>>
>> Total Not Run Passed Failed Blocked Completed [%]
>> Debian Linux 64bit 56 7 36 10 3 87.5
>> MacOS X 209 185 15 9 0 8.13
>> Redhat Linux 32bit 69 67 0 2 0 2.90
>> Redhat Linux 64bit 222 219 3 0 0 1.35
>> Ubuntu Linux 64bit 167 165 2 0 0 1.20
>> Windows 7 180 125 38 17 2 31.67
>> Windows 8 182 169 11 2 0 7.14
>> Total 1085 937 105 40 5 13.8
>>
>> *Defect summary:* see above bug lists in Test execution
>>
>> *Issues & quality highlight:*
>> 1. We have execution gap in FVT test as lack volunteers in testing, have
>> sent the 2nd call for volunteers
>> 2. Build for Mac 64bit is not available in buildbot and dev snapshot
>> 3. Build for Linux is not available in dev snapshot
>>
>> *Volunteer status: *
>> 1. No new volunteers(total 5 so far) on FVT execution work, 2 person(Edwin
>> and Liu Ping) ask for more as they have completed their assignment
>>
>> *Plan for next week:*
>> 1. Continue to do FVT test on Mac, Linux and Windows
>> 2. Continue to do testing on comments/Annotations on text ranges
>> 3. Summarize high priority issues in Bugzilla
>>
>> Thanks you all for effort this week, let's continue and make progress next
>> week!
>>
>> Regards,
>> Yu Zhen
>
> ---------------------------------------------------------------------
> To unsubscribe, e-mail: qa-unsubscribe@openoffice.apache.org
> For additional commands, e-mail: qa-help@openoffice.apache.org
>
---------------------------------------------------------------------
To unsubscribe, e-mail: qa-unsubscribe@openoffice.apache.org
For additional commands, e-mail: qa-help@openoffice.apache.org
Re: [QA][Test Report] Weekly Status Update as of 20140117
Posted by Edwin Sharp <el...@mail-page.com>.
85,083,221 downloads and only 5 volunteers???
On Fri, Jan 17, 2014, at 14:27, Yuzhen Fan wrote:
> Hi All,
> We started doing the AOO 4.1 Function Verification test(FVT), here is the
> weekly update (1/13 - 1/17):
>
> *Test execution:*
> 1. New feature testing on comments/Annotations on text ranges - Ongoing
> Bugs found: (red one is critical)
> Bug 124030 - Failed to open ODT file exported from AOO with
> comment/annotation in original docx file (fix submitted by Oliver, will
> verify with next build)
> Bug 124028 - Highlight of commented/annotated text range gets lost when
> export as PDF by AOO
> Bug 124027 - The list numbers/bullets in comment/annotation get lost when
> import .docx file to AOO
>
> 2. Improved feature testing on In-place editing of Input Fields - Complete
> Bugs found:
> Bug 123827- [Accessibility][IA2]Focus value of Field function type list
> can't be identified in writer
> Bug 123828 - [Accessibility]Tab Key can't travel in input field dialogue in
> writer
> Bug 123825 - The content change when importing .docx with “Date" field
> Bug 123826 - The content lost when importing .docx with “Fill-in" field
>
> 3. Existing feature on 3 APP testing - Ongoing
> We have assigned 287 text executions to about 5 volunteers, and completed
> about 13.8% in execution (150 test executions done). We are far from and
> tight to finish feature FVT before Feb 13 with current resource. I have
> sent 2nd call for volunteers in community.
>
>
> Total Not Run Passed Failed Blocked Completed [%]
> Debian Linux 64bit 56 7 36 10 3 87.5
> MacOS X 209 185 15 9 0 8.13
> Redhat Linux 32bit 69 67 0 2 0 2.90
> Redhat Linux 64bit 222 219 3 0 0 1.35
> Ubuntu Linux 64bit 167 165 2 0 0 1.20
> Windows 7 180 125 38 17 2 31.67
> Windows 8 182 169 11 2 0 7.14
> Total 1085 937 105 40 5 13.8
>
> *Defect summary:* see above bug lists in Test execution
>
> *Issues & quality highlight:*
> 1. We have execution gap in FVT test as lack volunteers in testing, have
> sent the 2nd call for volunteers
> 2. Build for Mac 64bit is not available in buildbot and dev snapshot
> 3. Build for Linux is not available in dev snapshot
>
> *Volunteer status: *
> 1. No new volunteers(total 5 so far) on FVT execution work, 2 person(Edwin
> and Liu Ping) ask for more as they have completed their assignment
>
> *Plan for next week:*
> 1. Continue to do FVT test on Mac, Linux and Windows
> 2. Continue to do testing on comments/Annotations on text ranges
> 3. Summarize high priority issues in Bugzilla
>
> Thanks you all for effort this week, let's continue and make progress next
> week!
>
> Regards,
> Yu Zhen
---------------------------------------------------------------------
To unsubscribe, e-mail: qa-unsubscribe@openoffice.apache.org
For additional commands, e-mail: qa-help@openoffice.apache.org