Request to Committers

[David E Jones <da...@hotwaxmedia.com>]

All OFBiz Committers,

This is kind of a reminder, but more of a request: please do not  
commit or even consider committing a contributed patch (ie through  
Jira) that you do not fully understand or that changes parts of OFBiz  
that you do not fully understand. If you really want to work on such a  
contribution then work to fully understand the parts involved and the  
changes in the patch. Alternatively, get someone else involved who has  
worked in that area and be patient for further involvement. Remember  
in the committer guidelines it mentions something about "first do no  
harm", or in other words don't break stuff when trying to improve it  
or things related to it.

Also, please be careful with other commits that seem to not be  
reviewed a whole lot. One example is localization patches. These seem  
to go in with little or no review, and the result is there are a LOT  
of weird and confusing labels throughout OFBiz. I usually look at  
OFBiz in English, and even there I've noticed a lot of cases where the  
original text was replaced by something that means something different  
from the original. We need to all be more careful, and while it's  
great to get contributions in we shouldn't feel pressured to get them  
in fast without careful review. In fact, the more contributions are  
reviewed and the more feedback we give as committers the more people  
contributing will learn and the higher the chances are that they will  
get more closely involved with OFBiz, and join the team of committers.

Thanks,
-David

Re: Request to Committers

[ri...@gmail.com]

Hello David,

I'm complete agree with you that there are a lot of confusing labels  
and I have start to clear most of the wrong labels into Ecommerce but  
it is a very big job.
So I decide to create a small tools that show us all the labels in  
OFBiz and advice on possible issues.
I have created a new JIRA issue (OFBIZ-2070) New tool to get labels  
information  for it also if it's not completed to develop it.
Hoping that it can help all of us to understand wrong labels and  
correct it.

Thanks
Marco


Il giorno 26/nov/08, alle ore 06:22, David E Jones ha scritto:

>
> All OFBiz Committers,
>
> This is kind of a reminder, but more of a request: please do not  
> commit or even consider committing a contributed patch (ie through  
> Jira) that you do not fully understand or that changes parts of  
> OFBiz that you do not fully understand. If you really want to work  
> on such a contribution then work to fully understand the parts  
> involved and the changes in the patch. Alternatively, get someone  
> else involved who has worked in that area and be patient for further  
> involvement. Remember in the committer guidelines it mentions  
> something about "first do no harm", or in other words don't break  
> stuff when trying to improve it or things related to it.
>
> Also, please be careful with other commits that seem to not be  
> reviewed a whole lot. One example is localization patches. These  
> seem to go in with little or no review, and the result is there are  
> a LOT of weird and confusing labels throughout OFBiz. I usually look  
> at OFBiz in English, and even there I've noticed a lot of cases  
> where the original text was replaced by something that means  
> something different from the original. We need to all be more  
> careful, and while it's great to get contributions in we shouldn't  
> feel pressured to get them in fast without careful review. In fact,  
> the more contributions are reviewed and the more feedback we give as  
> committers the more people contributing will learn and the higher  
> the chances are that they will get more closely involved with OFBiz,  
> and join the team of committers.
>
> Thanks,
> -David