You are viewing a plain text version of this content. The canonical link for it is here.
Posted to users@activemq.apache.org by Jelmer Marinus <je...@hotmail.com> on 2022/10/06 07:16:17 UTC
Messages getting lost on Artemis 2.25
Hi,
During the testing of the message-counters (see other mail) we also seem to have lost messages. It looks like these messages get lost during redistribution or when they get produced to the cluster. Any thoughts on that ?
Some extra information (the same as for the message-counter test).
We produced 5000 messages to a queue on each cluster node (3 node symmetric cluster). When we consumed the messages through on of the cluster nodes we didn't get all the messages. Sometimes we were missing 1/3 of the messages (probably from one node). So when we produced 3 times 5000 messages and we consumed them through one node, using redistribution to get the messages from the other nodes, we sometimes only got 10000 messages of the 15000 produced. The message-counters were back to zero and we were not able to consumer more messages. There we no other consumers on the queue.
Our set-up is as follows:
* Artemis 2.25 running in a Docker container on Linux.
* Primary - Backup setup using replication (there was no replication going on during the test)
* 3 node symmetric cluster (3 primary, 3 backup)
* One-to-one relationship between the addresses and the anycast queues.
* There was paging on the queues.
* ZGC garbage collector
Best regards,
Jelmer
Re: Messages getting lost on Artemis 2.25
Posted by Jelmer Marinus <je...@hotmail.com>.
We are trying to create a scenario which reproduces the issue in a few specific steps. But we haven't yet.
________________________________
From: Clebert Suconic <cl...@gmail.com>
Sent: Thursday, October 6, 2022 1:51 PM
To: users@activemq.apache.org <us...@activemq.apache.org>
Subject: Re: Messages getting lost on Artemis 2.25
Do you have a test to reproduce the issue ?
On Thu, Oct 6, 2022 at 3:16 AM Jelmer Marinus <je...@hotmail.com>
wrote:
> Hi,
>
> During the testing of the message-counters (see other mail) we also seem
> to have lost messages. It looks like these messages get lost during
> redistribution or when they get produced to the cluster. Any thoughts on
> that ?
>
> Some extra information (the same as for the message-counter test).
>
> We produced 5000 messages to a queue on each cluster node (3 node
> symmetric cluster). When we consumed the messages through on of the cluster
> nodes we didn't get all the messages. Sometimes we were missing 1/3 of the
> messages (probably from one node). So when we produced 3 times 5000
> messages and we consumed them through one node, using redistribution to get
> the messages from the other nodes, we sometimes only got 10000 messages of
> the 15000 produced. The message-counters were back to zero and we were not
> able to consumer more messages. There we no other consumers on the queue.
>
> Our set-up is as follows:
>
> * Artemis 2.25 running in a Docker container on Linux.
> * Primary - Backup setup using replication (there was no replication
> going on during the test)
> * 3 node symmetric cluster (3 primary, 3 backup)
> * One-to-one relationship between the addresses and the anycast queues.
> * There was paging on the queues.
> * ZGC garbage collector
>
> Best regards,
> Jelmer
>
> --
Clebert Suconic
Re: Messages getting lost on Artemis 2.25
Posted by Clebert Suconic <cl...@gmail.com>.
Do you have a test to reproduce the issue ?
On Thu, Oct 6, 2022 at 3:16 AM Jelmer Marinus <je...@hotmail.com>
wrote:
> Hi,
>
> During the testing of the message-counters (see other mail) we also seem
> to have lost messages. It looks like these messages get lost during
> redistribution or when they get produced to the cluster. Any thoughts on
> that ?
>
> Some extra information (the same as for the message-counter test).
>
> We produced 5000 messages to a queue on each cluster node (3 node
> symmetric cluster). When we consumed the messages through on of the cluster
> nodes we didn't get all the messages. Sometimes we were missing 1/3 of the
> messages (probably from one node). So when we produced 3 times 5000
> messages and we consumed them through one node, using redistribution to get
> the messages from the other nodes, we sometimes only got 10000 messages of
> the 15000 produced. The message-counters were back to zero and we were not
> able to consumer more messages. There we no other consumers on the queue.
>
> Our set-up is as follows:
>
> * Artemis 2.25 running in a Docker container on Linux.
> * Primary - Backup setup using replication (there was no replication
> going on during the test)
> * 3 node symmetric cluster (3 primary, 3 backup)
> * One-to-one relationship between the addresses and the anycast queues.
> * There was paging on the queues.
> * ZGC garbage collector
>
> Best regards,
> Jelmer
>
> --
Clebert Suconic