You are viewing a plain text version of this content. The canonical link for it is here.
Posted to users@spamassassin.apache.org by Chuck Campbell <ca...@accelinc.com> on 2004/06/15 23:38:06 UTC
Where do I read about surbl/SA v3.x?
I've seen tons of email on this list about surbl and uribl, but I haven't
really made sense of it yet.
Is ther a FAQ on this stuff for SA users? Does it deal with performance
issues?
thanks,
-chuck
Re: Where do I read about surbl/SA v3.x?
Posted by Jeff Chan <je...@surbl.org>.
On Wednesday, June 16, 2004, 1:36:17 PM, Chuck Campbell wrote:
> On Wed, Jun 16, 2004 at 01:17:49PM -0700, Jeff Chan wrote:
>> On Wednesday, June 16, 2004, 11:53:36 AM, Lucas Albers wrote:
>>
>> > Jeff Chan said:
>> >> You only need to set up a local mirror to cache the RBL zone
>> >> files if you have a high volume mail system, say more than
>> >> 100k inbound messages per day. For less volume it's ok to use
>> >> the public nameservers.
>> >>
>> > What caching systems do people use with surbl/spamassassin?
>> > Is their a document that goes over the steps to setting up a caching only
>> > dns server for spamassassin/surbl?
>>
>> Hehe, there are many documents describing setting up rbldnsd at:
>>
>> http://www.surbl.org/links.html
>>
>> Many people use rbldnsd....
> Is this in addition to a standard dns setup, or does it replace something?
rbldnsd is a specialized name server most often used for serving
up RBLs. It's significantly faster and smaller than BIND:
http://www.corpit.ru/mjt/rbldnsd.html
It can be used alone or with BIND as described at some of the
"Mirroring rbl zone files locally" links at:
http://www.surbl.org/links.html
Jeff C.
--
Jeff Chan
mailto:jeffc@surbl.org
http://www.surbl.org/
Re: Where do I read about surbl/SA v3.x?
Posted by Chuck Campbell <ca...@accelinc.com>.
On Wed, Jun 16, 2004 at 01:17:49PM -0700, Jeff Chan wrote:
> On Wednesday, June 16, 2004, 11:53:36 AM, Lucas Albers wrote:
>
> > Jeff Chan said:
> >> You only need to set up a local mirror to cache the RBL zone
> >> files if you have a high volume mail system, say more than
> >> 100k inbound messages per day. For less volume it's ok to use
> >> the public nameservers.
> >>
> > What caching systems do people use with surbl/spamassassin?
> > Is their a document that goes over the steps to setting up a caching only
> > dns server for spamassassin/surbl?
>
> Hehe, there are many documents describing setting up rbldnsd at:
>
> http://www.surbl.org/links.html
>
> Many people use rbldnsd....
Is this in addition to a standard dns setup, or does it replace something?
-chuck
Re: Where do I read about surbl/SA v3.x?
Posted by Jeff Chan <je...@surbl.org>.
On Wednesday, June 16, 2004, 11:53:36 AM, Lucas Albers wrote:
> Jeff Chan said:
>> You only need to set up a local mirror to cache the RBL zone
>> files if you have a high volume mail system, say more than
>> 100k inbound messages per day. For less volume it's ok to use
>> the public nameservers.
>>
> What caching systems do people use with surbl/spamassassin?
> Is their a document that goes over the steps to setting up a caching only
> dns server for spamassassin/surbl?
Hehe, there are many documents describing setting up rbldnsd at:
http://www.surbl.org/links.html
Many people use rbldnsd....
Jeff C.
--
Jeff Chan
mailto:jeffc@surbl.org
http://www.surbl.org/
Re: Where do I read about surbl/SA v3.x?
Posted by Lucas Albers <ad...@cs.montana.edu>.
Jeff Chan said:
> You only need to set up a local mirror to cache the RBL zone
> files if you have a high volume mail system, say more than
> 100k inbound messages per day. For less volume it's ok to use
> the public nameservers.
>
What caching systems do people use with surbl/spamassassin?
Is their a document that goes over the steps to setting up a caching only
dns server for spamassassin/surbl?
--
Luke Computer Science System Administrator
Security Administrator,College of Engineering
Montana State University-Bozeman,Montana
Re: Where do I read about surbl/SA v3.x?
Posted by Jeff Chan <je...@surbl.org>.
On Tuesday, June 15, 2004, 3:50:42 PM, Chuck Campbell wrote:
> If I elect to stay with SA 2.63, then I should download and install
> spamcopuri v0.18??
Yes, SpamCopURI is a program that can be used with all SURBLs
in SA 2.63.
> If I choose to go with SA 3.x, I first need to upgrade to teh new SA, and then
> use uridnsbl or uribl or urirhsbl or ...
uridnsbl is the SA 3 program that checks message body URIs
against numeric RBLs, i.e. by resolving the URI domain names
into IP addresses then checking those IP addresses against
the RBL.
urirhsbl is the SA 3 program that checks message body URIs
against SURBLs, i.e., it compares (mostly) domain names found
in message bodies against (mostly) domain names in SURBLs.
In fact the sample configurations shipped with uribl
(which is the pm that contains both uridnsbl and urirhsbl)
has those programs using sbl.spamhaus.org and SURBLs
respectively:
http://www.spamassassin.org/full/3.0.x/dist/rules/25_uribl.cf
uridnsbl URIBL_SBL sbl.spamhaus.org. TXT
header URIBL_SBL eval:check_uridnsbl('URIBL_SBL')
describe URIBL_SBL Contains a URL listed in the SBL blocklist
tflags URIBL_SBL net
urirhsbl URIBL_SC_SURBL sc.surbl.org. A
header URIBL_SC_SURBL eval:check_uridnsbl('URIBL_SC_SURBL')
describe URIBL_SC_SURBL Contains a URL listed in the SC SURBL blocklist
tflags URIBL_SC_SURBL net
I'm adding the above to the SURBL FAQ. If anyone spots any
errors with the above, please let me know.
> Then of course there is the ws.surbl and the be.surbl
> and all of the talk about setting up dns, etc.
You only need to set up a local mirror to cache the RBL zone
files if you have a high volume mail system, say more than
100k inbound messages per day. For less volume it's ok to use
the public nameservers.
At present [sc] and [ws] would be the lists to use. [be] is
being deprecated in favor of [ws].
Jeff C.
Re: Where do I read about surbl/SA v3.x?
Posted by Bill Landry <Bi...@Pointshare.com>.
----- Original Message -----
From: "Chuck Campbell" <ca...@accelinc.com>
> > Sure, check-out www.surbl.org for lots of info about surbl/uribl. If
you
> > are using any of the custom URI rulesets, then switching to the DNS
based
> > URI tests instead should provide a nice performance increase.
>
> I don't believe I'm using any custom URI rulesets (I've never added
anything
> but chickenpox, popcorn, bigevil). If these are custom URI rulesets, then
> I just learned some new vocabulary :-)
bigevil is a URI based ruleset. If you view the file contents, you will
note that each test begins with "uri". This means that the test is looking
for specific URIs in the message body.
> I read the whole site, and I have a fuzzy picture now, but I don't really
know
> how to jump into this pool.
There are additional requirements and setup instructions included in the
spamcop_uri plug-in tar file.
> If I elect to stay with SA 2.63, then I should download and install
> spamcopuri v0.18?? I assume I would find detailed instructions therein
> for setting it up?
Yes, and instructions are included.
> If I choose to go with SA 3.x, I first need to upgrade to teh new SA, and
then
> use uridnsbl or uribl or urirhsbl or ... This is where my confusion
> lies at the moment. Then of course there is the ws.surbl and the be.surbl
> and all of the talk about setting up dns, etc.
The basic spamcop_uri.cf included with the spamcopuri v0.18 tar file will
get you started. If you need help setting up any additional tests after the
install, let us know.
> I was hoping for a howto kind of document, but maybe I'm the one who has
> to write it as I learn???
Check out the instructions in the included INSTALL file and let us know if
you need more help.
Bill
Re: Where do I read about surbl/SA v3.x?
Posted by Chuck Campbell <ca...@accelinc.com>.
On Tue, Jun 15, 2004 at 02:47:27PM -0700, Bill Landry wrote:
> ----- Original Message -----
> From: "Chuck Campbell" <ca...@accelinc.com>
>
> > I've seen tons of email on this list about surbl and uribl, but I haven't
> > really made sense of it yet.
> >
> > Is ther a FAQ on this stuff for SA users? Does it deal with performance
> > issues?
>
> Sure, check-out www.surbl.org for lots of info about surbl/uribl. If you
> are using any of the custom URI rulesets, then switching to the DNS based
> URI tests instead should provide a nice performance increase.
I don't believe I'm using any custom URI rulesets (I've never added anything
but chickenpox, popcorn, bigevil). If these are custom URI rulesets, then
I just learned some new vocabulary :-)
I read the whole site, and I have a fuzzy picture now, but I don't really know
how to jump into this pool.
If I elect to stay with SA 2.63, then I should download and install
spamcopuri v0.18?? I assume I would find detailed instructions therein
for setting it up?
If I choose to go with SA 3.x, I first need to upgrade to teh new SA, and then
use uridnsbl or uribl or urirhsbl or ... This is where my confusion
lies at the moment. Then of course there is the ws.surbl and the be.surbl
and all of the talk about setting up dns, etc.
I was hoping for a howto kind of document, but maybe I'm the one who has
to write it as I learn???
-chuck
Re: Where do I read about surbl/SA v3.x?
Posted by Jeff Chan <je...@surbl.org>.
On Wednesday, June 16, 2004, 11:51:45 AM, Lucas Albers wrote:
> Bill Landry said:
>> We receives about 200,000 e-mail messages per day, split between two
> mail
>> gateways, and have had no resource issues with using the additional
> redirect
>> options with spamcop_uri. You can find info on how to setup and support
> the
>> redirect options in the "rules/spamcop_uri.cf" file of the spamcopuri
> tarball.
> Jeff,
> How bout changing the default surbl in 2.63 in the next release,
> so redirector support is enabled.
> It appears to not have any signifigant effect on performance, as per this
> email.
This is a suggestion for Erik Kolve, who is the author of
SpamCopURI. SURBLs themselves are only the data side of things.
Jeff C.
--
Jeff Chan
mailto:jeffc@surbl.org
http://www.surbl.org/
Re: Where do I read about surbl/SA v3.x?
Posted by Lucas Albers <ad...@cs.montana.edu>.
Bill Landry said:
> We receives about 200,000 e-mail messages per day, split between two
mail
> gateways, and have had no resource issues with using the additional
redirect
> options with spamcop_uri. You can find info on how to setup and support
the
> redirect options in the "rules/spamcop_uri.cf" file of the spamcopuri
tarball.
Jeff,
How bout changing the default surbl in 2.63 in the next release,
so redirector support is enabled.
It appears to not have any signifigant effect on performance, as per this
email.
--
Luke Computer Science System Administrator
Security Administrator,College of Engineering
Montana State University-Bozeman,Montana
Re: Where do I read about surbl/SA v3.x?
Posted by Bill Landry <Bi...@Pointshare.com>.
----- Original Message -----
From: "Chuck Campbell" <ca...@accelinc.com>
> > > Sure, check-out www.surbl.org for lots of info about surbl/uribl. If
you
> > > are using any of the custom URI rulesets, then switching to the DNS
based
> > > URI tests instead should provide a nice performance increase.
> >
> > High load sites should not enable redirector support in surbl.
>
> What is high load? I get about 5000 to 6000 emails a day where I'm
planning
> on implementing this. Currently I have a ratio (using SA) of about
> 2:1 ham to spam, specifically because of the high volume mailing lists.
>
> w/o mailing lists the ratio is more like 100:1 spam:ham
>
> I'm looking to sort this out for a group of about 30 email users.
We receives about 200,000 e-mail messages per day, split between two mail
gateways, and have had no resource issues with using the additional redirect
options with spamcop_uri. You can find info on how to setup and support the
redirect options in the "rules/spamcop_uri.cf" file of the spamcopuri
tarball.
Monitor your server processor utilization and if it start getting high, you
can always disable the redirect support later.
Bill
Re: Where do I read about surbl/SA v3.x?
Posted by Chuck Campbell <ca...@accelinc.com>.
On Tue, Jun 15, 2004 at 04:14:19PM -0600, Lucas Albers wrote:
>
> Bill Landry said:
> > Sure, check-out www.surbl.org for lots of info about surbl/uribl. If you
> > are using any of the custom URI rulesets, then switching to the DNS based
> > URI tests instead should provide a nice performance increase.
> >
> > Bill
>
> High load sites should not enable redirector support in surbl.
What is high load? I get about 5000 to 6000 emails a day where I'm planning
on implementing this. Currently I have a ratio (using SA) of about
2:1 ham to spam, specifically because of the high volume mailing lists.
w/o mailing lists the ratio is more like 100:1 spam:ham
I'm looking to sort this out for a group of about 30 email users.
thanks,
-chuck
Re: Where do I read about surbl/SA v3.x?
Posted by Lucas Albers <ad...@cs.montana.edu>.
Bill Landry said:
> Sure, check-out www.surbl.org for lots of info about surbl/uribl. If you
> are using any of the custom URI rulesets, then switching to the DNS based
> URI tests instead should provide a nice performance increase.
>
> Bill
High load sites should not enable redirector support in surbl.
Luke Computer Science System Administrator
--
Luke Computer Science System Administrator
Security Administrator,College of Engineering
Montana State University-Bozeman,Montana
Re: Where do I read about surbl/SA v3.x?
Posted by Bill Landry <Bi...@Pointshare.com>.
----- Original Message -----
From: "Chuck Campbell" <ca...@accelinc.com>
> I've seen tons of email on this list about surbl and uribl, but I haven't
> really made sense of it yet.
>
> Is ther a FAQ on this stuff for SA users? Does it deal with performance
> issues?
Sure, check-out www.surbl.org for lots of info about surbl/uribl. If you
are using any of the custom URI rulesets, then switching to the DNS based
URI tests instead should provide a nice performance increase.
Bill