You are viewing a plain text version of this content. The canonical link for it is here.
Posted to dev@flex.apache.org by Left Right <ol...@gmail.com> on 2012/08/31 11:30:29 UTC
May I fork the project for creating a reduced version of it?
Hi again,
After some thinking... this is my question, but I'm not yet mentally
ready to do it, only wondering about the consequences of it.
So... The SDK needs to be significantly changed in order for it to be
built and used on Linux. The changes aren't as much related to the
code of the SDK itself as to the way it is built, packaged and
distributed.
So, my very far going plan was like this: find the bits that will
function / make sense on Linux (these are the asc, compiler, debugger,
swfutils and some more) and create from them a DEB package. I'd host
it on launchpad.com because it will give at least the Ubuntu users the
familiar interface for installing / updating the program.
Things that are not possible to use include these:
- anything that uses Flash player 11.3 or later.
- anything that uses AIR 3.0 or later.
- anything that uses PixelBender.
- I'm not sure about things that target Android / iOS.
I would primarily try to get the compiler functioning.
Well, I guess, I'd need your permission to do this, as this isn't
technically a mirror or something. Besides you may or may not want to
give this permission :) are there any legal impediments for doing so?
If this is technically possible, I've also one more question: what is
the state of Falcon and how hard do you think will it be to get it to
compile and to work on Linux? I've tried to check it out, but the
sources aren't yet there.
Best.
Oleg
Re: May I fork the project for creating a reduced version of it?
Posted by Nicholas Kwiatkowski <ni...@spoon.as>.
That's a really good question. At the moment, we really don't have /any/
linux based tooling. The compilers may be compiled for Linux in the
future, but that hasn't been our focus at the moment. Let alone, we really
don't have any modern versions of FP debugger.
Making a Linux version of the compiler should be trivial*. The biggest
blocker would be the debugger, I think.
-Nick
* speaking completely out of my ass. I haven't looked at it, and my
experience with compiler design is from a comp-sci program that was rated
as "wait? that qualifies as a comp-sci program?!?" by the AP.
On Thu, Sep 6, 2012 at 6:34 AM, Left Right <ol...@gmail.com> wrote:
> Thanks for the encouragement.
>
> I would also like to discuss couple of related things.
>
> I am now in the process of setting a development environment on a
> 64-bit Fedora Linux, and there are certain impediments that have to be
> considered with regard to SDK.
>
> - practically none of debugging runtimes work.
> * Standalone player requires a good deal of i686 libraries (32-bit
> libraries for X, networking and who knows what else, I had some of
> those installed with wine, so I don't know how many of them is exactly
> needed).
> * I wasn't able to use any of browser plugins for debugging, but I
> don't know yet what is exactly the reason, perhaps there is some way
> to get them working. Google-chrome somehow packages Flash player for
> Pepper API - I would try to investigate that path because they
> actually have some rouge 11.3 version of the player, which can't be
> downloaded from Adobe (Adobe dropped support at 11.2).
> * AIR (haven't tried yet, but there ware a lot of complications in the
> early days on 64-bit distros).
> * Running AIR in Android emulator (tried!) but there's still a lot of
> research to be made.
> * AIR runtime under Wine - this actually seems to work fairly well...
> unless you try doing some GPU-related stuff on anything other than
> NVidia chips, and even then you will have to flush .xsession-errors
> log on a second by second basis :/ Wine doesn't seem to support DRI on
> AMD or Intell chips (this may be a very broad claim, only due to my
> personal failure to get any of that, perhaps, some are supported).
> * Flash player plugin running in Firefox in Wine (seems to work fairly
> well, but may encounter same issues with GPU-related stuff, not tested
> yet).
>
> I didn't yet try connecting to a mobile device running AIR from linux
> and debugging it, neither tried debugging in emulator, only saw it
> launch.
>
> So, given a much better luck I had with running Flash through Wine,
> would it make sense to choose this route for Flash developing under
> Linux? This is, practically, how I do it now anyway.
>
> Best.
>
> Oleg
>
Re: May I fork the project for creating a reduced version of it?
Posted by Left Right <ol...@gmail.com>.
Thanks for the encouragement.
I would also like to discuss couple of related things.
I am now in the process of setting a development environment on a
64-bit Fedora Linux, and there are certain impediments that have to be
considered with regard to SDK.
- practically none of debugging runtimes work.
* Standalone player requires a good deal of i686 libraries (32-bit
libraries for X, networking and who knows what else, I had some of
those installed with wine, so I don't know how many of them is exactly
needed).
* I wasn't able to use any of browser plugins for debugging, but I
don't know yet what is exactly the reason, perhaps there is some way
to get them working. Google-chrome somehow packages Flash player for
Pepper API - I would try to investigate that path because they
actually have some rouge 11.3 version of the player, which can't be
downloaded from Adobe (Adobe dropped support at 11.2).
* AIR (haven't tried yet, but there ware a lot of complications in the
early days on 64-bit distros).
* Running AIR in Android emulator (tried!) but there's still a lot of
research to be made.
* AIR runtime under Wine - this actually seems to work fairly well...
unless you try doing some GPU-related stuff on anything other than
NVidia chips, and even then you will have to flush .xsession-errors
log on a second by second basis :/ Wine doesn't seem to support DRI on
AMD or Intell chips (this may be a very broad claim, only due to my
personal failure to get any of that, perhaps, some are supported).
* Flash player plugin running in Firefox in Wine (seems to work fairly
well, but may encounter same issues with GPU-related stuff, not tested
yet).
I didn't yet try connecting to a mobile device running AIR from linux
and debugging it, neither tried debugging in emulator, only saw it
launch.
So, given a much better luck I had with running Flash through Wine,
would it make sense to choose this route for Flash developing under
Linux? This is, practically, how I do it now anyway.
Best.
Oleg
Re: May I fork the project for creating a reduced version of it?
Posted by Nicholas Kwiatkowski <ni...@spoon.as>.
Oleg,
Anybody is free to create an installable version of the SDK. Chances are,
we will probably link to it from the mail site as well (after a committer
double checks it to make sure it didn't break in the process). If you
would be willing to make a .DEB / .RPM / etc. packages, that would be
awesome.
-Nick
On Sun, Sep 2, 2012 at 2:38 PM, Left Right <ol...@gmail.com> wrote:
> > Why should it need a DEB package
> Because this is the common way to install programs on Debian-like
> systems. SDK has tons of dependencies, resolving them all by hand is
> difficult and time consuming.
> It could be RPM too, or whatever there's the way to install on other
> platforms. The more the merrier.
>
> For example, the build readme now says that it needs Java 1.6 (but you
> will have Java 1.7 most of the time). I don't think anyone tested the
> SDK with OpenJDK or IBM JDK - OpenJDK is what gets installed on Linux
> by default.
>
> It also makes it easier to support it, because if you know how the
> program was possibly installed, you'd know where to find it on other
> people systems and fix, if anything is broken.
>
> Best.
>
> Oleg
>
Re: May I fork the project for creating a reduced version of it?
Posted by Left Right <ol...@gmail.com>.
> Why should it need a DEB package
Because this is the common way to install programs on Debian-like
systems. SDK has tons of dependencies, resolving them all by hand is
difficult and time consuming.
It could be RPM too, or whatever there's the way to install on other
platforms. The more the merrier.
For example, the build readme now says that it needs Java 1.6 (but you
will have Java 1.7 most of the time). I don't think anyone tested the
SDK with OpenJDK or IBM JDK - OpenJDK is what gets installed on Linux
by default.
It also makes it easier to support it, because if you know how the
program was possibly installed, you'd know where to find it on other
people systems and fix, if anything is broken.
Best.
Oleg
Re: May I fork the project for creating a reduced version of it?
Posted by aYo ~ <ay...@binitie.com>.
Please permit a silly question, but why has the sdk moved from a platform
agnostic package to which you reference from your IDE to one that has now
become platform specific? Why should it need a DEB packager instead of a
folder you just reference?
Having said that, I'm happy to help with any move to make it more Linux
friendly
On Aug 31, 2012 10:30 AM, "Left Right" <ol...@gmail.com> wrote:
> Hi again,
> After some thinking... this is my question, but I'm not yet mentally
> ready to do it, only wondering about the consequences of it.
> So... The SDK needs to be significantly changed in order for it to be
> built and used on Linux. The changes aren't as much related to the
> code of the SDK itself as to the way it is built, packaged and
> distributed.
>
> So, my very far going plan was like this: find the bits that will
> function / make sense on Linux (these are the asc, compiler, debugger,
> swfutils and some more) and create from them a DEB package. I'd host
> it on launchpad.com because it will give at least the Ubuntu users the
> familiar interface for installing / updating the program.
> Things that are not possible to use include these:
> - anything that uses Flash player 11.3 or later.
> - anything that uses AIR 3.0 or later.
> - anything that uses PixelBender.
> - I'm not sure about things that target Android / iOS.
> I would primarily try to get the compiler functioning.
>
> Well, I guess, I'd need your permission to do this, as this isn't
> technically a mirror or something. Besides you may or may not want to
> give this permission :) are there any legal impediments for doing so?
> If this is technically possible, I've also one more question: what is
> the state of Falcon and how hard do you think will it be to get it to
> compile and to work on Linux? I've tried to check it out, but the
> sources aren't yet there.
>
> Best.
>
> Oleg
>
Re: May I fork the project for creating a reduced version of it?
Posted by Omar Gonzalez <om...@gmail.com>.
I've also one more question: what is
> the state of Falcon and how hard do you think will it be to get it to
> compile and to work on Linux? I've tried to check it out, but the
> sources aren't yet there.
>
> Best.
>
> Oleg
>
Gordon Smith is doing the Falcon submission, and he is currently on a
vacation as of Friday. I think for like a week or something like that, I
think he's going to get to it when he returns.
-omar
Re: May I fork the project for creating a reduced version of it?
Posted by Bertrand Delacretaz <bd...@apache.org>.
On Fri, Aug 31, 2012 at 11:30 AM, Left Right <ol...@gmail.com> wrote:
> ...Well, I guess, I'd need your permission to do this, as this isn't
> technically a mirror or something. Besides you may or may not want to
> give this permission :) are there any legal impediments for doing so?...
The Apache License allows you to fork without asking for permissions,
but your fork must be named in a way that prevents confusion with
Apache Flex, see http://www.apache.org/foundation/marks/
One big downside of forking is that your work would happen outside of
this community - if you can find a way to keep it here (or at least
most of it) that would be much better IMO. It's perfectly possible to
create a subproject or an experimental branch if that helps.
-Bertrand
Re: May I fork the project for creating a reduced version of it?
Posted by Bertrand Delacretaz <bd...@apache.org>.
On Fri, Aug 31, 2012 at 12:54 PM, Justin Mclean
<ju...@classsoftware.com> wrote:
> ...I was going to suggest a branch of the SVN trunk but you'd need
> a committer to check things in for you on a regular basis via patch
> files which might slow progress a little....
Suggesting good patches that make the flex sdk more linux friendly
should hopefully help someone become a committer ;-)
-Bertrand
Re: May I fork the project for creating a reduced version of it?
Posted by Carlos Rovira <ca...@codeoscopic.com>.
but I think github is not synced since some weeks ago. We are know
working on develop branch in svn...until we don't get trying to make
some great change would not work. We are using github to "overlay"
changes in a folder layout structure that did not change and submit
pull request for mustella fixes, but I think the same operative could
not be used if the work is over all the sdk.
2012/8/31 Justin Mclean <ju...@classsoftware.com>:
> Hi,
>
> The simplest way might be to fork the github mirror of the Flex SDK and then share that?
>
> I was going to suggest a branch of the SVN trunk but you'd need a committer to check things in for you on a regular basis via patch files which might slow progress a little.
>
> Thanks,
> Justin
--
Carlos Rovira
Director de Tecnología
M: +34 607 22 60 05
F: +34 912 35 57 77
CODEOSCOPIC S.A.
Avd. del General Perón, 32
Planta 10, Puertas P-Q
28020 Madrid
Re: May I fork the project for creating a reduced version of it?
Posted by Justin Mclean <ju...@classsoftware.com>.
Hi,
The simplest way might be to fork the github mirror of the Flex SDK and then share that?
I was going to suggest a branch of the SVN trunk but you'd need a committer to check things in for you on a regular basis via patch files which might slow progress a little.
Thanks,
Justin