You are viewing a plain text version of this content. The canonical link for it is here.
Posted to dev@directory.apache.org by Emmanuel Lecharny <el...@gmail.com> on 2011/01/24 15:13:51 UTC

About community, and how it works

Hi guys,

I'm writing this as I'm currently unhappy about how this project operates


I want to recall some elements about the way we work at The Apache 
Software Foundation, not that you don't know about those rules, but I'd 
like us to stick to the spirit of those rules, something I think we have 
lost a bit those last months.

First, everything is stated on 
http://www.apache.org/foundation/how-it-works.html

1)"Communication" is done via mailing lists. That means, if it's not on 
the mailing list, then it hasn't happened. Tell what you are doing, why 
you are doing it, and get approved (no dissents means it's approved). If 
you like ot experiment, then do it in a branch.

2) "Decision Making". Most of the time, it's enough to explain the 
rational about the changes, and we reach  consensus.We can disagree, and 
we can vote in this case. Veto are acceptable, they are usually just a 
signal sent, not as a punitive action. Of course, vetoes must be 
sustained by some technical ground.

3) "Philosophy". Out of the six points listed on the web page, I'd like 
to stress out one of them :
- "respectful, honest, technical-based interaction". This left no room 
for personal attacks on public fora, like the mailing list or IRC. Such 
attacks, being valid or not, this is not the problem, are not part of 
the Apache Way, final. We are human beings, we have feelings, and 
they're not always pure and nice, but there's not excuse for not being 
respectful to others,especially on public channels.

4) "Individuals compose the ASF". That means you are on your own when 
you do or write something. No action dictated by the company you are 
working with will be tolerated.

I'd like everyone to understand that we are working on an Apache project 
because we enjoy doing so, because it's technically challenging, because 
we feel that we are changing the world in our area, and also because 
this is a place we don't feel any pressure nor agenda.

If you don't feel like one of those rules applies to you, then you are 
free to find another place to play. On the other hand, we all do 
mistakes. We are human beings. Excuses don't remove the grieves, but 
they help forgiving. So please before expressing some feelings, think 
twice and use some proper language.

Thanks !

-- 
Regards,
Cordialement,
Emmanuel Lécharny
www.iktek.com