[Question][Alert-SPI] SqlTask should send notifications by alert server api,Alert server address configuration discussion

[zhuangchong6 <zh...@163.com>]

https://github.com/apache/incubator-dolphinscheduler/issues/3997



Describe the question
In the case of the SqlTask task, the task needs to send messages synchronously, and the final running status of this task depends on whether the message is sent successfully. Therefore, the alarm api needs to send messages synchronously.
Have a problem at this time? There are two ways to get the alert api for the SqlTask task: put the alertserver address into the configuration file of the worker or master; put the alertserver address into the zk registration center; it is recommended to use the first one, the first version is simple to implement, and there will be alertserver load later Related issues will also consider registry issues
Do you have any suggestions?

Which version of DolphinScheduler:
-[alert_plugin_design]

描述问题
在SqlTask任务情况下，任务需要同步发送消息，此任务的最终运行状态取决于消息是否发送成功。 因此，告警api需要同步发送消息。
此时有个问题？SqlTask 任务如何获取告警api，下面有两种方式：alertserver地址放入worker或master的配置文件；alertserver地址放入zk注册中心; 推荐使用第一种，第一版先简单实现，后期会有alertserver负载相关问题也会考虑注册中心问题。
大家有什么建议么？

哪个版本的DolphinScheduler：
-[alert_plugin_design]

Re: [Question][Alert-SPI] SqlTask should send notifications by alert server api,Alert server address configuration discussion

[JUN GAO <ga...@apache.org>]

Is registration center can use now ? If registration center is ready,
registration center is better.

CalvinKirs <ac...@163.com> 于2020年10月27日周二 上午9:57写道：

> registration center +1
> Hello, I think the registration center is relatively more flexible, and it
> can also help us manage the online and offline of alerts. If in the future,
> alert-server supports multiple deployments, the role of zk is more obvious.
>
>
> Best  wishes！
> CalvinKirs
>
>
> On 10/27/2020 09:48，zhuangchong6<zh...@163.com> wrote：
> https://github.com/apache/incubator-dolphinscheduler/issues/3997
>
>
>
> Describe the question
> In the case of the SqlTask task, the task needs to send messages
> synchronously, and the final running status of this task depends on whether
> the message is sent successfully. Therefore, the alarm api needs to send
> messages synchronously.
> Have a problem at this time? There are two ways to get the alert api for
> the SqlTask task: put the alertserver address into the configuration file
> of the worker or master; put the alertserver address into the zk
> registration center; it is recommended to use the first one, the first
> version is simple to implement, and there will be alertserver load later
> Related issues will also consider registry issues
> Do you have any suggestions?
>
> Which version of DolphinScheduler:
> -[alert_plugin_design]
>
> 描述问题
> 在SqlTask任务情况下，任务需要同步发送消息，此任务的最终运行状态取决于消息是否发送成功。 因此，告警api需要同步发送消息。
> 此时有个问题？SqlTask
> 任务如何获取告警api，下面有两种方式：alertserver地址放入worker或master的配置文件；alertserver地址放入zk注册中心;
> 推荐使用第一种，第一版先简单实现，后期会有alertserver负载相关问题也会考虑注册中心问题。
> 大家有什么建议么？
>
> 哪个版本的DolphinScheduler：
> -[alert_plugin_design]

Re:[Question][Alert-SPI] SqlTask should send notifications by alert server api,Alert server address configuration discussion

[CalvinKirs <ac...@163.com>]

registration center +1
Hello, I think the registration center is relatively more flexible, and it can also help us manage the online and offline of alerts. If in the future, alert-server supports multiple deployments, the role of zk is more obvious.


Best  wishes！
CalvinKirs


On 10/27/2020 09:48，zhuangchong6<zh...@163.com> wrote：
https://github.com/apache/incubator-dolphinscheduler/issues/3997



Describe the question
In the case of the SqlTask task, the task needs to send messages synchronously, and the final running status of this task depends on whether the message is sent successfully. Therefore, the alarm api needs to send messages synchronously.
Have a problem at this time? There are two ways to get the alert api for the SqlTask task: put the alertserver address into the configuration file of the worker or master; put the alertserver address into the zk registration center; it is recommended to use the first one, the first version is simple to implement, and there will be alertserver load later Related issues will also consider registry issues
Do you have any suggestions?

Which version of DolphinScheduler:
-[alert_plugin_design]

描述问题
在SqlTask任务情况下，任务需要同步发送消息，此任务的最终运行状态取决于消息是否发送成功。 因此，告警api需要同步发送消息。
此时有个问题？SqlTask 任务如何获取告警api，下面有两种方式：alertserver地址放入worker或master的配置文件；alertserver地址放入zk注册中心; 推荐使用第一种，第一版先简单实现，后期会有alertserver负载相关问题也会考虑注册中心问题。
大家有什么建议么？

哪个版本的DolphinScheduler：
-[alert_plugin_design]

Re: [Question][Alert-SPI] SqlTask should send notifications by alert server api,Alert server address configuration discussion

[JUN GAO <ga...@apache.org>]

I think put the alertserver address into the configuration file of the
worker or master is better now.

zhuangchong6 <zh...@163.com> 于2020年10月27日周二 上午9:48写道：

> https://github.com/apache/incubator-dolphinscheduler/issues/3997
>
>
>
> Describe the question
> In the case of the SqlTask task, the task needs to send messages
> synchronously, and the final running status of this task depends on whether
> the message is sent successfully. Therefore, the alarm api needs to send
> messages synchronously.
> Have a problem at this time? There are two ways to get the alert api for
> the SqlTask task: put the alertserver address into the configuration file
> of the worker or master; put the alertserver address into the zk
> registration center; it is recommended to use the first one, the first
> version is simple to implement, and there will be alertserver load later
> Related issues will also consider registry issues
> Do you have any suggestions?
>
> Which version of DolphinScheduler:
> -[alert_plugin_design]
>
> 描述问题
> 在SqlTask任务情况下，任务需要同步发送消息，此任务的最终运行状态取决于消息是否发送成功。 因此，告警api需要同步发送消息。
> 此时有个问题？SqlTask
> 任务如何获取告警api，下面有两种方式：alertserver地址放入worker或master的配置文件；alertserver地址放入zk注册中心;
> 推荐使用第一种，第一版先简单实现，后期会有alertserver负载相关问题也会考虑注册中心问题。
> 大家有什么建议么？
>
> 哪个版本的DolphinScheduler：
> -[alert_plugin_design]