You are viewing a plain text version of this content. The canonical link for it is here.
Posted to users@spamassassin.apache.org by Scot Desort <sd...@gmail.com> on 2004/09/24 19:30:30 UTC

Looking for Advice - setting up a SA/MD gateway server

We run a bunch of  Win32 mail servers on our network. These servers
already have spam and virus filtering for local email delivery.
However, when a mailbox has it's mail forwarded off-net, the mail is
not filtered. As such,  when a local users forwards their mailbox to
AOL, they then read their email in the AOL client, click the SPAM
button in the AOL client, and OUR IP address(es) get flagged by AOL.

Getting rid of the Win boxes is not an option. So, I want to force all
of my Win mail servers to gateway all of the OUTBOUND email to a SA
box that will filter it before it leaves my network. I will need to
have the filtering config ignore the IP addresses of all of my
internal boxes, and begin scanning at the next hop IP in the mail
header. I was originally thought about having some way to ONLY scan
forwarded mail (as opposed to mail originating on my network), but I
think that would not be worth the effort, and I might as well scan
everything.

>From reading as many FAQ's and sample configs as I could find, it
seems like SA with MD would be my best bet. It appears to give me the
flexibility I need, without being overly complicated.

Initially, the server would not handle inbound mail, but may be
expanded to included that as well.

Due to the way that the Win boxes handle forwarding, when a forwarded
message is detected as spam and sent back to the Win32 box from SA, I
can't really bounce it. I will need to either forward it to a mailbox
for my admins to review, or simple delete it.

Does it sound like the Sendmail/SA/MD combo meets the requirements above? If
so, is there an FAQ or some other document anyone knows about that
gives an example of this config?

Would Postfix/SA/amavis-new  be a better solution? 

TIA,


-- 
Scot

RE: Looking for Advice - setting up a SA/MD gateway server

Posted by Greg Deputy <gr...@blastzone.com>.
I just started using a postfix/mailscanner/SA setup to filter outbound
and inbound mail.  Currently scanning about 35k messages per day.  I'm a
long time windows user / short time linux user, but had no problem
getting it setup and running.  I'm happy with the results, that's for
sure.



> -----Original Message-----
> From: Scot Desort [mailto:sdesort@gmail.com] 
> Sent: Friday, September 24, 2004 10:31 AM
> To: users@spamassassin.apache.org
> Subject: Looking for Advice - setting up a SA/MD gateway server
> 
> 
> We run a bunch of  Win32 mail servers on our network. These 
> servers already have spam and virus filtering for local email 
> delivery. However, when a mailbox has it's mail forwarded 
> off-net, the mail is not filtered. As such,  when a local 
> users forwards their mailbox to AOL, they then read their 
> email in the AOL client, click the SPAM button in the AOL 
> client, and OUR IP address(es) get flagged by AOL.
> 
> Getting rid of the Win boxes is not an option. So, I want to 
> force all of my Win mail servers to gateway all of the 
> OUTBOUND email to a SA box that will filter it before it 
> leaves my network. I will need to have the filtering config 
> ignore the IP addresses of all of my internal boxes, and 
> begin scanning at the next hop IP in the mail header. I was 
> originally thought about having some way to ONLY scan 
> forwarded mail (as opposed to mail originating on my 
> network), but I think that would not be worth the effort, and 
> I might as well scan everything.
> 
> >From reading as many FAQ's and sample configs as I could find, it
> seems like SA with MD would be my best bet. It appears to 
> give me the flexibility I need, without being overly complicated.
> 
> Initially, the server would not handle inbound mail, but may 
> be expanded to included that as well.
> 
> Due to the way that the Win boxes handle forwarding, when a 
> forwarded message is detected as spam and sent back to the 
> Win32 box from SA, I can't really bounce it. I will need to 
> either forward it to a mailbox for my admins to review, or 
> simple delete it.
> 
> Does it sound like the Sendmail/SA/MD combo meets the 
> requirements above? If so, is there an FAQ or some other 
> document anyone knows about that gives an example of this config?
> 
> Would Postfix/SA/amavis-new  be a better solution? 
> 
> TIA,
> 
> 
> -- 
> Scot
> 
>