[jira] [Created] (TIKA-4082) Extraction from Microsoft Sharepoint protected PDFs doesn't expose exception like other parsers.

["Carey Halton (Jira)" <ji...@apache.org>]

Carey Halton created TIKA-4082:
----------------------------------

             Summary: Extraction from Microsoft Sharepoint protected PDFs doesn't expose exception like other parsers.
                 Key: TIKA-4082
                 URL: https://issues.apache.org/jira/browse/TIKA-4082
             Project: Tika
          Issue Type: Bug
          Components: parser
    Affects Versions: 2.4.1
            Reporter: Carey Halton
         Attachments: MSFT Transcript FY23-Q3.pdf, PasswordProtectedWorkbook.xlsx, password protected pdf exception.txt, password protected xlsx exception.txt

I have attached a PDF file (see "MSFT Transcript FY23-Q3.pdf") that we are currently attempting to extract content from using Tika 2.4.1 (via Tika server), but since the file has had password protection added to it via Microsoft Sharepoint service, instead of getting the actual file content, we get content that says this:

"

_This PDF file is protected_ 
  __  

_You'll need a different reader in order to view this content:_ 

_Download a compatible PDF reader._ 

  __  

_This PDF Document has been protected._ 

_The reader you are using does not support opening files protected by Microsoft Office_ 

_http://go.microsoft.com/fwlink/?LinkID=231373_

"

Which is fine since the original content can obviously not be accessed without the password. It also throws an exception that we can see in "X-TIKA:EXCEPTION:embedded_warning" that is attached in the file "password protected pdf exception.txt".

But we were surprised that we see any content at all as we have a similar document (see attached "PasswordProtectedWorkbook.xlsx") that we test with that is password protected in a similar way, albeit a XLSX instead of a PDF, that doesn't return any content and throws an exception in "X-TIKA:EXCEPTION:container_exception" (attached in "password protected xlsx.txt"), which we currently treat as a failure mode. whereas we don't currently treat "X-TIKA:EXCEPTION:embedded_warning" as a failure.

I realize these are different parsers, but since it is a very similar scenario, should they not be treated in the same way, at least voiding all content and emitting a proper failing exception instead of just what appears to be considered a warning? We are hesitant to make all instances of "X-TIKA:EXCEPTION:embedded_warning" as failures as we are unsure what other kinds of errors can be surfaced in that way. But it is clear to us that password protected files should be considered as failed to process. Thoughts?



--
This message was sent by Atlassian Jira
(v8.20.10#820010)