You are viewing a plain text version of this content. The canonical link for it is here.
Posted to jdo-dev@db.apache.org by Michelle Caisse <Mi...@Sun.COM> on 2006/03/23 21:42:52 UTC
JDO TCK Conference Call Friday, Mar 24, 9 am PST
Hi,
We will have our regular meeting Friday, March 24 at 9 am PST to discuss
JDO TCK issues and status.
Dial-in numbers are:
866 230-6968 294-0479#
International: +1 865 544-7856
Agenda:
1. Test status (Michael)
2. New tests status (Martin, Michael, Craig)
3. JSR 243 next steps (Craig)
4. Other issues (any and all)
Action Items from weeks past:
[Mar 17 2006] AI Craig: review EG discussion on JDOHelper constructor
vs. newInstance().
[Mar 17 2006] Remaining issue: datastore identity strategy is
currently defined as IDENTITY but some datastores don't support
IDENTITY columns. AI CraIg: propose a solution.
[Mar 17 2006] For the persistence manager newInstance(Class) method,
what should the implementation do for abstract classes or interfaces
that contain abstract methods other than property accessors? Answer:
throw an exception. This might happen during enhancement. This needs to
be clarified in the spec. AI Michael: file a JIRA.
[Mar 10 2006] Michael noticed a number of configurations have failed.
AI Craig: see if changes to PMInterface have affected this problem.
[Feb 24 2006] One of the query tests fails. JDO-310 DERBY-39 for
details. AI Craig: Can we get some help on this from the Derby team?
Craig asked at the team meeting. AI Craig: follow up.
[Feb 3 2006] AI Michael W fix list of teardown classes in company
model reader. JDO-285. But this fix cannot be checked in until JPOX is
fixed.
[Jan 20 2005] AI Craig look at new life cycle tests to see if it can
fail at the end printing failure messages. AI Craig review the spec
updates to make sure the test is consistent. AI Craig: resolve the
test case and spec issues. Done. Martin will start with the code that
Michael W updated and will update the test case not to fail on the
first error.
[Nov 18 2005] AI: BEA to sign the donation paperwork for their test
suite. Review how to merge their test cases into JDO TCK. The latest
news in BEA is that BEA plans to donate their object persistence
engine to open source; it's not clear where they will do this,
perhaps in Apache as a sister project to Apache JDO. BEA's OpenJPA is
currently under consideration in the Apache incubator, so the
integration work might be facilitated once this is resolved.
[Nov 4 2005] AI Martin: Update Martin's wiki with discusion of JDK 1.5
issues. in progress
[Sep 2 2005] AI: To recruit members, update the web site. Articles on
TheServerSide directing attention to the site. T-shirts, logo. AI:
Craig write a ServerSide article.
[July 29 2005] AI: Michelle Chapter 18 wiki needs to be updated to
include all JDO metadata elements and attributes.
[April 15 2005] AI: Brian Topping will do the maven goal for creating
and uploading the snapshots. He will create a directory parallel to
trunk called "releases" and put the snapshots there.
[May 13 2005] AI: Brian Topping will arrange for automated nightly
builds.
Re: Minutes: JDO TCK Conference Call Friday, Mar 24, 9 am PST
Posted by Michelle Caisse <Mi...@Sun.COM>.
Matthew Adams also attended the meeting.
-- Michelle
Craig L Russell wrote:
> Attendees: Michael Bouschen, Michelle Caisse, Martin Zaun, Craig Russell
>
> Agenda:
>
> 1. Test status (Michael) 1239 test cases; 2 errors, 4 failures; 4 of
> 57 configurations fail. Still an open issue on JDO-273 to update the
> life cycle for serialization with an active transaction. AI Martin
> fix the lifecycle tests and update the JIRA issues with the latest
> results. JPOX has issues with lifecycle and newInstance
> (PersistentInterface).
>
> 2. New tests status (Martin, Michael, Craig) Martin has one more test
> case to write: PMF close. Craig is still working on the datastore
> mapping for identity vs. sequence for primary key generation.
>
> 3. JSR 243 next steps (Craig) Assertions spreadsheet needs to be
> updated to reflect the new tests. New and updated TCK tests need to
> be finalized, and then we can cut the release branch. You can see the
> latest changes at http://svn.apache.org/viewcvs.cgi/db/jdo/trunk.
> JPOX is preparing a 1.1.0-rc2 for early next week, with the final
> 1.1.0 release scheduled for next Friday. The final artifact-id is
> expected to be jpox-1.1.0.
>
> 4. Other issues (any and all)
>
> Craig has instructions on creating a release, and will add a wiki
> page with the instructions in case anyone else has an itch to make a
> release.
>
> Need to resolve serialization of a detachable instance for durable
> storage. AI Craig: propose a solution for the specification.
>
> Action Items from weeks past:
>
> [Mar 17 2006] AI Craig: review EG discussion on JDOHelper
> constructor vs. newInstance(). Done. "There's no state in a JDOHelper
> instance so there's really not much of a reason to use a singleton
> pattern."
>
> [Mar 17 2006] Remaining issue: datastore identity strategy is
> currently defined as IDENTITY but some datastores don't support
> IDENTITY columns. AI CraIg: propose a solution. In progress
>
> [Mar 17 2006] For the persistence manager newInstance(Class) method,
> what should the implementation do for abstract classes or interfaces
> that contain abstract methods other than property accessors? Answer:
> throw an exception. This might happen during enhancement. This needs
> to be clarified in the spec. AI Michael: file a JIRA. AI Craig:
> update the change log. Done.
>
> [Feb 24 2006] One of the query tests fails. JDO-310 DERBY-39 for
> details. AI Craig: Can we get some help on this from the Derby
> team? Craig asked at the team meeting. AI Craig: follow up.
>
> [Feb 3 2006] AI Michael W fix list of teardown classes in company
> model reader. JDO-285. But this fix cannot be checked in until JPOX
> is fixed.
>
> [Jan 20 2005] AI Craig look at new life cycle tests to see if it
> can fail at the end printing failure messages. AI Craig review the
> spec updates to make sure the test is consistent. AI Craig:
> resolve the test case and spec issues. Done. Martin will start
> with the code that Michael W updated and will update the test case
> not to fail on the first error.
>
> [Nov 18 2005] AI: BEA to sign the donation paperwork for their test
> suite. Review how to merge their test cases into JDO TCK. The
> latest news in BEA is that BEA plans to donate their object
> persistence engine to open source; it's not clear where they will
> do this, perhaps in Apache as a sister project to Apache JDO.
> BEA's OpenJPA is currently under consideration in the Apache
> incubator, so the integration work might be facilitated once this
> is resolved.
>
> [Nov 4 2005] AI Martin: Update Martin's wiki with discusion of JDK
> 1.5 issues. in progress
>
> [Sep 2 2005] AI: To recruit members, update the web site. Articles
> on TheServerSide directing attention to the site. T-shirts, logo.
> AI: Craig write a ServerSide article.
>
> [July 29 2005] AI: Michelle Chapter 18 wiki needs to be updated to
> include all JDO metadata elements and attributes.
>
>
> Craig Russell
> Architect, Sun Java Enterprise System http://java.sun.com/products/jdo
> 408 276-5638 mailto:Craig.Russell@sun.com
> P.S. A good JDO? O, Gasp!
>
Minutes: JDO TCK Conference Call Friday, Mar 24, 9 am PST
Posted by Craig L Russell <Cr...@Sun.COM>.
Attendees: Michael Bouschen, Michelle Caisse, Martin Zaun, Craig Russell
Agenda:
1. Test status (Michael) 1239 test cases; 2 errors, 4 failures; 4 of
57 configurations fail. Still an open issue on JDO-273 to update the
life cycle for serialization with an active transaction. AI Martin
fix the lifecycle tests and update the JIRA issues with the latest
results. JPOX has issues with lifecycle and newInstance
(PersistentInterface).
2. New tests status (Martin, Michael, Craig) Martin has one more test
case to write: PMF close. Craig is still working on the datastore
mapping for identity vs. sequence for primary key generation.
3. JSR 243 next steps (Craig) Assertions spreadsheet needs to be
updated to reflect the new tests. New and updated TCK tests need to
be finalized, and then we can cut the release branch. You can see the
latest changes at http://svn.apache.org/viewcvs.cgi/db/jdo/trunk.
JPOX is preparing a 1.1.0-rc2 for early next week, with the final
1.1.0 release scheduled for next Friday. The final artifact-id is
expected to be jpox-1.1.0.
4. Other issues (any and all)
Craig has instructions on creating a release, and will add a wiki
page with the instructions in case anyone else has an itch to make a
release.
Need to resolve serialization of a detachable instance for durable
storage. AI Craig: propose a solution for the specification.
Action Items from weeks past:
[Mar 17 2006] AI Craig: review EG discussion on JDOHelper
constructor vs. newInstance(). Done. "There's no state in a JDOHelper
instance so there's really not much of a reason to use a singleton
pattern."
[Mar 17 2006] Remaining issue: datastore identity strategy is
currently defined as IDENTITY but some datastores don't support
IDENTITY columns. AI CraIg: propose a solution. In progress
[Mar 17 2006] For the persistence manager newInstance(Class) method,
what should the implementation do for abstract classes or interfaces
that contain abstract methods other than property accessors? Answer:
throw an exception. This might happen during enhancement. This needs
to be clarified in the spec. AI Michael: file a JIRA. AI Craig:
update the change log. Done.
[Feb 24 2006] One of the query tests fails. JDO-310 DERBY-39 for
details. AI Craig: Can we get some help on this from the Derby
team? Craig asked at the team meeting. AI Craig: follow up.
[Feb 3 2006] AI Michael W fix list of teardown classes in company
model reader. JDO-285. But this fix cannot be checked in until JPOX
is fixed.
[Jan 20 2005] AI Craig look at new life cycle tests to see if it
can fail at the end printing failure messages. AI Craig review the
spec updates to make sure the test is consistent. AI Craig:
resolve the test case and spec issues. Done. Martin will start
with the code that Michael W updated and will update the test case
not to fail on the first error.
[Nov 18 2005] AI: BEA to sign the donation paperwork for their test
suite. Review how to merge their test cases into JDO TCK. The
latest news in BEA is that BEA plans to donate their object
persistence engine to open source; it's not clear where they will
do this, perhaps in Apache as a sister project to Apache JDO.
BEA's OpenJPA is currently under consideration in the Apache
incubator, so the integration work might be facilitated once this
is resolved.
[Nov 4 2005] AI Martin: Update Martin's wiki with discusion of JDK
1.5 issues. in progress
[Sep 2 2005] AI: To recruit members, update the web site. Articles
on TheServerSide directing attention to the site. T-shirts, logo.
AI: Craig write a ServerSide article.
[July 29 2005] AI: Michelle Chapter 18 wiki needs to be updated to
include all JDO metadata elements and attributes.
Craig Russell
Architect, Sun Java Enterprise System http://java.sun.com/products/jdo
408 276-5638 mailto:Craig.Russell@sun.com
P.S. A good JDO? O, Gasp!
Minutes: JDO TCK Conference Call Friday, Mar 31 9 am PST
Posted by Craig L Russell <Cr...@Sun.COM>.
Attendees: Michelle Caisse, Michael Bouschen, Martin Zaun, Craig Russell
Agenda:
1. Test status (Michael) 1239 tests 0 errors 2 failures 2 of 57
configurations fail. The persistent interface test is the only test
that fails (both application and datastore identity). The symptoms of
the failure have been changing, indicating progress is being made on
the issue. The latest is that the class created for the persistent
interface is not found. Either it wasn't created, it was created with
the wrong name, or it was created in the wrong classloader.
2. Issues with staged release (any and all) JDO-356 has two doc
issues to be fixed. JDO-293 has some spreadsheet issues to be updated
before release. And JDO-327 (JPOX bug) needs to be resolved.
3. Integration and testing of JDO 2.0 release (Craig, others) The
plan is to respin just the tck20 once changes are made to the
documentation (not the code).
4. Other issues (any and all)
JPOX needs a release of JDO 2.0 api in order to release their 1.1.0-
rc-2. AI Craig: call for a vote to release just the API20 project to
allow us to publish the API20 project, including publishing the jar
files on ibiblio.
We would like to add a link from the JDO web site to the JIRA page to
do calculations of the open and closed issues by release. AI Craig:
make sure that all JIRA issues have a "resolved in release" entry.
Might have to reopen some JIRA issues just to add this info. AI
Michelle: add links in the web page to point to JIRA "open issues for
xxx release" and "resolved issues for xxx release".
Assertions: Martin reviewed the assertion spreadsheet and commented
extensively. Assertions that are exclusively lifecycle transitions
should be marked as duplicate. AI Michelle: incorporate Martin's
comments into the spreadsheet before Craig respins the release.
The coverage report should reflect the status of the released code.
AI Michelle: copy the coverage.txt from the branches/2.0-rc1 into the
branches/2.0 and update the statistics.
Action Items from weeks past:
[Mar 24 2006] Craig has instructions on creating a release, and will
add a wiki page with the instructions in case anyone else has an
itch to make a release. In progress.
[Mar 24 2006] Need to resolve serialization of a detachable instance
for durable storage. AI Craig: propose a solution for the
specification. Done.
[Mar 17 2006] Remaining issue: datastore identity strategy is
currently defined as IDENTITY but some datastores don't support
IDENTITY columns. AI CraIg: propose a solution. In progress
[Feb 3 2006] AI Michael W fix list of teardown classes in company
model reader. JDO-285. But this fix cannot be checked in until
JPOX is fixed. Done. Will look at this for maintenance.
[Nov 18 2005] AI: BEA to sign the donation paperwork for their
test suite. Review how to merge their test cases into JDO TCK.
The latest news in BEA is that BEA plans to donate their object
persistence engine to open source; it's not clear where they will
do this, perhaps in Apache as a sister project to Apache JDO.
BEA's OpenJPA is currently under consideration in the Apache
incubator, so the integration work might be facilitated once this
is resolved. Done. Too late.
[Nov 4 2005] AI Martin: Update Martin's wiki with discusion of JDK
1.5 issues. in progress
[Sep 2 2005] AI: To recruit members, update the web site. Articles
on TheServerSide directing attention to the site. T-shirts,
logo. AI: Craig write a ServerSide article.
[July 29 2005] AI: Michelle Chapter 18 wiki needs to be updated to
include all JDO metadata elements and attributes. Too late.
Craig Russell
Architect, Sun Java Enterprise System http://java.sun.com/products/jdo
408 276-5638 mailto:Craig.Russell@sun.com
P.S. A good JDO? O, Gasp!
Re: JDO TCK Conference Call Friday, Mar 31 9 am PST
Posted by Michelle Caisse <Mi...@Sun.COM>.
Hi,
We will have our regular meeting Friday, March 31 at 9 am PST to discuss
JDO TCK issues and status.
Dial-in numbers are:
866 230-6968 294-0479#
International: +1 865 544-7856
Agenda:
1. Test status (Michael)
2. Issues with staged release (any and all)
3. Integration and testing of JDO 2.0 release (Craig, others)
4. Other issues (any and all)
Action Items from weeks past:
[Mar 24 2006] Craig has instructions on creating a release, and will add
a wiki page with the instructions in case anyone else has an itch to
make a release.
[Mar 24 2006] Need to resolve serialization of a detachable instance for
durable storage. AI Craig: propose a solution for the specification.
[Mar 17 2006] AI Craig: review EG discussion on JDOHelper constructor
vs. newInstance(). Done. "There's no state in a JDOHelper instance so
there's really not much of a reason to use a singleton pattern."
[Mar 17 2006] Remaining issue: datastore identity strategy is
currently defined as IDENTITY but some datastores don't support
IDENTITY columns. AI CraIg: propose a solution. In progress
[Feb 3 2006] AI Michael W fix list of teardown classes in company
model reader. JDO-285. But this fix cannot be checked in until JPOX
is fixed.
[Jan 20 2005] AI Craig look at new life cycle tests to see if it can
fail at the end printing failure messages. AI Craig review the spec
updates to make sure the test is consistent. AI Craig: resolve the
test case and spec issues. Done. Martin will start with the code that
Michael W updated and will update the test case not to fail on the
first error.
[Nov 18 2005] AI: BEA to sign the donation paperwork for their test
suite. Review how to merge their test cases into JDO TCK. The latest
news in BEA is that BEA plans to donate their object persistence
engine to open source; it's not clear where they will do this,
perhaps in Apache as a sister project to Apache JDO. BEA's OpenJPA is
currently under consideration in the Apache incubator, so the
integration work might be facilitated once this is resolved.
[Nov 4 2005] AI Martin: Update Martin's wiki with discusion of JDK
1.5 issues. in progress
[Sep 2 2005] AI: To recruit members, update the web site. Articles on
TheServerSide directing attention to the site. T-shirts, logo. AI:
Craig write a ServerSide article.
[July 29 2005] AI: Michelle Chapter 18 wiki needs to be updated to
include all JDO metadata elements and attributes.