You are viewing a plain text version of this content. The canonical link for it is here.
Posted to dev@tomcat.apache.org by Sam Ruby <ru...@us.ibm.com> on 2000/12/15 20:31:13 UTC

Re: [tomcat-4.0] don't touch any of the build system in CVS for tomcat/servletapi

Jon Stevens wrote:
>
> i'm re-doing it this weekend and i don't want to have to
> merge conflicts.
>
> yes craig, i will keep the same level of functionality
> and simply add clean ness, ease of building, ant 1.2
> features and more functionality.

Please give us a chance to discuss before comitting?

I've spent the last two days building a meta-build system.  It consists of
an abstract definition of the system that you want to build, in XML.  A
concrete user profile, also in XML, binding names to locations to where you
want them to reside on disk.  And, finally, an XSLT transform which will
convert these two into a script designed for your native platform (I've
been focusing on with Windows and Linux).  One could easily image extending
this with a graphical front end.

One thing that would make life much easier would be if we could agree on
some simple things, like the names of targets - it is "package" or "dist"?
Where to find outputs.  How to specify inputs (environment var / properties
file / class path).

What we have now is Jon doing all of "his" projects one way and Craig doing
all of "his" projects another.

I know that Jon keeps telling me that I'm focusing on the wrong things, but
I would like to get to the point where the various projects are
standardized building blocks, with each project describing in a machine
readable fashion their dependencies.

- Sam Ruby


Re: [tomcat-4.0] don't touch any of the build system in CVS for tomcat/servletapi

Posted by Remy Maucherat <re...@apache.org>.
> I've spent the last two days building a meta-build system.  It consists of
> an abstract definition of the system that you want to build, in XML.  A
> concrete user profile, also in XML, binding names to locations to where
you
> want them to reside on disk.  And, finally, an XSLT transform which will
> convert these two into a script designed for your native platform (I've
> been focusing on with Windows and Linux).  One could easily image
extending
> this with a graphical front end.

That looks cool.
Could you post a sample project build file (the abstract one + the user
preferences) to see how things are done using this ?

Remy


Re: [tomcat-4.0] don't touch any of the build system in CVS for tomcat/servletapi

Posted by Jon Stevens <jo...@latchkey.com>.
on 12/15/2000 11:31 AM, "Sam Ruby" <ru...@us.ibm.com> wrote:

> Please give us a chance to discuss before comitting?
> 
> I've spent the last two days building a meta-build system.  It consists of
> an abstract definition of the system that you want to build, in XML.  A
> concrete user profile, also in XML, binding names to locations to where you
> want them to reside on disk.  And, finally, an XSLT transform which will
> convert these two into a script designed for your native platform (I've
> been focusing on with Windows and Linux).  One could easily image extending
> this with a graphical front end.
> 
> One thing that would make life much easier would be if we could agree on
> some simple things, like the names of targets - it is "package" or "dist"?
> Where to find outputs.  How to specify inputs (environment var / properties
> file / class path).
> 
> What we have now is Jon doing all of "his" projects one way and Craig doing
> all of "his" projects another.
> 
> I know that Jon keeps telling me that I'm focusing on the wrong things, but
> I would like to get to the point where the various projects are
> standardized building blocks, with each project describing in a machine
> readable fashion their dependencies.
> 
> - Sam Ruby

I didn't remember you posting about building such a system, but it is MOST
appreciated and wanted.

I will wait to use whatever you have.

-jon