You are viewing a plain text version of this content. The canonical link for it is here.
Posted to users@spamassassin.apache.org by Scott Rothgaber <sc...@palmetto.tv> on 2004/06/23 04:38:48 UTC
Can anyone explain this?
Never seen this happen before...
X-Spam-Status: Hits=2.7 Required=5.0 Tests=STRONG_BUY=2.7 Autolearn=ham
SA 2.63, threshholds are 1.0/12.0. WTF? ;-)
Re: Can anyone explain this? (clarification)
Posted by Scott Rothgaber <sc...@palmetto.tv>.
Ralf Guenthner wrote:
>> X-Spam-Status: Hits=2.7 Required=5.0 Tests=STRONG_BUY=2.7
>> Autolearn=ham
>>
>> SA 2.63, threshholds are 1.0/12.0. WTF? ;-)
>
> Um..your threshold is not 1.0 for spam but 5.0 as it says in the
> X-Spam-Status line. This msg. scored 2.7, so what problem do you see in
> that?
Sorry for the confusion! I ASS-U-MEd that by listing the two scores that
folks would reali[zs]e that I was talking about the autolearn threshholds.
Re: Can anyone explain this?
Posted by Jamie Pratt <ja...@nucdc.org>.
Bob Apthorpe wrote:
> On Wed, 23 Jun 2004 11:40:35 +0200 Ralf Guenthner <gu...@alphatel.de> wrote:
>
>
>>>Never seen this happen before...
>>>
>>>X-Spam-Status: Hits=2.7 Required=5.0 Tests=STRONG_BUY=2.7 Autolearn=ham
>>>
>>>SA 2.63, threshholds are 1.0/12.0. WTF? ;-)
>>
>>Um..your threshold is not 1.0 for spam but 5.0 as it says in the
>>X-Spam-Status line. This msg. scored 2.7, so what problem do you see in
>>that?
>
>
> I'm wondering why it's autolearned as ham...
>
> -- Bob
>
Not sure, but I get some mails like yours, and also have some with
*negative* scores that are autolearned as ham, so maybe this is normal?
(I have a default setup of SA 2.63)
Anyone else know what's up with that?
regards,
jamie
Re: Can anyone explain this?
Posted by Bob Apthorpe <ap...@cynistar.net>.
On Wed, 23 Jun 2004 11:40:35 +0200 Ralf Guenthner <gu...@alphatel.de> wrote:
> > Never seen this happen before...
> >
> > X-Spam-Status: Hits=2.7 Required=5.0 Tests=STRONG_BUY=2.7 Autolearn=ham
> >
> > SA 2.63, threshholds are 1.0/12.0. WTF? ;-)
>
> Um..your threshold is not 1.0 for spam but 5.0 as it says in the
> X-Spam-Status line. This msg. scored 2.7, so what problem do you see in
> that?
I'm wondering why it's autolearned as ham...
-- Bob
Re: Can anyone explain this?
Posted by Ralf Guenthner <gu...@alphatel.de>.
> Never seen this happen before...
>
> X-Spam-Status: Hits=2.7 Required=5.0 Tests=STRONG_BUY=2.7 Autolearn=ham
>
> SA 2.63, threshholds are 1.0/12.0. WTF? ;-)
Um..your threshold is not 1.0 for spam but 5.0 as it says in the
X-Spam-Status line. This msg. scored 2.7, so what problem do you see in
that?
Cheers
Ralf G.
Re: Can anyone explain this?
Posted by Matt Kettler <mk...@evi-inc.com>.
At 10:38 PM 6/22/2004, Scott Rothgaber wrote:
>Never seen this happen before...
>
>X-Spam-Status: Hits=2.7 Required=5.0 Tests=STRONG_BUY=2.7 Autolearn=ham
>
>SA 2.63, threshholds are 1.0/12.0. WTF? ;-) \
The score used to determine autolearning is NOT the same score as hits.
The score used is the score the email would have gotten if bayes was
completely disabled. This includes using a different scoreset.
The autolearner saw the score of this email as zero, since set1 was used
for autolearning scores.
Look at the scores of strong_buy:
score STRONG_BUY 2.799 0 2.800 2.700
Re: Can anyone explain this?
Posted by Andy Jezierski <aj...@stepan.com>.
Scott Rothgaber <sc...@palmetto.tv> wrote on 06/22/2004 09:38:48 PM:
> Never seen this happen before...
>
> X-Spam-Status: Hits=2.7 Required=5.0 Tests=STRONG_BUY=2.7
Autolearn=ham
>
> SA 2.63, threshholds are 1.0/12.0. WTF? ;-)
>
>
That's odd. Do you still have the original message? You can try running it
through spammassassin -D Might show you what happened.
Andy