You are viewing a plain text version of this content. The canonical link for it is here.
Posted to dev@flex.apache.org by Sebastian Mohr <ma...@gmail.com> on 2012/01/12 17:07:22 UTC
[VOTE] Moving "Best Coding Practices" talks to the flex-user list?
I am seeing to much pressure coming against
these "Best Coding Practices" talks. Talking about
"Best Coding Practices" for Flex is important ... BUT
not on this list!
I guess, now, this would be the right time to open
up the flex-user list to keep on talking over there!
What do you think?
-- Sebastian
Re: [VOTE] Moving "Best Coding Practices" talks to the flex-user list?
Posted by Omar Gonzalez <om...@gmail.com>.
-1 (binding)
I said it in an earlier post but didn't actually place a vote, I agree with
Peter.
-omar
RE: [VOTE] Moving "Best Coding Practices" talks to the flex-user
list?
Posted by Douglas Arthur <da...@vmware.com>.
> From: Peter Elst [mailto:peter.elst@gmail.com]
>
> No offense, but the vote thread is turning into more of a discussion - there
> are different opinions and think they've been voiced. Can we let the votes
> guide the decision and come to a conclusion?
>
> - Peter
Offense taken. :-) j/k
But I think this vote topic is way off. There's two subjects in question. One for the list creation, and the other for where to have a discussion. Can we trash this one and start over? In addition, I don't think a vote was needed for the list creation based on Bertrand's comments earlier. Maybe I'm wrong...
- Doug
RE: [VOTE] Moving "Best Coding Practices" talks to the flex-user
list?
Posted by Michael Schmalle <mi...@teotigraphix.com>.
Quoting Douglas Arthur <da...@vmware.com>:
>> From: Michael Schmalle [mailto:mike@teotigraphix.com]
>>
>> I just ran through all of the threads on this and get;
>>
>> +1 (binding)
>>
>> -1(binding), -1 (non-binding), -1 (binding), -1 (binding), -1 (binding), -1
>> (binding), -1(non binding)
>
> Add me to the -1 (binding) for this topic of moving "Best Coding
> Practices", and this should be completely separate from the creation
> of the list.
>
Right, this day was a mess.
Personally, I'm not starting anymore threads today. Maybe we should
let the dust clear for a day or so...
Mike
RE: [VOTE] Moving "Best Coding Practices" talks to the flex-user
list?
Posted by Douglas Arthur <da...@vmware.com>.
> From: Michael Schmalle [mailto:mike@teotigraphix.com]
>
> I just ran through all of the threads on this and get;
>
> +1 (binding)
>
> -1(binding), -1 (non-binding), -1 (binding), -1 (binding), -1 (binding), -1
> (binding), -1(non binding)
Add me to the -1 (binding) for this topic of moving "Best Coding Practices", and this should be completely separate from the creation of the list.
Re: [VOTE] Moving "Best Coding Practices" talks to the flex-user
list?
Posted by Michael Schmalle <mi...@teotigraphix.com>.
Quoting Tink <fl...@tink.ws>:
>> No offense, but the vote thread is turning into more of a discussion -
>> there are different opinions and think they've been voiced. Can we let the
>> votes guide the decision and come to a conclusion?
>>
>> - Peter
>
>
> +1 for creating it now
>
Hi Peter,
I just ran through all of the threads on this and get;
+1 (binding)
-1(binding), -1 (non-binding), -1 (binding), -1 (binding), -1
(binding), -1 (binding),
-1(non binding)
If you want the names I can go back, if this is a real vote it's
obvious what the binding votes are saying.
Mike
Re: [VOTE] Moving "Best Coding Practices" talks to the flex-user list?
Posted by Tink <fl...@tink.ws>.
> No offense, but the vote thread is turning into more of a discussion -
> there are different opinions and think they've been voiced. Can we
> let the
> votes guide the decision and come to a conclusion?
>
> - Peter
+1 for creating it now
Re: [VOTE] Moving "Best Coding Practices" talks to the flex-user list?
Posted by Peter Elst <pe...@gmail.com>.
> But I do think the list should be created now rather than later if it's
> decided we want one at all, and there's been plenty of people saying
> they'll think we'll eventually need it. What's the worst case? It doesn't
> get used, and it gets retired? What's wrong with that? But what if it
> provides to be useful, then great, we provided the support to the Apache
> Flex users.
>
No offense, but the vote thread is turning into more of a discussion -
there are different opinions and think they've been voiced. Can we let the
votes guide the decision and come to a conclusion?
- Peter
RE: [VOTE] Moving "Best Coding Practices" talks to the flex-user
list?
Posted by Douglas Arthur <da...@vmware.com>.
> From: John Gorena [mailto:spaz@killerspaz.com]
>
> Serious question: What is the intent of the flex-users list?
I don't think we need to completely decide that here. Let the users decide how they wil use it. If we, as PPMC members, decide a topic needs to be moved to the flex-dev list, then we can moderate it and have the topic moved. But we don't need to decide what it will be used for, rather we should decide what doesn't belong there. And I agree, this topic of "Best Coding Practices" does NOT belong there.
But I do think the list should be created now rather than later if it's decided we want one at all, and there's been plenty of people saying they'll think we'll eventually need it. What's the worst case? It doesn't get used, and it gets retired? What's wrong with that? But what if it provides to be useful, then great, we provided the support to the Apache Flex users.
- Doug
Re: [VOTE] Moving "Best Coding Practices" talks to the flex-user list?
Posted by John Gorena <sp...@killerspaz.com>.
Serious question: What is the intent of the flex-users list?
-1
Not to be rude, but don't we already have enough noob forums? Do we need
yet another? I agree it WOULD be nice to have a congregation of users in a
central location, but what's the likelihood of that?
With forums like kirupa.com, actionscript.org, and even the likes of
stackoverflow.com - they're WAY more advanced than a mailing list would be;
why would a user switch?
I could see the flex-users group helpful for some support; along the lines
of "The Button component isn't validating properly in this use-case, can
someone help me verify this?" And other users assist to turn it into a
legitimate, testable, and reproducible bug.
Not so much of the "How do you set the color of a button" variety.
... But maybe that's just me?
Re: [VOTE] Moving "Best Coding Practices" talks to the flex-user list?
Posted by Nicholas Kwiatkowski <ni...@spoon.as>.
-1 (binding)
On Thu, Jan 12, 2012 at 1:37 PM, Rogelio Castillo A. <
flex@rogeliocastillo.com> wrote:
> I agree with Peter, also I think the "best coding practices" don't really
> belong to an user list, I reckon it has to be defined by developers for
> developers.
>
> On 12/01/2012, at 2:11 PM, Peter Elst wrote:
>
> >> I guess, now, this would be the right time to open
> >> up the flex-user list to keep on talking over there!
> >
> >
> >
> > -1 (binding)
> >
> > Sorry, I see your point and appreciate the enthusiasm. To clarify my
> > negative vote, think there is only a use of a users mailing list when
> there
> > is an actual release build for Apache Flex and personally don't think
> best
> > practices discussions would necessarily belong in there.
> >
> > - Peter
>
>
Re: [VOTE] Moving "Best Coding Practices" talks to the flex-user list?
Posted by "Rogelio Castillo A." <fl...@rogeliocastillo.com>.
I agree with Peter, also I think the "best coding practices" don't really belong to an user list, I reckon it has to be defined by developers for developers.
On 12/01/2012, at 2:11 PM, Peter Elst wrote:
>> I guess, now, this would be the right time to open
>> up the flex-user list to keep on talking over there!
>
>
>
> -1 (binding)
>
> Sorry, I see your point and appreciate the enthusiasm. To clarify my
> negative vote, think there is only a use of a users mailing list when there
> is an actual release build for Apache Flex and personally don't think best
> practices discussions would necessarily belong in there.
>
> - Peter
Re: [VOTE] Moving "Best Coding Practices" talks to the flex-user
list?
Posted by iBrent <ib...@gmail.com>.
I think it's fine to wait on a new list if people realize that anyone
new to the project will continue to ask questions on this list that may
seem more appropriate for a flex-users list. So I hope people are
accommodating and don't scare them off too soon by saying things like
"That discussion doesn't apply here".
Questions is as questions does.
2 cents,
Brent
On 1/12/12 11:19 AM, Alex Harui wrote:
> -1 (binding)
>
> I agree with Peter.
>
> On 1/12/12 9:11 AM, "peter.elst@gmail.com"<pe...@gmail.com> wrote:
>
>>> I guess, now, this would be the right time to open
>>> up the flex-user list to keep on talking over there!
>>
>>
>> -1 (binding)
>>
>> Sorry, I see your point and appreciate the enthusiasm. To clarify my
>> negative vote, think there is only a use of a users mailing list when there
>> is an actual release build for Apache Flex and personally don't think best
>> practices discussions would necessarily belong in there.
>>
>> - Peter
Re: [VOTE] Moving "Best Coding Practices" talks to the flex-user
list?
Posted by Alex Harui <ah...@adobe.com>.
-1 (binding)
I agree with Peter.
On 1/12/12 9:11 AM, "peter.elst@gmail.com" <pe...@gmail.com> wrote:
>> I guess, now, this would be the right time to open
>> up the flex-user list to keep on talking over there!
>
>
>
> -1 (binding)
>
> Sorry, I see your point and appreciate the enthusiasm. To clarify my
> negative vote, think there is only a use of a users mailing list when there
> is an actual release build for Apache Flex and personally don't think best
> practices discussions would necessarily belong in there.
>
> - Peter
--
Alex Harui
Flex SDK Team
Adobe Systems, Inc.
http://blogs.adobe.com/aharui
Re: [VOTE] Moving "Best Coding Practices" talks to the flex-user list?
Posted by Peter Elst <pe...@gmail.com>.
> I guess, now, this would be the right time to open
> up the flex-user list to keep on talking over there!
-1 (binding)
Sorry, I see your point and appreciate the enthusiasm. To clarify my
negative vote, think there is only a use of a users mailing list when there
is an actual release build for Apache Flex and personally don't think best
practices discussions would necessarily belong in there.
- Peter
Re: [VOTE] Moving "Best Coding Practices" talks to the flex-user list?
Posted by Omar Gonzalez <om...@gmail.com>.
I am leaning to agree with Peter on this one... I don't think we need a
flex-users list until we have an Apache Flex release.
Any discussion on Flex Best Practices, at this moment in time, would be
exclusively based on Adobe Flex, for which there already exists a best
practices document (which nobody follows), I believe it's at
http://opensource.adobe.com, but I could be wrong because I don't really
follow it... ;)
-omar
Re: [VOTE] Moving "Best Coding Practices" talks to the flex-user
list?
Posted by Fréderic Cox <fr...@exuvis.com>.
+1 we should focus on the important things, especially in the beginning
On 12/01/12 17:07, "Sebastian Mohr" <ma...@gmail.com> wrote:
>I am seeing to much pressure coming against
>these "Best Coding Practices" talks. Talking about
>"Best Coding Practices" for Flex is important ... BUT
>not on this list!
>
>I guess, now, this would be the right time to open
>up the flex-user list to keep on talking over there!
>
>What do you think?
>
>
>-- Sebastian
>