You are viewing a plain text version of this content. The canonical link for it is here.
Posted to dev@juddi.apache.org by "Jason Brown (JIRA)" <ju...@ws.apache.org> on 2011/02/17 22:57:12 UTC
[jira] Created: (JUDDI-456) combineCategoryBags findQualifier not
performing correctly.
combineCategoryBags findQualifier not performing correctly.
-----------------------------------------------------------
Key: JUDDI-456
URL: https://issues.apache.org/jira/browse/JUDDI-456
Project: jUDDI
Issue Type: Bug
Components: core
Affects Versions: 3.0.3
Environment: Tomcat 6.0.29, PostgreSQL 8.4
Reporter: Jason Brown
Assignee: Kurt T Stam
Priority: Minor
When performing queries using the combineCategoryBags findQualifier the cateogoryBag does not appear to be combined as it is defined in the specification in section 5.1.4.3.
Considering the following setup (assuming that the tModels referenced are defined):
one business entity ("uddi:business:01") with a service ("udd:service:01") with a categoryBag containing tModelKey in a keyedReference which evaluates to "uddi:test01" and a keyValue which evalues "value-x" containing a binding (uddi:binding:01) with a cateogryBag which has the tModelKey which evaluates to "uddi:test02" and a keyValue which evaluates to "value-y"
<businessEntity businessKey="uddi:business:01">
<name>uddi:business:01</name>
<businessServices>
<businessService businessKey="uddi:business:01" serviceKey="uddi:service:01">
<name>uddi:service:01</name>
<bindingTemplates>
<bindingTemplate serviceKey="uddi:service:01" bindingKey="uddi:binding:01">
<accessPoint>http://www.testing.com/binding:01</accessPoint>
<categoryBag>
<keyedReference tModelKey="uddi:tmodel:01" keyValue="value-y"/>
</categoryBag>
</bindingTemplate>
</bindingTemplates>
<categoryBag>
<keyedReference tModelKey="uddi:tmodel:02" keyValue="value-x"/>
</categoryBag>
</businessService>
</businessServices>
</businessEntity>
a second business entity ("uddi:business:02") has a service ("udd:service:02") with a categoryBag containing tModelKey in a keyedReference which evaluates to "uddi:test01" and a keyValue which evalues "value-x" containing a binding (uddi:binding:02) with a cateogryBag which has the tModelKey which evaluates to "uddi:test02" and a keyValue which evaluates to "value-z"
<businessEntity businessKey="uddi:business:01">
<name>uddi:business:01</name>
<businessServices>
<businessService businessKey="uddi:business:02" serviceKey="uddi:service:02">
<name>uddi:service:02</name>
<bindingTemplates>
<bindingTemplate serviceKey="uddi:service:02" bindingKey="uddi:binding:02">
<accessPoint>http://www.testing.com/binding:02</accessPoint>
<categoryBag>
<keyedReference tModelKey="uddi:tmodel:01" keyValue="value-z"/>
</categoryBag>
</bindingTemplate>
</bindingTemplates>
<categoryBag>
<keyedReference tModelKey="uddi:tmodel:02" keyValue="value-x"/>
</categoryBag>
</businessService>
</businessServices>
</businessEntity>
If the following query is performed:
<find_service xmlns="urn:uddi-org:api_v3>
<findQualifiers>
<findQualifier>combineCategoryBags</findQualifier>
</findQualifiers>
<categoryBag>
<keyedReference keyValue="value-z" tModelKey="uddi:tmodel:01"/>
<keyedReference keyValue="value-x"tModelKey="uddi:tmodel:02"/>
</categoryBag>
</find_service>
If I am understanding the way the findQualifer is described in the specification (the category bags for the service level and below are combined for the purposes of the query),the expected service to be returned is "uddi:service:02". When this query is performed, no services are returned from the registry. Is this findQualifer implemented?
--
This message is automatically generated by JIRA.
-
For more information on JIRA, see: http://www.atlassian.com/software/jira
[jira] [Updated] (JUDDI-456) combineCategoryBags findQualifier not
performing correctly.
Posted by "Kurt T Stam (JIRA)" <ju...@ws.apache.org>.
[ https://issues.apache.org/jira/browse/JUDDI-456?page=com.atlassian.jira.plugin.system.issuetabpanels:all-tabpanel ]
Kurt T Stam updated JUDDI-456:
------------------------------
Attachment: union.sql
union the results
> combineCategoryBags findQualifier not performing correctly.
> -----------------------------------------------------------
>
> Key: JUDDI-456
> URL: https://issues.apache.org/jira/browse/JUDDI-456
> Project: jUDDI
> Issue Type: Bug
> Components: core
> Affects Versions: 3.0.3
> Environment: Tomcat 6.0.29, PostgreSQL 8.4
> Reporter: Jason Brown
> Assignee: Tom Cunningham
> Priority: Minor
> Fix For: 3.1.0
>
> Attachments: juddi-456-patch.txt, union.sql
>
>
> When performing queries using the combineCategoryBags findQualifier the cateogoryBag does not appear to be combined as it is defined in the specification in section 5.1.4.3.
> Considering the following setup (assuming that the tModels referenced are defined):
> one business entity ("uddi:business:01") with a service ("udd:service:01") with a categoryBag containing tModelKey in a keyedReference which evaluates to "uddi:test01" and a keyValue which evalues "value-x" containing a binding (uddi:binding:01) with a cateogryBag which has the tModelKey which evaluates to "uddi:test02" and a keyValue which evaluates to "value-y"
> <businessEntity businessKey="uddi:business:01">
> <name>uddi:business:01</name>
> <businessServices>
> <businessService businessKey="uddi:business:01" serviceKey="uddi:service:01">
> <name>uddi:service:01</name>
> <bindingTemplates>
> <bindingTemplate serviceKey="uddi:service:01" bindingKey="uddi:binding:01">
> <accessPoint>http://www.testing.com/binding:01</accessPoint>
> <categoryBag>
> <keyedReference tModelKey="uddi:tmodel:01" keyValue="value-y"/>
> </categoryBag>
> </bindingTemplate>
> </bindingTemplates>
> <categoryBag>
> <keyedReference tModelKey="uddi:tmodel:02" keyValue="value-x"/>
> </categoryBag>
> </businessService>
> </businessServices>
> </businessEntity>
> a second business entity ("uddi:business:02") has a service ("udd:service:02") with a categoryBag containing tModelKey in a keyedReference which evaluates to "uddi:test01" and a keyValue which evalues "value-x" containing a binding (uddi:binding:02) with a cateogryBag which has the tModelKey which evaluates to "uddi:test02" and a keyValue which evaluates to "value-z"
> <businessEntity businessKey="uddi:business:01">
> <name>uddi:business:01</name>
> <businessServices>
> <businessService businessKey="uddi:business:02" serviceKey="uddi:service:02">
> <name>uddi:service:02</name>
> <bindingTemplates>
> <bindingTemplate serviceKey="uddi:service:02" bindingKey="uddi:binding:02">
> <accessPoint>http://www.testing.com/binding:02</accessPoint>
> <categoryBag>
> <keyedReference tModelKey="uddi:tmodel:01" keyValue="value-z"/>
> </categoryBag>
> </bindingTemplate>
> </bindingTemplates>
> <categoryBag>
> <keyedReference tModelKey="uddi:tmodel:02" keyValue="value-x"/>
> </categoryBag>
> </businessService>
> </businessServices>
> </businessEntity>
> If the following query is performed:
> <find_service xmlns="urn:uddi-org:api_v3>
> <findQualifiers>
> <findQualifier>combineCategoryBags</findQualifier>
> </findQualifiers>
> <categoryBag>
> <keyedReference keyValue="value-z" tModelKey="uddi:tmodel:01"/>
> <keyedReference keyValue="value-x"tModelKey="uddi:tmodel:02"/>
> </categoryBag>
> </find_service>
> If I am understanding the way the findQualifer is described in the specification (the category bags for the service level and below are combined for the purposes of the query),the expected service to be returned is "uddi:service:02". When this query is performed, no services are returned from the registry. Is this findQualifer implemented?
--
This message is automatically generated by JIRA.
For more information on JIRA, see: http://www.atlassian.com/software/jira
[jira] [Closed] (JUDDI-456) combineCategoryBags findQualifier not
performing correctly.
Posted by "Tom Cunningham (JIRA)" <ju...@ws.apache.org>.
[ https://issues.apache.org/jira/browse/JUDDI-456?page=com.atlassian.jira.plugin.system.issuetabpanels:all-tabpanel ]
Tom Cunningham closed JUDDI-456.
--------------------------------
> combineCategoryBags findQualifier not performing correctly.
> -----------------------------------------------------------
>
> Key: JUDDI-456
> URL: https://issues.apache.org/jira/browse/JUDDI-456
> Project: jUDDI
> Issue Type: Bug
> Components: core
> Affects Versions: 3.0.3
> Environment: Tomcat 6.0.29, PostgreSQL 8.4
> Reporter: Jason Brown
> Assignee: Tom Cunningham
> Priority: Minor
> Fix For: 3.1.0
>
> Attachments: juddi-456-patch.txt, union.sql
>
>
> When performing queries using the combineCategoryBags findQualifier the cateogoryBag does not appear to be combined as it is defined in the specification in section 5.1.4.3.
> Considering the following setup (assuming that the tModels referenced are defined):
> one business entity ("uddi:business:01") with a service ("udd:service:01") with a categoryBag containing tModelKey in a keyedReference which evaluates to "uddi:test01" and a keyValue which evalues "value-x" containing a binding (uddi:binding:01) with a cateogryBag which has the tModelKey which evaluates to "uddi:test02" and a keyValue which evaluates to "value-y"
> <businessEntity businessKey="uddi:business:01">
> <name>uddi:business:01</name>
> <businessServices>
> <businessService businessKey="uddi:business:01" serviceKey="uddi:service:01">
> <name>uddi:service:01</name>
> <bindingTemplates>
> <bindingTemplate serviceKey="uddi:service:01" bindingKey="uddi:binding:01">
> <accessPoint>http://www.testing.com/binding:01</accessPoint>
> <categoryBag>
> <keyedReference tModelKey="uddi:tmodel:01" keyValue="value-y"/>
> </categoryBag>
> </bindingTemplate>
> </bindingTemplates>
> <categoryBag>
> <keyedReference tModelKey="uddi:tmodel:02" keyValue="value-x"/>
> </categoryBag>
> </businessService>
> </businessServices>
> </businessEntity>
> a second business entity ("uddi:business:02") has a service ("udd:service:02") with a categoryBag containing tModelKey in a keyedReference which evaluates to "uddi:test01" and a keyValue which evalues "value-x" containing a binding (uddi:binding:02) with a cateogryBag which has the tModelKey which evaluates to "uddi:test02" and a keyValue which evaluates to "value-z"
> <businessEntity businessKey="uddi:business:01">
> <name>uddi:business:01</name>
> <businessServices>
> <businessService businessKey="uddi:business:02" serviceKey="uddi:service:02">
> <name>uddi:service:02</name>
> <bindingTemplates>
> <bindingTemplate serviceKey="uddi:service:02" bindingKey="uddi:binding:02">
> <accessPoint>http://www.testing.com/binding:02</accessPoint>
> <categoryBag>
> <keyedReference tModelKey="uddi:tmodel:01" keyValue="value-z"/>
> </categoryBag>
> </bindingTemplate>
> </bindingTemplates>
> <categoryBag>
> <keyedReference tModelKey="uddi:tmodel:02" keyValue="value-x"/>
> </categoryBag>
> </businessService>
> </businessServices>
> </businessEntity>
> If the following query is performed:
> <find_service xmlns="urn:uddi-org:api_v3>
> <findQualifiers>
> <findQualifier>combineCategoryBags</findQualifier>
> </findQualifiers>
> <categoryBag>
> <keyedReference keyValue="value-z" tModelKey="uddi:tmodel:01"/>
> <keyedReference keyValue="value-x"tModelKey="uddi:tmodel:02"/>
> </categoryBag>
> </find_service>
> If I am understanding the way the findQualifer is described in the specification (the category bags for the service level and below are combined for the purposes of the query),the expected service to be returned is "uddi:service:02". When this query is performed, no services are returned from the registry. Is this findQualifer implemented?
--
This message is automatically generated by JIRA.
For more information on JIRA, see: http://www.atlassian.com/software/jira
[jira] [Resolved] (JUDDI-456) combineCategoryBags findQualifier not
performing correctly.
Posted by "Tom Cunningham (JIRA)" <ju...@ws.apache.org>.
[ https://issues.apache.org/jira/browse/JUDDI-456?page=com.atlassian.jira.plugin.system.issuetabpanels:all-tabpanel ]
Tom Cunningham resolved JUDDI-456.
----------------------------------
Resolution: Fixed
Added query classes for FindServiceByCombinedCategoryQuery and
FindBusinessByCategoryquery, added tests for both the find_business and the
find_service instance, and added calls to both within InquiryHelper.
> combineCategoryBags findQualifier not performing correctly.
> -----------------------------------------------------------
>
> Key: JUDDI-456
> URL: https://issues.apache.org/jira/browse/JUDDI-456
> Project: jUDDI
> Issue Type: Bug
> Components: core
> Affects Versions: 3.0.3
> Environment: Tomcat 6.0.29, PostgreSQL 8.4
> Reporter: Jason Brown
> Assignee: Tom Cunningham
> Priority: Minor
> Fix For: 3.1.0
>
> Attachments: juddi-456-patch.txt, union.sql
>
>
> When performing queries using the combineCategoryBags findQualifier the cateogoryBag does not appear to be combined as it is defined in the specification in section 5.1.4.3.
> Considering the following setup (assuming that the tModels referenced are defined):
> one business entity ("uddi:business:01") with a service ("udd:service:01") with a categoryBag containing tModelKey in a keyedReference which evaluates to "uddi:test01" and a keyValue which evalues "value-x" containing a binding (uddi:binding:01) with a cateogryBag which has the tModelKey which evaluates to "uddi:test02" and a keyValue which evaluates to "value-y"
> <businessEntity businessKey="uddi:business:01">
> <name>uddi:business:01</name>
> <businessServices>
> <businessService businessKey="uddi:business:01" serviceKey="uddi:service:01">
> <name>uddi:service:01</name>
> <bindingTemplates>
> <bindingTemplate serviceKey="uddi:service:01" bindingKey="uddi:binding:01">
> <accessPoint>http://www.testing.com/binding:01</accessPoint>
> <categoryBag>
> <keyedReference tModelKey="uddi:tmodel:01" keyValue="value-y"/>
> </categoryBag>
> </bindingTemplate>
> </bindingTemplates>
> <categoryBag>
> <keyedReference tModelKey="uddi:tmodel:02" keyValue="value-x"/>
> </categoryBag>
> </businessService>
> </businessServices>
> </businessEntity>
> a second business entity ("uddi:business:02") has a service ("udd:service:02") with a categoryBag containing tModelKey in a keyedReference which evaluates to "uddi:test01" and a keyValue which evalues "value-x" containing a binding (uddi:binding:02) with a cateogryBag which has the tModelKey which evaluates to "uddi:test02" and a keyValue which evaluates to "value-z"
> <businessEntity businessKey="uddi:business:01">
> <name>uddi:business:01</name>
> <businessServices>
> <businessService businessKey="uddi:business:02" serviceKey="uddi:service:02">
> <name>uddi:service:02</name>
> <bindingTemplates>
> <bindingTemplate serviceKey="uddi:service:02" bindingKey="uddi:binding:02">
> <accessPoint>http://www.testing.com/binding:02</accessPoint>
> <categoryBag>
> <keyedReference tModelKey="uddi:tmodel:01" keyValue="value-z"/>
> </categoryBag>
> </bindingTemplate>
> </bindingTemplates>
> <categoryBag>
> <keyedReference tModelKey="uddi:tmodel:02" keyValue="value-x"/>
> </categoryBag>
> </businessService>
> </businessServices>
> </businessEntity>
> If the following query is performed:
> <find_service xmlns="urn:uddi-org:api_v3>
> <findQualifiers>
> <findQualifier>combineCategoryBags</findQualifier>
> </findQualifiers>
> <categoryBag>
> <keyedReference keyValue="value-z" tModelKey="uddi:tmodel:01"/>
> <keyedReference keyValue="value-x"tModelKey="uddi:tmodel:02"/>
> </categoryBag>
> </find_service>
> If I am understanding the way the findQualifer is described in the specification (the category bags for the service level and below are combined for the purposes of the query),the expected service to be returned is "uddi:service:02". When this query is performed, no services are returned from the registry. Is this findQualifer implemented?
--
This message is automatically generated by JIRA.
For more information on JIRA, see: http://www.atlassian.com/software/jira
[jira] [Updated] (JUDDI-456) combineCategoryBags findQualifier not
performing correctly.
Posted by "Kurt T Stam (JIRA)" <ju...@ws.apache.org>.
[ https://issues.apache.org/jira/browse/JUDDI-456?page=com.atlassian.jira.plugin.system.issuetabpanels:all-tabpanel ]
Kurt T Stam updated JUDDI-456:
------------------------------
Fix Version/s: 3.1.0
> combineCategoryBags findQualifier not performing correctly.
> -----------------------------------------------------------
>
> Key: JUDDI-456
> URL: https://issues.apache.org/jira/browse/JUDDI-456
> Project: jUDDI
> Issue Type: Bug
> Components: core
> Affects Versions: 3.0.3
> Environment: Tomcat 6.0.29, PostgreSQL 8.4
> Reporter: Jason Brown
> Assignee: Kurt T Stam
> Priority: Minor
> Fix For: 3.1.0
>
>
> When performing queries using the combineCategoryBags findQualifier the cateogoryBag does not appear to be combined as it is defined in the specification in section 5.1.4.3.
> Considering the following setup (assuming that the tModels referenced are defined):
> one business entity ("uddi:business:01") with a service ("udd:service:01") with a categoryBag containing tModelKey in a keyedReference which evaluates to "uddi:test01" and a keyValue which evalues "value-x" containing a binding (uddi:binding:01) with a cateogryBag which has the tModelKey which evaluates to "uddi:test02" and a keyValue which evaluates to "value-y"
> <businessEntity businessKey="uddi:business:01">
> <name>uddi:business:01</name>
> <businessServices>
> <businessService businessKey="uddi:business:01" serviceKey="uddi:service:01">
> <name>uddi:service:01</name>
> <bindingTemplates>
> <bindingTemplate serviceKey="uddi:service:01" bindingKey="uddi:binding:01">
> <accessPoint>http://www.testing.com/binding:01</accessPoint>
> <categoryBag>
> <keyedReference tModelKey="uddi:tmodel:01" keyValue="value-y"/>
> </categoryBag>
> </bindingTemplate>
> </bindingTemplates>
> <categoryBag>
> <keyedReference tModelKey="uddi:tmodel:02" keyValue="value-x"/>
> </categoryBag>
> </businessService>
> </businessServices>
> </businessEntity>
> a second business entity ("uddi:business:02") has a service ("udd:service:02") with a categoryBag containing tModelKey in a keyedReference which evaluates to "uddi:test01" and a keyValue which evalues "value-x" containing a binding (uddi:binding:02) with a cateogryBag which has the tModelKey which evaluates to "uddi:test02" and a keyValue which evaluates to "value-z"
> <businessEntity businessKey="uddi:business:01">
> <name>uddi:business:01</name>
> <businessServices>
> <businessService businessKey="uddi:business:02" serviceKey="uddi:service:02">
> <name>uddi:service:02</name>
> <bindingTemplates>
> <bindingTemplate serviceKey="uddi:service:02" bindingKey="uddi:binding:02">
> <accessPoint>http://www.testing.com/binding:02</accessPoint>
> <categoryBag>
> <keyedReference tModelKey="uddi:tmodel:01" keyValue="value-z"/>
> </categoryBag>
> </bindingTemplate>
> </bindingTemplates>
> <categoryBag>
> <keyedReference tModelKey="uddi:tmodel:02" keyValue="value-x"/>
> </categoryBag>
> </businessService>
> </businessServices>
> </businessEntity>
> If the following query is performed:
> <find_service xmlns="urn:uddi-org:api_v3>
> <findQualifiers>
> <findQualifier>combineCategoryBags</findQualifier>
> </findQualifiers>
> <categoryBag>
> <keyedReference keyValue="value-z" tModelKey="uddi:tmodel:01"/>
> <keyedReference keyValue="value-x"tModelKey="uddi:tmodel:02"/>
> </categoryBag>
> </find_service>
> If I am understanding the way the findQualifer is described in the specification (the category bags for the service level and below are combined for the purposes of the query),the expected service to be returned is "uddi:service:02". When this query is performed, no services are returned from the registry. Is this findQualifer implemented?
--
This message is automatically generated by JIRA.
For more information on JIRA, see: http://www.atlassian.com/software/jira
[jira] [Commented] (JUDDI-456) combineCategoryBags findQualifier
not performing correctly.
Posted by "Kurt T Stam (JIRA)" <ju...@ws.apache.org>.
[ https://issues.apache.org/jira/browse/JUDDI-456?page=com.atlassian.jira.plugin.system.issuetabpanels:comment-tabpanel&focusedCommentId=13028880#comment-13028880 ]
Kurt T Stam commented on JUDDI-456:
-----------------------------------
Hi Tom,
So to be clear for a combineCategoryBags on Service (and also looking at the BindingTemplates we need to create QL that produces a UNION SQL like:
select service.entity_key, scb.id from juddiv3.j3_business_service service
join juddiv3.j3_service_category_bag scb on service.entity_key = scb.entity_key,
juddiv3.j3_keyed_reference kr0, juddiv3.j3_keyed_reference kr1
where (kr0.category_bag_id=scb.id and kr0.tmodel_key_ref='uddi:uddi.joepublisher.com:tmodel01' and kr0.key_value='value-z') or (kr1.category_bag_id=scb.id and
kr1.tmodel_key_ref='uddi:uddi.joepublisher.com:tmodel02' and kr1.key_value='value-x') group by service.entity_key, scb.id
UNION
select service.entity_key, bcb.id from juddiv3.j3_business_service service join juddiv3.j3_binding_template bt on service.entity_key = bt.service_key join
juddiv3.j3_binding_category_bag bcb on bt.entity_key = bcb.entity_key,
juddiv3.j3_keyed_reference kr0, juddiv3.j3_keyed_reference kr1
where (kr0.category_bag_id=bcb.id and kr0.tmodel_key_ref='uddi:uddi.joepublisher.com:tmodel01' and kr0.key_value='value-z') or (kr1.category_bag_id=bcb.id and
kr1.tmodel_key_ref='uddi:uddi.joepublisher.com:tmodel02' and kr1.key_value='value-x') group by service.entity_key, bcb.id ;
And then you get back a bag of keys and in java we need to see if we have both unique keys.
> combineCategoryBags findQualifier not performing correctly.
> -----------------------------------------------------------
>
> Key: JUDDI-456
> URL: https://issues.apache.org/jira/browse/JUDDI-456
> Project: jUDDI
> Issue Type: Bug
> Components: core
> Affects Versions: 3.0.3
> Environment: Tomcat 6.0.29, PostgreSQL 8.4
> Reporter: Jason Brown
> Assignee: Tom Cunningham
> Priority: Minor
> Fix For: 3.1.0
>
> Attachments: juddi-456-patch.txt, union.sql
>
>
> When performing queries using the combineCategoryBags findQualifier the cateogoryBag does not appear to be combined as it is defined in the specification in section 5.1.4.3.
> Considering the following setup (assuming that the tModels referenced are defined):
> one business entity ("uddi:business:01") with a service ("udd:service:01") with a categoryBag containing tModelKey in a keyedReference which evaluates to "uddi:test01" and a keyValue which evalues "value-x" containing a binding (uddi:binding:01) with a cateogryBag which has the tModelKey which evaluates to "uddi:test02" and a keyValue which evaluates to "value-y"
> <businessEntity businessKey="uddi:business:01">
> <name>uddi:business:01</name>
> <businessServices>
> <businessService businessKey="uddi:business:01" serviceKey="uddi:service:01">
> <name>uddi:service:01</name>
> <bindingTemplates>
> <bindingTemplate serviceKey="uddi:service:01" bindingKey="uddi:binding:01">
> <accessPoint>http://www.testing.com/binding:01</accessPoint>
> <categoryBag>
> <keyedReference tModelKey="uddi:tmodel:01" keyValue="value-y"/>
> </categoryBag>
> </bindingTemplate>
> </bindingTemplates>
> <categoryBag>
> <keyedReference tModelKey="uddi:tmodel:02" keyValue="value-x"/>
> </categoryBag>
> </businessService>
> </businessServices>
> </businessEntity>
> a second business entity ("uddi:business:02") has a service ("udd:service:02") with a categoryBag containing tModelKey in a keyedReference which evaluates to "uddi:test01" and a keyValue which evalues "value-x" containing a binding (uddi:binding:02) with a cateogryBag which has the tModelKey which evaluates to "uddi:test02" and a keyValue which evaluates to "value-z"
> <businessEntity businessKey="uddi:business:01">
> <name>uddi:business:01</name>
> <businessServices>
> <businessService businessKey="uddi:business:02" serviceKey="uddi:service:02">
> <name>uddi:service:02</name>
> <bindingTemplates>
> <bindingTemplate serviceKey="uddi:service:02" bindingKey="uddi:binding:02">
> <accessPoint>http://www.testing.com/binding:02</accessPoint>
> <categoryBag>
> <keyedReference tModelKey="uddi:tmodel:01" keyValue="value-z"/>
> </categoryBag>
> </bindingTemplate>
> </bindingTemplates>
> <categoryBag>
> <keyedReference tModelKey="uddi:tmodel:02" keyValue="value-x"/>
> </categoryBag>
> </businessService>
> </businessServices>
> </businessEntity>
> If the following query is performed:
> <find_service xmlns="urn:uddi-org:api_v3>
> <findQualifiers>
> <findQualifier>combineCategoryBags</findQualifier>
> </findQualifiers>
> <categoryBag>
> <keyedReference keyValue="value-z" tModelKey="uddi:tmodel:01"/>
> <keyedReference keyValue="value-x"tModelKey="uddi:tmodel:02"/>
> </categoryBag>
> </find_service>
> If I am understanding the way the findQualifer is described in the specification (the category bags for the service level and below are combined for the purposes of the query),the expected service to be returned is "uddi:service:02". When this query is performed, no services are returned from the registry. Is this findQualifer implemented?
--
This message is automatically generated by JIRA.
For more information on JIRA, see: http://www.atlassian.com/software/jira
[jira] [Assigned] (JUDDI-456) combineCategoryBags findQualifier not
performing correctly.
Posted by "Tom Cunningham (JIRA)" <ju...@ws.apache.org>.
[ https://issues.apache.org/jira/browse/JUDDI-456?page=com.atlassian.jira.plugin.system.issuetabpanels:all-tabpanel ]
Tom Cunningham reassigned JUDDI-456:
------------------------------------
Assignee: Tom Cunningham (was: Kurt T Stam)
> combineCategoryBags findQualifier not performing correctly.
> -----------------------------------------------------------
>
> Key: JUDDI-456
> URL: https://issues.apache.org/jira/browse/JUDDI-456
> Project: jUDDI
> Issue Type: Bug
> Components: core
> Affects Versions: 3.0.3
> Environment: Tomcat 6.0.29, PostgreSQL 8.4
> Reporter: Jason Brown
> Assignee: Tom Cunningham
> Priority: Minor
> Fix For: 3.1.0
>
>
> When performing queries using the combineCategoryBags findQualifier the cateogoryBag does not appear to be combined as it is defined in the specification in section 5.1.4.3.
> Considering the following setup (assuming that the tModels referenced are defined):
> one business entity ("uddi:business:01") with a service ("udd:service:01") with a categoryBag containing tModelKey in a keyedReference which evaluates to "uddi:test01" and a keyValue which evalues "value-x" containing a binding (uddi:binding:01) with a cateogryBag which has the tModelKey which evaluates to "uddi:test02" and a keyValue which evaluates to "value-y"
> <businessEntity businessKey="uddi:business:01">
> <name>uddi:business:01</name>
> <businessServices>
> <businessService businessKey="uddi:business:01" serviceKey="uddi:service:01">
> <name>uddi:service:01</name>
> <bindingTemplates>
> <bindingTemplate serviceKey="uddi:service:01" bindingKey="uddi:binding:01">
> <accessPoint>http://www.testing.com/binding:01</accessPoint>
> <categoryBag>
> <keyedReference tModelKey="uddi:tmodel:01" keyValue="value-y"/>
> </categoryBag>
> </bindingTemplate>
> </bindingTemplates>
> <categoryBag>
> <keyedReference tModelKey="uddi:tmodel:02" keyValue="value-x"/>
> </categoryBag>
> </businessService>
> </businessServices>
> </businessEntity>
> a second business entity ("uddi:business:02") has a service ("udd:service:02") with a categoryBag containing tModelKey in a keyedReference which evaluates to "uddi:test01" and a keyValue which evalues "value-x" containing a binding (uddi:binding:02) with a cateogryBag which has the tModelKey which evaluates to "uddi:test02" and a keyValue which evaluates to "value-z"
> <businessEntity businessKey="uddi:business:01">
> <name>uddi:business:01</name>
> <businessServices>
> <businessService businessKey="uddi:business:02" serviceKey="uddi:service:02">
> <name>uddi:service:02</name>
> <bindingTemplates>
> <bindingTemplate serviceKey="uddi:service:02" bindingKey="uddi:binding:02">
> <accessPoint>http://www.testing.com/binding:02</accessPoint>
> <categoryBag>
> <keyedReference tModelKey="uddi:tmodel:01" keyValue="value-z"/>
> </categoryBag>
> </bindingTemplate>
> </bindingTemplates>
> <categoryBag>
> <keyedReference tModelKey="uddi:tmodel:02" keyValue="value-x"/>
> </categoryBag>
> </businessService>
> </businessServices>
> </businessEntity>
> If the following query is performed:
> <find_service xmlns="urn:uddi-org:api_v3>
> <findQualifiers>
> <findQualifier>combineCategoryBags</findQualifier>
> </findQualifiers>
> <categoryBag>
> <keyedReference keyValue="value-z" tModelKey="uddi:tmodel:01"/>
> <keyedReference keyValue="value-x"tModelKey="uddi:tmodel:02"/>
> </categoryBag>
> </find_service>
> If I am understanding the way the findQualifer is described in the specification (the category bags for the service level and below are combined for the purposes of the query),the expected service to be returned is "uddi:service:02". When this query is performed, no services are returned from the registry. Is this findQualifer implemented?
--
This message is automatically generated by JIRA.
For more information on JIRA, see: http://www.atlassian.com/software/jira
[jira] [Updated] (JUDDI-456) combineCategoryBags findQualifier not
performing correctly.
Posted by "Kurt T Stam (JIRA)" <ju...@ws.apache.org>.
[ https://issues.apache.org/jira/browse/JUDDI-456?page=com.atlassian.jira.plugin.system.issuetabpanels:all-tabpanel ]
Kurt T Stam updated JUDDI-456:
------------------------------
Attachment: juddi-456-patch.txt
rough code, not real patch
> combineCategoryBags findQualifier not performing correctly.
> -----------------------------------------------------------
>
> Key: JUDDI-456
> URL: https://issues.apache.org/jira/browse/JUDDI-456
> Project: jUDDI
> Issue Type: Bug
> Components: core
> Affects Versions: 3.0.3
> Environment: Tomcat 6.0.29, PostgreSQL 8.4
> Reporter: Jason Brown
> Assignee: Tom Cunningham
> Priority: Minor
> Fix For: 3.1.0
>
> Attachments: juddi-456-patch.txt
>
>
> When performing queries using the combineCategoryBags findQualifier the cateogoryBag does not appear to be combined as it is defined in the specification in section 5.1.4.3.
> Considering the following setup (assuming that the tModels referenced are defined):
> one business entity ("uddi:business:01") with a service ("udd:service:01") with a categoryBag containing tModelKey in a keyedReference which evaluates to "uddi:test01" and a keyValue which evalues "value-x" containing a binding (uddi:binding:01) with a cateogryBag which has the tModelKey which evaluates to "uddi:test02" and a keyValue which evaluates to "value-y"
> <businessEntity businessKey="uddi:business:01">
> <name>uddi:business:01</name>
> <businessServices>
> <businessService businessKey="uddi:business:01" serviceKey="uddi:service:01">
> <name>uddi:service:01</name>
> <bindingTemplates>
> <bindingTemplate serviceKey="uddi:service:01" bindingKey="uddi:binding:01">
> <accessPoint>http://www.testing.com/binding:01</accessPoint>
> <categoryBag>
> <keyedReference tModelKey="uddi:tmodel:01" keyValue="value-y"/>
> </categoryBag>
> </bindingTemplate>
> </bindingTemplates>
> <categoryBag>
> <keyedReference tModelKey="uddi:tmodel:02" keyValue="value-x"/>
> </categoryBag>
> </businessService>
> </businessServices>
> </businessEntity>
> a second business entity ("uddi:business:02") has a service ("udd:service:02") with a categoryBag containing tModelKey in a keyedReference which evaluates to "uddi:test01" and a keyValue which evalues "value-x" containing a binding (uddi:binding:02) with a cateogryBag which has the tModelKey which evaluates to "uddi:test02" and a keyValue which evaluates to "value-z"
> <businessEntity businessKey="uddi:business:01">
> <name>uddi:business:01</name>
> <businessServices>
> <businessService businessKey="uddi:business:02" serviceKey="uddi:service:02">
> <name>uddi:service:02</name>
> <bindingTemplates>
> <bindingTemplate serviceKey="uddi:service:02" bindingKey="uddi:binding:02">
> <accessPoint>http://www.testing.com/binding:02</accessPoint>
> <categoryBag>
> <keyedReference tModelKey="uddi:tmodel:01" keyValue="value-z"/>
> </categoryBag>
> </bindingTemplate>
> </bindingTemplates>
> <categoryBag>
> <keyedReference tModelKey="uddi:tmodel:02" keyValue="value-x"/>
> </categoryBag>
> </businessService>
> </businessServices>
> </businessEntity>
> If the following query is performed:
> <find_service xmlns="urn:uddi-org:api_v3>
> <findQualifiers>
> <findQualifier>combineCategoryBags</findQualifier>
> </findQualifiers>
> <categoryBag>
> <keyedReference keyValue="value-z" tModelKey="uddi:tmodel:01"/>
> <keyedReference keyValue="value-x"tModelKey="uddi:tmodel:02"/>
> </categoryBag>
> </find_service>
> If I am understanding the way the findQualifer is described in the specification (the category bags for the service level and below are combined for the purposes of the query),the expected service to be returned is "uddi:service:02". When this query is performed, no services are returned from the registry. Is this findQualifer implemented?
--
This message is automatically generated by JIRA.
For more information on JIRA, see: http://www.atlassian.com/software/jira