You are viewing a plain text version of this content. The canonical link for it is here.
Posted to users@spamassassin.apache.org by Jeff Koch <je...@intersessions.com> on 2004/04/12 16:21:23 UTC
SURBL Poisoning?
I have not tried SURBL yet but I'm concerned about what would happen if
spammers started loading their emails up with links to legitimate websites
- like paypal - ebay - chase - expedia, etc. Are you doing a manual review?
At 06:20 AM 4/12/2004, you wrote:
>On Monday, April 12, 2004, 3:09:41 AM, Paul Barbeau wrote:
> > There still might be a place for BigEvil in this new world of SURBL. I
> find
> > there are a number of domain in BigEvil (and my own MidEvil) that are not
> > yet in the spam cop and therefore not in this service. Because of this
> > there might still be a place for this type of list as you could call it
> more
> > cutting edge.
>
>Hi Paul,
>I was just about to ask if you wanted to help us get MidEvil into
>an SURBL along with BigEvil. We've asked Chris to see if his
>data sources would allow the BigEvil domains to go out in an RBL
>and are hoping (fingers crossed!!) to hear that he can get a
>green light.
>
>There are SpamAssassin administrators hoping and waiting around
>the world to be able to use these good lists in RBL form and
>free up some memory from their SA servers. (By using them as
>SURBLs instead of SA rule sets, the data is cached in DNS zone
>files on their local name service.)
>
>All we need is a feed of a list of domains and our scripts can
>turn them into (SU)RBLs, and our network of DNS and rsync servers
>can get the RBL zone files out. Probably ideally we would combine
>MidEvil and BigEvil if you and Chris could go for that.
>
>We could also make a separate, combined list of *Evil and Bill
>Stearns' sa-blacklist which we already have in RBL form, pending
>agreement on the SURBL name for Bill's list.
>
>Jeff C.
>--
>Jeff Chan
>mailto:jeffc@surbl.org-nospam
>http://www.surbl.org/
Best Regards,
Jeff Koch, Intersessions
Re: SURBL Poisoning?
Posted by William Stearns <ws...@pobox.com>.
Good morning, Jeff,
On Mon, 12 Apr 2004, Jeff Koch wrote:
> I have not tried SURBL yet but I'm concerned about what would happen if
> spammers started loading their emails up with links to legitimate websites
> - like paypal - ebay - chase - expedia, etc. Are you doing a manual review?
You're correct in that the spams regularly contain links off to
legitimate domains. For a while, one spammer was even putting in
[a href="bogus.domain][/a]
all over the place. Spam chaff!
I won't speak for Spamcop, but for at least the sa.surbl.org piece
based on the sa-blacklist, I do a _lot_ of manual review. Nothing goes
into the list by an automated process.
I spend about 3 person days a week outside of my day job:
verifying that the messages really are spam, extracting domains, and
checking that they're spammer domains. I have live eyes on the messages
and extracted domains at least three times before a domain hits the
sa-blacklist. I specifically check for things like msn, yahoo, ebay,
geocities, and other common false positives.
Cheers,
- Bill
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
"Put down those Windows disks, Dave..."
-- HAL
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
William Stearns (wstearns@pobox.com). Mason, Buildkernel, freedups, p0f,
rsync-backup, ssh-keyinstall, dns-check, more at: http://www.stearns.org
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
Re: SURBL Poisoning?
Posted by Jeff Chan <je...@surbl.org>.
On Monday, April 12, 2004, 7:21:23 AM, Jeff Koch wrote:
> I have not tried SURBL yet but I'm concerned about what would happen if
> spammers started loading their emails up with links to legitimate websites
> - like paypal - ebay - chase - expedia, etc. Are you doing a manual review?
I am doing a manual review, but need to find a way to share that
load. Perhaps we can set up another discussion list and I can
gateway the new additions to the list to it.
Marc Perkel gave me access on his phpbb but I have not had time
to work with it. A bulletin board with voting mechanism and a
way to feed new domains into threads under a "spam or ham" board
might be ideal. Anyone who could help implement that would be
gratefully thanked.
There is an internal whitelisting mechanism in sc.surbl.org that
prevents legitimate domains like ebay, etc. from ever getting
added to the list, and it seems quite effective. Anyone who has
whitelists of common fp popular domains to share would be greatly
appreciated also.
However the primary defense against FPs is in the care SpamCop
users take in *unchecking* legitimate looking URIs when
they submit their reports. That also seems pretty effective
at preventing FPs, as the whitelist is small yet useful.
A log of the domains as they get added to the list can be found
at:
http://www.surbl.org/top-sites-domains.new.log
If anyone spots any FPs, please forward them to me.
Note also that version 2 of the data engine should have
better spam detection and a similar low false positive rate,
all automatically.
Hope this helps,
Jeff C.