You are viewing a plain text version of this content. The canonical link for it is here.
Posted to users@netbeans.apache.org by Ken Standard <ad...@qso.com> on 2023/01/03 14:54:08 UTC

NetBeans Platform JavaFX Integeration Tutorial

To whom it may concern:

There are several issues to address.

The mentioned tutorial is solely based on a Windows user perspective. 
That is  a very short/narrow view of a product widely used on many 
platforms, including Linux and Mac. This one-platform perspective does 
no good for those who do not wish to be a Windows user. The tree-list 
images only apply in one situation and do not apply to all (e.g. Linux 
users developing a MAVEN project).

The tutorial also assumes a Swing project as the starting base. Another 
very narrow perspective. If the user has the intention to create a 
JavaFX only project, it would be a MAVEN or GRADLE project. Why not 
start there or have a separate tutorial for that kind of project.

To broaden the usefulness and effectiveness, create separate sections 
(or tutorials) for Linux/Mac with the appropriate visuals and references.

The tone of the tutorial seems to assume an experienced Java programmer, 
already familiar with NetBeans and how projects are arranged and 
constructed. Bad mistake. That is a very short sighted assumption.

On the good side, the step by step instruction through the menus is 
helpful, as is the visuals (see notes above). However, the project 
subject is overly simple and barely functional. In other places on your 
web site, the Address Book subject is used for instruction on other 
subjects. Let me suggest it is used more often, in that it has a broader 
functionality that would cover more potential questions than this one 
window, one function example. The need for more examples and/or code 
modules would be reduced significantly.

If you have questions or need more information, please feel free to 
contact me.

Regards,
Ken Standard
ad5xj@qso.com
(985) 208-4236

Re: NetBeans Platform JavaFX Integeration Tutorial

Posted by Ernie Rael <er...@raelity.com>.
Greetings Ken,

As you're likely aware, NetBeans is now an Apache project supported by 
volunteers. Frustratingly for many, documentation and help need lots of 
attention. JavaFX in particular, has gotten little attention.

It would be great if you could turn your experience with JavaFX on 
NetBeans into some documentation that can be made generally available.

-ernie

On 23/01/03 6:54 AM, Ken Standard wrote:
>
> To whom it may concern:
>
> There are several issues to address.
>
> The mentioned tutorial is solely based on a Windows user perspective. 
> That is  a very short/narrow view of a product widely used on many 
> platforms, including Linux and Mac. This one-platform perspective does 
> no good for those who do not wish to be a Windows user. The tree-list 
> images only apply in one situation and do not apply to all (e.g. Linux 
> users developing a MAVEN project).
>
> The tutorial also assumes a Swing project as the starting base. 
> Another very narrow perspective. If the user has the intention to 
> create a JavaFX only project, it would be a MAVEN or GRADLE project. 
> Why not start there or have a separate tutorial for that kind of project.
>
> To broaden the usefulness and effectiveness, create separate sections 
> (or tutorials) for Linux/Mac with the appropriate visuals and references.
>
> The tone of the tutorial seems to assume an experienced Java 
> programmer, already familiar with NetBeans and how projects are 
> arranged and constructed. Bad mistake. That is a very short sighted 
> assumption.
>
> On the good side, the step by step instruction through the menus is 
> helpful, as is the visuals (see notes above). However, the project 
> subject is overly simple and barely functional. In other places on 
> your web site, the Address Book subject is used for instruction on 
> other subjects. Let me suggest it is used more often, in that it has a 
> broader functionality that would cover more potential questions than 
> this one window, one function example. The need for more examples 
> and/or code modules would be reduced significantly.
>
> If you have questions or need more information, please feel free to 
> contact me.
>
> Regards,
> Ken Standard
> ad5xj@qso.com
> (985) 208-4236
>