You are viewing a plain text version of this content. The canonical link for it is here.
Posted to users@jackrabbit.apache.org by Ian Boston <ie...@tfd.co.uk> on 2009/07/01 14:47:11 UTC

PrincipalManager question.

Hi,
I have 1 quick question.

If I want to determine if the an Authorizable has a Principal  
(presumably witht the PrincipalManager), is there a way of doing this  
with the DefaultSecurityManager in JR15 and later, other than  
iterating through all the possible principals and searching for a match.
We have uses that have a lot of principals, and getting them and  
iterating is inefficient (IMHO), I would like to be able to perform a  
search

eg
/**
  * @param myPrincipal the principal to be checked
  * @param candidatePrincipal the principal that we are checking to  
see if myPrincipal has
  * @retrun true if myPrincipal has candidatePrincipal, false otherwise
  */
boolean principalManager.hasPrincipal(Principal myPrincipal, Principal  
candidatePrincipal)

Ideally I would like that to propagate through to the  
PrincipalProviders as this is really an search query that could be  
expensive.

Is there a way of achinving this *without* changing anyhing inside  
JR15 ?

Ian

Re: PrincipalManager question.

Posted by Angela Schreiber <an...@day.com>.
> Question answered, thank you (I cant believe I was so stupid not to see 
> that)

perfect. thanks for reporting back.

Re: PrincipalManager question.

Posted by Ian Boston <ie...@tfd.co.uk>.
On 2 Jul 2009, at 09:31, Angela Schreiber wrote:

>
>> I need to answer the question.
>> Is userA a member of groupB either directly or indirectly.
>> userA is a member of about 100 groups, the group hierarchy is  
>> several levels deep and
>
> group membership can be discovered using
>
> Authorizable#memberOf()


makes sense

What I need is
Group#isMember(Authorizable)

Question answered, thank you (I cant believe I was so stupid not to  
see that)
Ian

> Authorizable#declaredMemberOf()
>
>> some of the principals are come from custom PrincipalProvider  
>> implementations.
>
> if i'm not mistaken you can configure multiple principalproviders.
>
> if an authorizable has multiple principals (!= group
> membership)

!= group membership was my mistake.

> then Authorizable#getPrincipals() is the thing
> you are looking for.
>
> The principal(s) of an authorizable are retrieved from the  
> principalmanager that in the default setup has been created
> using the configured providers.
>
> angela


Re: PrincipalManager question.

Posted by Angela Schreiber <an...@day.com>.
> I need to answer the question.
> 
> Is userA a member of groupB either directly or indirectly.
> 
> userA is a member of about 100 groups, the group hierarchy is several 
> levels deep and 

group membership can be discovered using

Authorizable#memberOf()
Authorizable#declaredMemberOf()

> some of the principals are come from custom 
> PrincipalProvider implementations.

if i'm not mistaken you can configure multiple principalproviders.

if an authorizable has multiple principals (!= group
membership) then Authorizable#getPrincipals() is the thing
you are looking for.

The principal(s) of an authorizable are retrieved from the 
principalmanager that in the default setup has been created
using the configured providers.

angela

Re: PrincipalManager question.

Posted by Ian Boston <ie...@tfd.co.uk>.
On 1 Jul 2009, at 13:59, Angela Schreiber wrote:

> hi ian
>
>> If I want to determine if the an Authorizable has a Principal
>
> what do you mean by "if an authorizable has a principal"?

I need to answer the question.

Is userA a member of groupB either directly or indirectly.

userA is a member of about 100 groups, the group hierarchy is several  
levels deep and some of the principals are come from custom  
PrincipalProvider implementations.


>
> in case you are referring to the fact that an authorizable
> can have more than a single principal associated with it
> there something like Authorizable#getPrincipals in the api.
>
> see also Authorizable#addReferee and #removeReferee.

thank you
Ian


>
> regards
> angela
>
>
>
>> (presumably witht the PrincipalManager), is there a way of doing  
>> this with the DefaultSecurityManager in JR15 and later, other than  
>> iterating through all the possible principals and searching for a  
>> match.
>> We have uses that have a lot of principals, and getting them and  
>> iterating is inefficient (IMHO), I would like to be able to perform  
>> a search
>> eg
>> /**
>> * @param myPrincipal the principal to be checked
>> * @param candidatePrincipal the principal that we are checking to  
>> see if myPrincipal has
>> * @retrun true if myPrincipal has candidatePrincipal, false otherwise
>> */
>> boolean principalManager.hasPrincipal(Principal myPrincipal,  
>> Principal candidatePrincipal)
>> Ideally I would like that to propagate through to the  
>> PrincipalProviders as this is really an search query that could be  
>> expensive.
>> Is there a way of achinving this *without* changing anyhing inside  
>> JR15 ?
>> Ian
>


Re: PrincipalManager question.

Posted by Angela Schreiber <an...@day.com>.
hi ian

> If I want to determine if the an Authorizable has a Principal 

what do you mean by "if an authorizable has a principal"?

in case you are referring to the fact that an authorizable
can have more than a single principal associated with it
there something like Authorizable#getPrincipals in the api.

see also Authorizable#addReferee and #removeReferee.

regards
angela



> (presumably witht the PrincipalManager), is there a way of doing this 
> with the DefaultSecurityManager in JR15 and later, other than iterating 
> through all the possible principals and searching for a match.
> We have uses that have a lot of principals, and getting them and 
> iterating is inefficient (IMHO), I would like to be able to perform a 
> search
> 
> eg
> /**
>  * @param myPrincipal the principal to be checked
>  * @param candidatePrincipal the principal that we are checking to see 
> if myPrincipal has
>  * @retrun true if myPrincipal has candidatePrincipal, false otherwise
>  */
> boolean principalManager.hasPrincipal(Principal myPrincipal, Principal 
> candidatePrincipal)
> 
> Ideally I would like that to propagate through to the PrincipalProviders 
> as this is really an search query that could be expensive.
> 
> Is there a way of achinving this *without* changing anyhing inside JR15 ?
> 
> Ian
>