You are viewing a plain text version of this content. The canonical link for it is here.
Posted to dev@tomcat.apache.org by Steve Madsen <st...@moonglade.com> on 2000/06/22 07:34:57 UTC

Replacing the default servlet except for some requests

I have what I think should be a fairly common situation, but I can't seem 
to get Tomcat to behave the way I want.

I have a servlet I want to handle all requests, except for those with 
static content (images, pure HTML).  I have mapped the servlet to "/", 
which replaces the default servlet.  My problem is how to get Tomcat to 
"undo" this mapping in the case of certain files.  I have tried:

/images/* -> default

and this sort of works, except my URLs now need to be 
"/images/images/foo.gif" in order to find the file /images/foo.gif in my 
tree.  This will break paths on my production server, due to the extra 
"/images".  (Apache handles static content before it ever gets to 
Tomcat.)  I've also tried:

*.gif -> default

This doesn't seem to have any effect at all.  I know it doesn't go to my 
servlet any longer, but I don't get the image I expect, and I can't find 
any error messages in the Tomcat logs or the Tomcat console.  If I ask for 
the image directly, instead of it being in a page, an extra "/" gets tacked 
on to the end of the URL, and then it *does* go to my servlet.

I don't want to resort to using some standard prefix ("/servlet") or 
extension (".do") for servlet-handled requests.  Is there any way to get 
Tomcat to do what I want?

BTW, is there a good reason that the rest of the Jakarta mailing lists 
aren't archived on the web site?

--
Steve Madsen <st...@moonglade.com>


Re: Replacing the default servlet except for some requests

Posted by co...@eng.sun.com.
> I have a servlet I want to handle all requests, except for those with 
> static content (images, pure HTML).  I have mapped the servlet to "/", 
> which replaces the default servlet.  My problem is how to get Tomcat to 
> "undo" this mapping in the case of certain files.  I have tried:

> /images/* -> default

"default" is not a portable or standard feature of tomcat. It used to work
for tomcat standalone, but in 3.2 it'll probably not work ( at least not
the way it did - there are 2 handlers, one for dir and one for static
files and none is a servlet ).

The spec doesn't require anything about this - you can of course define
your own "default" servlet - but it'll not work in all cases ( for example
it have no way to guess the user "welcome" files for dirs ).

> and this sort of works, except my URLs now need to be 
> "/images/images/foo.gif" in order to find the file /images/foo.gif in my 

Probably a consequence of the default servlet's implementation - it
expects "/" as servlet path, etc. It's the default servlet - it's not
supposed (or designed ) to work as a user servlet.

> tree.  This will break paths on my production server, due to the extra 
> "/images".  (Apache handles static content before it ever gets to 
> Tomcat.)  I've also tried:
> 
> *.gif -> default

Same. Don't use "default" - create your own servlet to serve static files
if you want.

Anyway - I don't think there is any "standard" solution for your
problem. If you use Apache you can write special mappings, and make it
forward only what you want. 

For tomcat standalone - we try to support the standard, all "special" 
mapping features will come after that. You can do any kind of mapping  in
Interceptors - but again, it's not standard/portable.

Costin