You are viewing a plain text version of this content. The canonical link for it is here.
Posted to dev@geronimo.apache.org by Joe Bohn <jo...@earthlink.net> on 2008/05/20 14:22:16 UTC
[VOTE] ASF hosted machines for TCK Proposal
If we are to take this proposal forward to the ASF Infrastructure team,
they want assurance that the Geronimo PMC is behind the recommendation
and supports the intended use of the systems. I think it also bodes
well to demonstrate that the entire Geronimo community stands behind the
proposal, particularly since we will administer the machines ourselves,
- so I encourage all to vote.
[ ] +1 I agree with the need and support the proposal. Present it to the
ASF Infrastructure team.
[ ] 0 No opinion
[ ] -1 I don't see the need or disagree with the proposal. Do not
present this proposal to the ASF Infrastructure team.
I'll plan on calling this vote on Friday (5/23) morning (9 AM EST).
PROPOSAL
Rationale:
The Apache Geronimo community has a need to support the execution and
sharing of results from Sun certification tests (cts) which are
necessary gain JavaEE5 certification compliance. This information is
only available to those Geronimo committers that have signed the Sun NDA
and other Apache committers that have signed an NDA and gained approval
of the Apache Geronimo PMC. This has allowed other Apache projects to
test new products/releases by running JavaEE 5 TCK tests using the
Apache Geronimo test infrastructure.
In the past these resource intensive tests have been run on private
machines by individuals. As more people become involved with Apache
Geronimo and related projects, it is becoming obvious that we need a
central system to run and share the results of these tests. A
centralized testing environment allows the Geronimo community to more
fully participate in the TCK process. Some committers don't have access
to the hardware resources needed to run the Java EE TCK tests in a
timely manner. Although some ad-hoc sharing of private machines has
occurred, this is not ideal from a community perspective. Community
controlled systems allow us to equitably share these resources.
Request:
To fulfill this requirement, the Apache Geronimo PMC is requesting the
ASF infrastructure team to provide and host machines that can be used
for this purpose. Initially, we would like to request two (2) machines
that meet (as closely as possible) the specification below. However, we
can see the need for 2 additional machines in the not too distant future.
Machine specs:
- 8 core (two 3.0 GHz quad-core)
- 16 GB memory
- two 750GB 7200 - rpm SATA 3GB/s disks
- DVD R/W (20x?)
- rack mountable specification to work with ASF infra requirements
- LOM or other features as necessary for ASF infra support
- to be developer managed and maintained by the Apache Geronimo Team
- Apache Geronimo would assume all responsibility for:
- configuration
- backup/recovery
- secure access
- Strictly limited to those Apache Geronimo committers with
NDAs on file or additional Apache committers with NDAs and approved by
Geronimo PMC.
- full, admin access would be granted to ASF infra with reboot directions
- At least 2 active Apache Geronimo committers (with NDA
authorization) would identified to manage the machines.
- Running Linux with something like Xen for 4 VM images per machine. We
may increase the number of VM images if it is feasible.
- We would require both ssh and VNC access to the VMs.
- It is not yet decided if we would use NAT to access the VMs or
public IP addresses. Is there are recommendation from ASF Infra?
- Automation will most likely be added to run builds, execute tests, and
produce reports.
- Capability to manually run tests on demand would also be supported.
Admin Volunteers:
- Joe Bohn (PMC)
- Jay McHugh (PMC)
- Jason Warner
- Matt Hogstrom (PMC)
- Kevan Miller (PMC)
Re: [VOTE] ASF hosted machines for TCK Proposal
Posted by "Jay D. McHugh" <ja...@gmail.com>.
+1
Jay
Joe Bohn wrote:
> If we are to take this proposal forward to the ASF Infrastructure team,
> they want assurance that the Geronimo PMC is behind the recommendation
> and supports the intended use of the systems. I think it also bodes
> well to demonstrate that the entire Geronimo community stands behind the
> proposal, particularly since we will administer the machines ourselves,
> - so I encourage all to vote.
>
>
> [ ] +1 I agree with the need and support the proposal. Present it to the
> ASF Infrastructure team.
> [ ] 0 No opinion
> [ ] -1 I don't see the need or disagree with the proposal. Do not
> present this proposal to the ASF Infrastructure team.
>
> I'll plan on calling this vote on Friday (5/23) morning (9 AM EST).
>
>
> PROPOSAL
>
> Rationale:
> The Apache Geronimo community has a need to support the execution and
> sharing of results from Sun certification tests (cts) which are
> necessary gain JavaEE5 certification compliance. This information is
> only available to those Geronimo committers that have signed the Sun NDA
> and other Apache committers that have signed an NDA and gained approval
> of the Apache Geronimo PMC. This has allowed other Apache projects to
> test new products/releases by running JavaEE 5 TCK tests using the
> Apache Geronimo test infrastructure.
>
> In the past these resource intensive tests have been run on private
> machines by individuals. As more people become involved with Apache
> Geronimo and related projects, it is becoming obvious that we need a
> central system to run and share the results of these tests. A
> centralized testing environment allows the Geronimo community to more
> fully participate in the TCK process. Some committers don't have access
> to the hardware resources needed to run the Java EE TCK tests in a
> timely manner. Although some ad-hoc sharing of private machines has
> occurred, this is not ideal from a community perspective. Community
> controlled systems allow us to equitably share these resources.
>
> Request:
> To fulfill this requirement, the Apache Geronimo PMC is requesting the
> ASF infrastructure team to provide and host machines that can be used
> for this purpose. Initially, we would like to request two (2) machines
> that meet (as closely as possible) the specification below. However, we
> can see the need for 2 additional machines in the not too distant future.
>
> Machine specs:
> - 8 core (two 3.0 GHz quad-core)
> - 16 GB memory
> - two 750GB 7200 - rpm SATA 3GB/s disks
> - DVD R/W (20x?)
> - rack mountable specification to work with ASF infra requirements
> - LOM or other features as necessary for ASF infra support
> - to be developer managed and maintained by the Apache Geronimo Team
> - Apache Geronimo would assume all responsibility for:
> - configuration
> - backup/recovery
> - secure access
> - Strictly limited to those Apache Geronimo committers with NDAs
> on file or additional Apache committers with NDAs and approved by
> Geronimo PMC.
> - full, admin access would be granted to ASF infra with reboot directions
> - At least 2 active Apache Geronimo committers (with NDA
> authorization) would identified to manage the machines.
> - Running Linux with something like Xen for 4 VM images per machine. We
> may increase the number of VM images if it is feasible.
> - We would require both ssh and VNC access to the VMs.
> - It is not yet decided if we would use NAT to access the VMs or
> public IP addresses. Is there are recommendation from ASF Infra?
> - Automation will most likely be added to run builds, execute tests, and
> produce reports.
> - Capability to manually run tests on demand would also be supported.
>
> Admin Volunteers:
> - Joe Bohn (PMC)
> - Jay McHugh (PMC)
> - Jason Warner
> - Matt Hogstrom (PMC)
> - Kevan Miller (PMC)
Re: [VOTE] ASF hosted machines for TCK Proposal
Posted by Joe Bohn <jo...@earthlink.net>.
Here's my +1.
Joe
Joe Bohn wrote:
> If we are to take this proposal forward to the ASF Infrastructure team,
> they want assurance that the Geronimo PMC is behind the recommendation
> and supports the intended use of the systems. I think it also bodes
> well to demonstrate that the entire Geronimo community stands behind the
> proposal, particularly since we will administer the machines ourselves,
> - so I encourage all to vote.
>
>
> [ ] +1 I agree with the need and support the proposal. Present it to the
> ASF Infrastructure team.
> [ ] 0 No opinion
> [ ] -1 I don't see the need or disagree with the proposal. Do not
> present this proposal to the ASF Infrastructure team.
>
> I'll plan on calling this vote on Friday (5/23) morning (9 AM EST).
>
>
> PROPOSAL
>
> Rationale:
> The Apache Geronimo community has a need to support the execution and
> sharing of results from Sun certification tests (cts) which are
> necessary gain JavaEE5 certification compliance. This information is
> only available to those Geronimo committers that have signed the Sun NDA
> and other Apache committers that have signed an NDA and gained approval
> of the Apache Geronimo PMC. This has allowed other Apache projects to
> test new products/releases by running JavaEE 5 TCK tests using the
> Apache Geronimo test infrastructure.
>
> In the past these resource intensive tests have been run on private
> machines by individuals. As more people become involved with Apache
> Geronimo and related projects, it is becoming obvious that we need a
> central system to run and share the results of these tests. A
> centralized testing environment allows the Geronimo community to more
> fully participate in the TCK process. Some committers don't have access
> to the hardware resources needed to run the Java EE TCK tests in a
> timely manner. Although some ad-hoc sharing of private machines has
> occurred, this is not ideal from a community perspective. Community
> controlled systems allow us to equitably share these resources.
>
> Request:
> To fulfill this requirement, the Apache Geronimo PMC is requesting the
> ASF infrastructure team to provide and host machines that can be used
> for this purpose. Initially, we would like to request two (2) machines
> that meet (as closely as possible) the specification below. However, we
> can see the need for 2 additional machines in the not too distant future.
>
> Machine specs:
> - 8 core (two 3.0 GHz quad-core)
> - 16 GB memory
> - two 750GB 7200 - rpm SATA 3GB/s disks
> - DVD R/W (20x?)
> - rack mountable specification to work with ASF infra requirements
> - LOM or other features as necessary for ASF infra support
> - to be developer managed and maintained by the Apache Geronimo Team
> - Apache Geronimo would assume all responsibility for:
> - configuration
> - backup/recovery
> - secure access
> - Strictly limited to those Apache Geronimo committers with NDAs
> on file or additional Apache committers with NDAs and approved by
> Geronimo PMC.
> - full, admin access would be granted to ASF infra with reboot directions
> - At least 2 active Apache Geronimo committers (with NDA
> authorization) would identified to manage the machines.
> - Running Linux with something like Xen for 4 VM images per machine. We
> may increase the number of VM images if it is feasible.
> - We would require both ssh and VNC access to the VMs.
> - It is not yet decided if we would use NAT to access the VMs or
> public IP addresses. Is there are recommendation from ASF Infra?
> - Automation will most likely be added to run builds, execute tests, and
> produce reports.
> - Capability to manually run tests on demand would also be supported.
>
> Admin Volunteers:
> - Joe Bohn (PMC)
> - Jay McHugh (PMC)
> - Jason Warner
> - Matt Hogstrom (PMC)
> - Kevan Miller (PMC)
>
Re: [VOTE] ASF hosted machines for TCK Proposal
Posted by Viet Nguyen <vh...@gmail.com>.
+1
Viet
Re: [VOTE] ASF hosted machines for TCK Proposal
Posted by Davanum Srinivas <da...@gmail.com>.
-----BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE-----
Hash: SHA1
+1
Rick McGuire wrote:
| +1
|
| Joe Bohn wrote:
|> If we are to take this proposal forward to the ASF Infrastructure
|> team, they want assurance that the Geronimo PMC is behind the
|> recommendation and supports the intended use of the systems. I think
|> it also bodes well to demonstrate that the entire Geronimo community
|> stands behind the proposal, particularly since we will administer the
|> machines ourselves, - so I encourage all to vote.
|>
|>
|> [ ] +1 I agree with the need and support the proposal. Present it to
|> the ASF Infrastructure team.
|> [ ] 0 No opinion
|> [ ] -1 I don't see the need or disagree with the proposal. Do not
|> present this proposal to the ASF Infrastructure team.
|>
|> I'll plan on calling this vote on Friday (5/23) morning (9 AM EST).
|>
|>
|> PROPOSAL
|>
|> Rationale:
|> The Apache Geronimo community has a need to support the execution and
|> sharing of results from Sun certification tests (cts) which are
|> necessary gain JavaEE5 certification compliance. This information is
|> only available to those Geronimo committers that have signed the Sun
|> NDA and other Apache committers that have signed an NDA and gained
|> approval of the Apache Geronimo PMC. This has allowed other Apache
|> projects to test new products/releases by running JavaEE 5 TCK tests
|> using the Apache Geronimo test infrastructure.
|>
|> In the past these resource intensive tests have been run on private
|> machines by individuals. As more people become involved with Apache
|> Geronimo and related projects, it is becoming obvious that we need a
|> central system to run and share the results of these tests. A
|> centralized testing environment allows the Geronimo community to more
|> fully participate in the TCK process. Some committers don't have
|> access to the hardware resources needed to run the Java EE TCK tests
|> in a timely manner. Although some ad-hoc sharing of private machines
|> has occurred, this is not ideal from a community perspective.
|> Community controlled systems allow us to equitably share these resources.
|>
|> Request:
|> To fulfill this requirement, the Apache Geronimo PMC is requesting the
|> ASF infrastructure team to provide and host machines that can be used
|> for this purpose. Initially, we would like to request two (2)
|> machines that meet (as closely as possible) the specification below.
|> However, we can see the need for 2 additional machines in the not too
|> distant future.
|>
|> Machine specs:
|> - 8 core (two 3.0 GHz quad-core)
|> - 16 GB memory
|> - two 750GB 7200 - rpm SATA 3GB/s disks
|> - DVD R/W (20x?)
|> - rack mountable specification to work with ASF infra requirements
|> - LOM or other features as necessary for ASF infra support
|> - to be developer managed and maintained by the Apache Geronimo Team
|> - Apache Geronimo would assume all responsibility for:
|> - configuration
|> - backup/recovery
|> - secure access
|> - Strictly limited to those Apache Geronimo committers with
|> NDAs on file or additional Apache committers with NDAs and approved by
|> Geronimo PMC.
|> - full, admin access would be granted to ASF infra with reboot
|> directions
|> - At least 2 active Apache Geronimo committers (with NDA
|> authorization) would identified to manage the machines.
|> - Running Linux with something like Xen for 4 VM images per machine.
|> We may increase the number of VM images if it is feasible.
|> - We would require both ssh and VNC access to the VMs.
|> - It is not yet decided if we would use NAT to access the VMs or
|> public IP addresses. Is there are recommendation from ASF Infra?
|> - Automation will most likely be added to run builds, execute tests,
|> and produce reports.
|> - Capability to manually run tests on demand would also be supported.
|>
|> Admin Volunteers:
|> - Joe Bohn (PMC)
|> - Jay McHugh (PMC)
|> - Jason Warner
|> - Matt Hogstrom (PMC)
|> - Kevan Miller (PMC)
|>
|
-----BEGIN PGP SIGNATURE-----
Version: GnuPG v1.4.5 (Cygwin)
iD8DBQFIMsSwgNg6eWEDv1kRAn9BAJ9JfWeO87zqcgar6Fbf3lqHIbwbaQCg76xH
V7FYVtydEILZQEi1uAZKA+g=
=dIbP
-----END PGP SIGNATURE-----
Re: [VOTE] ASF hosted machines for TCK Proposal
Posted by Rick McGuire <ri...@gmail.com>.
+1
Joe Bohn wrote:
> If we are to take this proposal forward to the ASF Infrastructure
> team, they want assurance that the Geronimo PMC is behind the
> recommendation and supports the intended use of the systems. I think
> it also bodes well to demonstrate that the entire Geronimo community
> stands behind the proposal, particularly since we will administer the
> machines ourselves, - so I encourage all to vote.
>
>
> [ ] +1 I agree with the need and support the proposal. Present it to
> the ASF Infrastructure team.
> [ ] 0 No opinion
> [ ] -1 I don't see the need or disagree with the proposal. Do not
> present this proposal to the ASF Infrastructure team.
>
> I'll plan on calling this vote on Friday (5/23) morning (9 AM EST).
>
>
> PROPOSAL
>
> Rationale:
> The Apache Geronimo community has a need to support the execution and
> sharing of results from Sun certification tests (cts) which are
> necessary gain JavaEE5 certification compliance. This information is
> only available to those Geronimo committers that have signed the Sun
> NDA and other Apache committers that have signed an NDA and gained
> approval of the Apache Geronimo PMC. This has allowed other Apache
> projects to test new products/releases by running JavaEE 5 TCK tests
> using the Apache Geronimo test infrastructure.
>
> In the past these resource intensive tests have been run on private
> machines by individuals. As more people become involved with Apache
> Geronimo and related projects, it is becoming obvious that we need a
> central system to run and share the results of these tests. A
> centralized testing environment allows the Geronimo community to more
> fully participate in the TCK process. Some committers don't have
> access to the hardware resources needed to run the Java EE TCK tests
> in a timely manner. Although some ad-hoc sharing of private machines
> has occurred, this is not ideal from a community perspective.
> Community controlled systems allow us to equitably share these resources.
>
> Request:
> To fulfill this requirement, the Apache Geronimo PMC is requesting the
> ASF infrastructure team to provide and host machines that can be used
> for this purpose. Initially, we would like to request two (2)
> machines that meet (as closely as possible) the specification below.
> However, we can see the need for 2 additional machines in the not too
> distant future.
>
> Machine specs:
> - 8 core (two 3.0 GHz quad-core)
> - 16 GB memory
> - two 750GB 7200 - rpm SATA 3GB/s disks
> - DVD R/W (20x?)
> - rack mountable specification to work with ASF infra requirements
> - LOM or other features as necessary for ASF infra support
> - to be developer managed and maintained by the Apache Geronimo Team
> - Apache Geronimo would assume all responsibility for:
> - configuration
> - backup/recovery
> - secure access
> - Strictly limited to those Apache Geronimo committers with
> NDAs on file or additional Apache committers with NDAs and approved by
> Geronimo PMC.
> - full, admin access would be granted to ASF infra with reboot
> directions
> - At least 2 active Apache Geronimo committers (with NDA
> authorization) would identified to manage the machines.
> - Running Linux with something like Xen for 4 VM images per machine.
> We may increase the number of VM images if it is feasible.
> - We would require both ssh and VNC access to the VMs.
> - It is not yet decided if we would use NAT to access the VMs or
> public IP addresses. Is there are recommendation from ASF Infra?
> - Automation will most likely be added to run builds, execute tests,
> and produce reports.
> - Capability to manually run tests on demand would also be supported.
>
> Admin Volunteers:
> - Joe Bohn (PMC)
> - Jay McHugh (PMC)
> - Jason Warner
> - Matt Hogstrom (PMC)
> - Kevan Miller (PMC)
>
Re: [VOTE] ASF hosted machines for TCK Proposal
Posted by Jarek Gawor <jg...@gmail.com>.
+1
Jarek
On Tue, May 20, 2008 at 8:22 AM, Joe Bohn <jo...@earthlink.net> wrote:
> If we are to take this proposal forward to the ASF Infrastructure team, they
> want assurance that the Geronimo PMC is behind the recommendation and
> supports the intended use of the systems. I think it also bodes well to
> demonstrate that the entire Geronimo community stands behind the proposal,
> particularly since we will administer the machines ourselves, - so I
> encourage all to vote.
>
>
> [ ] +1 I agree with the need and support the proposal. Present it to the ASF
> Infrastructure team.
> [ ] 0 No opinion
> [ ] -1 I don't see the need or disagree with the proposal. Do not present
> this proposal to the ASF Infrastructure team.
>
> I'll plan on calling this vote on Friday (5/23) morning (9 AM EST).
>
>
> PROPOSAL
>
> Rationale:
> The Apache Geronimo community has a need to support the execution and
> sharing of results from Sun certification tests (cts) which are necessary
> gain JavaEE5 certification compliance. This information is only available
> to those Geronimo committers that have signed the Sun NDA and other Apache
> committers that have signed an NDA and gained approval of the Apache
> Geronimo PMC. This has allowed other Apache projects to test new
> products/releases by running JavaEE 5 TCK tests using the Apache Geronimo
> test infrastructure.
>
> In the past these resource intensive tests have been run on private machines
> by individuals. As more people become involved with Apache Geronimo and
> related projects, it is becoming obvious that we need a central system to
> run and share the results of these tests. A centralized testing environment
> allows the Geronimo community to more fully participate in the TCK process.
> Some committers don't have access to the hardware resources needed to run
> the Java EE TCK tests in a timely manner. Although some ad-hoc sharing of
> private machines has occurred, this is not ideal from a community
> perspective. Community controlled systems allow us to equitably share these
> resources.
>
> Request:
> To fulfill this requirement, the Apache Geronimo PMC is requesting the ASF
> infrastructure team to provide and host machines that can be used for this
> purpose. Initially, we would like to request two (2) machines that meet (as
> closely as possible) the specification below. However, we can see the need
> for 2 additional machines in the not too distant future.
>
> Machine specs:
> - 8 core (two 3.0 GHz quad-core)
> - 16 GB memory
> - two 750GB 7200 - rpm SATA 3GB/s disks
> - DVD R/W (20x?)
> - rack mountable specification to work with ASF infra requirements
> - LOM or other features as necessary for ASF infra support
> - to be developer managed and maintained by the Apache Geronimo Team
> - Apache Geronimo would assume all responsibility for:
> - configuration
> - backup/recovery
> - secure access
> - Strictly limited to those Apache Geronimo committers with NDAs on
> file or additional Apache committers with NDAs and approved by Geronimo PMC.
> - full, admin access would be granted to ASF infra with reboot directions
> - At least 2 active Apache Geronimo committers (with NDA authorization)
> would identified to manage the machines.
> - Running Linux with something like Xen for 4 VM images per machine. We may
> increase the number of VM images if it is feasible.
> - We would require both ssh and VNC access to the VMs.
> - It is not yet decided if we would use NAT to access the VMs or public IP
> addresses. Is there are recommendation from ASF Infra?
> - Automation will most likely be added to run builds, execute tests, and
> produce reports.
> - Capability to manually run tests on demand would also be supported.
>
> Admin Volunteers:
> - Joe Bohn (PMC)
> - Jay McHugh (PMC)
> - Jason Warner
> - Matt Hogstrom (PMC)
> - Kevan Miller (PMC)
>
Re: [VOTE] ASF hosted machines for TCK Proposal
Posted by "Erik B. Craig" <gi...@gmail.com>.
+1
On May 20, 2008, at 7:22 AM, Joe Bohn <jo...@earthlink.net> wrote:
> If we are to take this proposal forward to the ASF Infrastructure
> team, they want assurance that the Geronimo PMC is behind the
> recommendation and supports the intended use of the systems. I
> think it also bodes well to demonstrate that the entire Geronimo
> community stands behind the proposal, particularly since we will
> administer the machines ourselves, - so I encourage all to vote.
>
>
> [ ] +1 I agree with the need and support the proposal. Present it to
> the ASF Infrastructure team.
> [ ] 0 No opinion
> [ ] -1 I don't see the need or disagree with the proposal. Do not
> present this proposal to the ASF Infrastructure team.
>
> I'll plan on calling this vote on Friday (5/23) morning (9 AM EST).
>
>
> PROPOSAL
>
> Rationale:
> The Apache Geronimo community has a need to support the execution
> and sharing of results from Sun certification tests (cts) which are
> necessary gain JavaEE5 certification compliance. This information
> is only available to those Geronimo committers that have signed the
> Sun NDA and other Apache committers that have signed an NDA and
> gained approval of the Apache Geronimo PMC. This has allowed other
> Apache projects to test new products/releases by running JavaEE 5
> TCK tests using the Apache Geronimo test infrastructure.
>
> In the past these resource intensive tests have been run on private
> machines by individuals. As more people become involved with Apache
> Geronimo and related projects, it is becoming obvious that we need a
> central system to run and share the results of these tests. A
> centralized testing environment allows the Geronimo community to
> more fully participate in the TCK process. Some committers don't
> have access to the hardware resources needed to run the Java EE TCK
> tests in a timely manner. Although some ad-hoc sharing of private
> machines has occurred, this is not ideal from a community
> perspective. Community controlled systems allow us to equitably
> share these resources.
>
> Request:
> To fulfill this requirement, the Apache Geronimo PMC is requesting
> the ASF infrastructure team to provide and host machines that can be
> used for this purpose. Initially, we would like to request two (2)
> machines that meet (as closely as possible) the specification
> below. However, we can see the need for 2 additional machines in
> the not too distant future.
>
> Machine specs:
> - 8 core (two 3.0 GHz quad-core)
> - 16 GB memory
> - two 750GB 7200 - rpm SATA 3GB/s disks
> - DVD R/W (20x?)
> - rack mountable specification to work with ASF infra requirements
> - LOM or other features as necessary for ASF infra support
> - to be developer managed and maintained by the Apache Geronimo Team
> - Apache Geronimo would assume all responsibility for:
> - configuration
> - backup/recovery
> - secure access
> - Strictly limited to those Apache Geronimo committers with
> NDAs on file or additional Apache committers with NDAs and approved
> by Geronimo PMC.
> - full, admin access would be granted to ASF infra with reboot
> directions
> - At least 2 active Apache Geronimo committers (with NDA
> authorization) would identified to manage the machines.
> - Running Linux with something like Xen for 4 VM images per
> machine. We may increase the number of VM images if it is feasible.
> - We would require both ssh and VNC access to the VMs.
> - It is not yet decided if we would use NAT to access the VMs or
> public IP addresses. Is there are recommendation from ASF Infra?
> - Automation will most likely be added to run builds, execute tests,
> and produce reports.
> - Capability to manually run tests on demand would also be supported.
>
> Admin Volunteers:
> - Joe Bohn (PMC)
> - Jay McHugh (PMC)
> - Jason Warner
> - Matt Hogstrom (PMC)
> - Kevan Miller (PMC)
Re: [VOTE] ASF hosted machines for TCK Proposal
Posted by Dan Becker <da...@gmail.com>.
Joe Bohn wrote:
> [ ] +1 I agree with the need and support the proposal. Present it to the
> ASF Infrastructure team.
> [ ] 0 No opinion
> [ ] -1 I don't see the need or disagree with the proposal. Do not
> present this proposal to the ASF Infrastructure team.
+1
--
Thanks, Dan Becker
Re: [VOTE] ASF hosted machines for TCK Proposal
Posted by Jason Warner <ja...@apache.org>.
+1
On Tue, May 20, 2008 at 10:08 AM, David Jencks <da...@yahoo.com>
wrote:
> +1
> david jencks
>
>
> On May 20, 2008, at 8:22 AM, Joe Bohn wrote:
>
> If we are to take this proposal forward to the ASF Infrastructure team,
>> they want assurance that the Geronimo PMC is behind the recommendation and
>> supports the intended use of the systems. I think it also bodes well to
>> demonstrate that the entire Geronimo community stands behind the proposal,
>> particularly since we will administer the machines ourselves, - so I
>> encourage all to vote.
>>
>>
>> [ ] +1 I agree with the need and support the proposal. Present it to the
>> ASF Infrastructure team.
>> [ ] 0 No opinion
>> [ ] -1 I don't see the need or disagree with the proposal. Do not present
>> this proposal to the ASF Infrastructure team.
>>
>> I'll plan on calling this vote on Friday (5/23) morning (9 AM EST).
>>
>>
>> PROPOSAL
>>
>> Rationale:
>> The Apache Geronimo community has a need to support the execution and
>> sharing of results from Sun certification tests (cts) which are necessary
>> gain JavaEE5 certification compliance. This information is only available
>> to those Geronimo committers that have signed the Sun NDA and other Apache
>> committers that have signed an NDA and gained approval of the Apache
>> Geronimo PMC. This has allowed other Apache projects to test new
>> products/releases by running JavaEE 5 TCK tests using the Apache Geronimo
>> test infrastructure.
>>
>> In the past these resource intensive tests have been run on private
>> machines by individuals. As more people become involved with Apache
>> Geronimo and related projects, it is becoming obvious that we need a central
>> system to run and share the results of these tests. A centralized testing
>> environment allows the Geronimo community to more fully participate in the
>> TCK process. Some committers don't have access to the hardware resources
>> needed to run the Java EE TCK tests in a timely manner. Although some ad-hoc
>> sharing of private machines has occurred, this is not ideal from a community
>> perspective. Community controlled systems allow us to equitably share these
>> resources.
>>
>> Request:
>> To fulfill this requirement, the Apache Geronimo PMC is requesting the ASF
>> infrastructure team to provide and host machines that can be used for this
>> purpose. Initially, we would like to request two (2) machines that meet (as
>> closely as possible) the specification below. However, we can see the need
>> for 2 additional machines in the not too distant future.
>>
>> Machine specs:
>> - 8 core (two 3.0 GHz quad-core)
>> - 16 GB memory
>> - two 750GB 7200 - rpm SATA 3GB/s disks
>> - DVD R/W (20x?)
>> - rack mountable specification to work with ASF infra requirements
>> - LOM or other features as necessary for ASF infra support
>> - to be developer managed and maintained by the Apache Geronimo Team
>> - Apache Geronimo would assume all responsibility for:
>> - configuration
>> - backup/recovery
>> - secure access
>> - Strictly limited to those Apache Geronimo committers with NDAs on
>> file or additional Apache committers with NDAs and approved by Geronimo PMC.
>> - full, admin access would be granted to ASF infra with reboot directions
>> - At least 2 active Apache Geronimo committers (with NDA authorization)
>> would identified to manage the machines.
>> - Running Linux with something like Xen for 4 VM images per machine. We
>> may increase the number of VM images if it is feasible.
>> - We would require both ssh and VNC access to the VMs.
>> - It is not yet decided if we would use NAT to access the VMs or public
>> IP addresses. Is there are recommendation from ASF Infra?
>> - Automation will most likely be added to run builds, execute tests, and
>> produce reports.
>> - Capability to manually run tests on demand would also be supported.
>>
>> Admin Volunteers:
>> - Joe Bohn (PMC)
>> - Jay McHugh (PMC)
>> - Jason Warner
>> - Matt Hogstrom (PMC)
>> - Kevan Miller (PMC)
>>
>
>
--
~Jason Warner
Re: [VOTE] ASF hosted machines for TCK Proposal
Posted by David Jencks <da...@yahoo.com>.
+1
david jencks
On May 20, 2008, at 8:22 AM, Joe Bohn wrote:
> If we are to take this proposal forward to the ASF Infrastructure
> team, they want assurance that the Geronimo PMC is behind the
> recommendation and supports the intended use of the systems. I
> think it also bodes well to demonstrate that the entire Geronimo
> community stands behind the proposal, particularly since we will
> administer the machines ourselves, - so I encourage all to vote.
>
>
> [ ] +1 I agree with the need and support the proposal. Present it to
> the ASF Infrastructure team.
> [ ] 0 No opinion
> [ ] -1 I don't see the need or disagree with the proposal. Do not
> present this proposal to the ASF Infrastructure team.
>
> I'll plan on calling this vote on Friday (5/23) morning (9 AM EST).
>
>
> PROPOSAL
>
> Rationale:
> The Apache Geronimo community has a need to support the execution
> and sharing of results from Sun certification tests (cts) which are
> necessary gain JavaEE5 certification compliance. This information
> is only available to those Geronimo committers that have signed the
> Sun NDA and other Apache committers that have signed an NDA and
> gained approval of the Apache Geronimo PMC. This has allowed other
> Apache projects to test new products/releases by running JavaEE 5
> TCK tests using the Apache Geronimo test infrastructure.
>
> In the past these resource intensive tests have been run on private
> machines by individuals. As more people become involved with Apache
> Geronimo and related projects, it is becoming obvious that we need a
> central system to run and share the results of these tests. A
> centralized testing environment allows the Geronimo community to
> more fully participate in the TCK process. Some committers don't
> have access to the hardware resources needed to run the Java EE TCK
> tests in a timely manner. Although some ad-hoc sharing of private
> machines has occurred, this is not ideal from a community
> perspective. Community controlled systems allow us to equitably
> share these resources.
>
> Request:
> To fulfill this requirement, the Apache Geronimo PMC is requesting
> the ASF infrastructure team to provide and host machines that can be
> used for this purpose. Initially, we would like to request two (2)
> machines that meet (as closely as possible) the specification
> below. However, we can see the need for 2 additional machines in
> the not too distant future.
>
> Machine specs:
> - 8 core (two 3.0 GHz quad-core)
> - 16 GB memory
> - two 750GB 7200 - rpm SATA 3GB/s disks
> - DVD R/W (20x?)
> - rack mountable specification to work with ASF infra requirements
> - LOM or other features as necessary for ASF infra support
> - to be developer managed and maintained by the Apache Geronimo Team
> - Apache Geronimo would assume all responsibility for:
> - configuration
> - backup/recovery
> - secure access
> - Strictly limited to those Apache Geronimo committers with
> NDAs on file or additional Apache committers with NDAs and approved
> by Geronimo PMC.
> - full, admin access would be granted to ASF infra with reboot
> directions
> - At least 2 active Apache Geronimo committers (with NDA
> authorization) would identified to manage the machines.
> - Running Linux with something like Xen for 4 VM images per
> machine. We may increase the number of VM images if it is feasible.
> - We would require both ssh and VNC access to the VMs.
> - It is not yet decided if we would use NAT to access the VMs or
> public IP addresses. Is there are recommendation from ASF Infra?
> - Automation will most likely be added to run builds, execute tests,
> and produce reports.
> - Capability to manually run tests on demand would also be supported.
>
> Admin Volunteers:
> - Joe Bohn (PMC)
> - Jay McHugh (PMC)
> - Jason Warner
> - Matt Hogstrom (PMC)
> - Kevan Miller (PMC)
Re: [VOTE] ASF hosted machines for TCK Proposal
Posted by Joseph Leong <jo...@gmail.com>.
+1
On Tue, May 20, 2008 at 8:22 AM, Joe Bohn <jo...@earthlink.net> wrote:
> If we are to take this proposal forward to the ASF Infrastructure team,
> they want assurance that the Geronimo PMC is behind the recommendation and
> supports the intended use of the systems. I think it also bodes well to
> demonstrate that the entire Geronimo community stands behind the proposal,
> particularly since we will administer the machines ourselves, - so I
> encourage all to vote.
>
>
> [ ] +1 I agree with the need and support the proposal. Present it to the
> ASF Infrastructure team.
> [ ] 0 No opinion
> [ ] -1 I don't see the need or disagree with the proposal. Do not present
> this proposal to the ASF Infrastructure team.
>
> I'll plan on calling this vote on Friday (5/23) morning (9 AM EST).
>
>
> PROPOSAL
>
> Rationale:
> The Apache Geronimo community has a need to support the execution and
> sharing of results from Sun certification tests (cts) which are necessary
> gain JavaEE5 certification compliance. This information is only available
> to those Geronimo committers that have signed the Sun NDA and other Apache
> committers that have signed an NDA and gained approval of the Apache
> Geronimo PMC. This has allowed other Apache projects to test new
> products/releases by running JavaEE 5 TCK tests using the Apache Geronimo
> test infrastructure.
>
> In the past these resource intensive tests have been run on private
> machines by individuals. As more people become involved with Apache
> Geronimo and related projects, it is becoming obvious that we need a central
> system to run and share the results of these tests. A centralized testing
> environment allows the Geronimo community to more fully participate in the
> TCK process. Some committers don't have access to the hardware resources
> needed to run the Java EE TCK tests in a timely manner. Although some ad-hoc
> sharing of private machines has occurred, this is not ideal from a community
> perspective. Community controlled systems allow us to equitably share these
> resources.
>
> Request:
> To fulfill this requirement, the Apache Geronimo PMC is requesting the ASF
> infrastructure team to provide and host machines that can be used for this
> purpose. Initially, we would like to request two (2) machines that meet (as
> closely as possible) the specification below. However, we can see the need
> for 2 additional machines in the not too distant future.
>
> Machine specs:
> - 8 core (two 3.0 GHz quad-core)
> - 16 GB memory
> - two 750GB 7200 - rpm SATA 3GB/s disks
> - DVD R/W (20x?)
> - rack mountable specification to work with ASF infra requirements
> - LOM or other features as necessary for ASF infra support
> - to be developer managed and maintained by the Apache Geronimo Team
> - Apache Geronimo would assume all responsibility for:
> - configuration
> - backup/recovery
> - secure access
> - Strictly limited to those Apache Geronimo committers with NDAs on
> file or additional Apache committers with NDAs and approved by Geronimo PMC.
> - full, admin access would be granted to ASF infra with reboot directions
> - At least 2 active Apache Geronimo committers (with NDA authorization)
> would identified to manage the machines.
> - Running Linux with something like Xen for 4 VM images per machine. We
> may increase the number of VM images if it is feasible.
> - We would require both ssh and VNC access to the VMs.
> - It is not yet decided if we would use NAT to access the VMs or public IP
> addresses. Is there are recommendation from ASF Infra?
> - Automation will most likely be added to run builds, execute tests, and
> produce reports.
> - Capability to manually run tests on demand would also be supported.
>
> Admin Volunteers:
> - Joe Bohn (PMC)
> - Jay McHugh (PMC)
> - Jason Warner
> - Matt Hogstrom (PMC)
> - Kevan Miller (PMC)
>
Re: [VOTE] ASF hosted machines for TCK Proposal
Posted by Kevan Miller <ke...@gmail.com>.
+1
--kevan
On May 20, 2008, at 8:22 AM, Joe Bohn <jo...@earthlink.net> wrote:
> If we are to take this proposal forward to the ASF Infrastructure
> team, they want assurance that the Geronimo PMC is behind the
> recommendation and supports the intended use of the systems. I
> think it also bodes well to demonstrate that the entire Geronimo
> community stands behind the proposal, particularly since we will
> administer the machines ourselves, - so I encourage all to vote.
>
>
> [ ] +1 I agree with the need and support the proposal. Present it to
> the ASF Infrastructure team.
> [ ] 0 No opinion
> [ ] -1 I don't see the need or disagree with the proposal. Do not
> present this proposal to the ASF Infrastructure team.
>
> I'll plan on calling this vote on Friday (5/23) morning (9 AM EST).
>
>
> PROPOSAL
>
> Rationale:
> The Apache Geronimo community has a need to support the execution
> and sharing of results from Sun certification tests (cts) which are
> necessary gain JavaEE5 certification compliance. This information
> is only available to those Geronimo committers that have signed the
> Sun NDA and other Apache committers that have signed an NDA and
> gained approval of the Apache Geronimo PMC. This has allowed other
> Apache projects to test new products/releases by running JavaEE 5
> TCK tests using the Apache Geronimo test infrastructure.
>
> In the past these resource intensive tests have been run on private
> machines by individuals. As more people become involved with Apache
> Geronimo and related projects, it is becoming obvious that we need a
> central system to run and share the results of these tests. A
> centralized testing environment allows the Geronimo community to
> more fully participate in the TCK process. Some committers don't
> have access to the hardware resources needed to run the Java EE TCK
> tests in a timely manner. Although some ad-hoc sharing of private
> machines has occurred, this is not ideal from a community
> perspective. Community controlled systems allow us to equitably
> share these resources.
>
> Request:
> To fulfill this requirement, the Apache Geronimo PMC is requesting
> the ASF infrastructure team to provide and host machines that can be
> used for this purpose. Initially, we would like to request two (2)
> machines that meet (as closely as possible) the specification
> below. However, we can see the need for 2 additional machines in
> the not too distant future.
>
> Machine specs:
> - 8 core (two 3.0 GHz quad-core)
> - 16 GB memory
> - two 750GB 7200 - rpm SATA 3GB/s disks
> - DVD R/W (20x?)
> - rack mountable specification to work with ASF infra requirements
> - LOM or other features as necessary for ASF infra support
> - to be developer managed and maintained by the Apache Geronimo Team
> - Apache Geronimo would assume all responsibility for:
> - configuration
> - backup/recovery
> - secure access
> - Strictly limited to those Apache Geronimo committers with
> NDAs on file or additional Apache committers with NDAs and approved
> by Geronimo PMC.
> - full, admin access would be granted to ASF infra with reboot
> directions
> - At least 2 active Apache Geronimo committers (with NDA
> authorization) would identified to manage the machines.
> - Running Linux with something like Xen for 4 VM images per
> machine. We may increase the number of VM images if it is feasible.
> - We would require both ssh and VNC access to the VMs.
> - It is not yet decided if we would use NAT to access the VMs or
> public IP addresses. Is there are recommendation from ASF Infra?
> - Automation will most likely be added to run builds, execute tests,
> and produce reports.
> - Capability to manually run tests on demand would also be supported.
>
> Admin Volunteers:
> - Joe Bohn (PMC)
> - Jay McHugh (PMC)
> - Jason Warner
> - Matt Hogstrom (PMC)
> - Kevan Miller (PMC)
Re: [VOTE] ASF hosted machines for TCK Proposal
Posted by Donald Woods <dw...@apache.org>.
+1
-Donald
Joe Bohn wrote:
> If we are to take this proposal forward to the ASF Infrastructure team,
> they want assurance that the Geronimo PMC is behind the recommendation
> and supports the intended use of the systems. I think it also bodes
> well to demonstrate that the entire Geronimo community stands behind the
> proposal, particularly since we will administer the machines ourselves,
> - so I encourage all to vote.
>
>
> [ ] +1 I agree with the need and support the proposal. Present it to the
> ASF Infrastructure team.
> [ ] 0 No opinion
> [ ] -1 I don't see the need or disagree with the proposal. Do not
> present this proposal to the ASF Infrastructure team.
>
> I'll plan on calling this vote on Friday (5/23) morning (9 AM EST).
>
>
> PROPOSAL
>
> Rationale:
> The Apache Geronimo community has a need to support the execution and
> sharing of results from Sun certification tests (cts) which are
> necessary gain JavaEE5 certification compliance. This information is
> only available to those Geronimo committers that have signed the Sun NDA
> and other Apache committers that have signed an NDA and gained approval
> of the Apache Geronimo PMC. This has allowed other Apache projects to
> test new products/releases by running JavaEE 5 TCK tests using the
> Apache Geronimo test infrastructure.
>
> In the past these resource intensive tests have been run on private
> machines by individuals. As more people become involved with Apache
> Geronimo and related projects, it is becoming obvious that we need a
> central system to run and share the results of these tests. A
> centralized testing environment allows the Geronimo community to more
> fully participate in the TCK process. Some committers don't have access
> to the hardware resources needed to run the Java EE TCK tests in a
> timely manner. Although some ad-hoc sharing of private machines has
> occurred, this is not ideal from a community perspective. Community
> controlled systems allow us to equitably share these resources.
>
> Request:
> To fulfill this requirement, the Apache Geronimo PMC is requesting the
> ASF infrastructure team to provide and host machines that can be used
> for this purpose. Initially, we would like to request two (2) machines
> that meet (as closely as possible) the specification below. However, we
> can see the need for 2 additional machines in the not too distant future.
>
> Machine specs:
> - 8 core (two 3.0 GHz quad-core)
> - 16 GB memory
> - two 750GB 7200 - rpm SATA 3GB/s disks
> - DVD R/W (20x?)
> - rack mountable specification to work with ASF infra requirements
> - LOM or other features as necessary for ASF infra support
> - to be developer managed and maintained by the Apache Geronimo Team
> - Apache Geronimo would assume all responsibility for:
> - configuration
> - backup/recovery
> - secure access
> - Strictly limited to those Apache Geronimo committers with NDAs
> on file or additional Apache committers with NDAs and approved by
> Geronimo PMC.
> - full, admin access would be granted to ASF infra with reboot directions
> - At least 2 active Apache Geronimo committers (with NDA
> authorization) would identified to manage the machines.
> - Running Linux with something like Xen for 4 VM images per machine. We
> may increase the number of VM images if it is feasible.
> - We would require both ssh and VNC access to the VMs.
> - It is not yet decided if we would use NAT to access the VMs or
> public IP addresses. Is there are recommendation from ASF Infra?
> - Automation will most likely be added to run builds, execute tests, and
> produce reports.
> - Capability to manually run tests on demand would also be supported.
>
> Admin Volunteers:
> - Joe Bohn (PMC)
> - Jay McHugh (PMC)
> - Jason Warner
> - Matt Hogstrom (PMC)
> - Kevan Miller (PMC)
>
Re: [VOTE] ASF hosted machines for TCK Proposal - Final Results
Posted by Joe Bohn <jo...@earthlink.net>.
Ok ... here are the final results.
The vote passes with 17 votes (12 by PMC members).
I will forward this request on to the ASF Infrastructure team and
communicate back to the Geronimo team any "negotiation" that occurs as a
result.
Thank you all.
Joe
Joe Bohn wrote:
> If we are to take this proposal forward to the ASF Infrastructure team,
> they want assurance that the Geronimo PMC is behind the recommendation
> and supports the intended use of the systems. I think it also bodes
> well to demonstrate that the entire Geronimo community stands behind the
> proposal, particularly since we will administer the machines ourselves,
> - so I encourage all to vote.
>
>
> [ ] +1 I agree with the need and support the proposal. Present it to the
> ASF Infrastructure team.
> [ ] 0 No opinion
> [ ] -1 I don't see the need or disagree with the proposal. Do not
> present this proposal to the ASF Infrastructure team.
>
> I'll plan on calling this vote on Friday (5/23) morning (9 AM EST).
>
>
> PROPOSAL
>
> Rationale:
> The Apache Geronimo community has a need to support the execution and
> sharing of results from Sun certification tests (cts) which are
> necessary gain JavaEE5 certification compliance. This information is
> only available to those Geronimo committers that have signed the Sun NDA
> and other Apache committers that have signed an NDA and gained approval
> of the Apache Geronimo PMC. This has allowed other Apache projects to
> test new products/releases by running JavaEE 5 TCK tests using the
> Apache Geronimo test infrastructure.
>
> In the past these resource intensive tests have been run on private
> machines by individuals. As more people become involved with Apache
> Geronimo and related projects, it is becoming obvious that we need a
> central system to run and share the results of these tests. A
> centralized testing environment allows the Geronimo community to more
> fully participate in the TCK process. Some committers don't have access
> to the hardware resources needed to run the Java EE TCK tests in a
> timely manner. Although some ad-hoc sharing of private machines has
> occurred, this is not ideal from a community perspective. Community
> controlled systems allow us to equitably share these resources.
>
> Request:
> To fulfill this requirement, the Apache Geronimo PMC is requesting the
> ASF infrastructure team to provide and host machines that can be used
> for this purpose. Initially, we would like to request two (2) machines
> that meet (as closely as possible) the specification below. However, we
> can see the need for 2 additional machines in the not too distant future.
>
> Machine specs:
> - 8 core (two 3.0 GHz quad-core)
> - 16 GB memory
> - two 750GB 7200 - rpm SATA 3GB/s disks
> - DVD R/W (20x?)
> - rack mountable specification to work with ASF infra requirements
> - LOM or other features as necessary for ASF infra support
> - to be developer managed and maintained by the Apache Geronimo Team
> - Apache Geronimo would assume all responsibility for:
> - configuration
> - backup/recovery
> - secure access
> - Strictly limited to those Apache Geronimo committers with NDAs
> on file or additional Apache committers with NDAs and approved by
> Geronimo PMC.
> - full, admin access would be granted to ASF infra with reboot directions
> - At least 2 active Apache Geronimo committers (with NDA
> authorization) would identified to manage the machines.
> - Running Linux with something like Xen for 4 VM images per machine. We
> may increase the number of VM images if it is feasible.
> - We would require both ssh and VNC access to the VMs.
> - It is not yet decided if we would use NAT to access the VMs or
> public IP addresses. Is there are recommendation from ASF Infra?
> - Automation will most likely be added to run builds, execute tests, and
> produce reports.
> - Capability to manually run tests on demand would also be supported.
>
> Admin Volunteers:
> - Joe Bohn (PMC)
> - Jay McHugh (PMC)
> - Jason Warner
> - Matt Hogstrom (PMC)
> - Kevan Miller (PMC)
>
Re: [VOTE] ASF hosted machines for TCK Proposal
Posted by Gianny Damour <gi...@optusnet.com.au>.
+1
I hope that the ASF Infrastructure Team has a good idea of the type
of rather heavyweight testing involved by the TCK to warrant such a
configuration.
Thanks,
Gianny
On 20/05/2008, at 10:22 PM, Joe Bohn wrote:
> If we are to take this proposal forward to the ASF Infrastructure
> team, they want assurance that the Geronimo PMC is behind the
> recommendation and supports the intended use of the systems. I
> think it also bodes well to demonstrate that the entire Geronimo
> community stands behind the proposal, particularly since we will
> administer the machines ourselves, - so I encourage all to vote.
>
>
> [ ] +1 I agree with the need and support the proposal. Present it
> to the ASF Infrastructure team.
> [ ] 0 No opinion
> [ ] -1 I don't see the need or disagree with the proposal. Do not
> present this proposal to the ASF Infrastructure team.
>
> I'll plan on calling this vote on Friday (5/23) morning (9 AM EST).
>
>
> PROPOSAL
>
> Rationale:
> The Apache Geronimo community has a need to support the execution
> and sharing of results from Sun certification tests (cts) which are
> necessary gain JavaEE5 certification compliance. This information
> is only available to those Geronimo committers that have signed the
> Sun NDA and other Apache committers that have signed an NDA and
> gained approval of the Apache Geronimo PMC. This has allowed other
> Apache projects to test new products/releases by running JavaEE 5
> TCK tests using the Apache Geronimo test infrastructure.
>
> In the past these resource intensive tests have been run on private
> machines by individuals. As more people become involved with
> Apache Geronimo and related projects, it is becoming obvious that
> we need a central system to run and share the results of these
> tests. A centralized testing environment allows the Geronimo
> community to more fully participate in the TCK process. Some
> committers don't have access to the hardware resources needed to
> run the Java EE TCK tests in a timely manner. Although some ad-hoc
> sharing of private machines has occurred, this is not ideal from a
> community perspective. Community controlled systems allow us to
> equitably share these resources.
>
> Request:
> To fulfill this requirement, the Apache Geronimo PMC is requesting
> the ASF infrastructure team to provide and host machines that can
> be used for this purpose. Initially, we would like to request two
> (2) machines that meet (as closely as possible) the specification
> below. However, we can see the need for 2 additional machines in
> the not too distant future.
>
> Machine specs:
> - 8 core (two 3.0 GHz quad-core)
> - 16 GB memory
> - two 750GB 7200 - rpm SATA 3GB/s disks
> - DVD R/W (20x?)
> - rack mountable specification to work with ASF infra requirements
> - LOM or other features as necessary for ASF infra support
> - to be developer managed and maintained by the Apache Geronimo Team
> - Apache Geronimo would assume all responsibility for:
> - configuration
> - backup/recovery
> - secure access
> - Strictly limited to those Apache Geronimo committers with
> NDAs on file or additional Apache committers with NDAs and approved
> by Geronimo PMC.
> - full, admin access would be granted to ASF infra with reboot
> directions
> - At least 2 active Apache Geronimo committers (with NDA
> authorization) would identified to manage the machines.
> - Running Linux with something like Xen for 4 VM images per
> machine. We may increase the number of VM images if it is feasible.
> - We would require both ssh and VNC access to the VMs.
> - It is not yet decided if we would use NAT to access the VMs or
> public IP addresses. Is there are recommendation from ASF Infra?
> - Automation will most likely be added to run builds, execute
> tests, and produce reports.
> - Capability to manually run tests on demand would also be supported.
>
> Admin Volunteers:
> - Joe Bohn (PMC)
> - Jay McHugh (PMC)
> - Jason Warner
> - Matt Hogstrom (PMC)
> - Kevan Miller (PMC)
Re: [VOTE] ASF hosted machines for TCK Proposal
Posted by Jason Dillon <ja...@planet57.com>.
+1
--jason
On May 20, 2008, at 7:22 PM, Joe Bohn wrote:
> If we are to take this proposal forward to the ASF Infrastructure
> team, they want assurance that the Geronimo PMC is behind the
> recommendation and supports the intended use of the systems. I
> think it also bodes well to demonstrate that the entire Geronimo
> community stands behind the proposal, particularly since we will
> administer the machines ourselves, - so I encourage all to vote.
>
>
> [ ] +1 I agree with the need and support the proposal. Present it to
> the ASF Infrastructure team.
> [ ] 0 No opinion
> [ ] -1 I don't see the need or disagree with the proposal. Do not
> present this proposal to the ASF Infrastructure team.
>
> I'll plan on calling this vote on Friday (5/23) morning (9 AM EST).
>
>
> PROPOSAL
>
> Rationale:
> The Apache Geronimo community has a need to support the execution
> and sharing of results from Sun certification tests (cts) which are
> necessary gain JavaEE5 certification compliance. This information
> is only available to those Geronimo committers that have signed the
> Sun NDA and other Apache committers that have signed an NDA and
> gained approval of the Apache Geronimo PMC. This has allowed other
> Apache projects to test new products/releases by running JavaEE 5
> TCK tests using the Apache Geronimo test infrastructure.
>
> In the past these resource intensive tests have been run on private
> machines by individuals. As more people become involved with Apache
> Geronimo and related projects, it is becoming obvious that we need a
> central system to run and share the results of these tests. A
> centralized testing environment allows the Geronimo community to
> more fully participate in the TCK process. Some committers don't
> have access to the hardware resources needed to run the Java EE TCK
> tests in a timely manner. Although some ad-hoc sharing of private
> machines has occurred, this is not ideal from a community
> perspective. Community controlled systems allow us to equitably
> share these resources.
>
> Request:
> To fulfill this requirement, the Apache Geronimo PMC is requesting
> the ASF infrastructure team to provide and host machines that can be
> used for this purpose. Initially, we would like to request two (2)
> machines that meet (as closely as possible) the specification
> below. However, we can see the need for 2 additional machines in
> the not too distant future.
>
> Machine specs:
> - 8 core (two 3.0 GHz quad-core)
> - 16 GB memory
> - two 750GB 7200 - rpm SATA 3GB/s disks
> - DVD R/W (20x?)
> - rack mountable specification to work with ASF infra requirements
> - LOM or other features as necessary for ASF infra support
> - to be developer managed and maintained by the Apache Geronimo Team
> - Apache Geronimo would assume all responsibility for:
> - configuration
> - backup/recovery
> - secure access
> - Strictly limited to those Apache Geronimo committers with
> NDAs on file or additional Apache committers with NDAs and approved
> by Geronimo PMC.
> - full, admin access would be granted to ASF infra with reboot
> directions
> - At least 2 active Apache Geronimo committers (with NDA
> authorization) would identified to manage the machines.
> - Running Linux with something like Xen for 4 VM images per
> machine. We may increase the number of VM images if it is feasible.
> - We would require both ssh and VNC access to the VMs.
> - It is not yet decided if we would use NAT to access the VMs or
> public IP addresses. Is there are recommendation from ASF Infra?
> - Automation will most likely be added to run builds, execute tests,
> and produce reports.
> - Capability to manually run tests on demand would also be supported.
>
> Admin Volunteers:
> - Joe Bohn (PMC)
> - Jay McHugh (PMC)
> - Jason Warner
> - Matt Hogstrom (PMC)
> - Kevan Miller (PMC)
Re: [VOTE] ASF hosted machines for TCK Proposal
Posted by Hernan Cunico <hc...@gmail.com>.
+1
Cheers!
Hernan
Joe Bohn wrote:
> If we are to take this proposal forward to the ASF Infrastructure team,
> they want assurance that the Geronimo PMC is behind the recommendation
> and supports the intended use of the systems. I think it also bodes
> well to demonstrate that the entire Geronimo community stands behind the
> proposal, particularly since we will administer the machines ourselves,
> - so I encourage all to vote.
>
>
> [ ] +1 I agree with the need and support the proposal. Present it to the
> ASF Infrastructure team.
> [ ] 0 No opinion
> [ ] -1 I don't see the need or disagree with the proposal. Do not
> present this proposal to the ASF Infrastructure team.
>
> I'll plan on calling this vote on Friday (5/23) morning (9 AM EST).
>
>
> PROPOSAL
>
> Rationale:
> The Apache Geronimo community has a need to support the execution and
> sharing of results from Sun certification tests (cts) which are
> necessary gain JavaEE5 certification compliance. This information is
> only available to those Geronimo committers that have signed the Sun NDA
> and other Apache committers that have signed an NDA and gained approval
> of the Apache Geronimo PMC. This has allowed other Apache projects to
> test new products/releases by running JavaEE 5 TCK tests using the
> Apache Geronimo test infrastructure.
>
> In the past these resource intensive tests have been run on private
> machines by individuals. As more people become involved with Apache
> Geronimo and related projects, it is becoming obvious that we need a
> central system to run and share the results of these tests. A
> centralized testing environment allows the Geronimo community to more
> fully participate in the TCK process. Some committers don't have access
> to the hardware resources needed to run the Java EE TCK tests in a
> timely manner. Although some ad-hoc sharing of private machines has
> occurred, this is not ideal from a community perspective. Community
> controlled systems allow us to equitably share these resources.
>
> Request:
> To fulfill this requirement, the Apache Geronimo PMC is requesting the
> ASF infrastructure team to provide and host machines that can be used
> for this purpose. Initially, we would like to request two (2) machines
> that meet (as closely as possible) the specification below. However, we
> can see the need for 2 additional machines in the not too distant future.
>
> Machine specs:
> - 8 core (two 3.0 GHz quad-core)
> - 16 GB memory
> - two 750GB 7200 - rpm SATA 3GB/s disks
> - DVD R/W (20x?)
> - rack mountable specification to work with ASF infra requirements
> - LOM or other features as necessary for ASF infra support
> - to be developer managed and maintained by the Apache Geronimo Team
> - Apache Geronimo would assume all responsibility for:
> - configuration
> - backup/recovery
> - secure access
> - Strictly limited to those Apache Geronimo committers with NDAs
> on file or additional Apache committers with NDAs and approved by
> Geronimo PMC.
> - full, admin access would be granted to ASF infra with reboot directions
> - At least 2 active Apache Geronimo committers (with NDA
> authorization) would identified to manage the machines.
> - Running Linux with something like Xen for 4 VM images per machine. We
> may increase the number of VM images if it is feasible.
> - We would require both ssh and VNC access to the VMs.
> - It is not yet decided if we would use NAT to access the VMs or
> public IP addresses. Is there are recommendation from ASF Infra?
> - Automation will most likely be added to run builds, execute tests, and
> produce reports.
> - Capability to manually run tests on demand would also be supported.
>
> Admin Volunteers:
> - Joe Bohn (PMC)
> - Jay McHugh (PMC)
> - Jason Warner
> - Matt Hogstrom (PMC)
> - Kevan Miller (PMC)
>
Re: [VOTE] ASF hosted machines for TCK Proposal
Posted by David Blevins <da...@visi.com>.
+1
David
On May 20, 2008, at 5:22 AM, Joe Bohn wrote:
> If we are to take this proposal forward to the ASF Infrastructure
> team, they want assurance that the Geronimo PMC is behind the
> recommendation and supports the intended use of the systems. I
> think it also bodes well to demonstrate that the entire Geronimo
> community stands behind the proposal, particularly since we will
> administer the machines ourselves, - so I encourage all to vote.
>
>
> [ ] +1 I agree with the need and support the proposal. Present it to
> the ASF Infrastructure team.
> [ ] 0 No opinion
> [ ] -1 I don't see the need or disagree with the proposal. Do not
> present this proposal to the ASF Infrastructure team.
>
> I'll plan on calling this vote on Friday (5/23) morning (9 AM EST).
>
>
> PROPOSAL
>
> Rationale:
> The Apache Geronimo community has a need to support the execution
> and sharing of results from Sun certification tests (cts) which are
> necessary gain JavaEE5 certification compliance. This information
> is only available to those Geronimo committers that have signed the
> Sun NDA and other Apache committers that have signed an NDA and
> gained approval of the Apache Geronimo PMC. This has allowed other
> Apache projects to test new products/releases by running JavaEE 5
> TCK tests using the Apache Geronimo test infrastructure.
>
> In the past these resource intensive tests have been run on private
> machines by individuals. As more people become involved with Apache
> Geronimo and related projects, it is becoming obvious that we need a
> central system to run and share the results of these tests. A
> centralized testing environment allows the Geronimo community to
> more fully participate in the TCK process. Some committers don't
> have access to the hardware resources needed to run the Java EE TCK
> tests in a timely manner. Although some ad-hoc sharing of private
> machines has occurred, this is not ideal from a community
> perspective. Community controlled systems allow us to equitably
> share these resources.
>
> Request:
> To fulfill this requirement, the Apache Geronimo PMC is requesting
> the ASF infrastructure team to provide and host machines that can be
> used for this purpose. Initially, we would like to request two (2)
> machines that meet (as closely as possible) the specification
> below. However, we can see the need for 2 additional machines in
> the not too distant future.
>
> Machine specs:
> - 8 core (two 3.0 GHz quad-core)
> - 16 GB memory
> - two 750GB 7200 - rpm SATA 3GB/s disks
> - DVD R/W (20x?)
> - rack mountable specification to work with ASF infra requirements
> - LOM or other features as necessary for ASF infra support
> - to be developer managed and maintained by the Apache Geronimo Team
> - Apache Geronimo would assume all responsibility for:
> - configuration
> - backup/recovery
> - secure access
> - Strictly limited to those Apache Geronimo committers with
> NDAs on file or additional Apache committers with NDAs and approved
> by Geronimo PMC.
> - full, admin access would be granted to ASF infra with reboot
> directions
> - At least 2 active Apache Geronimo committers (with NDA
> authorization) would identified to manage the machines.
> - Running Linux with something like Xen for 4 VM images per
> machine. We may increase the number of VM images if it is feasible.
> - We would require both ssh and VNC access to the VMs.
> - It is not yet decided if we would use NAT to access the VMs or
> public IP addresses. Is there are recommendation from ASF Infra?
> - Automation will most likely be added to run builds, execute tests,
> and produce reports.
> - Capability to manually run tests on demand would also be supported.
>
> Admin Volunteers:
> - Joe Bohn (PMC)
> - Jay McHugh (PMC)
> - Jason Warner
> - Matt Hogstrom (PMC)
> - Kevan Miller (PMC)
>
Re: [VOTE] ASF hosted machines for TCK Proposal - RESULTS
Posted by Joe Bohn <jo...@earthlink.net>.
Hmmm .. just realized that I said I would call the vote on Friday rather
than Thursday. So, the vote is still open in case you still want to
chime in.
Sorry for the premature call of the vote.
Joe
Joe Bohn wrote:
> The vote passes with 17 votes (12 by PMC members).
>
>
> I will forward this request on to the ASF Infrastructure team and
> communicate back to the Geronimo team any "negotiation" that occurs as a
> result.
>
> Thank you all.
> Joe
>
>
>
>
> Joe Bohn wrote:
>> If we are to take this proposal forward to the ASF Infrastructure
>> team, they want assurance that the Geronimo PMC is behind the
>> recommendation and supports the intended use of the systems. I think
>> it also bodes well to demonstrate that the entire Geronimo community
>> stands behind the proposal, particularly since we will administer the
>> machines ourselves, - so I encourage all to vote.
>>
>>
>> [ ] +1 I agree with the need and support the proposal. Present it to
>> the ASF Infrastructure team.
>> [ ] 0 No opinion
>> [ ] -1 I don't see the need or disagree with the proposal. Do not
>> present this proposal to the ASF Infrastructure team.
>>
>> I'll plan on calling this vote on Friday (5/23) morning (9 AM EST).
>>
>>
>> PROPOSAL
>>
>> Rationale:
>> The Apache Geronimo community has a need to support the execution and
>> sharing of results from Sun certification tests (cts) which are
>> necessary gain JavaEE5 certification compliance. This information is
>> only available to those Geronimo committers that have signed the Sun
>> NDA and other Apache committers that have signed an NDA and gained
>> approval of the Apache Geronimo PMC. This has allowed other Apache
>> projects to test new products/releases by running JavaEE 5 TCK tests
>> using the Apache Geronimo test infrastructure.
>>
>> In the past these resource intensive tests have been run on private
>> machines by individuals. As more people become involved with Apache
>> Geronimo and related projects, it is becoming obvious that we need a
>> central system to run and share the results of these tests. A
>> centralized testing environment allows the Geronimo community to more
>> fully participate in the TCK process. Some committers don't have
>> access to the hardware resources needed to run the Java EE TCK tests
>> in a timely manner. Although some ad-hoc sharing of private machines
>> has occurred, this is not ideal from a community perspective.
>> Community controlled systems allow us to equitably share these resources.
>>
>> Request:
>> To fulfill this requirement, the Apache Geronimo PMC is requesting the
>> ASF infrastructure team to provide and host machines that can be used
>> for this purpose. Initially, we would like to request two (2)
>> machines that meet (as closely as possible) the specification below.
>> However, we can see the need for 2 additional machines in the not too
>> distant future.
>>
>> Machine specs:
>> - 8 core (two 3.0 GHz quad-core)
>> - 16 GB memory
>> - two 750GB 7200 - rpm SATA 3GB/s disks
>> - DVD R/W (20x?)
>> - rack mountable specification to work with ASF infra requirements
>> - LOM or other features as necessary for ASF infra support
>> - to be developer managed and maintained by the Apache Geronimo Team
>> - Apache Geronimo would assume all responsibility for:
>> - configuration
>> - backup/recovery
>> - secure access
>> - Strictly limited to those Apache Geronimo committers with
>> NDAs on file or additional Apache committers with NDAs and approved by
>> Geronimo PMC.
>> - full, admin access would be granted to ASF infra with reboot
>> directions
>> - At least 2 active Apache Geronimo committers (with NDA
>> authorization) would identified to manage the machines.
>> - Running Linux with something like Xen for 4 VM images per machine.
>> We may increase the number of VM images if it is feasible.
>> - We would require both ssh and VNC access to the VMs.
>> - It is not yet decided if we would use NAT to access the VMs or
>> public IP addresses. Is there are recommendation from ASF Infra?
>> - Automation will most likely be added to run builds, execute tests,
>> and produce reports.
>> - Capability to manually run tests on demand would also be supported.
>>
>> Admin Volunteers:
>> - Joe Bohn (PMC)
>> - Jay McHugh (PMC)
>> - Jason Warner
>> - Matt Hogstrom (PMC)
>> - Kevan Miller (PMC)
>>
>
>
Re: [VOTE] ASF hosted machines for TCK Proposal - RESULTS
Posted by Joe Bohn <jo...@earthlink.net>.
The vote passes with 17 votes (12 by PMC members).
I will forward this request on to the ASF Infrastructure team and
communicate back to the Geronimo team any "negotiation" that occurs as a
result.
Thank you all.
Joe
Joe Bohn wrote:
> If we are to take this proposal forward to the ASF Infrastructure team,
> they want assurance that the Geronimo PMC is behind the recommendation
> and supports the intended use of the systems. I think it also bodes
> well to demonstrate that the entire Geronimo community stands behind the
> proposal, particularly since we will administer the machines ourselves,
> - so I encourage all to vote.
>
>
> [ ] +1 I agree with the need and support the proposal. Present it to the
> ASF Infrastructure team.
> [ ] 0 No opinion
> [ ] -1 I don't see the need or disagree with the proposal. Do not
> present this proposal to the ASF Infrastructure team.
>
> I'll plan on calling this vote on Friday (5/23) morning (9 AM EST).
>
>
> PROPOSAL
>
> Rationale:
> The Apache Geronimo community has a need to support the execution and
> sharing of results from Sun certification tests (cts) which are
> necessary gain JavaEE5 certification compliance. This information is
> only available to those Geronimo committers that have signed the Sun NDA
> and other Apache committers that have signed an NDA and gained approval
> of the Apache Geronimo PMC. This has allowed other Apache projects to
> test new products/releases by running JavaEE 5 TCK tests using the
> Apache Geronimo test infrastructure.
>
> In the past these resource intensive tests have been run on private
> machines by individuals. As more people become involved with Apache
> Geronimo and related projects, it is becoming obvious that we need a
> central system to run and share the results of these tests. A
> centralized testing environment allows the Geronimo community to more
> fully participate in the TCK process. Some committers don't have access
> to the hardware resources needed to run the Java EE TCK tests in a
> timely manner. Although some ad-hoc sharing of private machines has
> occurred, this is not ideal from a community perspective. Community
> controlled systems allow us to equitably share these resources.
>
> Request:
> To fulfill this requirement, the Apache Geronimo PMC is requesting the
> ASF infrastructure team to provide and host machines that can be used
> for this purpose. Initially, we would like to request two (2) machines
> that meet (as closely as possible) the specification below. However, we
> can see the need for 2 additional machines in the not too distant future.
>
> Machine specs:
> - 8 core (two 3.0 GHz quad-core)
> - 16 GB memory
> - two 750GB 7200 - rpm SATA 3GB/s disks
> - DVD R/W (20x?)
> - rack mountable specification to work with ASF infra requirements
> - LOM or other features as necessary for ASF infra support
> - to be developer managed and maintained by the Apache Geronimo Team
> - Apache Geronimo would assume all responsibility for:
> - configuration
> - backup/recovery
> - secure access
> - Strictly limited to those Apache Geronimo committers with NDAs
> on file or additional Apache committers with NDAs and approved by
> Geronimo PMC.
> - full, admin access would be granted to ASF infra with reboot directions
> - At least 2 active Apache Geronimo committers (with NDA
> authorization) would identified to manage the machines.
> - Running Linux with something like Xen for 4 VM images per machine. We
> may increase the number of VM images if it is feasible.
> - We would require both ssh and VNC access to the VMs.
> - It is not yet decided if we would use NAT to access the VMs or
> public IP addresses. Is there are recommendation from ASF Infra?
> - Automation will most likely be added to run builds, execute tests, and
> produce reports.
> - Capability to manually run tests on demand would also be supported.
>
> Admin Volunteers:
> - Joe Bohn (PMC)
> - Jay McHugh (PMC)
> - Jason Warner
> - Matt Hogstrom (PMC)
> - Kevan Miller (PMC)
>