You are viewing a plain text version of this content. The canonical link for it is here.
Posted to xindice-dev@xml.apache.org by Gianugo Rabellino <gi...@apache.org> on 2002/12/20 12:55:35 UTC

Modified jars

With my previous commit we have now three libraries that arent in sync 
with their official implementation: xmldb-api, xmldb-commons and 
xmldb-xupdate. I see two problems here:

1. source code for the modifications right now sits on Vladimir's PC and 
on mine. This is no good: how about storing at least the diffs somewhere 
in the repository?

2. we have three non-official versions of the jars, but since it looks 
like the XML:DB group is quite reluctant to accept any changes, we are 
pretty stuck. I'd suggest then to at least mark them as "patched", 
changing their name to xmldb-api.PATCHED.jar, xmldb-xupdate.PATCHED.jar 
and so on (of course any other naming scheme would do). How about it?

Ciao,

-- 
Gianugo


Re: Modified jars

Posted by "Vladimir R. Bossicard" <vl...@apache.org>.
> I do not think there is any reluctancy to change in the XML:DB group. My feel 
> is that the commiters are very busy with other stuff and as a result 
> sometimes issues gets lost.

That's also my impression.  I think that Lars agreed to introduce a new 
method 'public String[] getName()' and deprecate 'public String 
getName()' but the code of yesterday doesn't contain this modification.

> alternatively find a solution that works for everyone...

I think that the best solution is simply for xmldb to support 
xalan-2.4.1 and make the tests pass (some tests fail with a fresh 
checkout of xmldb).

Do you have some time over the week-end to fix this (I'll try to find 
some time to help, too)

-Vladimir

-- 
Vladimir R. Bossicard
Apache Xindice - http://xml.apache.org/xindice


Re: Modified jars

Posted by Per Nyfelt <pe...@nordicwave.com>.
On Friday 20 December 2002 12.55, Gianugo Rabellino wrote:
> With my previous commit we have now three libraries that arent in sync
> with their official implementation: xmldb-api, xmldb-commons and
> xmldb-xupdate. I see two problems here:
>
> 1. source code for the modifications right now sits on Vladimir's PC and
> on mine. This is no good: how about storing at least the diffs somewhere
> in the repository?
>
> 2. we have three non-official versions of the jars, but since it looks
> like the XML:DB group is quite reluctant to accept any changes, we are
> pretty stuck. I'd suggest then to at least mark them as "patched",
> changing their name to xmldb-api.PATCHED.jar, xmldb-xupdate.PATCHED.jar
> and so on (of course any other naming scheme would do). How about it?

Hi Gianugo,

I do not think there is any reluctancy to change in the XML:DB group. My feel 
is that the commiters are very busy with other stuff and as a result 
sometimes issues gets lost. My harddrive crached a couple of weeks ago and I 
lost all mails so I do not know what was agreed upon regarding this issue but 
I seem to recall Lars was doing something about it. Anyhow, please bring it 
up on the XMl:DB list again and I'l do what I can to put your pathces in or 
alternatively find a solution that works for everyone...

Best regards,
Per

>
> Ciao,


Re: Modified jars

Posted by "Vladimir R. Bossicard" <vl...@apache.org>.
> With my previous commit we have now three libraries that arent in sync 
> with their official implementation: xmldb-api, xmldb-commons and 
> xmldb-xupdate.

[...]

the right thing to do IMO.

-Vladimir

-- 
Vladimir R. Bossicard
Apache Xindice - http://xml.apache.org/xindice