You are viewing a plain text version of this content. The canonical link for it is here.
Posted to dev@httpd.apache.org by Randy Terbush <ra...@zyzzyva.com> on 1997/06/19 00:46:08 UTC

[PATCH] a different approach to setuid scripts

He has chosen the path of setting effective UIDs, which was 
originally not acceptable. My feelings haven't changed much in that 
regard. Would someone else like to comment?

------- Forwarded Message

To: Randy Terbush <ra...@zyzzyva.com>
Subject: Re: Possible security hole in suEXEC 
In-Reply-To: Your message of "Wed, 18 Jun 1997 16:54:17 CDT."
             <19...@sierra.zyzzyva.com> 
Date: Wed, 18 Jun 1997 18:19:29 EDT
From: Monty <xi...@MIT.EDU>


No problem.

Monty

::::: Included File :::::

diff -wPrc apache_1.2b10/src/Configuration apache_1.2b10monty/src/Configuration
*** apache_1.2b10/src/Configuration	Mon Apr 28 22:11:16 1997
- --- apache_1.2b10monty/src/Configuration	Wed Jun 18 15:06:17 1997
***************
*** 41,47 ****
  # Settings here have priority; If not set, Configure will attempt to guess
  # the C compiler, and set OPTIM to '-O2'
  #
! EXTRA_CFLAGS=
  EXTRA_LFLAGS=
  EXTRA_LIBS=
  EXTRA_INCLUDES=
- --- 41,47 ----
  # Settings here have priority; If not set, Configure will attempt to guess
  # the C compiler, and set OPTIM to '-O2'
  #
! EXTRA_CFLAGS=	-DSERVER_SUBVERSION="\"Monty-ScriptUser/1.0-alpha\""
  EXTRA_LFLAGS=
  EXTRA_LIBS=
  EXTRA_INCLUDES=
diff -wPrc apache_1.2b10/src/alloc.c apache_1.2b10monty/src/alloc.c
*** apache_1.2b10/src/alloc.c	Thu Apr 24 16:35:18 1997
- --- apache_1.2b10monty/src/alloc.c	Wed Jun 18 13:16:05 1997
***************
*** 764,770 ****
      cleanup_pool_for_exec (p);
  }
  
! void cleanup_for_exec()
  {
    block_alarms();
    cleanup_pool_for_exec (permanent_pool);
- --- 764,770 ----
      cleanup_pool_for_exec (p);
  }
  
! void alloc_cleanup_for_exec()
  {
    block_alarms();
    cleanup_pool_for_exec (permanent_pool);
diff -wPrc apache_1.2b10/src/alloc.h apache_1.2b10monty/src/alloc.h
*** apache_1.2b10/src/alloc.h	Thu Apr 24 16:35:19 1997
- --- apache_1.2b10monty/src/alloc.h	Wed Jun 18 13:19:06 1997
***************
*** 87,93 ****
   * buffers, *don't* wait for subprocesses, and *don't* free any memory.
   */
  
! void cleanup_for_exec ();
  
  /* routines to allocate memory from an pool... */
  
- --- 87,93 ----
   * buffers, *don't* wait for subprocesses, and *don't* free any memory.
   */
  
! void alloc_cleanup_for_exec ();
  
  /* routines to allocate memory from an pool... */
  
diff -wPrc apache_1.2b10/src/http_main.c apache_1.2b10monty/src/http_main.c
*** apache_1.2b10/src/http_main.c	Mon Apr 28 19:39:01 1997
- --- apache_1.2b10monty/src/http_main.c	Tue Jun 17 00:10:52 1997
***************
*** 1430,1437 ****
  	exit (1);
      }
  #endif
!     if (setgid(group_id) == -1) {
! 	log_unixerr("setgid", NULL, "unable to set group id", server_conf);
  	exit (1);
      }
  #endif 
- --- 1430,1437 ----
  	exit (1);
      }
  #endif
!     if (setegid(group_id) == -1) {
! 	log_unixerr("setegid", NULL, "unable to set group id", server_conf);
  	exit (1);
      }
  #endif 
***************
*** 1670,1682 ****
      /* Only try to switch if we're running as MANAGER.SYS */
      if (geteuid() == 1 && user_id > 1) {
          GETPRIVMODE();
!         if (setuid(user_id) == -1) {
              GETUSERMODE();
  #else
      /* Only try to switch if we're running as root */
!     if (!geteuid() && setuid(user_id) == -1) {
  #endif
!         log_unixerr("setuid", NULL, "unable to change uid", server_conf);
  	exit (1);
      }
  #ifdef MPE
- --- 1670,1682 ----
      /* Only try to switch if we're running as MANAGER.SYS */
      if (geteuid() == 1 && user_id > 1) {
          GETPRIVMODE();
!         if (seteuid(user_id) == -1) {
              GETUSERMODE();
  #else
      /* Only try to switch if we're running as root */
!     if (!geteuid() && seteuid(user_id) == -1) {
  #endif
!         log_unixerr("seteuid", NULL, "unable to change euid", server_conf);
  	exit (1);
      }
  #ifdef MPE
***************
*** 2409,2421 ****
        /* Only try to switch if we're running as MANAGER.SYS */
        if (geteuid() == 1 && user_id > 1) {
            GETPRIVMODE();
!           if (setuid(user_id) == -1) {
                GETUSERMODE();
  #else
        /* Only try to switch if we're running as root */
!       if(!geteuid() && setuid(user_id) == -1) {
  #endif
!           log_unixerr("setuid", NULL, "unable to change uid", server_conf);
            exit (1);
        }
  #ifdef MPE
- --- 2409,2421 ----
        /* Only try to switch if we're running as MANAGER.SYS */
        if (geteuid() == 1 && user_id > 1) {
            GETPRIVMODE();
!           if (seteuid(user_id) == -1) {
                GETUSERMODE();
  #else
        /* Only try to switch if we're running as root */
!       if(!geteuid() && seteuid(user_id) == -1) {
  #endif
!           log_unixerr("setuid", NULL, "unable to change euid", server_conf);
            exit (1);
        }
  #ifdef MPE
diff -wPrc apache_1.2b10/src/httpd.h apache_1.2b10monty/src/httpd.h
*** apache_1.2b10/src/httpd.h	Mon Apr 28 22:08:12 1997
- --- apache_1.2b10monty/src/httpd.h	Tue Jun 17 01:30:24 1997
***************
*** 703,709 ****
  uid_t uname2id(const char *name);
  gid_t gname2id(const char *name);
  int is_directory(const char *name);
! int can_exec(const struct stat *);     
  void chdir_file(const char *file);
       
  char *get_local_host(pool *);
- --- 703,709 ----
  uid_t uname2id(const char *name);
  gid_t gname2id(const char *name);
  int is_directory(const char *name);
! int can_exec(const struct stat *,uid_t uid,gid_t gid);     
  void chdir_file(const char *file);
       
  char *get_local_host(pool *);
diff -wPrc apache_1.2b10/src/mod_cgi.c apache_1.2b10monty/src/mod_cgi.c
*** apache_1.2b10/src/mod_cgi.c	Mon Apr 21 13:29:09 1997
- --- apache_1.2b10monty/src/mod_cgi.c	Wed Jun 18 14:02:28 1997
***************
*** 96,127 ****
      char *logname;
      long logbytes;
      int bufbytes;
! } cgi_server_conf;
  
  void *create_cgi_config (pool *p, server_rec *s)
  {
!     cgi_server_conf *c = 
!       (cgi_server_conf *)pcalloc (p, sizeof(cgi_server_conf));
  
      c->logname = NULL;
      c->logbytes = DEFAULT_LOGBYTES;
      c->bufbytes = DEFAULT_BUFBYTES;
  
      return c;
  }
  
  void *merge_cgi_config (pool *p, void *basev, void *overridesv)
  {
!     cgi_server_conf *base = (cgi_server_conf *)basev,
!       *overrides = (cgi_server_conf *)overridesv;
  
      return overrides->logname ? overrides : base;
  }
  
  const char *set_scriptlog (cmd_parms *cmd, void *dummy, char *arg) {
      server_rec *s = cmd->server;
!     cgi_server_conf *conf = 
!       (cgi_server_conf *)get_module_config(s->module_config, &cgi_module);
  
      conf->logname = arg;
      return NULL;
- --- 96,183 ----
      char *logname;
      long logbytes;
      int bufbytes;
!     int exec_uid;
!     int exec_gid;
! } cgi_sd_conf;
  
  void *create_cgi_config (pool *p, server_rec *s)
  {
!     cgi_sd_conf *c = 
!       (cgi_sd_conf *)pcalloc (p, sizeof(cgi_sd_conf));
! #ifdef DEBUG_CGI    
! #ifdef __EMX__
!     /* Under OS/2 need to use device con. */
!     FILE *dbg = fopen ("con", "w");
! #else    
!     FILE *dbg = fopen ("/dev/tty", "w");
! #endif    
! #endif
  
      c->logname = NULL;
      c->logbytes = DEFAULT_LOGBYTES;
      c->bufbytes = DEFAULT_BUFBYTES;
+     c->exec_uid=-1;
+     c->exec_gid=-1;
+ 
+ #ifdef DEBUG_CGI
+     fprintf (dbg, "**IDs exiting create: \n");
+     fprintf (dbg, "  uid:%d gid:%d\n",
+ 	     c->exec_uid,c->exec_gid);
+     fprintf (dbg, "  config:%x\n",c);
+     fclose(dbg);
+ #endif
  
      return c;
  }
  
+ void *create_cgi_dir_config (pool *p, char *d){
+   return(create_cgi_config(p,NULL));
+ }
+ 
  void *merge_cgi_config (pool *p, void *basev, void *overridesv)
  {
!     cgi_sd_conf *base = (cgi_sd_conf *)basev,
!       *overrides = (cgi_sd_conf *)overridesv;
! 
! #ifdef DEBUG_CGI    
! #ifdef __EMX__
!     /* Under OS/2 need to use device con. */
!     FILE *dbg = fopen ("con", "w");
! #else    
!     FILE *dbg = fopen ("/dev/tty", "w");
! #endif    
!     fprintf (dbg, "**IDs entering merge: \n");
!     fprintf (dbg, "  base_uid:%d base_gif:%d over_uid:%d over_gid:%d\n",
! 	     base->exec_uid,base->exec_gid,overrides->exec_uid,
! 	     overrides->exec_gid);
!     fclose(dbg);
! #endif
! 
!     if(overrides->exec_uid!=-1 || overrides->exec_gid!=-1){
!       base->exec_uid=overrides->exec_uid;
!       base->exec_gid=overrides->exec_gid;
!     }else{
!       overrides->exec_uid=base->exec_uid;
!       overrides->exec_gid=base->exec_gid;
!     }
  
      return overrides->logname ? overrides : base;
  }
  
+ const char *set_script_user (cmd_parms *cmd, cgi_sd_conf *conf, char *arg) {
+     conf->exec_uid=uname2id(arg);
+     return NULL;
+ }
+ 
+ const char *set_script_group (cmd_parms *cmd, cgi_sd_conf *conf, char *arg) {
+     conf->exec_gid=gname2id(arg);
+     return NULL;
+ }
+ 
  const char *set_scriptlog (cmd_parms *cmd, void *dummy, char *arg) {
      server_rec *s = cmd->server;
!     cgi_sd_conf *conf = 
!       (cgi_sd_conf *)get_module_config(s->module_config, &cgi_module);
  
      conf->logname = arg;
      return NULL;
***************
*** 129,136 ****
  
  const char *set_scriptlog_length (cmd_parms *cmd, void *dummy, char *arg) {
      server_rec *s = cmd->server;
!     cgi_server_conf *conf = 
!       (cgi_server_conf *)get_module_config(s->module_config, &cgi_module);
  
      conf->logbytes = atol (arg);
      return NULL;
- --- 185,192 ----
  
  const char *set_scriptlog_length (cmd_parms *cmd, void *dummy, char *arg) {
      server_rec *s = cmd->server;
!     cgi_sd_conf *conf = 
!       (cgi_sd_conf *)get_module_config(s->module_config, &cgi_module);
  
      conf->logbytes = atol (arg);
      return NULL;
***************
*** 138,145 ****
  
  const char *set_scriptlog_buffer (cmd_parms *cmd, void *dummy, char *arg) {
      server_rec *s = cmd->server;
!     cgi_server_conf *conf = 
!       (cgi_server_conf *)get_module_config(s->module_config, &cgi_module);
  
      conf->bufbytes = atoi (arg);
      return NULL;
- --- 194,201 ----
  
  const char *set_scriptlog_buffer (cmd_parms *cmd, void *dummy, char *arg) {
      server_rec *s = cmd->server;
!     cgi_sd_conf *conf = 
!       (cgi_sd_conf *)get_module_config(s->module_config, &cgi_module);
  
      conf->bufbytes = atoi (arg);
      return NULL;
***************
*** 152,161 ****
    "the maximum length (in bytes) of the script debug log"},
  { "ScriptLogBuffer", set_scriptlog_buffer, NULL, RSRC_CONF, TAKE1,
    "the maximum size (in bytes) to record of a POST request"},
  { NULL}
  };
  
! static int log_scripterror(request_rec *r, cgi_server_conf *conf, int ret,
  		    char *error)
  {
      FILE *f;
- --- 208,222 ----
    "the maximum length (in bytes) of the script debug log"},
  { "ScriptLogBuffer", set_scriptlog_buffer, NULL, RSRC_CONF, TAKE1,
    "the maximum size (in bytes) to record of a POST request"},
+   /* Monty hack */
+ { "ScriptUser", set_script_user,NULL,RSRC_CONF|ACCESS_CONF, TAKE1,
+     "the desired target uid of a CGI script"},
+ { "ScriptGroup", set_script_group,NULL,RSRC_CONF|ACCESS_CONF, TAKE1,
+     "the desired target gid of a CGI script"},
  { NULL}
  };
  
! static int log_scripterror(request_rec *r, cgi_sd_conf *conf, int ret,
  		    char *error)
  {
      FILE *f;
***************
*** 182,188 ****
      return ret;
  }
  
! static int log_script(request_rec *r, cgi_server_conf *conf, int ret,
  	       char *dbuf, char *sbuf, FILE *script_in, FILE *script_err)
  {
      table *hdrs_arr = r->headers_in;
- --- 243,249 ----
      return ret;
  }
  
! static int log_script(request_rec *r, cgi_sd_conf *conf, int ret,
  	       char *dbuf, char *sbuf, FILE *script_in, FILE *script_err)
  {
      table *hdrs_arr = r->headers_in;
***************
*** 317,323 ****
       * NB only ISINDEX scripts get decoded arguments.
       */
      
!     cleanup_for_exec();
      
      call_exec(r, argv0, env, 0);
  
- --- 378,421 ----
       * NB only ISINDEX scripts get decoded arguments.
       */
  
! 
!     /* Monty's CGI ScriptUser/Script Group hack; call_exec does the
!        actual setting from the globals; we've already forked, so go
!        ahead and clobber state */
!     {
!       cgi_sd_conf *conf = get_module_config(r->per_dir_config,&cgi_module);
! 
! #ifdef DEBUG_CGI
!       fprintf (dbg, "**IDs before exec: \n");
!       fprintf (dbg, "  uid:%d  euid:%d  gid:%d  egid:%d\n",(int)getuid(),
! 	       (int)geteuid(),(int)getgid(),(int)getegid());
!       fprintf (dbg, "  user_id:%d  group_id:%d\n",(int)user_id,(int)group_id);
!       fprintf (dbg, "  request:%x  dir_config:%x\n",r,conf);
! #endif    
! 
!       /* First, some paranoia; check consistency */
! 
!       check_uidgid(r->server);
! 
!       /* Set what we want to use for the exec */
! 
!       user_id=(conf->exec_uid<1)?user_id:conf->exec_uid;
!       group_id=(conf->exec_gid<1)?group_id:conf->exec_gid;
!       make_exec_safe(r->server);
! 
! #ifdef DEBUG_CGI
!       fprintf (dbg, "**IDs after exec prep: \n");
!       fprintf (dbg, "  uid:%d  euid:%d  gid:%d  egid:%d\n",(int)getuid(),
! 	       (int)geteuid(),(int)getgid(),(int)getegid());
!       fprintf (dbg, "  user_id:%d  group_id:%d\n",(int)user_id,(int)group_id);
! #endif    
!     }
! 
!     /* We already called (above) the contents of the new cleanup_for_exec()
!        preceeding alloc_cleanup_for_exec() [which is the old 
!        cleanup_for_exec()] */
! 
!     alloc_cleanup_for_exec();
      
      call_exec(r, argv0, env, 0);
  
***************
*** 346,353 ****
      char argsbuffer[HUGE_STRING_LEN];
      int is_included = !strcmp (r->protocol, "INCLUDED");
      void *sconf = r->server->module_config;
!     cgi_server_conf *conf =
! 	(cgi_server_conf *)get_module_config(sconf, &cgi_module);
  
      struct cgi_child_stuff cld;
      pid_t child_pid;
- --- 444,453 ----
      char argsbuffer[HUGE_STRING_LEN];
      int is_included = !strcmp (r->protocol, "INCLUDED");
      void *sconf = r->server->module_config;
!     cgi_sd_conf *conf =
! 	(cgi_sd_conf *)get_module_config(sconf, &cgi_module);
!     cgi_sd_conf *dirconf = 
!         (cgi_sd_conf *)get_module_config(r->per_dir_config,&cgi_module);
  
      struct cgi_child_stuff cld;
      pid_t child_pid;
***************
*** 393,399 ****
  			       "script not found or unable to stat");
  #endif
      if (!suexec_enabled) {
!         if (!can_exec(&r->finfo))
              return log_scripterror(r, conf, FORBIDDEN,
                                     "file permissions deny server execution");
      }
- --- 493,502 ----
  			       "script not found or unable to stat");
  #endif
      if (!suexec_enabled) {
!         int uid=dirconf->exec_uid;
!         int gid=dirconf->exec_gid;
!         if (!can_exec(&r->finfo,(uid==-1)?user_id:uid,
! 		      (gid==-1?group_id:gid)))
              return log_scripterror(r, conf, FORBIDDEN,
                                     "file permissions deny server execution");
      }
***************
*** 557,564 ****
  module cgi_module = {
     STANDARD_MODULE_STUFF,
     NULL,			/* initializer */
!    NULL,			/* dir config creater */
!    NULL,			/* dir merger --- default is to override */
     create_cgi_config,		/* server config */
     merge_cgi_config,	       	/* merge server config */
     cgi_cmds,			/* command table */
- --- 660,667 ----
  module cgi_module = {
     STANDARD_MODULE_STUFF,
     NULL,			/* initializer */
!    create_cgi_dir_config,       /* dir config creater */
!    merge_cgi_config,		/* dir merger --- default is to override */
     create_cgi_config,		/* server config */
     merge_cgi_config,	       	/* merge server config */
     cgi_cmds,			/* command table */
diff -wPrc apache_1.2b10/src/util.c apache_1.2b10monty/src/util.c
*** apache_1.2b10/src/util.c	Fri Apr 11 21:24:59 1997
- --- apache_1.2b10monty/src/util.c	Tue Jun 17 00:43:42 1997
***************
*** 937,943 ****
      return (x ? 1 : 0);  /* If the first character is ':', it's broken, too */
  }
  
! int can_exec(const struct stat *finfo) {
  #ifdef MULTIPLE_GROUPS
    int cnt;
  #endif
- --- 937,943 ----
      return (x ? 1 : 0);  /* If the first character is ':', it's broken, too */
  }
  
! int can_exec(const struct stat *finfo,uid_t uid,gid_t gid) {
  #ifdef MULTIPLE_GROUPS
    int cnt;
  #endif
***************
*** 945,954 ****
      /* OS/2 dosen't have Users and Groups */
      return 1;
  #else    
!     if(user_id == finfo->st_uid)
          if(finfo->st_mode & S_IXUSR)
              return 1;
!     if(group_id == finfo->st_gid)
          if(finfo->st_mode & S_IXGRP)
              return 1;
  #ifdef MULTIPLE_GROUPS
- --- 945,954 ----
      /* OS/2 dosen't have Users and Groups */
      return 1;
  #else    
!     if(uid == finfo->st_uid)
          if(finfo->st_mode & S_IXUSR)
              return 1;
!     if(gid == finfo->st_gid)
          if(finfo->st_mode & S_IXGRP)
              return 1;
  #ifdef MULTIPLE_GROUPS
diff -wPrc apache_1.2b10/src/util_script.c apache_1.2b10monty/src/util_script.c
*** apache_1.2b10/src/util_script.c	Mon Apr 28 21:45:52 1997
- --- apache_1.2b10monty/src/util_script.c	Wed Jun 18 14:10:57 1997
***************
*** 439,444 ****
- --- 439,531 ----
  }
  #endif
  
+ void check_uidgid(server_rec *s)
+ {
+   /* The redundancy is intentional */
+   
+   if(geteuid()!=user_id || getegid()!=group_id){
+     if(s)
+       log_unixerr("uid/gid",NULL,
+ 		  "Internal error: uid/euid/gid/egid security compromised!\n"
+ 		  "                crashing child process NOW!\n",
+ 		  s);
+     else
+       fprintf(stderr,
+ 	      "uid/gid: Internal error: inconsistent uid/euid/gid/egid\n"
+ 	      "         avoiding exec\n");
+ 
+     exit(0);
+   }
+ }
+ 
+ void make_exec_safe(server_rec *s)
+ {
+   /* Monty's euid/egid hack that lets us do ScriptUser and ScriptGroup
+      must now be made safe */
+   
+     /* disallow root */
+ 
+     if(!user_id || !group_id){
+       if(s)
+ 	log_unixerr("uid/gid",NULL,
+ 		    "Exec error: execing a child with real uid/gid\n"    
+ 		    "            set to root is not permitted.\n",
+ 		    s);
+       else
+ 	fprintf(stderr,
+ 		"uid/gid: execing with uid/gid root is not allowed.\n");
+       
+       exit(0);
+     }
+ 
+     /* Set what we really want for the exec */
+ 
+     seteuid(0);
+     setegid(0);
+     setgid(group_id);
+     setuid(user_id);
+     
+     if(getgid()!=group_id || getegid()!=group_id){
+       if(s)
+ 	log_unixerr("setgid",NULL,
+ 		    "Internal error: failed to set real/saved gid before exec\n"
+ 		    "                possible security compromise: "
+ 		    "crashing child process NOW!\n",
+ 		    s);
+       else
+ 	fprintf(stderr,
+ 		"setgid: Internal error: Failed to set gid; avoiding exec.\n");
+       exit(0);
+     }
+     if(getuid()!=user_id || geteuid()!=user_id){
+       if(s)
+ 	log_unixerr("setuid",NULL,
+ 		    "Internal error: failed to set real/saved gid before exec\n"
+ 		    "                possible security compromise: "
+ 		    "crashing child process NOW!\n",
+ 		    s);
+       else
+ 	fprintf(stderr,
+ 		"setgid: Internal error: Failed to set uid; avoiding exec.\n");
+ 
+       exit(0);
+     }
+ }
+ 
+ /* A wrapper for the old cleanup_for_exec that makes sure our uid/gid are safe.
+    This stuff didn't really belong in alloc.c :-) */
+ 
+ void cleanup_for_exec(){
+ 
+   /* Call our new stuff */
+ 
+   check_uidgid(NULL);
+   make_exec_safe(NULL);
+ 
+   /* Call the original */
+ 
+   alloc_cleanup_for_exec();
+ }
  
  void call_exec (request_rec *r, char *argv0, char **env, int shellcmd) 
  {
diff -wPrc apache_1.2b10/src/util_script.h apache_1.2b10monty/src/util_script.h
*** apache_1.2b10/src/util_script.h	Mon Apr 28 20:41:13 1997
- --- apache_1.2b10monty/src/util_script.h	Wed Jun 18 14:10:33 1997
***************
*** 66,69 ****
  int scan_script_header_err(request_rec *r, FILE *f, char *buffer);
  void send_size(size_t size, request_rec *r);
  void call_exec (request_rec *r, char *argv0, char **env, int shellcmd);
! 
- --- 66,71 ----
  int scan_script_header_err(request_rec *r, FILE *f, char *buffer);
  void send_size(size_t size, request_rec *r);
  void call_exec (request_rec *r, char *argv0, char **env, int shellcmd);
! void check_uidgid(server_rec *s);
! void make_exec_safe(server_rec *s);
! void cleanup_for_exec();

------- End of Forwarded Message




Re: [PATCH] a different approach to setuid scripts

Posted by Dean Gaudet <dg...@arctic.org>.
I'm quite tired of the linux bashing.  I know I'm one of the few people
here who supports linux. 

Any kernel-based threads implementation has a tid to tid_specific_data
mapping in addition to a pid to pid_specific_data mapping.  It is trivial
to put a uid into the tid_specific_data instead of the pid_specific_data. 
This is not heavy-weight at all.  Of course it's not feasible to do this
in a userland threads package. 

Dean

On Thu, 19 Jun 1997, Marc Slemko wrote:

> And the pessimistic would say that is because Linux's threads are too
> heavy...
> 
> On Wed, 18 Jun 1997, Dean Gaudet wrote:
> 
> > Only linux that I know of allows threads to run as different uids. 
> > 
> > Dean
> > 
> > On Wed, 18 Jun 1997, Marc Slemko wrote:
> > 
> > > On Wed, 18 Jun 1997, Randy Terbush wrote:
> > > 
> > > > 
> > > > He has chosen the path of setting effective UIDs, which was 
> > > > originally not acceptable. My feelings haven't changed much in that 
> > > > regard. Would someone else like to comment?
> > > > 
> > > 
> > > Easy to do, lets you do a lot more (like access web pages as
> > > different users, not just run scripts) but it ain't secure.  It
> > > would also probably tend to introduce too many hassles in a 
> > > threaded world, no?
> > > 
> > > 
> > 
> 
> 


Re: [PATCH] a different approach to setuid scripts

Posted by Marc Slemko <ma...@worldgate.com>.
And the pessimistic would say that is because Linux's threads are too
heavy...

On Wed, 18 Jun 1997, Dean Gaudet wrote:

> Only linux that I know of allows threads to run as different uids. 
> 
> Dean
> 
> On Wed, 18 Jun 1997, Marc Slemko wrote:
> 
> > On Wed, 18 Jun 1997, Randy Terbush wrote:
> > 
> > > 
> > > He has chosen the path of setting effective UIDs, which was 
> > > originally not acceptable. My feelings haven't changed much in that 
> > > regard. Would someone else like to comment?
> > > 
> > 
> > Easy to do, lets you do a lot more (like access web pages as
> > different users, not just run scripts) but it ain't secure.  It
> > would also probably tend to introduce too many hassles in a 
> > threaded world, no?
> > 
> > 
> 


Re: [PATCH] a different approach to setuid scripts

Posted by Dean Gaudet <dg...@arctic.org>.
Only linux that I know of allows threads to run as different uids. 

Dean

On Wed, 18 Jun 1997, Marc Slemko wrote:

> On Wed, 18 Jun 1997, Randy Terbush wrote:
> 
> > 
> > He has chosen the path of setting effective UIDs, which was 
> > originally not acceptable. My feelings haven't changed much in that 
> > regard. Would someone else like to comment?
> > 
> 
> Easy to do, lets you do a lot more (like access web pages as
> different users, not just run scripts) but it ain't secure.  It
> would also probably tend to introduce too many hassles in a 
> threaded world, no?
> 
> 


Re: [PATCH] a different approach to setuid scripts

Posted by Marc Slemko <ma...@worldgate.com>.
On Wed, 18 Jun 1997, Randy Terbush wrote:

> 
> He has chosen the path of setting effective UIDs, which was 
> originally not acceptable. My feelings haven't changed much in that 
> regard. Would someone else like to comment?
> 

Easy to do, lets you do a lot more (like access web pages as
different users, not just run scripts) but it ain't secure.  It
would also probably tend to introduce too many hassles in a 
threaded world, no?


Re: [PATCH] a different approach to setuid scripts

Posted by Dean Gaudet <dg...@arctic.org>.
Can we provide this cleanly as a compile time option?  Some people might
want to take the risks.  Then again, if we provide it that way we're
obliged to maintain it ... ok forget that.  +1 for contrib with an
explanation of the risks involved. 

Dean

On Wed, 18 Jun 1997, Randy Terbush wrote:

> He has chosen the path of setting effective UIDs, which was 
> originally not acceptable. My feelings haven't changed much in that 
> regard. Would someone else like to comment?