You are viewing a plain text version of this content. The canonical link for it is here.
Posted to general@jakarta.apache.org by Ceki Gülcü <ce...@qos.ch> on 2002/03/23 17:03:39 UTC
Re: Why Sun won't certify JBoss (was Re: "Jakarta is not an
open source project in the pure community sense anymore")
At 09:50 23.03.2002 -0500, you wrote:
>On 3/22/02 12:19 PM, "James Strachan" <ja...@yahoo.co.uk> wrote:
>
> > A thought struck me today which is probably totally obvious to folk but I
> > thought I'd share it anyways. Sun gets pots of cash from companies who
> > develop J2EE compliant software from the J2EE license fees. So its in Sun's
> > interest to protect the BEA's, IBM's and their own J2EE products. The money
> > they get is based on revenue of the company (so thats quite a lot of money
> > from BEA & IBM).
> >
> > The money-men at Sun probably see open source J2EE solutions as lost
> revenue
> > to possible commercial J2EE solutions so when folks like JBoss come along
> > they see it as in Sun's interest to not certify them to protect their J2EE
> > licence revenue nest egg.
> >
> > Though with the .NET competition now I think its in their interest to
> > protect their J2EE market place by allowing open source solutions;
> otherwise
> > long term folks will just move away from J2EE.
>
>I think that it gets even worse for us - it's my understanding that since
>the J2EE licensees had to pay pots for the license, bring open-source-able
>JSR's into that umbrella will dilute the value of the licenses they own.
>Therefore, it's conceivable that would be a motivation to oppose the opening
>of the J2EE API's.
This well may be case. It is pure speculation nonetheless. Or do you
know something I don't?
First, we don't know how much money Sun gets from licensing.
Second, the price of the license will drop if independent
implementations are allowed. For App Servers, I think the barrier of
entry is in the difficulty implementating the spec not in the licensing.
It's going to be JBoss, Weblogic, and Webspere for a long time. As
such, BEA and IBM will be thrilled to see a lower price -- assuming the
price was high.
Again, my claims are long on speculation and short on facts.
--
Ceki
My link of the month: http://java.sun.com/aboutJava/standardization/
--
To unsubscribe, e-mail: <ma...@jakarta.apache.org>
For additional commands, e-mail: <ma...@jakarta.apache.org>
Re: Why Sun won't certify JBoss (was Re:
"Jakarta is not an open source project in the pure community sense anymore")
Posted by "Geir Magnusson Jr." <ge...@optonline.net>.
On 3/23/02 11:03 AM, "Ceki Gülcü" <ce...@qos.ch> wrote:
> At 09:50 23.03.2002 -0500, you wrote:
>> On 3/22/02 12:19 PM, "James Strachan" <ja...@yahoo.co.uk> wrote:
>>
>>> A thought struck me today which is probably totally obvious to folk but I
>>> thought I'd share it anyways. Sun gets pots of cash from companies who
>>> develop J2EE compliant software from the J2EE license fees. So its in Sun's
>>> interest to protect the BEA's, IBM's and their own J2EE products. The money
>>> they get is based on revenue of the company (so thats quite a lot of money
>>> from BEA & IBM).
>>>
>>> The money-men at Sun probably see open source J2EE solutions as lost
>> revenue
>>> to possible commercial J2EE solutions so when folks like JBoss come along
>>> they see it as in Sun's interest to not certify them to protect their J2EE
>>> licence revenue nest egg.
>>>
>>> Though with the .NET competition now I think its in their interest to
>>> protect their J2EE market place by allowing open source solutions;
>> otherwise
>>> long term folks will just move away from J2EE.
>>
>> I think that it gets even worse for us - it's my understanding that since
>> the J2EE licensees had to pay pots for the license, bring open-source-able
>> JSR's into that umbrella will dilute the value of the licenses they own.
>> Therefore, it's conceivable that would be a motivation to oppose the opening
>> of the J2EE API's.
>
> This well may be case. It is pure speculation nonetheless. Or do you
> know something I don't?
I have no solid facts - no one has ever said to me "J2EE licensees protect
their investment...", but it's a reasonable supposition.
>
> First, we don't know how much money Sun gets from licensing.
>
> Second, the price of the license will drop if independent
> implementations are allowed.
That depends on a few factors, such as what qualifies compatibility, but you
are right, and the recent Great Leap Forward re the JSPA will address that.
> For App Servers, I think the barrier of
> entry is in the difficulty implementating the spec not in the licensing.
> It's going to be JBoss, Weblogic, and Webspere for a long time. As
> such, BEA and IBM will be thrilled to see a lower price -- assuming the
> price was high.
Seems that Macromedia Jrun is trying to compete in the space on price...
And Jboss is a different thing, right? They pay nothing for the licensing,
but don't get certified as a compatible J2EE impl.
> Again, my claims are long on speculation and short on facts.
>
Me too :)
--
Geir Magnusson Jr. geirm@optonline.net
System and Software Consulting
My inner cowboy needs to yodel.
--
To unsubscribe, e-mail: <ma...@jakarta.apache.org>
For additional commands, e-mail: <ma...@jakarta.apache.org>
Re: Why Sun won't certify JBoss (was Re:
"Jakarta is not an open source project in the pure community sense anymore")
Posted by "Geir Magnusson Jr." <ge...@optonline.net>.
On 3/23/02 12:12 PM, "Danny Angus" <da...@thought.co.uk> wrote:
>
>> Second, the price of the license will drop if independent
>> implementations are allowed. For App Servers, I think the barrier of
>> entry is in the difficulty implementating the spec not in the licensing.
>> It's going to be JBoss, Weblogic, and Webspere for a long time. As
>> such, BEA and IBM will be thrilled to see a lower price -- assuming the
>> price was high.
>
> All this makes me wonder what influence the recently reported comments by
> Sun, disparaging OS access to J2EE in favour of their commercial interests,
> and the bad reaction that it got here and elsewhere, has had on the recent
> JSPA development.
> I'm a cynic when it comes to the motives of Selfless Big Business, and as
> such I see the JSPA announcement having the effect of oil poured on waters
> increasingly troubled on a number of seperate fronts.
What exactly does that mean?
> Perhaps thats being disingenuous towards Sun, or perhaps their PR does have
> that muscle, I honestly don't know.
> Either way I'd like to add my hearty congratulations to all the guys
> invloved in putting the Apache case, and hope that Sun is as good as its
> word, because if I understand the issue correctly it could lead to
> interesting times here and elsewhere.
>
I think that you will find that this is a step forward - the JSPA vote
showed Sun that there was significant interest in getting the open source
issues as defined by the ASF straightened out - even the 'Yes' votes had
explicit support for the Apache position, and the recent public statements
by Sun are specific to those issues, rather than vague promises.
Sun just didn't do this by themselves - there was a lot of hard work by the
ASF, spearheaded by Jason, Chuck and others, to ensure that this happened.
I am very, very confident things are as they appear.
geir
--
Geir Magnusson Jr. geirm@optonline.net
System and Software Consulting
"Whoever would overthrow the liberty of a nation must begin by subduing the
freeness of speech." - Benjamin Franklin
--
To unsubscribe, e-mail: <ma...@jakarta.apache.org>
For additional commands, e-mail: <ma...@jakarta.apache.org>
RE: Why Sun won't certify JBoss (was Re: "Jakarta is not an open source project in the pure community sense anymore")
Posted by Danny Angus <da...@thought.co.uk>.
> Second, the price of the license will drop if independent
> implementations are allowed. For App Servers, I think the barrier of
> entry is in the difficulty implementating the spec not in the licensing.
> It's going to be JBoss, Weblogic, and Webspere for a long time. As
> such, BEA and IBM will be thrilled to see a lower price -- assuming the
> price was high.
All this makes me wonder what influence the recently reported comments by
Sun, disparaging OS access to J2EE in favour of their commercial interests,
and the bad reaction that it got here and elsewhere, has had on the recent
JSPA development.
I'm a cynic when it comes to the motives of Selfless Big Business, and as
such I see the JSPA announcement having the effect of oil poured on waters
increasingly troubled on a number of seperate fronts.
Perhaps thats being disingenuous towards Sun, or perhaps their PR does have
that muscle, I honestly don't know.
Either way I'd like to add my hearty congratulations to all the guys
invloved in putting the Apache case, and hope that Sun is as good as its
word, because if I understand the issue correctly it could lead to
interesting times here and elsewhere.
d.
--
To unsubscribe, e-mail: <ma...@jakarta.apache.org>
For additional commands, e-mail: <ma...@jakarta.apache.org>