You are viewing a plain text version of this content. The canonical link for it is here.
Posted to dev@openoffice.apache.org by Oliver-Rainer Wittmann <or...@googlemail.com> on 2011/09/23 09:55:57 UTC

Re: consolidation of Windows Build software requirements

Hi Mathias,

On 22.09.2011 22:35, Mathias Bauer wrote:
> Am 21.09.2011 12:07, schrieb Martin Hollmichel:
>
>> Hi,
>>
>> Am 20.09.2011 12:26, schrieb Oliver-Rainer Wittmann:
>>> Hi,
>>>
>> [...]
>>> I will start working on a consolidation of the Windows Build software
>>> requirements as given on
>>> http://ooo-wiki.apache.org/wiki/Documentation/Building_Guide/Building_on_Windows:
>>> - get rid of dependence on unicows.dll
>> This will have some impact wrt system requirements ? Which Windows
>> version will be affected by this change ?
>>> -- take over issue 88652
>>> (https://issues.apache.org/ooo/show_bug.cgi?id=88652) from Mathias and
>>> perform the given tasks.
>>> - get rid of dependence on instmsiw.exe and instmsia.exe
>> also this will iirc have some dependencies wrt system requirements, what
>> do  you consider as minimum Windows baseline ? I would be fine with a XP
>> System SP2,
>
> Why not SP3?
> Really, SP2 is a totally outdated system.
>

I am not recognizing in my mind which service packs are available for 
which Windows version.
I am only repeating Martin here thinking that SP2 was the latest SP for 
Win XP. Thus, no reason special reason for Win XP SP2.
My opinion is that we should always rely on the most updated version of 
an operating system which we want to support.
Thus, for Windows XP it should be Win XP SP3, if this is the most 
updated version.

> Besides that, we don't need unicows.dll on any Windows XP installation,
> WinXP is UniCode enabled. unicows.dll ist just for Win9x.
>

That is what I understand from the comments which you have been made in 
issue 88652.

> Maybe you mixed unicows.dll with the notorious uwinapi.dll that at least
> has some value on WinXP, though it's unclear how much.
>

Hm...
Why do you think I am mixing unicows.dll with uwinapi.dll?
I am only planning to perform the stuff which is mentioned in issue 
88652 regarding unicows.dll.

Best regards, Oliver.

Re: consolidation of Windows Build software requirements

Posted by floris v <fl...@gmail.com>.
Op 23-9-2011 11:39, Tor Lillqvist schreef:
>> Sp2is still widely used and installed in low specs computers in developing
>> countries where no licensed copies of MS exist (and where the use of
>> unlicensed copies of software is not illegal). These computers are a part of
>> OOo's market.
> Sorry if I am missing something, but why wouldn't these people use an
> unlicensed copy (cracked if necessary) of the "real thing", i.e. MS
> Office, then, if it is not illegal?
>
> Imagine trying to convince them to use OOo: "OK, I see you are using
> an unlicensed copy of Windows, oh well, that is legal in your country,
> and MS is evil anyway, so I don't mind. Now, look at what I have here,
> lovely office software which is almost as good as MS Office, and it
> doesn't cost anything! And it is Open Source! Don't you want to use
> it, please? Please?"
>
> --tml
Win XP is also still widely used by people who post in the Dutch nl 
community forum to report problems with installing the latest version of 
OOo. I doubt very much that those people post from a developing country. 
Then again, those people will have a fully upgraded system with SP3, 
yes, that's the latest.
Peter aka floris v

Re: consolidation of Windows Build software requirements

Posted by Tor Lillqvist <tm...@iki.fi>.
> Yes you are missing something ;-) You are assuming here that MS Windows is
> better than OpenOffice. In this case it is a wrong assumption.

Oooh, good for OOo then.

--tml

Re: consolidation of Windows Build software requirements

Posted by Javier Sola <li...@khmeros.info>.
On 9/23/11 4:39 PM, Tor Lillqvist wrote:
>> Sp2is still widely used and installed in low specs computers in developing
>> countries where no licensed copies of MS exist (and where the use of
>> unlicensed copies of software is not illegal). These computers are a part of
>> OOo's market.
> Sorry if I am missing something, but why wouldn't these people use an
> unlicensed copy (cracked if necessary) of the "real thing", i.e. MS
> Office, then, if it is not illegal?
>
> Imagine trying to convince them to use OOo: "OK, I see you are using
> an unlicensed copy of Windows, oh well, that is legal in your country,
> and MS is evil anyway, so I don't mind. Now, look at what I have here,
> lovely office software which is almost as good as MS Office, and it
> doesn't cost anything! And it is Open Source! Don't you want to use
> it, please? Please?"
Hi Tor,

Yes you are missing something ;-) You are assuming here that MS Windows 
is better than OpenOffice. In this case it is a wrong assumption.

In Cambodia, for example, OpenOffice is in the local language (Khmer), 
it has a nice spell-checker, sorts words correctly in Khmer, uses Khmer 
dates, and it is mandatory in the education system.

Why would you want to use MS Office in English (sorry, no Khmer, formats 
or spell-checker) in your Windows XP SP2, when you can use a program 
that it is easy to learn, it is in your language and it helps you 
write?  ;-)

Cheers,

Javier

>
> --tml
>
>


Re: consolidation of Windows Build software requirements

Posted by Tor Lillqvist <tm...@iki.fi>.
> Sp2is still widely used and installed in low specs computers in developing
> countries where no licensed copies of MS exist (and where the use of
> unlicensed copies of software is not illegal). These computers are a part of
> OOo's market.

Sorry if I am missing something, but why wouldn't these people use an
unlicensed copy (cracked if necessary) of the "real thing", i.e. MS
Office, then, if it is not illegal?

Imagine trying to convince them to use OOo: "OK, I see you are using
an unlicensed copy of Windows, oh well, that is legal in your country,
and MS is evil anyway, so I don't mind. Now, look at what I have here,
lovely office software which is almost as good as MS Office, and it
doesn't cost anything! And it is Open Source! Don't you want to use
it, please? Please?"

--tml

Re: consolidation of Windows Build software requirements

Posted by Javier Sola <li...@khmeros.info>.
On 9/23/11 2:55 PM, Oliver-Rainer Wittmann wrote:
>
> I am not recognizing in my mind which service packs are available for 
> which Windows version.
> I am only repeating Martin here thinking that SP2 was the latest SP 
> for Win XP. Thus, no reason special reason for Win XP SP2.
> My opinion is that we should always rely on the most updated version 
> of an operating system which we want to support.
> Thus, for Windows XP it should be Win XP SP3, if this is the most 
> updated version.
>
Well... Sp3 has a nasty side effect. You might remember that MS 
introduced a change that made desktops black for software that they 
considered as not original.

Sp2is still widely used and installed in low specs computers in 
developing countries where no licensed copies of MS exist (and where the 
use of unlicensed copies of software is not illegal). These computers 
are a part of OOo's market.

In any case, I do not think that SP2 and SP3 will be very different.

Cheers,

Javier

Re: consolidation of Windows Build software requirements

Posted by Mathias Bauer <Ma...@gmx.net>.
Am 23.09.2011 09:55, schrieb Oliver-Rainer Wittmann:

>> Maybe you mixed unicows.dll with the notorious uwinapi.dll that at least
>> has some value on WinXP, though it's unclear how much.
> 
> Hm...
> Why do you think I am mixing unicows.dll with uwinapi.dll?

I replied to Martin. :-)

Regards,
Mathias