You are viewing a plain text version of this content. The canonical link for it is here.
Posted to derby-dev@db.apache.org by Kristian Waagan <Kr...@Sun.COM> on 2006/03/13 23:32:11 UTC

Not allowed to delete from Jira anymore?

Hello,

Have I missed why we are not allowed to delete stuff from Jira anymore?
I saw Kathey was unable to delete a comment, and I am not able to delete 
an attachment I would like to replace.
I tried deleting from a issue I both reported and was assigned to (I was 
even logged in!), but the delete controls are not there anymore.

Is this a change of policy, or just a issue that will go away in a 
little while?


--
Kristian

Re: Not allowed to delete from Jira anymore?

Posted by Andrew McIntyre <mc...@gmail.com>.
On 3/13/06, David W. Van Couvering <Da...@sun.com> wrote:
>
> In the meantime, maybe we can log some bugs/feature requests against
> JIRA?  (a) ability to grant delete of elements of an issue without being
> able to delete the issue and (b) delete merely marks its status as
> deleted, it does not permanently delete and (c) because of -b-, add
> support for a purge operation.

JIRA, of course, has its own JIRA:

http://jira.atlassian.com/secure/Dashboard.jspa

Looks like there's already one for (a):

http://jira.atlassian.com/browse/JRA-2367

and with 56 votes, its one of the most requested features.

andrew

Re: Not allowed to delete from Jira anymore?

Posted by "David W. Van Couvering" <Da...@Sun.COM>.
I think we can give this a shot, although it may be the cause for 
confusion.  Given that we don't have recoverability, we might as well 
have multi-versioning :)

In the meantime, maybe we can log some bugs/feature requests against 
JIRA?  (a) ability to grant delete of elements of an issue without being 
able to delete the issue and (b) delete merely marks its status as 
deleted, it does not permanently delete and (c) because of -b-, add 
support for a purge operation.

David

Andrew McIntyre wrote:
> On 3/13/06, Kristian Waagan <Kr...@sun.com> wrote:
> 
>>Have I missed why we are not allowed to delete stuff from Jira anymore?
>>I saw Kathey was unable to delete a comment, and I am not able to delete
>>an attachment I would like to replace.
>>I tried deleting from a issue I both reported and was assigned to (I was
>>even logged in!), but the delete controls are not there anymore.
>>
>>Is this a change of policy, or just a issue that will go away in a
>>little while?
> 
> 
> I was concerned last week when an entire issue was deleted, and I
> double-checked the permissions and some permissions (like delete) were
> granted too widely, in my opinion, allowing any jira user to perform
> them. Deleting an issue (which is then not recoverable), I restricted
> to the derby-administrators group, although I had not realized at the
> time that the delete privilege covers the ability to delete comments
> and attachments as well, a bit of poor granularity on the part of
> JIRA's permissions schemes.
> 
> Others on the list have requested that patches and comments not be
> deleted from JIRA so that there is a record of how patches progress,
> along with all relevant comments, so I'm tempted to leave it as-is.
> 
> Anyone else feel differently? The permanent deletion of issues is a
> bad thing, I sort of hoped that JIRA would actually keep the records,
> but it appears not. But if people really want to be able to delete
> comments, I can give the derby-developers group the delete permission
> back.
> 
> andrew

Re: Not allowed to delete from Jira anymore?

Posted by Kristian Waagan <Kr...@Sun.COM>.
Andrew McIntyre wrote:

>On 3/13/06, Kristian Waagan <Kr...@sun.com> wrote:
>  
>
>>Have I missed why we are not allowed to delete stuff from Jira anymore?
>>I saw Kathey was unable to delete a comment, and I am not able to delete
>>an attachment I would like to replace.
>>I tried deleting from a issue I both reported and was assigned to (I was
>>even logged in!), but the delete controls are not there anymore.
>>
>>Is this a change of policy, or just a issue that will go away in a
>>little while?
>>    
>>
>
>I was concerned last week when an entire issue was deleted, and I
>double-checked the permissions and some permissions (like delete) were
>granted too widely, in my opinion, allowing any jira user to perform
>them. Deleting an issue (which is then not recoverable), I restricted
>to the derby-administrators group, although I had not realized at the
>time that the delete privilege covers the ability to delete comment
>and attachments as well, a bit of poor granularity on the part of
>JIRA's permissions schemes.
>
>Others on the list have requested that patches and comments not be
>deleted from JIRA so that there is a record of how patches progress,
>along with all relevant comments, so I'm tempted to leave it as-is.
>
>Anyone else feel differently? The permanent deletion of issues is a
>bad thing, I sort of hoped that JIRA would actually keep the records,
>but it appears not. But if people really want to be able to delete
>comments, I can give the derby-developers group the delete permission
>back.
>
>andrew
>  
>
Okay, thanks for the explanation.
It was me that deleted a Jira entry, when I found out that a sub-task 
can only be made from clicking the "Create sub task" link, and not 
through the "Create issue" dialog. Guess I should have notified the list 
about it.

Anyway, in general I agree that things should not be deleted, but 
sometimes I feel the need to delete attachments - or actually replace one. 
I have a Jira where I uploaded a file recently, and noone has probably 
looked at the file yet. The problem is that I made a last minute change 
which caused the file not to compile, and I don't see any good reason 
for keeping it on Jira.

The regular developer should in my opinion only be able to delete 
her/his own comments and attachments.



--
Kristian

Re: Not allowed to delete from Jira anymore?

Posted by Andrew McIntyre <mc...@gmail.com>.
On 3/13/06, Kristian Waagan <Kr...@sun.com> wrote:
>
> Have I missed why we are not allowed to delete stuff from Jira anymore?
> I saw Kathey was unable to delete a comment, and I am not able to delete
> an attachment I would like to replace.
> I tried deleting from a issue I both reported and was assigned to (I was
> even logged in!), but the delete controls are not there anymore.
>
> Is this a change of policy, or just a issue that will go away in a
> little while?

I was concerned last week when an entire issue was deleted, and I
double-checked the permissions and some permissions (like delete) were
granted too widely, in my opinion, allowing any jira user to perform
them. Deleting an issue (which is then not recoverable), I restricted
to the derby-administrators group, although I had not realized at the
time that the delete privilege covers the ability to delete comments
and attachments as well, a bit of poor granularity on the part of
JIRA's permissions schemes.

Others on the list have requested that patches and comments not be
deleted from JIRA so that there is a record of how patches progress,
along with all relevant comments, so I'm tempted to leave it as-is.

Anyone else feel differently? The permanent deletion of issues is a
bad thing, I sort of hoped that JIRA would actually keep the records,
but it appears not. But if people really want to be able to delete
comments, I can give the derby-developers group the delete permission
back.

andrew