You are viewing a plain text version of this content. The canonical link for it is here.
Posted to dev@openoffice.apache.org by Greg Stein <gs...@gmail.com> on 2011/06/16 08:21:41 UTC

Teams and Leads (was: Proposed short term goals)

A little late to this, but...

On Mon, Jun 13, 2011 at 15:07,  <ro...@us.ibm.com> wrote:
>...
> Although we are not obligated to do things exactly how they were done
> before in OpenOffice.org, it seems that the nature of the project is that
> we'll have some clearly distinguished functional subgroups within the
> project, including:
>
> 1) Development, including release management
> 2) Translation/Localization
> 3) Documentation, both in-product and on-website
> 4) User support, including user forums
> 5) Marketing
>
> (Are there any others?  I may be missing something.)

Please be wary about dividing responsibilities. About having "teams".

At Apache, everybody is responsible for every aspect, and they can
participate in every aspect that they so choose. We *do* assume that
they'll be intelligent about it, and avoid derailing efforts through
inexperience.

But remember that we operate by consensus. If somebody wants to
participate in that consensus in *any* area, then they will be
welcome. In that sense, there are no "teams". Just people focusing on
different aspects of the overall community.

We certainly don't have "Leads". I know that is a different model from
how the OOo community has operated in the past. We'll need to find
ways to coordinate actions. It is certainly possible to have
"coordinators" or "managers" (such as a Release Manager, or Patch
Manager), but these are different from "Leads". They have no more say
than anybody else in the community. They are just the focal point for
coordinating the broader activities.

For example, my focus would be on development, but there should be no
barrier to my participation in the Marketing efforts. I should not
have to be on a list, and my input (assuming I'm not a total dumbass
about it) should be welcome when offered. This should apply to
everybody in the community.

Cheers,
-g

RE: Teams and Leads (was: Proposed short term goals)

Posted by "Dennis E. Hamilton" <de...@acm.org>.
+1

(Workforces might not be a good term.  I can see specialized lists for addressing particular subject areas that have their own specialized traffic, but it is careful to avoid suggesting organizational division when what we are doing is filtering traffic.  There are other ways to do that, but separate lists are very effective, because they don't depend on complex subject-line rituals.)

-----Original Message-----
From: IngridvdM [mailto:IngridvdM@gmx-topmail.de] 
Sent: Thursday, June 16, 2011 03:47
To: ooo-dev@incubator.apache.org
Subject: Re: Teams and Leads (was: Proposed short term goals)

[ ... ]

I would like to try the structures and ways Apache has. That everybody 
has a voice at Apache and that the goal is to seek consensus by 
exchanging arguments is a very democratic aspect. That in the end those 
do that choose to participate more is the meritocratic aspect. I think 
this is highly fair.
I am not so convinced that the structures we had on old OOo have been 
good. Obviously there has been to much room for distrust and hidden 
discussions, so repeatedly individuals or whole groups felt excluded on 
multiple sides.

I am really in favor of going without anyone being named leader or 
manager or any name that could create the impression that this person 
has more rights than the others. Maybe we can choose 'contact' as a 
neutral description in case something turns out to be needed? Or is 
there even a more neutral word?

Christian Grobmeier has mentioned "workforces". That sounds interesting. 
Is there more about that in the documentation somewhere?

Ingrid


Re: Teams and Leads (was: Proposed short term goals)

Posted by Christian Grobmeier <gr...@gmail.com>.
Hey Manfred,

>> The only 'contact' that people need for this project is
>> ooo-dev@incubator.apache.org.
>
> As long as we're talking about people like us. ;-)
> But: what's with an enduser in Nagano, japan or an enduser in Chapéco, Brasil?

we are waiting for your suggestions :-)

Seriously - we need a few good ideas to make Nagano happy.

In my world, I think we should start to think about how we would like
to community with the endusers. Probably mailinglist - but which name?


>> If this list grows too large or too busy, then we can create
>> additional 'contacts' in the form of more mailing lists.
>
> Is it intended from NewOOo to deliver final products to the market?
>
> If yes,
> than IMHO we should think *right now*
> about an infrastructure for these parts of the project.
> else ...

We need to bring this question up with another subject. Then devs
might have a chance to say what they think. personally I would say
"yes", we need that and I thought this was always th e plan. Maybe iam
wrong

>  Nevertheless: The earlier you start these national projects, the more
> uncertainty is removed from the market.

true


> IMHO that was the question from Kazunari Hirano.
> https://mail.google.com/mail/?shva=1#label/...ApacheOOo/13092fd2961dd406
> Unfortunately his has now answer until now.

Yes - to much chaos at the moment. We are asked to make suggestions
and implement the necessary stuff.

If you have ideas - please respond to Kazunari Hiranos email and lets
start a discussion

> If would be fine, if a "almighty" could answer the questions of our
> friends from Japan.

Have you signed the icla? Yes? You are almighty then :-)
We nearly - but you have the power to bring up a proposal, and if the
others like it, we will make it true. No need to wait for other
"almightys"
We just need to do it

Cheers!

>
> 0,02 eurocents
>
> M.
>



-- 
http://www.grobmeier.de

Re: Teams and Leads (was: Proposed short term goals)

Posted by Raphael Bircher <r....@gmx.ch>.
Hi Manfred

Am 16.06.11 14:47, schrieb Manfred A. Reiter:
> Hi Sam, *,
> Is it intended from NewOOo to deliver final products to the market?
>
> If yes,
> than IMHO we should think *right now*
> about an infrastructure for these parts of the project.
> else ...
>
> Or do you think that there are too many unstability still in the process?
>
> Nevertheless: The earlier you start these national projects, the more
> uncertainty is removed from the market.
Atm, I think we should work on the NLC's with the "old" OOo 
infrastructure. The size of te project make a quick move to Apache 
nearly impossible. So we will first move the defeloper stuff, and then 
the End User things. At the same time we have the time to discuss, waths 
the best for End Users. The courent sites are realy not optimal. So we 
need first to talk wath we realy need, then clarify the tecnical 
options, and finale migrate. So I hope we will have a propper solution 
for the final page.

Greetings Raphael

-- 
My private Homepage: http://www.raphaelbircher.ch/

Re: Teams and Leads

Posted by "Manfred A. Reiter" <ma...@gmail.com>.
Hi Ross, *,

Am 16.06.2011 14:55, schrieb Ross Gardler:
> On 16/06/2011 13:47, Manfred A. Reiter wrote:
>> Hi Sam, *,
>>
>> 2011/6/16 Sam Ruby<ru...@intertwingly.net>:
>>> On Thu, Jun 16, 2011 at 6:47 AM, 
>>> IngridvdM<In...@gmx-topmail.de>  wrote:
>>>
[...]
>> As long as we're talking about people like us. ;-)
>> But: what's with an enduser in Nagano, japan or an enduser in 
>> Chapéco, Brasil?
>
> At some point it will make sense to create an ooo-user@ mailing list. 
> As Sam says below, new contact points can be created if/when they are 
> needed.

[...]

>> Is it intended from NewOOo to deliver final products to the market?
>>
>> If yes,
>> than IMHO we should think *right now*
>> about an infrastructure for these parts of the project.
>> else ...
>>
>> Or do you think that there are too many unstability still in the 
>> process?
>
> Generally the ASF approach is to *only* create additional channels 
> when the noise in the existing channels is too high. 

right for a project which starts from scratch

> We are nowhere near that point yet. 
really?
There a millions of installations around the world, right now.
... and ... behind ... the grant of the code Apache received a lot of 
"clients", ;-)
in different countries, with different culture and different languages.
sorry for talking about self-evident things, but they must be obseved

> At this point of incubation users are a key part of the development 
> process for this project.
>

Yes and *they are* for more than 10 years.
All these users don't disappear while sourcecode is going from Oracle to 
Apache.

> For example, how can we answer your question above without 
> understanding what both the project members and its users want?
>
>> Nevertheless: The earlier you start these national projects, the more
>> uncertainty is removed from the market.
>
> You don't need a separate contact point to start working on these issues.

Could you please explain that point?

[...]

cheers

M.

Re: Teams and Leads

Posted by Alexandro Colorado <jz...@openoffice.org>.
On Thu, Jun 16, 2011 at 9:01 AM, Rob Weir <ap...@robweir.com> wrote:

> On Thu, Jun 16, 2011 at 9:27 AM, RA Stehmann
> <an...@rechtsanwalt-stehmann.de> wrote:
> > I think we shouldn't invent the wheel twice ;-).
> >
> > The OpenOffice.org community has an more or less good working
> > infrastructure of leads, contact persons, native lang communities,
> > teams, mailing lists, websites etc..
> >
> > IMO we should make an inventory, keep the usefull elements and drop the
> > dated. And let persons, who undertake the task of doing something and
> > who are elected by the OpenOffice.org community, doing their job forward.
> >
>
> That makes sense to me.  But I think this is less about "wearing
> crowns" and more about "doing".  We don't need to give someone the
> title of "X Lead".  But if someone steps up and starts doing X, and
> does it well, works well in the project, and ensure that decisions
> occur via consensus on the list, than that person will start taking on
> the attributes of the de facto "X Lead".
>

This is me thinking out loud on a time I am normally thinking in silent
(sleeping). But I also have been co/leading many projects within the
OpenOffice.org community including BizDev, Education, Certification, and
Spanish community as well as being LATAM Marcon and contribute to many other
projects like DBA, XML, and Extensions.

I have also participate and contribute to other FLOSS communities like KDE
and Mozilla with their own processes. I've seen places where these
leadership role helps the project advance and places where there actually
becomes a hurdle in advancing the community.

I have heard arguments saying that OOo leadership is clutter by
non-developer members for years now. Making some technical needs advance
very slow, and others like press releases and OOo events much faster.

That said, every region of OOo had their own structure, their mini-marketing
plans for ES or Education, and others a spare but interesting talks like XML
or DBA.

Again no conclusion just random thoughts about the topic.


>
> We have a request entered with Apache Infrastructure for a wiki to
> help us with your second point.  Once we have the wiki it should be
> possible to map out a inventory or "site map" of the existing
> OpenOffice.org web site.   So maybe a big table listing each of the
> subsites or services on OpenOffice.org, along with columns for
> "migrate/archive/trash", "priority" and "volunteer".  Something like
> that.
>
> -Rob
>



-- 
*Alexandro Colorado*
*OpenOffice.org* Español
http://es.openoffice.org

Re: Teams and Leads

Posted by "Manfred A. Reiter" <ma...@gmail.com>.
Hi André,
nice to see you ;-)

2011/6/16 Andre Schnabel <An...@gmx.net>:
> Hi,
>
>> Von: "Manfred A. Reiter" <ma...@gmail.com>
>

[...]

>>
>> at the beginning the geramanophone branche of OOo startet with only
>> *two* mailinglist
>> all the others where created according to the needs of the German Project.
>
> I'd say two mailing lists should be enough for 99% of the language teams.

absolutely right ... *(as in the majority of cases ;-) )*


> But ...
>>
>> But IMHO each "national project" should start with at least a userlist
>> and a list to organise the "national needs" ;-)
>
>
> Creating the user lists would be really important. And you cannot only
> creat localized user lists, *after* you see to much traffic on any other
> (non localized) list. Non-english users will only join discussion at
> large if they can discuss in their native lang. As long as you do not
> offer locale user lists, you would hardly realize that there is a need
> for it ;)

thank you André ...
your last paragraph is so important, that I'd like to repeat it:

Creating the user lists would be really important. And you cannot only
creat localized user lists, *after* you see to much traffic on any other
(non localized) list. Non-english users will only join discussion at
large if they can discuss in their native lang. As long as you do not
offer locale user lists, you would hardly realize that there is a need
for it ;)


-- 
## Manfred

Re: Teams and Leads

Posted by Andre Schnabel <An...@gmx.net>.
Hi,

> Von: "Manfred A. Reiter" <ma...@gmail.com>

> 
> to have an idea ... these are the current mailinglists
> in the OOo ... german subdomain.
> 
> announce@de.openoffice.org
> dev@de.openoffice.org
> users@de.openoffice.org
> cvs@de.openoffice.org
> issues@de.openoffice.org
> marketing@de.openoffice.org
> qa@de.openoffice.org
> business@de.openoffice.org
> ooocamp@de.openoffice.org
> cdrom@de.openoffice.org
> 
> at the beginning the geramanophone branche of OOo startet with only
> *two* mailinglist
> all the others where created according to the needs of the German Project.

I'd say two mailing lists should be enough for 99% of the language teams.
But ...


> 
> But IMHO each "national project" should start with at least a userlist
> and a list to organise the "national needs" ;-)


Creating the user lists would be really important. And you cannot only
creat localized user lists, *after* you see to much traffic on any other
(non localized) list. Non-english users will only join discussion at 
large if they can discuss in their native lang. As long as you do not 
offer locale user lists, you would hardly realize that there is a need
for it ;)

regards,

André


Re: Teams and Leads

Posted by "Manfred A. Reiter" <ma...@gmail.com>.
Hi Kazunari Hirano san,

2011/6/16 Kazunari Hirano <kh...@gmail.com>:
> Hi Manfred A. Reiter san,
>
> On Thu, Jun 16, 2011 at 11:18 PM, Manfred A. Reiter <ma...@gmail.com> wrote:
>> But IMHO each "national project" should start with at least a userlist
>> and a list to organise the "national needs" ;-)
> Good idea.
> :)
> Can we say "language project" instead of "national project"?

Yes, we can. ;-)

I said "national project" to avoid "interferences".
Sometimes developers use "language project" and think about localization.
You are right, we should be more severe to use right terms. ;-)

> Because German is spoken in several countries, and there are several
> languages spoken in Germany, right?
> :)

yes, you are right. ;-)

Best regards

M.

Re: Teams and Leads

Posted by Kazunari Hirano <kh...@gmail.com>.
Hi Manfred A. Reiter san,

On Thu, Jun 16, 2011 at 11:18 PM, Manfred A. Reiter <ma...@gmail.com> wrote:
> But IMHO each "national project" should start with at least a userlist
> and a list to organise the "national needs" ;-)
Good idea.
:)
Can we say "language project" instead of "national project"?
Because German is spoken in several countries, and there are several
languages spoken in Germany, right?
:)
Thanks,
khirano

RE: Teams and Leads

Posted by "Dennis E. Hamilton" <de...@acm.org>.
+1

-----Original Message-----
From: Jomar Silva [mailto:homembit@gmail.com] 
Sent: Thursday, June 16, 2011 16:04
To: ooo-dev@incubator.apache.org
Subject: Re: Teams and Leads

On Thu, Jun 16, 2011 at 11:39 AM, Rob Weir <ap...@robweir.com> wrote:
[ ... ]
>
> 2) Have the national language projects run outside of Apache.  Since
> anyone can modify the code we released and repackage it and distribute
> it, it should be possible for any party to independently add
> translations and even rename it for distribution in their country.  Of
> course, while respecting the license and trademark requirements.
>

I really like the idea number 2.

At least in Brazil, we used to have a lot of traffic on our native
language mailing list, and a lot of people raising their hands to help
with a lot of things. A big part of the BR community here don't speak
english, so they may only contribute when they have a place to discuss
on our native language (I really dislike the idea to have some folks
acting as a language proxy for the whole community). There are also
many particularities on how each country's community do their
collaborative work and how they're organized.

As far as the Apache licence and trademarks policy are respected by
the "national languages" teams, I believe that we could have a better
dinamic on the whole process if we go for something like Rob's idea
#2.

Best,

Jomar


Re: Teams and Leads

Posted by Jomar Silva <ho...@gmail.com>.
On Thu, Jun 16, 2011 at 11:39 AM, Rob Weir <ap...@robweir.com> wrote:
> It might be worth describing how national language projects and the
> OpenOffce NLC has worked in the past.  I think this would be
> educational for our Apache mentors to understand a little of what they
> do.  It is much more than just translation.  They are almost more like
> affiliate organizations that promote OpenOffice in their countries.,
> They are the "face of OOo" in their respective countries.  But you
> could explain it better than me.
>
> A top level question for is is how we see this mapping to the Apache
> project.  The two extremes are:
>
> 1) Move all of this into the Apache project.  All 100+ translation
> projects, country marketing projects, etc.
>
> 2) Have the national language projects run outside of Apache.  Since
> anyone can modify the code we released and repackage it and distribute
> it, it should be possible for any party to independently add
> translations and even rename it for distribution in their country.  Of
> course, while respecting the license and trademark requirements.
>

I really like the idea number 2.

At least in Brazil, we used to have a lot of traffic on our native
language mailing list, and a lot of people raising their hands to help
with a lot of things. A big part of the BR community here don't speak
english, so they may only contribute when they have a place to discuss
on our native language (I really dislike the idea to have some folks
acting as a language proxy for the whole community). There are also
many particularities on how each country's community do their
collaborative work and how they're organized.

As far as the Apache licence and trademarks policy are respected by
the "national languages" teams, I believe that we could have a better
dinamic on the whole process if we go for something like Rob's idea
#2.

Best,

Jomar

Re: Teams and Leads

Posted by "Manfred A. Reiter" <ma...@gmail.com>.
> It was swarm intelligence at it's best.

:-(

Re: Teams and Leads

Posted by "Manfred A. Reiter" <ma...@gmail.com>.
Hi Rob,

sorry ... I didn't saw that your answer was addressed to me,
because of top-posting and ... because of heavy traffic on the
lists I had reinstall an email client to see the threads ;-)

Am 16.06.2011 16:39, schrieb Rob Weir:
> It might be worth describing how national language projects and the
> OpenOffce NLC has worked in the past.  I think this would be
> educational for our Apache mentors to understand a little of what they
> do.  It is much more than just translation.  They are almost more like
> affiliate organizations that promote OpenOffice in their countries.,
absolutely right ...
- costumer care (mailinglists, FAQ's aso.)
- promotion (fairs, events ...)
- proactive marketing
- press releases,
-
> They are the "face of OOo" in their respective countries.  But you
> could explain it better than me.
> A top level question for is is how we see this mapping to the Apache
> project.  The two extremes are:
>
> 1) Move all of this into the Apache project.  All 100+ translation
> projects, country marketing projects, etc.
>
-1
> 2) Have the national language projects run outside of Apache.  Since
> anyone can modify the code we released and repackage it and distribute
> it, it should be possible for any party to independently add
> translations and even rename it for distribution in their country.  Of
> course, while respecting the license and trademark requirements.
-1
> Of course, we can do some intermediate thing to.

yes, IMHO you/we should choose the intemediate way

> For example, it
> might work well to have volunteers who produce material that is
> directly included in a release, such as translations, localization
> patches, product help files, etc., be part of the Apache project.  But
> then there would be freedom for external groups to continue
> distributing, marketing, etc., localized versions outside of the
> Apache project.
+1
> One way to look at this is what your actual experience has been with
> this in OpenOffice before, in terms of patterns of collaboration and
> interaction.  For example, is there often peer-to-peer coordination
> required between the German and the Spanish language projects?

It was more or less like Apache works (as far as I can give an opioion 
of it).
"Don't talk, do it."  ...
(please observe:  I don't talk about what happend in Hamburg. ;-) )

As you can see for example the CD/DVD project in the german community.
It was created by a group which would like to offer a CD to the community.

But, as André reads here, he can talk a little bit more about. ;-)

> Or is
> it more of a hub-and-spokes model where the language "teams" are
> semi-autonomous, but coordinate with the main OOo project, receiving
> releases and submitting patches, etc.?
Yes, as well ;-) -
The model you will not find in a textbook. For me as an business
economist it was amazing to see how it worked. I was swarm
intelligence at it's best.
> I'd be interested in hearing arguments either way.
>
> -Rob
HTH

M.

excuse typos, grammer, diction or spelling


Re: Teams and Leads

Posted by Rob Weir <ap...@robweir.com>.
It might be worth describing how national language projects and the
OpenOffce NLC has worked in the past.  I think this would be
educational for our Apache mentors to understand a little of what they
do.  It is much more than just translation.  They are almost more like
affiliate organizations that promote OpenOffice in their countries.,
They are the "face of OOo" in their respective countries.  But you
could explain it better than me.

A top level question for is is how we see this mapping to the Apache
project.  The two extremes are:

1) Move all of this into the Apache project.  All 100+ translation
projects, country marketing projects, etc.

2) Have the national language projects run outside of Apache.  Since
anyone can modify the code we released and repackage it and distribute
it, it should be possible for any party to independently add
translations and even rename it for distribution in their country.  Of
course, while respecting the license and trademark requirements.

Of course, we can do some intermediate thing to.  For example, it
might work well to have volunteers who produce material that is
directly included in a release, such as translations, localization
patches, product help files, etc., be part of the Apache project.  But
then there would be freedom for external groups to continue
distributing, marketing, etc., localized versions outside of the
Apache project.

One way to look at this is what your actual experience has been with
this in OpenOffice before, in terms of patterns of collaboration and
interaction.  For example, is there often peer-to-peer coordination
required between the German and the Spanish language projects?  Or is
it more of a hub-and-spokes model where the language "teams" are
semi-autonomous, but coordinate with the main OOo project, receiving
releases and submitting patches, etc.?

I'd be interested in hearing arguments either way.

-Rob


On Thu, Jun 16, 2011 at 10:18 AM, Manfred A. Reiter <ma...@gmail.com> wrote:
> 2011/6/16 Rob Weir <ap...@robweir.com>:
>> On Thu, Jun 16, 2011 at 9:27 AM, RA Stehmann
>> <an...@rechtsanwalt-stehmann.de> wrote:
>>> I think we shouldn't invent the wheel twice ;-).
>>>
>>> The OpenOffice.org community has an more or less good working
>>> infrastructure of leads, contact persons, native lang communities,
>>> teams, mailing lists, websites etc..
>>>
>>> IMO we should make an inventory, keep the usefull elements and drop the
>>> dated. And let persons, who undertake the task of doing something and
>>> who are elected by the OpenOffice.org community, doing their job forward.
>>>
>>
>> That makes sense to me.  But I think this is less about "wearing
>> crowns" and more about "doing".  We don't need to give someone the
>> title of "X Lead".  But if someone steps up and starts doing X, and
>> does it well, works well in the project, and ensure that decisions
>> occur via consensus on the list, than that person will start taking on
>> the attributes of the de facto "X Lead".
>>
>> We have a request entered with Apache Infrastructure for a wiki to
>> help us with your second point.  Once we have the wiki it should be
>> possible to map out a inventory or "site map" of the existing
>> OpenOffice.org web site.   So maybe a big table listing each of the
>> subsites or services on OpenOffice.org, along with columns for
>> "migrate/archive/trash", "priority" and "volunteer".  Something like
>> that.
>>
>
> to have an idea ... these are the current mailinglists
> in the OOo ... german subdomain.
>
> announce@de.openoffice.org
> dev@de.openoffice.org
> users@de.openoffice.org
> cvs@de.openoffice.org
> issues@de.openoffice.org
> marketing@de.openoffice.org
> qa@de.openoffice.org
> business@de.openoffice.org
> ooocamp@de.openoffice.org
> cdrom@de.openoffice.org
>
> at the beginning the geramanophone branche of OOo startet with only
> *two* mailinglist
> all the others where created according to the needs of the German Project.
>
> I don't know how ot organise the national parts of the project.
> Subdomains?
>
> But IMHO each "national project" should start with at least a userlist
> and a list to organise the "national needs" ;-)
>
> ... Ingrid ... Christian other ideas?
>
>
> Manfred
> excuse typos, grammer and diction
>

Re: Teams and Leads

Posted by "Manfred A. Reiter" <ma...@gmail.com>.
2011/6/16 Rob Weir <ap...@robweir.com>:
> On Thu, Jun 16, 2011 at 9:27 AM, RA Stehmann
> <an...@rechtsanwalt-stehmann.de> wrote:
>> I think we shouldn't invent the wheel twice ;-).
>>
>> The OpenOffice.org community has an more or less good working
>> infrastructure of leads, contact persons, native lang communities,
>> teams, mailing lists, websites etc..
>>
>> IMO we should make an inventory, keep the usefull elements and drop the
>> dated. And let persons, who undertake the task of doing something and
>> who are elected by the OpenOffice.org community, doing their job forward.
>>
>
> That makes sense to me.  But I think this is less about "wearing
> crowns" and more about "doing".  We don't need to give someone the
> title of "X Lead".  But if someone steps up and starts doing X, and
> does it well, works well in the project, and ensure that decisions
> occur via consensus on the list, than that person will start taking on
> the attributes of the de facto "X Lead".
>
> We have a request entered with Apache Infrastructure for a wiki to
> help us with your second point.  Once we have the wiki it should be
> possible to map out a inventory or "site map" of the existing
> OpenOffice.org web site.   So maybe a big table listing each of the
> subsites or services on OpenOffice.org, along with columns for
> "migrate/archive/trash", "priority" and "volunteer".  Something like
> that.
>

to have an idea ... these are the current mailinglists
in the OOo ... german subdomain.

announce@de.openoffice.org
dev@de.openoffice.org
users@de.openoffice.org
cvs@de.openoffice.org
issues@de.openoffice.org
marketing@de.openoffice.org
qa@de.openoffice.org
business@de.openoffice.org
ooocamp@de.openoffice.org
cdrom@de.openoffice.org

at the beginning the geramanophone branche of OOo startet with only
*two* mailinglist
all the others where created according to the needs of the German Project.

I don't know how ot organise the national parts of the project.
Subdomains?

But IMHO each "national project" should start with at least a userlist
and a list to organise the "national needs" ;-)

... Ingrid ... Christian other ideas?


Manfred
excuse typos, grammer and diction

Re: Teams and Leads

Posted by Rob Weir <ap...@robweir.com>.
On Thu, Jun 16, 2011 at 9:27 AM, RA Stehmann
<an...@rechtsanwalt-stehmann.de> wrote:
> I think we shouldn't invent the wheel twice ;-).
>
> The OpenOffice.org community has an more or less good working
> infrastructure of leads, contact persons, native lang communities,
> teams, mailing lists, websites etc..
>
> IMO we should make an inventory, keep the usefull elements and drop the
> dated. And let persons, who undertake the task of doing something and
> who are elected by the OpenOffice.org community, doing their job forward.
>

That makes sense to me.  But I think this is less about "wearing
crowns" and more about "doing".  We don't need to give someone the
title of "X Lead".  But if someone steps up and starts doing X, and
does it well, works well in the project, and ensure that decisions
occur via consensus on the list, than that person will start taking on
the attributes of the de facto "X Lead".

We have a request entered with Apache Infrastructure for a wiki to
help us with your second point.  Once we have the wiki it should be
possible to map out a inventory or "site map" of the existing
OpenOffice.org web site.   So maybe a big table listing each of the
subsites or services on OpenOffice.org, along with columns for
"migrate/archive/trash", "priority" and "volunteer".  Something like
that.

-Rob

Re: Teams and Leads

Posted by Ian Lynch <ia...@gmail.com>.
On 16 June 2011 14:27, RA Stehmann <an...@rechtsanwalt-stehmann.de> wrote:

> I think we shouldn't invent the wheel twice ;-).
>
> The OpenOffice.org community has an more or less good working
> infrastructure of leads, contact persons, native lang communities,
> teams, mailing lists, websites etc..
>

This might be a daft question but where will these be hosted? Do they all
get moved from Oracle to Apache hosting?

IMO we should make an inventory, keep the usefull elements and drop the
> dated. And let persons, who undertake the task of doing something and
> who are elected by the OpenOffice.org community, doing their job forward.
>

Agree that it should be possible from past history to see which lists are
active and which aren't. For teams and leaders that has to be some focus for
communication. Setting up subject threads here for those active mailing
lists would enable the participants to decide here what to do. Discontinue,
move to an existing list, set up a new list. I say here so to start with
there are not several separate conversations going on in parallel :-)

-- 
Ian

Ofqual Accredited IT Qualifications (The Schools ITQ)

www.theINGOTs.org +44 (0)1827 305940

The Learning Machine Limited, Reg Office, 36 Ashby Road, Tamworth,
Staffordshire, B79 8AQ. Reg No: 05560797, Registered in England and
Wales.

Re: Teams and Leads

Posted by Ross Gardler <rg...@apache.org>.
On 16/06/2011 14:27, RA Stehmann wrote:
> I think we shouldn't invent the wheel twice ;-).

So you want to reinvent the Apache wheel instead? For all 170+ projects?

I do agree the task is to make the OO.o model fit within the ASF model, 
but that will involve some changes. The good news is that in the vast 
majority of changes it will make running the OO.o project easier.

The ASF is designed to let project contributors get on with 
contributing. We have existing infrastructure for handling the generic 
stuff (press, trademarks, legal etc.) The OO.o project would be best 
using it.

> The OpenOffice.org community has an more or less good working
> infrastructure of leads, contact persons, native lang communities,
> teams, mailing lists, websites etc..

As explained elsewhere in the thread it is only the language that seems 
to be a problem.

ASF does not have "leaders", it does have people who lead by doing. 
We're told that that's how the OO.o project works too - no problem

There is only one contact point. The "contact persons" should do their 
business through that contact point. This allows others to step in and 
help should the "contact person" be busy - no problem.

Native lang communities can be created as and when they are needed. 
However, all development must be done here, on this list. There needs to 
be people connecting native language communities to this list to make 
sure their needs are heard here, in the common language of the project. 
These communities should be created when there is a demonstratable need 
(that's up to the project contributors to judge)

mailing lists, websites etc. will be moved, as needed, to ASF 
infrastructure as and when needed - this is already underway.

> IMO we should make an inventory, keep the usefull elements and drop the
> dated. And let persons, who undertake the task of doing something and
> who are elected by the OpenOffice.org community, doing their job forward.

+1

Ross

Re: Teams and Leads

Posted by RA Stehmann <an...@rechtsanwalt-stehmann.de>.
I think we shouldn't invent the wheel twice ;-).

The OpenOffice.org community has an more or less good working
infrastructure of leads, contact persons, native lang communities,
teams, mailing lists, websites etc..

IMO we should make an inventory, keep the usefull elements and drop the
dated. And let persons, who undertake the task of doing something and
who are elected by the OpenOffice.org community, doing their job forward.

Regards
Michael


Re: Teams and Leads

Posted by "Manfred A. Reiter" <ma...@gmail.com>.
upps ...

2011/6/16 Ross Gardler <rg...@apache.org>:

[...]

>> IMHO that was the question from Kazunari Hirano.
>> https://mail.google.com/mail/?shva=1#label/...ApacheOOo/13092fd2961dd406
>> Unfortunately his has now answer until now.
>
> That link is no use to people not using GMail, I can't see the mail in my
> inbox. Sorry
>

I'm sorry ...

http://mail-archives.apache.org/mod_mbox/incubator-ooo-dev/201106.mbox/%3CBANLkTinR1SyreyOB7HfaaGv1K67CSYVDLg@mail.gmail.com%3E

:-(

M.

Re: Teams and Leads

Posted by Ross Gardler <rg...@apache.org>.
On 16/06/2011 13:47, Manfred A. Reiter wrote:
> Hi Sam, *,
>
> 2011/6/16 Sam Ruby<ru...@intertwingly.net>:
>> On Thu, Jun 16, 2011 at 6:47 AM, IngridvdM<In...@gmx-topmail.de>  wrote:
>>>
>>> I am really in favor of going without anyone being named leader or manager
>>> or any name that could create the impression that this person has more
>>> rights than the others. Maybe we can choose 'contact' as a neutral
>>> description in case something turns out to be needed? Or is there even a
>>> more neutral word?
>>
>> The only 'contact' that people need for this project is
>> ooo-dev@incubator.apache.org.
>
> As long as we're talking about people like us. ;-)
> But: what's with an enduser in Nagano, japan or an enduser in Chapéco, Brasil?

At some point it will make sense to create an ooo-user@ mailing list. As 
Sam says below, new contact points can be created if/when they are needed.

>> If this list grows too large or too busy, then we can create
>> additional 'contacts' in the form of more mailing lists.
>
> Is it intended from NewOOo to deliver final products to the market?
>
> If yes,
> than IMHO we should think *right now*
> about an infrastructure for these parts of the project.
> else ...
>
> Or do you think that there are too many unstability still in the process?

Generally the ASF approach is to *only* create additional channels when 
the noise in the existing channels is too high. We are nowhere near that 
point yet. At this point of incubation users are a key part of the 
development process for this project.

For example, how can we answer your question above without understanding 
what both the project members and its users want?

> Nevertheless: The earlier you start these national projects, the more
> uncertainty is removed from the market.

You don't need a separate contact point to start working on these issues.

> IMHO that was the question from Kazunari Hirano.
> https://mail.google.com/mail/?shva=1#label/...ApacheOOo/13092fd2961dd406
> Unfortunately his has now answer until now.

That link is no use to people not using GMail, I can't see the mail in 
my inbox. Sorry

Ross

-- 
rgardler@apache.org
@rgardler

Re: Teams and Leads (was: Proposed short term goals)

Posted by "Manfred A. Reiter" <ma...@gmail.com>.
Hi Sam, *,

2011/6/16 Sam Ruby <ru...@intertwingly.net>:
> On Thu, Jun 16, 2011 at 6:47 AM, IngridvdM <In...@gmx-topmail.de> wrote:
>>
>> I am really in favor of going without anyone being named leader or manager
>> or any name that could create the impression that this person has more
>> rights than the others. Maybe we can choose 'contact' as a neutral
>> description in case something turns out to be needed? Or is there even a
>> more neutral word?
>
> The only 'contact' that people need for this project is
> ooo-dev@incubator.apache.org.

As long as we're talking about people like us. ;-)
But: what's with an enduser in Nagano, japan or an enduser in Chapéco, Brasil?


> If this list grows too large or too busy, then we can create
> additional 'contacts' in the form of more mailing lists.

Is it intended from NewOOo to deliver final products to the market?

If yes,
than IMHO we should think *right now*
about an infrastructure for these parts of the project.
else ...

Or do you think that there are too many unstability still in the process?

Nevertheless: The earlier you start these national projects, the more
uncertainty is removed from the market.

IMHO that was the question from Kazunari Hirano.
https://mail.google.com/mail/?shva=1#label/...ApacheOOo/13092fd2961dd406
Unfortunately his has now answer until now.

If would be fine, if a "almighty" could answer the questions of our
friends from Japan.

0,02 eurocents

M.

Re: Teams and Leads

Posted by Steve Lee <st...@fullmeasure.co.uk>.
On 16 June 2011 14:23, Ian Lynch <ia...@gmail.com> wrote:
> Thanks, still learning. Hopefully this process will help other newbies too.
> :-)

+1

To this I'd like to add that already having only scanned and dipped
into some of the conversations I've already learned an enormous
amount.

Excellent.

Steve Lee

Re: Teams and Leads

Posted by Ian Lynch <ia...@gmail.com>.
>
>
>  Sam has effectively done that in his reply to this thread that was copied
>>> to the trademarks PMC. Trademarks will assess the situation and respond
>>> via
>>> both the trademarks and this list.
>>>
>>>
>> Ok, thanks. I think it is important that ordinary members have an
>> opportunity to comment either one way or another so we are seen to be
>> acting
>> openly.
>>
>
> +1
>
> If you intention was  to actually ask for permission in your case it would
> have been a good idea to start a new thread (or at least change the subject
> to something like "permission to use OO.o trademark) as Sam did when copying
> to trademarks.


Thanks, still learning. Hopefully this process will help other newbies too.
:-)

-- 
Ian

Ofqual Accredited IT Qualifications (The Schools ITQ)

www.theINGOTs.org +44 (0)1827 305940

The Learning Machine Limited, Reg Office, 36 Ashby Road, Tamworth,
Staffordshire, B79 8AQ. Reg No: 05560797, Registered in England and
Wales.

Re: Teams and Leads

Posted by Ross Gardler <rg...@apache.org>.
On 16/06/2011 14:08, Ian Lynch wrote:
> On 16 June 2011 14:04, Ross Gardler<rg...@apache.org>  wrote:

...

>> Sam has effectively done that in his reply to this thread that was copied
>> to the trademarks PMC. Trademarks will assess the situation and respond via
>> both the trademarks and this list.
>>
>
> Ok, thanks. I think it is important that ordinary members have an
> opportunity to comment either one way or another so we are seen to be acting
> openly.

+1

If you intention was  to actually ask for permission in your case it 
would have been a good idea to start a new thread (or at least change 
the subject to something like "permission to use OO.o trademark) as Sam 
did when copying to trademarks.

Ross

-- 
rgardler@apache.org
@rgardler

Re: Teams and Leads

Posted by Ian Lynch <ia...@gmail.com>.
On 16 June 2011 14:04, Ross Gardler <rg...@apache.org> wrote:

> On 16/06/2011 13:49, Ian Lynch wrote:
>
>> But presumably if we want broader community support this list is the place
>> to get it? I will talk to the trademark committee but I feel happier if
>> this
>> is as public as possible.
>>
>
> Ahhh... I see what you were "testing" in your original email. I thought you
> were testing whether there were sufficient contact points if ooo-dev was not
> felt to be appropriate. I see now you were testing if this list could give
> you an answer.
>
> Let me try and answer again.
>
> The OO.o PMC is expected to police any trademarks associated with the
> project. THe trademarks committee is there to help the PMC interpret the
> policy and, if necessary, to enforce it on behalf of the PMC.
>
> So in my original reply rather than saying "if you were confident that your
> use conformed to the ASF policy" I should have said, "if the PMC is
> confident that your use conforms to the ASF policy they can say so, if not
> they can ask advice of trademarks".
>
> However, the PMC doesn't give permission, the trademarks committee does. So
> if you (as requestor) want formal permission the PMC would have to ask the
> trademarks committee to do so.
>
> Sam has effectively done that in his reply to this thread that was copied
> to the trademarks PMC. Trademarks will assess the situation and respond via
> both the trademarks and this list.
>

Ok, thanks. I think it is important that ordinary members have an
opportunity to comment either one way or another so we are seen to be acting
openly.

-- 
Ian

Ofqual Accredited IT Qualifications (The Schools ITQ)

www.theINGOTs.org +44 (0)1827 305940

The Learning Machine Limited, Reg Office, 36 Ashby Road, Tamworth,
Staffordshire, B79 8AQ. Reg No: 05560797, Registered in England and
Wales.

Re: Teams and Leads

Posted by Ross Gardler <rg...@apache.org>.
On 16/06/2011 13:49, Ian Lynch wrote:
> But presumably if we want broader community support this list is the place
> to get it? I will talk to the trademark committee but I feel happier if this
> is as public as possible.

Ahhh... I see what you were "testing" in your original email. I thought 
you were testing whether there were sufficient contact points if ooo-dev 
was not felt to be appropriate. I see now you were testing if this list 
could give you an answer.

Let me try and answer again.

The OO.o PMC is expected to police any trademarks associated with the 
project. THe trademarks committee is there to help the PMC interpret the 
policy and, if necessary, to enforce it on behalf of the PMC.

So in my original reply rather than saying "if you were confident that 
your use conformed to the ASF policy" I should have said, "if the PMC is 
confident that your use conforms to the ASF policy they can say so, if 
not they can ask advice of trademarks".

However, the PMC doesn't give permission, the trademarks committee does. 
So if you (as requestor) want formal permission the PMC would have to 
ask the trademarks committee to do so.

Sam has effectively done that in his reply to this thread that was 
copied to the trademarks PMC. Trademarks will assess the situation and 
respond via both the trademarks and this list.

Ross



>
> The trademarks committee will either grant or refuse permission (usually
>> after consulting with the OO.o PMC).
>>
>> Ross
>>
>> [1] http://www.apache.org/foundation/marks/
>>
>> --
>> rgardler@apache.org
>> @rgardler
>>
>
>
>


-- 
rgardler@apache.org
@rgardler

Re: Teams and Leads

Posted by Ian Lynch <ia...@gmail.com>.
>
> ASSUMPTION: The OOo trademark is assigned to the ASF as expected
>
>
> First point of call is the ASF trademark policy [1]. If you are confident
> your use complies with the policy then no formal permission is required.
>

That's the problem, I have read this and I'm not certain that nominative use
is the right interpretation. Really we want community backing and that
implies more than nominative use and I want to err on the side of caution so
there is no possibility later of misunderstandings etc. Also think these
things should be open and transparent.

If you feel you need formal permission then trademarks@apache.org is the
> contact point as described in the policy.
>

But presumably if we want broader community support this list is the place
to get it? I will talk to the trademark committee but I feel happier if this
is as public as possible.

The trademarks committee will either grant or refuse permission (usually
> after consulting with the OO.o PMC).
>
> Ross
>
> [1] http://www.apache.org/foundation/marks/
>
> --
> rgardler@apache.org
> @rgardler
>



-- 
Ian

Ofqual Accredited IT Qualifications (The Schools ITQ)

www.theINGOTs.org +44 (0)1827 305940

The Learning Machine Limited, Reg Office, 36 Ashby Road, Tamworth,
Staffordshire, B79 8AQ. Reg No: 05560797, Registered in England and
Wales.

Re: Teams and Leads

Posted by Ross Gardler <rg...@apache.org>.
On 16/06/2011 12:52, Ian Lynch wrote:
> On 16 June 2011 12:00, Sam Ruby<ru...@intertwingly.net>  wrote:
>
>> On Thu, Jun 16, 2011 at 6:47 AM, IngridvdM<In...@gmx-topmail.de>
>> wrote:
>>>
>>> I am really in favor of going without anyone being named leader or
>> manager
>>> or any name that could create the impression that this person has more
>>> rights than the others. Maybe we can choose 'contact' as a neutral
>>> description in case something turns out to be needed? Or is there even a
>>> more neutral word?
>>
>> The only 'contact' that people need for this project is
>> ooo-dev@incubator.apache.org.
>>
>> If this list grows too large or too busy, then we can create
>> additional 'contacts' in the form of more mailing lists.
>
>
> OK, sounds sensible to try using what already exists until there is a good
> reason not too :-)
>
> Let me test the system ;-)

<snip what="a description of why trademark permission is required"/>

>
> So what I'm asking for is permission to use the OOo Trademark and general
> community support.

ASSUMPTION: The OOo trademark is assigned to the ASF as expected

First point of call is the ASF trademark policy [1]. If you are 
confident your use complies with the policy then no formal permission is 
required.

If you feel you need formal permission then trademarks@apache.org is the 
contact point as described in the policy.

The trademarks committee will either grant or refuse permission (usually 
after consulting with the OO.o PMC).

Ross

[1] http://www.apache.org/foundation/marks/


-- 
rgardler@apache.org
@rgardler

Re: Teams and Leads (was: Proposed short term goals)

Posted by Ian Lynch <ia...@gmail.com>.
On 16 June 2011 12:00, Sam Ruby <ru...@intertwingly.net> wrote:

> On Thu, Jun 16, 2011 at 6:47 AM, IngridvdM <In...@gmx-topmail.de>
> wrote:
> >
> > I am really in favor of going without anyone being named leader or
> manager
> > or any name that could create the impression that this person has more
> > rights than the others. Maybe we can choose 'contact' as a neutral
> > description in case something turns out to be needed? Or is there even a
> > more neutral word?
>
> The only 'contact' that people need for this project is
> ooo-dev@incubator.apache.org.
>
> If this list grows too large or too busy, then we can create
> additional 'contacts' in the form of more mailing lists.


OK, sounds sensible to try using what already exists until there is a good
reason not too :-)

Let me test the system ;-)

Alexandro Colorado and myself (both been involved with the OOo community for
years) have been negotiating with a large training company to provide a
community backed certification for OOo but with a vector to potentially 1500
centres. I previously sought and was granted permission by Oracle to use the
OOo branding on certificates. I guess we need community consensus here now,
to carry on with that. There is quite a long history to all this and I
declare a financial interest. I set up a UK government accredited awarding
organisation (The Learning Machine Ltd) to enable a mechanism for funding
FOSS and CC education development that was independent of licensing ie the
business model is QA so no problem licensing any supporting stuff freely.

To get started required investment so the only way to do that was to set up
a for profit and sell shares. That together with EU grants has put well over
£1m of investment into this. We have had some successes such as schools that
started using our generic certification with MS products that have now
switched to OOo. I can get the FOSS voice heard in influential government
places. The strategy is in general to be product neutral but to use FOSS for
all exemplars and supporting materials. This gives us a channel to get
closed source users at least in contact with FOSS so there is a clear
marketing strategy. With OOo certification we can say eg the WP certificate
was achieved in the context of OOo Writer and put an OOo logo on the
certificate. The assessment criteria are generic so we could do the same
with LibO, Koffice etc. or indeed any FOSS software project, Inkscape, Gimp,
Audacity etc. WE could even do professional Apache qualifications if there
was a demand. Once we work out delivery costs (Its variable and depends on
volume) we give a kick back to community funds in return for using the
branding. We have the infrastructure in place using a LAMP stack for
assessment and certification and Drupal for community support with dynamic
links between the 2. Portal is at www.theingots.org. The acronym INGOT is
International Grades - Open Technologies.

We are accredited by Ofqual the UK national exam regulators and endorsed by
the UK Sector Skills Council for Business and IT. All our qualifications are
referenced to the European Qualifications Framework. We have 2 EU Transfer
of innovation projects and we are monitored by all these so the community
can have some confidence that we "know what we are doing". My background is
that I was a UK School Inspection Team leader and assessor of the National
Professional Qualification for Headteachers.

So what I'm asking for is permission to use the OOo Trademark and general
community support.

Trying to keep this reasonably short so please feel free to ask any
questions.

-- 
Ian

Ofqual Accredited IT Qualifications (The Schools ITQ)

www.theINGOTs.org +44 (0)1827 305940

The Learning Machine Limited, Reg Office, 36 Ashby Road, Tamworth,
Staffordshire, B79 8AQ. Reg No: 05560797, Registered in England and
Wales.

Re: Teams and Leads (was: Proposed short term goals)

Posted by "Manfred A. Reiter" <ma...@gmail.com>.
Hi Dennis,

2011/6/16 Dennis E. Hamilton <de...@acm.org>:
> +1
>
> (I also favor not solving a problem we don't have [yet].)
>

what you are talking about, I hope you are not
reffering on the following email

http://mail-archives.apache.org/mod_mbox/incubator-ooo-dev/201106.mbox/%3CBANLkTinR1SyreyOB7HfaaGv1K67CSYVDLg@mail.gmail.com%3E

cheers

M.

RE: Teams and Leads (was: Proposed short term goals)

Posted by "Dennis E. Hamilton" <de...@acm.org>.
+1

(I also favor not solving a problem we don't have [yet].)

-----Original Message-----
From: IngridvdM [mailto:IngridvdM@gmx-topmail.de] 
Sent: Thursday, June 16, 2011 04:15
To: ooo-dev@incubator.apache.org
Subject: Re: Teams and Leads (was: Proposed short term goals)

Am 16.06.2011 13:00, schrieb Sam Ruby:
> The only 'contact' that people need for this project is
> ooo-dev@incubator.apache.org.
>
> If this list grows too large or too busy, then we can create
> additional 'contacts' in the form of more mailing lists.
>

Great! :-)

Ingrid


Re: Teams and Leads (was: Proposed short term goals)

Posted by IngridvdM <In...@gmx-topmail.de>.
Am 16.06.2011 13:00, schrieb Sam Ruby:
> The only 'contact' that people need for this project is
> ooo-dev@incubator.apache.org.
>
> If this list grows too large or too busy, then we can create
> additional 'contacts' in the form of more mailing lists.
>

Great! :-)

Ingrid

Re: Teams and Leads

Posted by Ross Gardler <rg...@apache.org>.
On 16/06/2011 12:44, RA Stehmann wrote:
> Sam Ruby schrieb:
>
>> The only 'contact' that people need for this project is
>> ooo-dev@incubator.apache.org.
>>
>
> I don't think so. If for example the press wants to know, what's new in
> OpenOffice.org version x.y, you cann't say, ask at ooo-dev ... . They
> need a contact person or more than one in each native lang community.
>

That would be press@apache.org, who would liaise with the OOo PMC. Only 
the ASF can speak for the ASF, each of the committers speak for themselves.

So the press can ask Fred Blogs what's new, but that will be Freds 
opinion not an official statement.

I realise you are trying to make a more general point with a concrete 
answer, I'm confident the mentors will be able to point you to the right 
contact point in each case.

Ross

Re: Teams and Leads (was: Proposed short term goals)

Posted by Sam Ruby <ru...@intertwingly.net>.
On Thu, Jun 16, 2011 at 7:44 AM, RA Stehmann
<an...@rechtsanwalt-stehmann.de> wrote:
> Sam Ruby schrieb:
>
>> The only 'contact' that people need for this project is
>> ooo-dev@incubator.apache.org.
>
> I don't think so. If for example the press wants to know, what's new in
> OpenOffice.org version x.y, you cann't say, ask at ooo-dev ... . They
> need a contact person or more than one in each native lang community.

We have a 'contact' for that too:

http://www.apache.org/press/index.html#contact

> Regards
> Michael

- Sam Ruby

Re: Teams and Leads (was: Proposed short term goals)

Posted by RA Stehmann <an...@rechtsanwalt-stehmann.de>.
Sam Ruby schrieb:

> The only 'contact' that people need for this project is
> ooo-dev@incubator.apache.org.
> 

I don't think so. If for example the press wants to know, what's new in
OpenOffice.org version x.y, you cann't say, ask at ooo-dev ... . They
need a contact person or more than one in each native lang community.

Regards
Michael




Re: Teams and Leads (was: Proposed short term goals)

Posted by Sam Ruby <ru...@intertwingly.net>.
On Thu, Jun 16, 2011 at 6:47 AM, IngridvdM <In...@gmx-topmail.de> wrote:
>
> I am really in favor of going without anyone being named leader or manager
> or any name that could create the impression that this person has more
> rights than the others. Maybe we can choose 'contact' as a neutral
> description in case something turns out to be needed? Or is there even a
> more neutral word?

The only 'contact' that people need for this project is
ooo-dev@incubator.apache.org.

If this list grows too large or too busy, then we can create
additional 'contacts' in the form of more mailing lists.

> Ingrid

- Sam Ruby

Re: Teams and Leads (was: Proposed short term goals)

Posted by IngridvdM <In...@gmx-topmail.de>.
Am 16.06.2011 13:29, schrieb Christian Grobmeier:
>> I am really in favor of going without anyone being named leader or manager
>> or any name that could create the impression that this person has more
>> rights than the others. Maybe we can choose 'contact' as a neutral
>> description in case something turns out to be needed? Or is there even a
>> more neutral word?
>>
>> Christian Grobmeier has mentioned "workforces". That sounds interesting. Is
>> there more about that in the documentation somewhere?
>
> Its a term from me, it is not official.
>
> It is a bit like Sam said: if you subscribe to a mailinglist, then you
> part of a "workforce".
> Like subscribing to ooo-dev@incubator.apache.org makes you - if you
> write emails - to a contributor and therefore to a part of the
> developers workforce.
>
> If the project decides that a new workforce is needed, like
> "translations", it can simply be established with a new mailinglist
> like ooo-translations@i.a.o
> Everybody can subscribe and help with working.
>
> That being said, "workforce" is a bit an unnecessary term - i
> described a bunch of people having fun to discuss similar topics at
> one mailinglist.

:-). I like that style very much! Thank you for the additional explanation!

Ingrid

Re: Teams and Leads (was: Proposed short term goals)

Posted by Christian Grobmeier <gr...@gmail.com>.
> I am really in favor of going without anyone being named leader or manager
> or any name that could create the impression that this person has more
> rights than the others. Maybe we can choose 'contact' as a neutral
> description in case something turns out to be needed? Or is there even a
> more neutral word?
>
> Christian Grobmeier has mentioned "workforces". That sounds interesting. Is
> there more about that in the documentation somewhere?

Its a term from me, it is not official.

It is a bit like Sam said: if you subscribe to a mailinglist, then you
part of a "workforce".
Like subscribing to ooo-dev@incubator.apache.org makes you - if you
write emails - to a contributor and therefore to a part of the
developers workforce.

If the project decides that a new workforce is needed, like
"translations", it can simply be established with a new mailinglist
like ooo-translations@i.a.o
Everybody can subscribe and help with working.

That being said, "workforce" is a bit an unnecessary term - i
described a bunch of people having fun to discuss similar topics at
one mailinglist.

Cheers

Re: Teams and Leads (was: Proposed short term goals)

Posted by IngridvdM <In...@gmx-topmail.de>.
Am 16.06.2011 11:52, schrieb Ian Lynch:
> On 16 June 2011 10:44, RA Stehmann<an...@rechtsanwalt-stehmann.de>  wrote:
>
>> IMO the things aren't very different, even you talk about "meritocracy"
>> and I about "democratic culture" (that is more than "one man, one
>> vote"). In their teams or communities leads have the same vote like
>> every other member.
>>
>> Also in the OpenOffice.org project people try to do their best to find a
>> consensus based on the respect to each other. There wasn't any
>> "benevolent dictator".
>>
>
> I guess the community manager Louis was the nearest thing to this. Question
> is whether the same structure is maintained or whether it needs to start
> afresh? How will that decision be made?
>
> In a bigger community you need some structure to work efficiently (see
>> for an example the Debian project). OpenOffice.org has tried to find
>> such a structure. Nothing is carved in stone. But something is worth to
>> keep.
>>
>
> The faster a structure is in place the quicker it will be to get going. OTOH
> the structure will have to have consensus to be accepted and it will have to
> have the possibility for change in the future.
>

I would like to try the structures and ways Apache has. That everybody 
has a voice at Apache and that the goal is to seek consensus by 
exchanging arguments is a very democratic aspect. That in the end those 
do that choose to participate more is the meritocratic aspect. I think 
this is highly fair.
I am not so convinced that the structures we had on old OOo have been 
good. Obviously there has been to much room for distrust and hidden 
discussions, so repeatedly individuals or whole groups felt excluded on 
multiple sides.

I am really in favor of going without anyone being named leader or 
manager or any name that could create the impression that this person 
has more rights than the others. Maybe we can choose 'contact' as a 
neutral description in case something turns out to be needed? Or is 
there even a more neutral word?

Christian Grobmeier has mentioned "workforces". That sounds interesting. 
Is there more about that in the documentation somewhere?

Ingrid


Re: Teams and Leads (was: Proposed short term goals)

Posted by Ian Lynch <ia...@gmail.com>.
On 16 June 2011 10:44, RA Stehmann <an...@rechtsanwalt-stehmann.de> wrote:

> IMO the things aren't very different, even you talk about "meritocracy"
> and I about "democratic culture" (that is more than "one man, one
> vote"). In their teams or communities leads have the same vote like
> every other member.
>
> Also in the OpenOffice.org project people try to do their best to find a
> consensus based on the respect to each other. There wasn't any
> "benevolent dictator".
>

I guess the community manager Louis was the nearest thing to this. Question
is whether the same structure is maintained or whether it needs to start
afresh? How will that decision be made?

In a bigger community you need some structure to work efficiently (see
> for an example the Debian project). OpenOffice.org has tried to find
> such a structure. Nothing is carved in stone. But something is worth to
> keep.
>

The faster a structure is in place the quicker it will be to get going. OTOH
the structure will have to have consensus to be accepted and it will have to
have the possibility for change in the future.

-- 
Ian

Ofqual Accredited IT Qualifications (The Schools ITQ)

www.theINGOTs.org +44 (0)1827 305940

The Learning Machine Limited, Reg Office, 36 Ashby Road, Tamworth,
Staffordshire, B79 8AQ. Reg No: 05560797, Registered in England and
Wales.

Re: Teams and Leads (was: Proposed short term goals)

Posted by "Manfred A. Reiter" <ma...@gmail.com>.
Am 16.06.2011 21:15, schrieb Greg Stein:
> On Thu, Jun 16, 2011 at 05:44, RA Stehmann
> <an...@rechtsanwalt-stehmann.de>  wrote:
>> ...
>> In a bigger community you need some structure to work efficiently (see
>> for an example the Debian project).
> Wow. I never thought I would see "Debian" and "efficient" in the same sentence.
>
> My life is now complete.
>
> ;-)
and what are you doing tomorrow onwards?

Your life beeing complete sounds pretty final
with no chance for further discoveries ;-)

M.

Re: Teams and Leads (was: Proposed short term goals)

Posted by Greg Stein <gs...@gmail.com>.
On Thu, Jun 16, 2011 at 05:44, RA Stehmann
<an...@rechtsanwalt-stehmann.de> wrote:
>...
> In a bigger community you need some structure to work efficiently (see
> for an example the Debian project).

Wow. I never thought I would see "Debian" and "efficient" in the same sentence.

My life is now complete.


;-)

Re: Teams and Leads (was: Proposed short term goals)

Posted by RA Stehmann <an...@rechtsanwalt-stehmann.de>.
IMO the things aren't very different, even you talk about "meritocracy"
and I about "democratic culture" (that is more than "one man, one
vote"). In their teams or communities leads have the same vote like
every other member.

Also in the OpenOffice.org project people try to do their best to find a
consensus based on the respect to each other. There wasn't any
"benevolent dictator".

In a bigger community you need some structure to work efficiently (see
for an example the Debian project). OpenOffice.org has tried to find
such a structure. Nothing is carved in stone. But something is worth to
keep.

Regards
Michael


Re: Teams and Leads (was: Proposed short term goals)

Posted by Christian Grobmeier <gr...@gmail.com>.
> I read, there is no single vision on how PMCs should run a project and
> the communities they host. So I think the OpenOffice.org community can
> create or better bring in its own customary constitution even it's
> hosted by Apache.
>
> OpenOffice.org is a little bit different from other Apache projects.
> That makes sense to gover it in a different way.

I agree that OOo might need some other things as other projects. I
also agree with the freedom a PMC has inside the ASF.

But before rules are established: the ASF is a meritocracy.

The voice of a - lets say "responsible" - for a specific task is not
more worth than the voice of every other PMC at the project. As long
as this is respected I think it is OK to go. In fact, I also think
there will be (and must be) some specific roles in OOo such as
"translators", "end user managers" along to "dev", or "PMC".

On the leading, I believe a leader will "grow" out of the masses and
"lead" as long as he does it. There is no need to name somebody imho -
they are acting as leaders and respected or not. In many cases there
are many leaders. If you want to name "responsibles", then you can
name a set of people who are committing to the specific part of the
project.

For example: http://commons.apache.org/compress/team-list.html
The commons project is made out of tons of people. For this specific
component only a few of them care. We have named them, just in case.
But everybody at commons has the same rights on the component as the
named people have. everybody can veto against decision.

I think there is need to name "workforces" like "translators". They
are - imho - pretty similar to components in commons. A workforce does
its work on a specific mailinglist. So, translators should have their
own mailinglist were they are not bothered with technical details.

What Greg wanted to express (or what I think he wanted to express) is,
that every committer in every "workforce" can vote and raise his voice
in the matters of the other workforce. This not really likely to
happen but might. For example, a dev guy can vote against a decision
in the translator workforce. On the other hand, every PMC working
mainly on the "translator" list might veto against a technical
decision.

Re: Teams and Leads (was: Proposed short term goals)

Posted by RA Stehmann <an...@rechtsanwalt-stehmann.de>.
Greg Stein schrieb:

> We certainly don't have "Leads". I know that is a different model from
> how the OOo community has operated in the past. We'll need to find
> ways to coordinate actions. It is certainly possible to have
> "coordinators" or "managers" (such as a Release Manager, or Patch
> Manager), but these are different from "Leads". They have no more say
> than anybody else in the community. They are just the focal point for
> coordinating the broader activities.
> 
To be "lead" in the OpenOffice.org project never has been a question of
power but of responsibility.

Their only power is the power of those who do. It's the same for other
officers in the OpenOffice.org project.

I read, there is no single vision on how PMCs should run a project and
the communities they host. So I think the OpenOffice.org community can
create or better bring in its own customary constitution even it's
hosted by Apache.

OpenOffice.org is a little bit different from other Apache projects.
That makes sense to gover it in a different way.

Regards
Michael