You are viewing a plain text version of this content. The canonical link for it is here.
Posted to dev@netbeans.apache.org by Jaroslav Tulach <ja...@oracle.com> on 2017/09/06 17:37:06 UTC
Do you count or blindly trust was: (Main) NetBeans source to Apache
Dear Bertrand,
thanks for your patience.
On úterý 5. září 2017 14:41:30 CEST Bertrand Delacretaz wrote:
> On Tue, Sep 5, 2017 at 11:24 AM, Geertjan Wielenga
>
> <ge...@googlemail.com> wrote:
> > ...We're following the advice of caution -- and waiting to hear
> > whether/when the push of the 'netbeans' repo can be done....
>
> I have created
> https://urldefense.proofpoint.com/v2/url?u=https-3A__issues.apache.org_jira
> _browse_NETBEANS-2D54&d=DwIBaQ&c=RoP1YumCXCgaWHvlZYR8PQcxBKCX5YTpkKY057SbK10
> &r=tnLz5-vaI8x9g_xBBlFGf_ldS0-TN1M3i9fMP1FPWgk&m=xdwuNnSHUZ9xpxCzEXlkfLExoZ2
> fXyUbvBlMXTrDZs4&s=AoOFSXlwNPiAqufXZAzBpaqTOeLqSSfPYnBPsYAjaZ4&e= to track
> the issue of which files are donated or not, suggesting the two options
> that look valid to me at this point.
>
> Unless option b) is possible (getting an updated grant) I think the
> review and filtering of files can be done in the Apache netbeans
> repository, as long as it's done before the first release and in a
> traceable and deterministic way.
Yes, it would be way easier if the donation documents used firm language
without any conditionals. However, I am afraid that isn't possible (unless
Apache loudly refuses the donation and accuses Oracle of not acting fair).
Moreover I have just heard an explanation why the Oracle position is correct:
When you get some amount of money, do you count them or do you trust the other
person to give you the right amount? I try to count them. When I am giving
money I encourage others to count them as well. It isn't a matter of trust, it
is a matter of verification. Everyone can make mistakes, but when we work
together to avoid them, we can solve them openly before we start to be
suspicious of each other.
I believe we can interpret the sentence in the donation document by Oracle as
an encouragement to Apache foundation to "count". Just like I am asking others
to count my money, we (Oracle) are asking us (Apache community) to verify we
are OK with the donated source files.
> Given the number of files a scripted process is probably the only way,
> but it looks like many files have an Oracle copyright header, which
> might help get a large percentage out of the way.
I know it is not a simple task, but I think it is doable. Automatic conversion
of well known Oracle license headers to Apache (as suggested by Jan Lahoda)
and excluding well known exception (manifest.mf files and *.form files) is, in
my opinion, a great way to start and reduce the amount of work.
Bertrand, our mentor, please help us do the "counting" or loudly refuse the
donation, if "counting" isn't acceptable way to verify donation to the Apache
Foundation.
Thanks in advance for you doings.
Jaroslav Tulach
NetBeans Found and Initial Architect
Re: Do you count or blindly trust was: (Main) NetBeans source to Apache
Posted by Bertrand Delacretaz <bd...@apache.org>.
Hi Jaroslav,
On Wed, Sep 6, 2017 at 7:37 PM, Jaroslav Tulach
<ja...@oracle.com> wrote:
> ...it would be way easier if the donation documents used firm language
> without any conditionals...
Yes. It looks like the Incubator will not accept software grants with
conditionals going forward, as they complicate things unnecessarily.
> ...When you get some amount of money, do you count them or do you trust the other
> person to give you the right amount?...
In general I trust people.
But when it's a big organization on the other side I'm much more
cautious. People leave companies, new people come in and they
sometimes have different ideas and might be missing some background on
how to interpret things that happened in the past.
It's the same on our side - five years down the line the NetBeans PMC
might be different people, and if for some reason they need to go back
to what's happening now the history needs to be documented.
That's why I insist on this donation and how it is handled being clean
from a formal point of view - which would have been easier without
conditionals in the grant, but that's where we are now.
It is *not* a lack of trust in the people who are involved in this now
- it is with a view on the future where different people might be
involved on both sides.
As you mention, a semi-automatic check of the donated files is possible.
Hope this clarifies my point of view. I'm just one mentor here, if
others have different opinions they are welcome.
-Bertrand