You are viewing a plain text version of this content. The canonical link for it is here.
Posted to dev@hertzbeat.apache.org by Chao Gong <go...@apache.org> on 2025/06/29 15:57:46 UTC
[DISCUSS] Graduate Apache HertzBeat (Incubating) from the Apache Incubator to a Top-Level Project
Hello HertzBeat Mentors, PPMCs, and Community,
As you know, Apache HertzBeat (incubating) entered the Apache Incubator on
April 5, 2024. After more than a year of incubation and development,
HertzBeat has grown into a vibrant and healthy community, with 271+
contributors and a growing user base.
This progress and community vitality were recently recognized by another
Apache Incubator mentor,
https://lists.apache.org/thread/pk1vxfgtm8j0t2mttdfrcg98o2g1tk92
I’d like to initiate a discussion regarding the graduation of Apache
HertzBeat from the Apache Incubator to become a Top-Level Project (TLP).
*About HertzBeat*
Apache HertzBeat (incubating) is an easy-to-use, agentless, real-time
monitoring and observability platform.
• GitHub: https://github.com/apache/hertzbeat
• Website: https://hertzbeat.apache.org/
*Community & Contributors*
The community consists of *271 contributors, including 9 Committers and 13
PPMC members*, under the guidance of four mentors: *Yonglun Zhang, Yu Xiao,
Justn Mclean, and Francis Chuang.*
Recent community growth includes:
• New PPMC members: Tianyou Liu (2025‑04‑30), Shenghang Zhang (2025‑03‑26)
• New Committers: Lixin Diao, Kang Li, Yijun Yin
Contributions include code, documentation, testing, blog content, and event
participation.
*Releases & Milestones*
• 4 releases since entering incubation:
• First incubating release: 1.6.0‑incubating (2024‑06‑15)
• Latest stable release: 1.7.1‑incubating (2025‑05‑15)
• Version 1.7.2-incubating is currently under vote
• We provide binary, source, and Docker distributions for both the core and
collector modules.
*Governance & ASF Compliance*
• Followed The Apache Way.
• A documented and practiced contributor-to-committer process.
• Licensed under Apache-2.0; integrates with Apache Arrow, Apache Maven,
and other ASF projects.
⸻
*Sincere appreciation goes to:*
• Our mentors for their invaluable guidance and support
• All Committers, PPMC members, and contributors for their efforts in
development, documentation, testing, advocacy, and community building
⸻
*Do you think we are ready to graduate as a TLP?*
Looking forward to your feedback, suggestions, and support!
Best regards,
Tom
Re: [DISCUSS] Graduate Apache HertzBeat (Incubating) from the Apache Incubator to a Top-Level Project
Posted by zhangshenghang <sh...@apache.org>.
Dear HertzBeat Community,
I am delighted to witness the remarkable progress Apache HertzBeat has made
during incubation and wholeheartedly support its graduation as a Top-Level
Project (TLP). Having observed the project’s growth and achievements, I
firmly believe HertzBeat has demonstrated the maturity and potential
required for TLP status.
The following points highlight its readiness:
1. Vibrant and Diverse Community
With 270+ contributors, 9 committers, and 13 PPMC members, the project
has fostered an inclusive and sustainable ecosystem. The steady onboarding
of new contributors and their progression to committers reflects a healthy,
meritocratic culture.
2. Open and Transparent Collaboration
Regular community meetings, active GitHub discussions, and
well-documented governance exemplify the "Community Over Code" principle.
This culture ensures the project’s long-term resilience.
3. Clear Technical Value and Adoption
As an innovative monitoring solution, HertzBeat’s architecture and
growing user base validate its technical merit. Integrations with other ASF
projects further amplify its impact within the ecosystem.
My sincere thanks to the mentors and every contributor—your dedication has
brought HertzBeat this far. I am confident in its future as a TLP and look
forward to celebrating this milestone!
Regards,
Jast (Shenghang)
Chao Gong <go...@apache.org> 于2025年6月29日周日 23:58写道：
> Hello HertzBeat Mentors, PPMCs, and Community,
>
> As you know, Apache HertzBeat (incubating) entered the Apache Incubator on
> April 5, 2024. After more than a year of incubation and development,
> HertzBeat has grown into a vibrant and healthy community, with 271+
> contributors and a growing user base.
> This progress and community vitality were recently recognized by another
> Apache Incubator mentor,
> https://lists.apache.org/thread/pk1vxfgtm8j0t2mttdfrcg98o2g1tk92
>
> I’d like to initiate a discussion regarding the graduation of Apache
> HertzBeat from the Apache Incubator to become a Top-Level Project (TLP).
>
> *About HertzBeat*
> Apache HertzBeat (incubating) is an easy-to-use, agentless, real-time
> monitoring and observability platform.
> • GitHub: https://github.com/apache/hertzbeat
> • Website: https://hertzbeat.apache.org/
>
> *Community & Contributors*
> The community consists of *271 contributors, including 9 Committers and
> 13 PPMC members*, under the guidance of four mentors: *Yonglun Zhang, Yu
> Xiao, Justn Mclean, and Francis Chuang.*
> Recent community growth includes:
> • New PPMC members: Tianyou Liu (2025‑04‑30), Shenghang Zhang (2025‑03‑26)
> • New Committers: Lixin Diao, Kang Li, Yijun Yin
> Contributions include code, documentation, testing, blog content, and
> event participation.
>
> *Releases & Milestones*
> • 4 releases since entering incubation:
> • First incubating release: 1.6.0‑incubating (2024‑06‑15)
> • Latest stable release: 1.7.1‑incubating (2025‑05‑15)
> • Version 1.7.2-incubating is currently under vote
> • We provide binary, source, and Docker distributions for both the core
> and collector modules.
>
> *Governance & ASF Compliance*
> • Followed The Apache Way.
> • A documented and practiced contributor-to-committer process.
> • Licensed under Apache-2.0; integrates with Apache Arrow, Apache Maven,
> and other ASF projects.
>
> ⸻
>
> *Sincere appreciation goes to:*
> • Our mentors for their invaluable guidance and support
> • All Committers, PPMC members, and contributors for their efforts in
> development, documentation, testing, advocacy, and community building
>
> ⸻
>
> *Do you think we are ready to graduate as a TLP?*
>
> Looking forward to your feedback, suggestions, and support!
>
> Best regards,
> Tom
>
Re: [DISCUSS] Graduate Apache HertzBeat (Incubating) from the Apache Incubator to a Top-Level Project
Posted by Hongyu Liu <li...@apache.org>.
Dear Tom and Heartbeat community,
Congratulations on the remarkable growth and achievements of Apache HertzBeat during its incubation period! It’s truly inspiring to see the project grows so rapidly, and to witness the consistent release cadence and solid governance practices.
From the details you’ve shared, it’s evident that HertzBeat has met many key criteria for TLP graduation. The clear contributor-to-committer process, strict adherence to "The Apache Way", and successful integration with other ASF projects demonstrate maturity. The regular releases and diverse contributions across code, docs, and testing further underscore its readiness.
However, before officially moving towards graduation, I’d suggest ensuring all aspects of the Apache TLP graduation requirements are thoroughly reviewed. This could include double-checking community diversity metrics, ensuring sufficient global participation, and confirming that any outstanding technical debt or process improvements are addressed.
I wholeheartedly support HertzBeat’s journey towards TLP status and am happy to contribute further feedback or assistance. Let’s collaborate closely to make this graduation a smooth and successful milestone for the project!
Best wishes,
Hongyu Liu
---- Replied Message ----
| From | Chao Gong<go...@apache.org> |
| Date | 06/29/2025 23:57 |
| To | hertzbeat-dev <de...@hertzbeat.apache.org>,
private <pr...@hertzbeat.apache.org> |
| Subject | [DISCUSS] Graduate Apache HertzBeat (Incubating) from the Apache Incubator to a Top-Level Project |
Hello HertzBeat Mentors, PPMCs, and Community,
As you know, Apache HertzBeat (incubating) entered the Apache Incubator on
April 5, 2024. After more than a year of incubation and development,
HertzBeat has grown into a vibrant and healthy community, with 271+
contributors and a growing user base.
This progress and community vitality were recently recognized by another
Apache Incubator mentor,
https://lists.apache.org/thread/pk1vxfgtm8j0t2mttdfrcg98o2g1tk92
I’d like to initiate a discussion regarding the graduation of Apache
HertzBeat from the Apache Incubator to become a Top-Level Project (TLP).
*About HertzBeat*
Apache HertzBeat (incubating) is an easy-to-use, agentless, real-time
monitoring and observability platform.
• GitHub: https://github.com/apache/hertzbeat
• Website: https://hertzbeat.apache.org/
*Community & Contributors*
The community consists of *271 contributors, including 9 Committers and 13
PPMC members*, under the guidance of four mentors: *Yonglun Zhang, Yu Xiao,
Justn Mclean, and Francis Chuang.*
Recent community growth includes:
• New PPMC members: Tianyou Liu (2025‑04‑30), Shenghang Zhang (2025‑03‑26)
• New Committers: Lixin Diao, Kang Li, Yijun Yin
Contributions include code, documentation, testing, blog content, and event
participation.
*Releases & Milestones*
• 4 releases since entering incubation:
• First incubating release: 1.6.0‑incubating (2024‑06‑15)
• Latest stable release: 1.7.1‑incubating (2025‑05‑15)
• Version 1.7.2-incubating is currently under vote
• We provide binary, source, and Docker distributions for both the core and
collector modules.
*Governance & ASF Compliance*
• Followed The Apache Way.
• A documented and practiced contributor-to-committer process.
• Licensed under Apache-2.0; integrates with Apache Arrow, Apache Maven,
and other ASF projects.
⸻
*Sincere appreciation goes to:*
• Our mentors for their invaluable guidance and support
• All Committers, PPMC members, and contributors for their efforts in
development, documentation, testing, advocacy, and community building
⸻
*Do you think we are ready to graduate as a TLP?*
Looking forward to your feedback, suggestions, and support!
Best regards,
Tom
Re: [DISCUSS] Graduate Apache HertzBeat (Incubating) from the Apache Incubator to a Top-Level Project
Posted by ShuMing Yan <sh...@apache.org>.
It is with great enthusiasm that I welcome Hertzbeat’s initiative to pursue Apache project graduation. I wholeheartedly endorse its journey to become a Top-Level Project (TLP), standing firmly behind its technical merit and community-driven growth.
As a committer within the Hertzbeat community, I have had the privilege of witnessing its remarkable evolution firsthand. The project has not only advanced exponentially in technical depth—with continuous innovations in distributed monitoring and event-driven architecture—but also thrived through a vibrant, inclusive community. What truly distinguishes Hertzbeat is the unwavering dedication of its contributors: their proactive collaboration, rapid response to issues, and commitment to open governance exemplify the Apache Way in its purest form.
From fostering cross-cultural collaboration to upholding rigorous code reviews, the community has consistently demonstrated best practices in open-source stewardship. This not only ensures the project’s technical excellence but also paves the way for its long-term sustainability. I am convinced that Hertzbeat’s maturity, both in technology and community governance, makes it a deserving candidate for TLP status.
With full confidence in its vision and capabilities, I eagerly support Hertzbeat’s pursuit of this milestone and look forward to its continued leadership in the Apache ecosystem.
Best regards,
shuming
B
---------------------------------------------------------------------
To unsubscribe, e-mail: dev-unsubscribe@hertzbeat.apache.org
For additional commands, e-mail: dev-help@hertzbeat.apache.org
Re: [DISCUSS] Graduate Apache HertzBeat (Incubating) from the Apache Incubator to a Top-Level Project
Posted by Shusheng Zhou <sh...@apache.org>.
Hello Tom and HertzBeat Community,
I wholeheartedly support Apache HertzBeat's promotion to a Top-Level Project (TLP). Since HertzBeat joined the Apache Incubator in April 2024, we have been dedicated to making it better. Having witnessed the project's evolution during the incubation period, I am convinced that we have met all the criteria for this crucial milestone. Currently, HertzBeat has demonstrated the following characteristics:
**Growth and Diversity**: More than 271 contributors, 9 dedicated committers, and 13 PPMC members form a thriving ecosystem. Recent additions of committers (e.g., Lixin Diao, Kang Li) and PPMC members (e.g., Tianyou Liu, Shenghang Zhang) confirm our sustainable development.
**Active Engagement**: Sustained GitHub issue/PR activities and monthly community meetings attract new contributors, reflecting its organic vitality.
**Excellent Release Management**: Four successful releases (from 1.6.0 to 1.7.1-incubating) have been delivered since incubation, with 1.7.2-incubating currently under voting. Multiple release managers have demonstrated proficiency in ASF processes.
**Rigorous Governance System**: The documented contributor-to-committer promotion mechanism and transparent merit-based decision-making fully embody Apache's values.
**Platform Value**: As an agentless real-time monitoring solution, HertzBeat provides clear value with its stable architecture and growing adoption.
**Integration with Apache Principles**: Verified during the incubation period, the project's seamless collaboration with ASF projects (e.g., Arrow, Maven) and adherence to the "Community Over Code" principle have been fully demonstrated.
The endorsement from mentors (reference materials) highlights our readiness.
HertzBeat's technical advantages, community health, and operational discipline position it to excel as a TLP. I call on the community to advance the graduation process.
Deep gratitude to mentors Yonglun Zhang, Yu Xiao, Justin McLean, Francis Chuang, PJ Fanning, Tom, and all community members! Thank you to every contributor who has shaped this journey!
Best Wishes,
a-little-fool
---------------------------------------------------------------------
To unsubscribe, e-mail: dev-unsubscribe@hertzbeat.apache.org
For additional commands, e-mail: dev-help@hertzbeat.apache.org
回复：[DISCUSS] Graduate Apache HertzBeat (Incubating) from the Apache Incubator to a Top-Level Project
Posted by Yang <15...@qq.com.INVALID>.
Dear Tom and Heartbeat community,
This is excellent news! Based on your comprehensive update, my answer to "Do you think we're ready to graduate as a TLP?" is a resounding YES!
Strong Case for Graduation
The information you've provided clearly indicates that HertzBeat has not only excelled within the Apache Incubator but has also fully met and surpassed the criteria for becoming a Top-Level Project (TLP). The project's active and growing community, robust development and release cadence, and strict adherence to the Apache Way all form a powerful foundation for its graduation.
My Personal Experience as a Contributor
As a contributor, I can personally attest to the vibrancy and inclusivity of the Apache HertzBeat (incubating) community. My journey began in March with my first Pull Request, and it was immediately apparent what an exceptional open-source project this is. I distinctly recall collaborating with users on issues, testing solutions, and quickly receiving feedback on my PRs. This immediate and positive response solidified my commitment to the community.
Before HertzBeat, my understanding of open source was limited, and the Apache Foundation was merely a name to me. Through my involvement, I've gained invaluable insights into what open source truly means and the profound principles of the "Apache Way." I've been deeply impressed and inspired by this philosophy.
Today, I genuinely enjoy participating in community discussions and have learned a great deal about fostering project growth. My personal journey and the knowledge I've gained directly attest to the positive impact and healthy development of the HertzBeat community.
Considering all these factors, I believe Apache HertzBeat (incubating) is not only ready but also fully deserving of TLP status. The project's technical achievements, community strength, and adherence to Apache principles provide a compelling case for graduation.
------------------ 原始邮件 ------------------
发件人: "dev" <gongchao@apache.org>;
发送时间: 2025年6月29日(星期天) 晚上11:57
收件人: "hertzbeat-dev"<dev@hertzbeat.apache.org>;"private"<private@hertzbeat.apache.org>;
主题: [DISCUSS] Graduate Apache HertzBeat (Incubating) from the Apache Incubator to a Top-Level Project
Hello HertzBeat Mentors, PPMCs, and Community,
As you know, Apache HertzBeat (incubating) entered the Apache Incubator on
April 5, 2024. After more than a year of incubation and development,
HertzBeat has grown into a vibrant and healthy community, with 271+
contributors and a growing user base.
This progress and community vitality were recently recognized by another
Apache Incubator mentor,
https://lists.apache.org/thread/pk1vxfgtm8j0t2mttdfrcg98o2g1tk92
I’d like to initiate a discussion regarding the graduation of Apache
HertzBeat from the Apache Incubator to become a Top-Level Project (TLP).
*About HertzBeat*
Apache HertzBeat (incubating) is an easy-to-use, agentless, real-time
monitoring and observability platform.
• GitHub: https://github.com/apache/hertzbeat
• Website: https://hertzbeat.apache.org/
*Community & Contributors*
The community consists of *271 contributors, including 9 Committers and 13
PPMC members*, under the guidance of four mentors: *Yonglun Zhang, Yu Xiao,
Justn Mclean, and Francis Chuang.*
Recent community growth includes:
• New PPMC members: Tianyou Liu (2025‑04‑30), Shenghang Zhang (2025‑03‑26)
• New Committers: Lixin Diao, Kang Li, Yijun Yin
Contributions include code, documentation, testing, blog content, and event
participation.
*Releases & Milestones*
• 4 releases since entering incubation:
• First incubating release: 1.6.0‑incubating (2024‑06‑15)
• Latest stable release: 1.7.1‑incubating (2025‑05‑15)
• Version 1.7.2-incubating is currently under vote
• We provide binary, source, and Docker distributions for both the core and
collector modules.
*Governance & ASF Compliance*
• Followed The Apache Way.
• A documented and practiced contributor-to-committer process.
• Licensed under Apache-2.0; integrates with Apache Arrow, Apache Maven,
and other ASF projects.
⸻
*Sincere appreciation goes to:*
• Our mentors for their invaluable guidance and support
• All Committers, PPMC members, and contributors for their efforts in
development, documentation, testing, advocacy, and community building
⸻
*Do you think we are ready to graduate as a TLP?*
Looking forward to your feedback, suggestions, and support!
Best regards,
Tom
Re: [DISCUSS] Graduate Apache HertzBeat (Incubating) from the Apache Incubator to a Top-Level Project
Posted by Kang Li <li...@apache.org>.
Dear Tom and the HertzBeat Community,
I am glad to see the graduation discussion of the Apache Hertzbeat project.
Since entering the incubator in April 2024, the project has made significant progress. The growth indicators - over 271 contributors, 9 submitters, and 13 PPMC members - fully demonstrate the vitality and collaborative spirit of the community.
I strongly support Apache Hertzbeat becoming a top-level project. From my initial code contribution to becoming a committer, I have witnessed the flourishing development of Apache Hertzbeat. I believe that in the future, Apache Hertzbeat will attract more developers and expand to a wider user base
Best regards,
pwallk
On 2025/06/29 15:57:46 Chao Gong wrote:
> Hello HertzBeat Mentors, PPMCs, and Community,
>
> As you know, Apache HertzBeat (incubating) entered the Apache Incubator on
> April 5, 2024. After more than a year of incubation and development,
> HertzBeat has grown into a vibrant and healthy community, with 271+
> contributors and a growing user base.
> This progress and community vitality were recently recognized by another
> Apache Incubator mentor,
> https://lists.apache.org/thread/pk1vxfgtm8j0t2mttdfrcg98o2g1tk92
>
> I’d like to initiate a discussion regarding the graduation of Apache
> HertzBeat from the Apache Incubator to become a Top-Level Project (TLP).
>
> *About HertzBeat*
> Apache HertzBeat (incubating) is an easy-to-use, agentless, real-time
> monitoring and observability platform.
> • GitHub: https://github.com/apache/hertzbeat
> • Website: https://hertzbeat.apache.org/
>
> *Community & Contributors*
> The community consists of *271 contributors, including 9 Committers and 13
> PPMC members*, under the guidance of four mentors: *Yonglun Zhang, Yu Xiao,
> Justn Mclean, and Francis Chuang.*
> Recent community growth includes:
> • New PPMC members: Tianyou Liu (2025‑04‑30), Shenghang Zhang (2025‑03‑26)
> • New Committers: Lixin Diao, Kang Li, Yijun Yin
> Contributions include code, documentation, testing, blog content, and event
> participation.
>
> *Releases & Milestones*
> • 4 releases since entering incubation:
> • First incubating release: 1.6.0‑incubating (2024‑06‑15)
> • Latest stable release: 1.7.1‑incubating (2025‑05‑15)
> • Version 1.7.2-incubating is currently under vote
> • We provide binary, source, and Docker distributions for both the core and
> collector modules.
>
> *Governance & ASF Compliance*
> • Followed The Apache Way.
> • A documented and practiced contributor-to-committer process.
> • Licensed under Apache-2.0; integrates with Apache Arrow, Apache Maven,
> and other ASF projects.
>
> ⸻
>
> *Sincere appreciation goes to:*
> • Our mentors for their invaluable guidance and support
> • All Committers, PPMC members, and contributors for their efforts in
> development, documentation, testing, advocacy, and community building
>
> ⸻
>
> *Do you think we are ready to graduate as a TLP?*
>
> Looking forward to your feedback, suggestions, and support!
>
> Best regards,
> Tom
>
---------------------------------------------------------------------
To unsubscribe, e-mail: dev-unsubscribe@hertzbeat.apache.org
For additional commands, e-mail: dev-help@hertzbeat.apache.org
Re: [DISCUSS] Graduate Apache HertzBeat (Incubating) from the Apache Incubator to a Top-Level Project
Posted by Yang Zhang <zh...@apache.org>.
Hello Tom and HertzBeat Community,
Thanks for initiating this graduation discussion.
Over the past months, I’ve been following the project’s progress and I’m impressed by the steady community growth, increasing contributor diversity, and overall engagement. It’s clear that the project is operating in line with the Apache Way – with open discussions, transparent decision-making, and healthy participation from both committers and new contributors.
The project has also demonstrated strong release discipline, with multiple successful releases and properly followed procedures. The PMC is functioning effectively, showing ownership and responsibility for the direction of the project.
From both a community and technical standpoint, I believe the project has reached a level of maturity appropriate for graduation. I’m confident the team is ready to manage the responsibilities of a top-level project.
Best regards,
DongFeng
On 2025/06/29 15:57:46 Chao Gong wrote:
> Hello HertzBeat Mentors, PPMCs, and Community,
>
> As you know, Apache HertzBeat (incubating) entered the Apache Incubator on
> April 5, 2024. After more than a year of incubation and development,
> HertzBeat has grown into a vibrant and healthy community, with 271+
> contributors and a growing user base.
> This progress and community vitality were recently recognized by another
> Apache Incubator mentor,
> https://lists.apache.org/thread/pk1vxfgtm8j0t2mttdfrcg98o2g1tk92
>
> I’d like to initiate a discussion regarding the graduation of Apache
> HertzBeat from the Apache Incubator to become a Top-Level Project (TLP).
>
> *About HertzBeat*
> Apache HertzBeat (incubating) is an easy-to-use, agentless, real-time
> monitoring and observability platform.
> • GitHub: https://github.com/apache/hertzbeat
> • Website: https://hertzbeat.apache.org/
>
> *Community & Contributors*
> The community consists of *271 contributors, including 9 Committers and 13
> PPMC members*, under the guidance of four mentors: *Yonglun Zhang, Yu Xiao,
> Justn Mclean, and Francis Chuang.*
> Recent community growth includes:
> • New PPMC members: Tianyou Liu (2025‑04‑30), Shenghang Zhang (2025‑03‑26)
> • New Committers: Lixin Diao, Kang Li, Yijun Yin
> Contributions include code, documentation, testing, blog content, and event
> participation.
>
> *Releases & Milestones*
> • 4 releases since entering incubation:
> • First incubating release: 1.6.0‑incubating (2024‑06‑15)
> • Latest stable release: 1.7.1‑incubating (2025‑05‑15)
> • Version 1.7.2-incubating is currently under vote
> • We provide binary, source, and Docker distributions for both the core and
> collector modules.
>
> *Governance & ASF Compliance*
> • Followed The Apache Way.
> • A documented and practiced contributor-to-committer process.
> • Licensed under Apache-2.0; integrates with Apache Arrow, Apache Maven,
> and other ASF projects.
>
> ⸻
>
> *Sincere appreciation goes to:*
> • Our mentors for their invaluable guidance and support
> • All Committers, PPMC members, and contributors for their efforts in
> development, documentation, testing, advocacy, and community building
>
> ⸻
>
> *Do you think we are ready to graduate as a TLP?*
>
> Looking forward to your feedback, suggestions, and support!
>
> Best regards,
> Tom
>
---------------------------------------------------------------------
To unsubscribe, e-mail: dev-unsubscribe@hertzbeat.apache.org
For additional commands, e-mail: dev-help@hertzbeat.apache.org
Re: [DISCUSS] Graduate Apache HertzBeat (Incubating) from the Apache Incubator to a Top-Level Project
Posted by Tianyou Liu <li...@apache.org>.
Dear Tom and the Apache HertzBeat Community,
I am delighted to witness the significant progress and achievements Apache HertzBeat has made during its incubation period. The project has fostered an open, friendly, and active community, attracting over 270 contributors, 9 Committers, and 13 PPMC members.
During incubation, HertzBeat delivered three high-quality releases (1.6.0, 1.7.0, and 1.7.1), with the 1.7.2 release currently undergoing voting.
I believe HertzBeat has fully met the maturity criteria required for incubation. This is demonstrated by:
* Strong community diversity (270+ contributors)
* Resilient governance processes, demonstrated by regular meetings and structured voting,
* A tangible implementation of the Apache Way
Collectively, these elements confirm the project's capability for independent operation.
As a deeply involved participant, I have observed the community consistently prioritizing the core principle of "Community Over Code"—the very essence of Apache Top-Level Projects (TLP).
Therefore, I wholeheartedly and firmly support HertzBeat's graduation as a TLP, and eagerly anticipate its leadership in driving sustained innovation within the area of open-source monitoring at the TLP stage.
Best wishes,
Tianyou Liu
On 2025/06/29 15:57:46 Chao Gong wrote:
> Hello HertzBeat Mentors, PPMCs, and Community,
>
> As you know, Apache HertzBeat (incubating) entered the Apache Incubator on
> April 5, 2024. After more than a year of incubation and development,
> HertzBeat has grown into a vibrant and healthy community, with 271+
> contributors and a growing user base.
> This progress and community vitality were recently recognized by another
> Apache Incubator mentor,
> https://lists.apache.org/thread/pk1vxfgtm8j0t2mttdfrcg98o2g1tk92
>
> I’d like to initiate a discussion regarding the graduation of Apache
> HertzBeat from the Apache Incubator to become a Top-Level Project (TLP).
>
> *About HertzBeat*
> Apache HertzBeat (incubating) is an easy-to-use, agentless, real-time
> monitoring and observability platform.
> • GitHub: https://github.com/apache/hertzbeat
> • Website: https://hertzbeat.apache.org/
>
> *Community & Contributors*
> The community consists of *271 contributors, including 9 Committers and 13
> PPMC members*, under the guidance of four mentors: *Yonglun Zhang, Yu Xiao,
> Justn Mclean, and Francis Chuang.*
> Recent community growth includes:
> • New PPMC members: Tianyou Liu (2025‑04‑30), Shenghang Zhang (2025‑03‑26)
> • New Committers: Lixin Diao, Kang Li, Yijun Yin
> Contributions include code, documentation, testing, blog content, and event
> participation.
>
> *Releases & Milestones*
> • 4 releases since entering incubation:
> • First incubating release: 1.6.0‑incubating (2024‑06‑15)
> • Latest stable release: 1.7.1‑incubating (2025‑05‑15)
> • Version 1.7.2-incubating is currently under vote
> • We provide binary, source, and Docker distributions for both the core and
> collector modules.
>
> *Governance & ASF Compliance*
> • Followed The Apache Way.
> • A documented and practiced contributor-to-committer process.
> • Licensed under Apache-2.0; integrates with Apache Arrow, Apache Maven,
> and other ASF projects.
>
> ⸻
>
> *Sincere appreciation goes to:*
> • Our mentors for their invaluable guidance and support
> • All Committers, PPMC members, and contributors for their efforts in
> development, documentation, testing, advocacy, and community building
>
> ⸻
>
> *Do you think we are ready to graduate as a TLP?*
>
> Looking forward to your feedback, suggestions, and support!
>
> Best regards,
> Tom
>
---------------------------------------------------------------------
To unsubscribe, e-mail: dev-unsubscribe@hertzbeat.apache.org
For additional commands, e-mail: dev-help@hertzbeat.apache.org
Re: [DISCUSS] Graduate Apache HertzBeat (Incubating) from the Apache Incubator to a Top-Level Project
Posted by Qingran Zhao <zh...@apache.org>.
Hello Tom and HertzBeat Community,
I fully support the graduation of Apache HertzBeat to become a Top-Level Project (TLP). After reviewing the community's progress and achievements, I believe we are indeed ready for this important milestone.
The evidence speaks for itself:
**Strong Community Foundation**: With 271+ contributors, 9 committed committers, and 13 PPMC members, we have built a robust and diverse community. The recent additions of new PPMC members and committers demonstrate our healthy growth and active contributor pipeline.
**Proven Release Management**: Our community has successfully delivered 4 releases since entering incubation, with multiple release managers who are well-versed in Apache processes. This demonstrates our operational maturity and ability to maintain consistent delivery cycles.
**Active Community Engagement**: The high level of activity on GitHub issues and pull requests, combined with our monthly community meetings that attract newcomers interested in the project, shows a vibrant and growing ecosystem. This organic growth is a strong indicator of project health.
**Apache Way Adoption**: Most importantly, we have embraced The Apache Way in our community interactions and governance. Our documented contributor-to-committer process and commitment to transparent, merit-based decision-making align perfectly with Apache's values.
**Technical Maturity**: HertzBeat has established itself as a valuable monitoring and observability platform with a clear value proposition, stable architecture, and growing user base.
The combination of technical excellence, community vitality, operational competence, and cultural alignment with Apache principles makes a compelling case for graduation. I'm confident that HertzBeat will continue to thrive as a TLP and contribute meaningfully to the broader Apache ecosystem.
Thank you to all mentors, committers, PPMC members, and contributors who have made this journey possible. Let's move forward with the graduation process!
Best regards,
Logic
On 2025/06/29 15:57:46 Chao Gong wrote:
> Hello HertzBeat Mentors, PPMCs, and Community,
>
> As you know, Apache HertzBeat (incubating) entered the Apache Incubator on
> April 5, 2024. After more than a year of incubation and development,
> HertzBeat has grown into a vibrant and healthy community, with 271+
> contributors and a growing user base.
> This progress and community vitality were recently recognized by another
> Apache Incubator mentor,
> https://lists.apache.org/thread/pk1vxfgtm8j0t2mttdfrcg98o2g1tk92
>
> I’d like to initiate a discussion regarding the graduation of Apache
> HertzBeat from the Apache Incubator to become a Top-Level Project (TLP).
>
> *About HertzBeat*
> Apache HertzBeat (incubating) is an easy-to-use, agentless, real-time
> monitoring and observability platform.
> • GitHub: https://github.com/apache/hertzbeat
> • Website: https://hertzbeat.apache.org/
>
> *Community & Contributors*
> The community consists of *271 contributors, including 9 Committers and 13
> PPMC members*, under the guidance of four mentors: *Yonglun Zhang, Yu Xiao,
> Justn Mclean, and Francis Chuang.*
> Recent community growth includes:
> • New PPMC members: Tianyou Liu (2025‑04‑30), Shenghang Zhang (2025‑03‑26)
> • New Committers: Lixin Diao, Kang Li, Yijun Yin
> Contributions include code, documentation, testing, blog content, and event
> participation.
>
> *Releases & Milestones*
> • 4 releases since entering incubation:
> • First incubating release: 1.6.0‑incubating (2024‑06‑15)
> • Latest stable release: 1.7.1‑incubating (2025‑05‑15)
> • Version 1.7.2-incubating is currently under vote
> • We provide binary, source, and Docker distributions for both the core and
> collector modules.
>
> *Governance & ASF Compliance*
> • Followed The Apache Way.
> • A documented and practiced contributor-to-committer process.
> • Licensed under Apache-2.0; integrates with Apache Arrow, Apache Maven,
> and other ASF projects.
>
> ⸻
>
> *Sincere appreciation goes to:*
> • Our mentors for their invaluable guidance and support
> • All Committers, PPMC members, and contributors for their efforts in
> development, documentation, testing, advocacy, and community building
>
> ⸻
>
> *Do you think we are ready to graduate as a TLP?*
>
> Looking forward to your feedback, suggestions, and support!
>
> Best regards,
> Tom
>
---------------------------------------------------------------------
To unsubscribe, e-mail: dev-unsubscribe@hertzbeat.apache.org
For additional commands, e-mail: dev-help@hertzbeat.apache.org
Re: [DISCUSS] Graduate Apache HertzBeat (Incubating) from the Apache Incubator to a Top-Level Project
Posted by QingHua Wang <hu...@apache.org>.
Dear Apache Hertzbeat Team Members, I fully support the graduation of Apache HertzBeat to become a Top-Level Project (TLP). We have thoroughly prepared and are confident in elevating Apache HertzBeat to the next level to successfully graduate.
The journey of Apache Hertzbeat has never been just about technical innovation—it is a testament to the power of our community-driven ecosystem. With 271 contributors, 9 committers, and 13 PPMC members, we’ve built a robust and diverse community. Every code contribution, documentation improvement, and issue discussion reflects the collective effort that fuels this project.
Our strong community foundation is the cornerstone of Hertzbeat’s success. The recent addition of new PPMC members and committers highlights our healthy growth and sustainable contributor pipeline. Whether it’s in-depth technical discussions, active community events, or rapid responses to user feedback, Hertzbeat has proven its value within the Apache ecosystem.
Mature technology and governance are the pillars of our progress. From standardized release processes, to rigorous code review mechanisms, and efficient community coordination, Hertzbeat has evolved into a reliable open-source project. This maturity is a direct result of the professionalism and dedication of every contributor.
Graduation marks not an end, but a new beginning. Let us continue to embrace the spirit of openness, collaboration, and innovation to expand Hertzbeat’s impact across more use cases and empower a broader developer audience. Together, let’s take bold steps toward the next milestone in Hertzbeat’s journey.
Thank you to every contributor—your efforts make the future shine!
On 2025/06/29 15:57:46 Chao Gong wrote:
> Hello HertzBeat Mentors, PPMCs, and Community,
>
> As you know, Apache HertzBeat (incubating) entered the Apache Incubator on
> April 5, 2024. After more than a year of incubation and development,
> HertzBeat has grown into a vibrant and healthy community, with 271+
> contributors and a growing user base.
> This progress and community vitality were recently recognized by another
> Apache Incubator mentor,
> https://lists.apache.org/thread/pk1vxfgtm8j0t2mttdfrcg98o2g1tk92
>
> I’d like to initiate a discussion regarding the graduation of Apache
> HertzBeat from the Apache Incubator to become a Top-Level Project (TLP).
>
> *About HertzBeat*
> Apache HertzBeat (incubating) is an easy-to-use, agentless, real-time
> monitoring and observability platform.
> • GitHub: https://github.com/apache/hertzbeat
> • Website: https://hertzbeat.apache.org/
>
> *Community & Contributors*
> The community consists of *271 contributors, including 9 Committers and 13
> PPMC members*, under the guidance of four mentors: *Yonglun Zhang, Yu Xiao,
> Justn Mclean, and Francis Chuang.*
> Recent community growth includes:
> • New PPMC members: Tianyou Liu (2025‑04‑30), Shenghang Zhang (2025‑03‑26)
> • New Committers: Lixin Diao, Kang Li, Yijun Yin
> Contributions include code, documentation, testing, blog content, and event
> participation.
>
> *Releases & Milestones*
> • 4 releases since entering incubation:
> • First incubating release: 1.6.0‑incubating (2024‑06‑15)
> • Latest stable release: 1.7.1‑incubating (2025‑05‑15)
> • Version 1.7.2-incubating is currently under vote
> • We provide binary, source, and Docker distributions for both the core and
> collector modules.
>
> *Governance & ASF Compliance*
> • Followed The Apache Way.
> • A documented and practiced contributor-to-committer process.
> • Licensed under Apache-2.0; integrates with Apache Arrow, Apache Maven,
> and other ASF projects.
>
> ⸻
>
> *Sincere appreciation goes to:*
> • Our mentors for their invaluable guidance and support
> • All Committers, PPMC members, and contributors for their efforts in
> development, documentation, testing, advocacy, and community building
>
> ⸻
>
> *Do you think we are ready to graduate as a TLP?*
>
> Looking forward to your feedback, suggestions, and support!
>
> Best regards,
> Tom
>
---------------------------------------------------------------------
To unsubscribe, e-mail: dev-unsubscribe@hertzbeat.apache.org
For additional commands, e-mail: dev-help@hertzbeat.apache.org
Re: [DISCUSS] Graduate Apache HertzBeat (Incubating) from the Apache Incubator to a Top-Level Project
Posted by Zhang Yonglun <zh...@apache.org>.
Thank you for starting the discussion on Apache HertzBeat’s graduation
to a Top-Level Project. Since joining the Incubator in April 2024, the
project has shown impressive growth, with over 271 contributors,
consistent releases, and strong adherence to Apache way. I fully
support HertzBeat’s readiness to become a TLP.
To improve your proposal, show how HertzBeat aligns with the Apache
Project Maturity Model[1], focusing on community strength and
governance. Let me know if you need help with the graduation process.
[1] https://community.apache.org/apache-way/apache-project-maturity-model.html
Best Regards,
Zhang Yonglun
Chao Gong <go...@apache.org> 于2025年6月29日周日 23:58写道：
>
> Hello HertzBeat Mentors, PPMCs, and Community,
>
> As you know, Apache HertzBeat (incubating) entered the Apache Incubator on
> April 5, 2024. After more than a year of incubation and development,
> HertzBeat has grown into a vibrant and healthy community, with 271+
> contributors and a growing user base.
> This progress and community vitality were recently recognized by another
> Apache Incubator mentor,
> https://lists.apache.org/thread/pk1vxfgtm8j0t2mttdfrcg98o2g1tk92
>
> I’d like to initiate a discussion regarding the graduation of Apache
> HertzBeat from the Apache Incubator to become a Top-Level Project (TLP).
>
> *About HertzBeat*
> Apache HertzBeat (incubating) is an easy-to-use, agentless, real-time
> monitoring and observability platform.
> • GitHub: https://github.com/apache/hertzbeat
> • Website: https://hertzbeat.apache.org/
>
> *Community & Contributors*
> The community consists of *271 contributors, including 9 Committers and 13
> PPMC members*, under the guidance of four mentors: *Yonglun Zhang, Yu Xiao,
> Justn Mclean, and Francis Chuang.*
> Recent community growth includes:
> • New PPMC members: Tianyou Liu (2025‑04‑30), Shenghang Zhang (2025‑03‑26)
> • New Committers: Lixin Diao, Kang Li, Yijun Yin
> Contributions include code, documentation, testing, blog content, and event
> participation.
>
> *Releases & Milestones*
> • 4 releases since entering incubation:
> • First incubating release: 1.6.0‑incubating (2024‑06‑15)
> • Latest stable release: 1.7.1‑incubating (2025‑05‑15)
> • Version 1.7.2-incubating is currently under vote
> • We provide binary, source, and Docker distributions for both the core and
> collector modules.
>
> *Governance & ASF Compliance*
> • Followed The Apache Way.
> • A documented and practiced contributor-to-committer process.
> • Licensed under Apache-2.0; integrates with Apache Arrow, Apache Maven,
> and other ASF projects.
>
> ⸻
>
> *Sincere appreciation goes to:*
> • Our mentors for their invaluable guidance and support
> • All Committers, PPMC members, and contributors for their efforts in
> development, documentation, testing, advocacy, and community building
>
> ⸻
>
> *Do you think we are ready to graduate as a TLP?*
>
> Looking forward to your feedback, suggestions, and support!
>
> Best regards,
> Tom
---------------------------------------------------------------------
To unsubscribe, e-mail: dev-unsubscribe@hertzbeat.apache.org
For additional commands, e-mail: dev-help@hertzbeat.apache.org
Re: [DISCUSS] Graduate Apache HertzBeat (Incubating) from the Apache Incubator to a Top-Level Project
Posted by luo yu <yu...@gmail.com>.
hi, Dear Community.
I am very happy to see Hertzbeat initiate the discussion of Apache project
graduation. I strongly support Hertzbeat becoming a Top-Level Project
(TLP).
During the time I have been a community committer, I have witnessed the
continuous development of the Hertzbeat community,
the active participation of community participants, and the rapid response.
I am impressed. The community has fully practiced the Apache way in open
governance. I have full confidence in Hertzbeat.
Best,
Shown.Ji
Yijun Yin <yi...@apache.org> 于2025年6月30日周一 19:33写道：
> Dear Community,
>
> I wholeheartedly support Apache HertzBeat's promotion to a Top-Level
> Project (TLP). Since joining as a contributor in January 2025, The
> project's rapid growth and vibrant community atmosphere have left a very
> deep impression on me.
>
> HertzBeat truly embodies the Apache Way. It maintains a clear roadmap
> while excelling in community-driven governance, transparency, and open
> collaboration. Today, the community boasts over 271 contributors – and new
> contributors keep joining.
>
> I have confidence Apache HertzBeat will achieve even greater things in the
> future. I eagerly anticipate this milestone, fully endorse its graduation,
> and will continue supporting this goal.
>
> Best regards,
> MasamiYui
>
> On 2025/06/29 15:57:46 Chao Gong wrote:
> > Hello HertzBeat Mentors, PPMCs, and Community,
> >
> > As you know, Apache HertzBeat (incubating) entered the Apache Incubator
> on
> > April 5, 2024. After more than a year of incubation and development,
> > HertzBeat has grown into a vibrant and healthy community, with 271+
> > contributors and a growing user base.
> > This progress and community vitality were recently recognized by another
> > Apache Incubator mentor,
> > https://lists.apache.org/thread/pk1vxfgtm8j0t2mttdfrcg98o2g1tk92
> >
> > I’d like to initiate a discussion regarding the graduation of Apache
> > HertzBeat from the Apache Incubator to become a Top-Level Project (TLP).
> >
> > *About HertzBeat*
> > Apache HertzBeat (incubating) is an easy-to-use, agentless, real-time
> > monitoring and observability platform.
> > • GitHub: https://github.com/apache/hertzbeat
> > • Website: https://hertzbeat.apache.org/
> >
> > *Community & Contributors*
> > The community consists of *271 contributors, including 9 Committers and
> 13
> > PPMC members*, under the guidance of four mentors: *Yonglun Zhang, Yu
> Xiao,
> > Justn Mclean, and Francis Chuang.*
> > Recent community growth includes:
> > • New PPMC members: Tianyou Liu (2025‑04‑30), Shenghang Zhang
> (2025‑03‑26)
> > • New Committers: Lixin Diao, Kang Li, Yijun Yin
> > Contributions include code, documentation, testing, blog content, and
> event
> > participation.
> >
> > *Releases & Milestones*
> > • 4 releases since entering incubation:
> > • First incubating release: 1.6.0‑incubating (2024‑06‑15)
> > • Latest stable release: 1.7.1‑incubating (2025‑05‑15)
> > • Version 1.7.2-incubating is currently under vote
> > • We provide binary, source, and Docker distributions for both the core
> and
> > collector modules.
> >
> > *Governance & ASF Compliance*
> > • Followed The Apache Way.
> > • A documented and practiced contributor-to-committer process.
> > • Licensed under Apache-2.0; integrates with Apache Arrow, Apache Maven,
> > and other ASF projects.
> >
> > ⸻
> >
> > *Sincere appreciation goes to:*
> > • Our mentors for their invaluable guidance and support
> > • All Committers, PPMC members, and contributors for their efforts in
> > development, documentation, testing, advocacy, and community building
> >
> > ⸻
> >
> > *Do you think we are ready to graduate as a TLP?*
> >
> > Looking forward to your feedback, suggestions, and support!
> >
> > Best regards,
> > Tom
> >
>
> ---------------------------------------------------------------------
> To unsubscribe, e-mail: dev-unsubscribe@hertzbeat.apache.org
> For additional commands, e-mail: dev-help@hertzbeat.apache.org
>
>
Re: [DISCUSS] Graduate Apache HertzBeat (Incubating) from the Apache Incubator to a Top-Level Project
Posted by Yijun Yin <yi...@apache.org>.
Dear Community,
I wholeheartedly support Apache HertzBeat's promotion to a Top-Level Project (TLP). Since joining as a contributor in January 2025, The project's rapid growth and vibrant community atmosphere have left a very deep impression on me.
HertzBeat truly embodies the Apache Way. It maintains a clear roadmap while excelling in community-driven governance, transparency, and open collaboration. Today, the community boasts over 271 contributors – and new contributors keep joining.
I have confidence Apache HertzBeat will achieve even greater things in the future. I eagerly anticipate this milestone, fully endorse its graduation, and will continue supporting this goal.
Best regards,
MasamiYui
On 2025/06/29 15:57:46 Chao Gong wrote:
> Hello HertzBeat Mentors, PPMCs, and Community,
>
> As you know, Apache HertzBeat (incubating) entered the Apache Incubator on
> April 5, 2024. After more than a year of incubation and development,
> HertzBeat has grown into a vibrant and healthy community, with 271+
> contributors and a growing user base.
> This progress and community vitality were recently recognized by another
> Apache Incubator mentor,
> https://lists.apache.org/thread/pk1vxfgtm8j0t2mttdfrcg98o2g1tk92
>
> I’d like to initiate a discussion regarding the graduation of Apache
> HertzBeat from the Apache Incubator to become a Top-Level Project (TLP).
>
> *About HertzBeat*
> Apache HertzBeat (incubating) is an easy-to-use, agentless, real-time
> monitoring and observability platform.
> • GitHub: https://github.com/apache/hertzbeat
> • Website: https://hertzbeat.apache.org/
>
> *Community & Contributors*
> The community consists of *271 contributors, including 9 Committers and 13
> PPMC members*, under the guidance of four mentors: *Yonglun Zhang, Yu Xiao,
> Justn Mclean, and Francis Chuang.*
> Recent community growth includes:
> • New PPMC members: Tianyou Liu (2025‑04‑30), Shenghang Zhang (2025‑03‑26)
> • New Committers: Lixin Diao, Kang Li, Yijun Yin
> Contributions include code, documentation, testing, blog content, and event
> participation.
>
> *Releases & Milestones*
> • 4 releases since entering incubation:
> • First incubating release: 1.6.0‑incubating (2024‑06‑15)
> • Latest stable release: 1.7.1‑incubating (2025‑05‑15)
> • Version 1.7.2-incubating is currently under vote
> • We provide binary, source, and Docker distributions for both the core and
> collector modules.
>
> *Governance & ASF Compliance*
> • Followed The Apache Way.
> • A documented and practiced contributor-to-committer process.
> • Licensed under Apache-2.0; integrates with Apache Arrow, Apache Maven,
> and other ASF projects.
>
> ⸻
>
> *Sincere appreciation goes to:*
> • Our mentors for their invaluable guidance and support
> • All Committers, PPMC members, and contributors for their efforts in
> development, documentation, testing, advocacy, and community building
>
> ⸻
>
> *Do you think we are ready to graduate as a TLP?*
>
> Looking forward to your feedback, suggestions, and support!
>
> Best regards,
> Tom
>
---------------------------------------------------------------------
To unsubscribe, e-mail: dev-unsubscribe@hertzbeat.apache.org
For additional commands, e-mail: dev-help@hertzbeat.apache.org
Re: [DISCUSS] Graduate Apache HertzBeat (Incubating) from the Apache Incubator to a Top-Level Project
Posted by Chao Gong <go...@apache.org>.
Thank you all for your responses. ✨✨
We will now move on to the voting phase.
Francis Chuang <fr...@apache.org> 于2025年7月1日周二 07:04写道：
> I also fully support HertzBeat's graduation to a TLP. The project has
> on-boarded a lot of new committers and PMC members since inception and
> the community has been very active and helpful.
>
> The release process has been smooth and I have seen many different
> committers taking on the role of release manager, which is very
> inclusive and encouraging.
>
> HertzBeat is in a very good position to graduate as a TLP and I fully
> support this move.
>
> Francis
>
> On 1/07/2025 2:58 am, Lixin Diao wrote:
> > Dear Tom and HertzBeat Community,
> >
> > I fully support Apache HertzBeat’s graduation to a Top-Level Project
> (TLP).
> >
> > As a committer, I’ve witnessed firsthand how responsive and active the
> community is—questions are addressed promptly, discussions are open and
> constructive, and the documentation is well-maintained and
> beginner-friendly. These are all strong indicators of a mature and
> sustainable project.
> >
> > The project has consistently delivered high-quality releases, grown a
> diverse contributor base, and upheld The Apache Way throughout incubation.
> I believe HertzBeat is more than ready to graduate and thrive as a TLP.
> >
> > Thanks to all mentors, PPMC members, and contributors for their
> dedication and hard work.
> >
> > Best regards,
> > yunfan24
> >
> > ---------------------------------------------------------------------
> > To unsubscribe, e-mail: dev-unsubscribe@hertzbeat.apache.org
> > For additional commands, e-mail: dev-help@hertzbeat.apache.org
> >
>
>
> ---------------------------------------------------------------------
> To unsubscribe, e-mail: dev-unsubscribe@hertzbeat.apache.org
> For additional commands, e-mail: dev-help@hertzbeat.apache.org
>
>
Re: [DISCUSS] Graduate Apache HertzBeat (Incubating) from the Apache Incubator to a Top-Level Project
Posted by Francis Chuang <fr...@apache.org>.
I also fully support HertzBeat's graduation to a TLP. The project has
on-boarded a lot of new committers and PMC members since inception and
the community has been very active and helpful.
The release process has been smooth and I have seen many different
committers taking on the role of release manager, which is very
inclusive and encouraging.
HertzBeat is in a very good position to graduate as a TLP and I fully
support this move.
Francis
On 1/07/2025 2:58 am, Lixin Diao wrote:
> Dear Tom and HertzBeat Community,
>
> I fully support Apache HertzBeat’s graduation to a Top-Level Project (TLP).
>
> As a committer, I’ve witnessed firsthand how responsive and active the community is—questions are addressed promptly, discussions are open and constructive, and the documentation is well-maintained and beginner-friendly. These are all strong indicators of a mature and sustainable project.
>
> The project has consistently delivered high-quality releases, grown a diverse contributor base, and upheld The Apache Way throughout incubation. I believe HertzBeat is more than ready to graduate and thrive as a TLP.
>
> Thanks to all mentors, PPMC members, and contributors for their dedication and hard work.
>
> Best regards,
> yunfan24
>
> ---------------------------------------------------------------------
> To unsubscribe, e-mail: dev-unsubscribe@hertzbeat.apache.org
> For additional commands, e-mail: dev-help@hertzbeat.apache.org
>
---------------------------------------------------------------------
To unsubscribe, e-mail: dev-unsubscribe@hertzbeat.apache.org
For additional commands, e-mail: dev-help@hertzbeat.apache.org
Re: [DISCUSS] Graduate Apache HertzBeat (Incubating) from the Apache Incubator to a Top-Level Project
Posted by Lixin Diao <di...@apache.org>.
Dear Tom and HertzBeat Community,
I fully support Apache HertzBeat’s graduation to a Top-Level Project (TLP).
As a committer, I’ve witnessed firsthand how responsive and active the community is—questions are addressed promptly, discussions are open and constructive, and the documentation is well-maintained and beginner-friendly. These are all strong indicators of a mature and sustainable project.
The project has consistently delivered high-quality releases, grown a diverse contributor base, and upheld The Apache Way throughout incubation. I believe HertzBeat is more than ready to graduate and thrive as a TLP.
Thanks to all mentors, PPMC members, and contributors for their dedication and hard work.
Best regards,
yunfan24
---------------------------------------------------------------------
To unsubscribe, e-mail: dev-unsubscribe@hertzbeat.apache.org
For additional commands, e-mail: dev-help@hertzbeat.apache.org
Re: [DISCUSS] Graduate Apache HertzBeat (Incubating) from the Apache Incubator to a Top-Level Project
Posted by Xingcun Gao <ga...@apache.org>.
Dear Tom and Heartbeat community,
I wholeheartedly support Apache HertzBeat's graduation to a TLP. The project's achievements since entering the incubator in 2024 are impressive.
With 271+ contributors, 9 Committers, and 13 PPMC members, the community is vibrant and growing. New talent constantly joins, ensuring diverse contributions.
The four releases, including the stable 1.7.1 - incubating and the upcoming 1.7.2 - incubating, prove consistent high - quality delivery. Available binary, source, and Docker distributions widen its usability.
HertzBeat strictly follows "The Apache Way", has a clear contributor - to - committer process, and integrates well with other ASF projects. It's fully compliant and ready to stand alone.
Thanks to mentors, Committers, PPMC members, and contributors. I'm confident HertzBeat is ready for this milestone and will offer my support.
Best regards,
Xiaobao!
---------------------------------------------------------------------
To unsubscribe, e-mail: dev-unsubscribe@hertzbeat.apache.org
For additional commands, e-mail: dev-help@hertzbeat.apache.org
Re: [DISCUSS] Graduate Apache HertzBeat (Incubating) from the Apache Incubator to a Top-Level Project
Posted by Qiwei Zheng <zh...@apache.org>.
Dear Tom and Hertzbeat Community,
As an Apache HertzBeat Committer, I completely support for its promotion to an Apache Top-Level Project (TLP). Apache HertzBeat, our easy-to-use, open source, real-time monitoring system, has shown remarkable growth and maturity within the Apache Incubator.
It's ready for TLP status for these key reasons:
Strong Community & Active Development: HertzBeat boasts a vibrant, growing community and consistent progress With 271+ contributors, 9 committed committers, and 13 PPMC members. We have built a robust and diverse community.
Technical Maturity: The project is a stable, robust observability platform. We've integrated mature and widely used technology in it and its code robustness is growing steadily.
Adherence to "The Apache Way": We've fully embraced Apache's open, transparent, and meritocratic principles.
Promoting Apache HertzBeat as an Apache Top-Level Project (TLP) will give it the autonomy needed to thrive, attract more contributors, and solidify its place as a leading open-source monitoring solution.
Best regards,
Calvin
---------------------------------------------------------------------
To unsubscribe, e-mail: dev-unsubscribe@hertzbeat.apache.org
For additional commands, e-mail: dev-help@hertzbeat.apache.org