You are viewing a plain text version of this content. The canonical link for it is here.
Posted to dev@uima.apache.org by Marshall Schor <ms...@schor.com> on 2006/11/16 17:32:14 UTC

use of the term XCAS

XCAS is used as
a) the generic name for an externalized CAS
b) a specific format for the externalized CAS (not XMI).

In the documentation, should we use XCAS in the (a) sense, or substitute 
XMI-formatted-CAS (or another term?) for it?

-Marshall

Re: use of the term XCAS

Posted by Adam Lally <al...@alum.rpi.edu>.
> We should not use it in the a) sense, as there are and will continue to
> be other serialization forms (non-xml).
>
> If we drop the old XCAS format, I would suggest using the term XCAS to
> refer to the new XMI-style serialization -- or is that going to confuse
> long-time UIMA users?  If we decide not to use XCAS in that sense, then
> I would vote for eliminating the concept entirely.
>

Another comment I forgot to mention earlier:  we are not currently
using the term XCAS in the current draft of the OASIS specification,
instead using terms more like "the XMI representation of a CAS".

-Adam

Re: use of the term XCAS

Posted by Thilo Goetz <tw...@gmx.de>.
Marshall Schor wrote:
> XCAS is used as
> a) the generic name for an externalized CAS
> b) a specific format for the externalized CAS (not XMI).
> 
> In the documentation, should we use XCAS in the (a) sense, or substitute 
> XMI-formatted-CAS (or another term?) for it?
> 
> -Marshall

We should not use it in the a) sense, as there are and will continue to 
be other serialization forms (non-xml).

If we drop the old XCAS format, I would suggest using the term XCAS to 
refer to the new XMI-style serialization -- or is that going to confuse 
long-time UIMA users?  If we decide not to use XCAS in that sense, then 
I would vote for eliminating the concept entirely.

--Thilo

Re: use of the term XCAS

Posted by Adam Lally <al...@alum.rpi.edu>.
On 11/16/06, Marshall Schor <ms...@schor.com> wrote:
> XCAS is used as
> a) the generic name for an externalized CAS
> b) a specific format for the externalized CAS (not XMI).
>
> In the documentation, should we use XCAS in the (a) sense, or substitute
> XMI-formatted-CAS (or another term?) for it?

I have generally used the term "XMI CAS" rather than XCAS, when
referring to the XMI version, but I don't feel too strongly about it.
Certainly this helps avoid confusion as long as the "old XCAS" format
is still around.

Dave Ferrucci is an advocate of saying something like "XMI is the new
format for XCAS", which is similar to your option (a), except I would
say "an XML CAS" rather than an "externalized CAS" since we never use
XCAS to refer to a binary serialization of the CAS.

-Adam