You are viewing a plain text version of this content. The canonical link for it is here.
Posted to general@incubator.apache.org by "Noel J. Bergman" <no...@devtech.com> on 2006/02/21 21:18:20 UTC

Account requests for Incubator projects

Infrastructure,

All projects in the Incubator are managed by the Incubator PMC.  All Mentors
are Incubator PMC members (see committee info if in doubt).

Requests for infrastructure and accounts should be coming from those
Mentors, and should be cc'd to the Incubator PMC, so that it can maintain
oversight.

	--- Noel


---------------------------------------------------------------------
To unsubscribe, e-mail: general-unsubscribe@incubator.apache.org
For additional commands, e-mail: general-help@incubator.apache.org


Re: Account requests for Incubator projects

Posted by robert burrell donkin <ro...@gmail.com>.
On 2/23/06, Geir Magnusson Jr <ge...@pobox.com> wrote:
>
> Why not just modify incubator procedure to make it clear that
>
> 1) Mentors make the requests and
>
> 2) They sign the email w/ the title "$PODLING_NAME Mentor"


+1

Now #2 don't prevent someone from misrepresenting themselves - which
> would have to be dealt with - but rather it allows us to not act on but
> simply reply back to those that ask for accounts w/o representing
> themselves as mentors...


the copy to the incubator pmc should allow oversight for this case

- robert

Re: Account requests for Incubator projects

Posted by Don Brown <mr...@apache.org>.
We could also add to the request email a link to the podling's Status page, since that page will list the mentors and is 
only writable by a PMC member.

Don

Geir Magnusson Jr wrote:
> Why not just modify incubator procedure to make it clear that
> 
> 1) Mentors make the requests and
> 
> 2) They sign the email w/ the title "$PODLING_NAME Mentor"
> 
> Now #2 don't prevent someone from misrepresenting themselves - which 
> would have to be dealt with - but rather it allows us to not act on but 
> simply reply back to those that ask for accounts w/o representing 
> themselves as mentors...
> 
> geir
> 
> 
> Erik Abele wrote:
>> On 21.02.2006, at 21:18, Noel J. Bergman wrote:
>>
>>> Infrastructure,
>>>
>>> All projects in the Incubator are managed by the Incubator PMC.  All 
>>> Mentors
>>> are Incubator PMC members (see committee info if in doubt).
>>>
>>> Requests for infrastructure and accounts should be coming from those
>>> Mentors, and should be cc'd to the Incubator PMC, so that it can 
>>> maintain
>>> oversight.
>>
>> Hmm, while this makes sense it also makes it very hard to recognize 
>> valid requestors. The Incubator PMC membership is not always a 
>> long-term relationship and so root@ (et al) will have to find out 
>> about new mentors in some easy way.
>>
>> For example there's this account request from Don Brown 
>> <mr...@apache.org> from today - it's not easily possible to find out 
>> if he is supposed to be in charge of that - there's nothing on the PMC 
>> list and there's just one vote thread covering the proposal on the 
>> public list, nothing else... so how are we supposed to find out if he 
>> is a mentor for some poddling?
>>
>> (And btw, I don't think it is efficient to dig mailing list archives 
>> on every incubator request but that's the only possibilty right now, 
>> the website isn't up2date in this regard.)
>>
>> Cheers,
>> Erik
>>
> 


---------------------------------------------------------------------
To unsubscribe, e-mail: general-unsubscribe@incubator.apache.org
For additional commands, e-mail: general-help@incubator.apache.org


Re: Account requests for Incubator projects

Posted by Upayavira <uv...@odoko.co.uk>.
Alan D. Cabrera wrote:
> On 2/23/2006 9:16 AM, Upayavira wrote:
> 
>> Niclas Hedhman wrote:
>>  
>>
>>> On Thursday 23 February 2006 15:46, Geir Magnusson Jr wrote:
>>>   
>>>> Why not just modify incubator procedure to make it clear that
>>>>
>>>> 1) Mentors make the requests and
>>>>
>>>> 2) They sign the email w/ the title "$PODLING_NAME Mentor"
>>>>
>>>> Now #2 don't prevent someone from misrepresenting themselves - which
>>>> would have to be dealt with - but rather it allows us to not act on but
>>>> simply reply back to those that ask for accounts w/o representing
>>>> themselves as mentors...
>>>>     
>>> Infra doesn't want emails with requests. They want JIRA issues for
>>> better tracking of progress et al.
>>>
>>> Make a list what the issue must contain, for instance;
>>>
>>> * Proper title according to some template.
>>> * URL to VOTE SUMMARY,
>>> * Name of Mentor
>>> * Incubator General and/or PMC mailing list as a subscriber, so that
>>> someone
>>>   can step in and hit the breaks if it wrong.
>>> * List of Resources.
>>>
>>> and whatever else the Infra people like to see...
>>>
>>> Then keep a template somewhere, which the Mentor copy/paste into the
>>> Jira issue, fills in and off we go :o)
>>>   
>>
>> No. Account requests should go by mail to root@. That's their preferred
>> route. Jira requests will likely be ignored.
>>  
>>
> 
> This strikes me as odd.  Jira can be setup so that only authorized
> people can post requests.  We can also create issue types that have the
> required data that needs to be suppiled.  It also allows us to track the
> outstanding requests.

I'm only repeating what has been said before. Not being root, I don't
know the exact justifications, other than perhaps a general loathing of
Jira.

Upayavira


---------------------------------------------------------------------
To unsubscribe, e-mail: general-unsubscribe@incubator.apache.org
For additional commands, e-mail: general-help@incubator.apache.org


Re: Account requests for Incubator projects

Posted by Leo Simons <ma...@leosimons.com>.
On Thu, Feb 23, 2006 at 09:20:34AM -0800, Alan D. Cabrera wrote:
> On 2/23/2006 9:16 AM, Upayavira wrote:
> >No. Account requests should go by mail to root@. That's their preferred
> >route. Jira requests will likely be ignored.
> 
> This strikes me as odd. 

*shrug*. There has previously been a lot of talk about infrastructure work
flow (really, years of it). I started out at some point to help build a
tool for handling these kinds of requests but it fell by the wayside since
there weren't enough people to help and I ran out of steam. Someone from
infrastructure first sent email about the kind of webapp needed to
committers@ a few years ago but no-one ever stepped up to the plate to build
it and finish it.

> Jira can be setup so that only authorized 
> people can post requests.  We can also create issue types that have the 
> required data that needs to be suppiled.  It also allows us to track the 
> outstanding requests.

Jira has been evaluated for handling this kind of stuff. We do use it for
mailing list requests but not for accounts. Security, accountability,
stability, traceability, shell-based workflow, etc etc. All this is
documented.

The right list for discussing this kind of stuff is infrastructure@a.o. In
any case, the people who do the work get to make these decisions, and they
say to use email :-)

- LSD


---------------------------------------------------------------------
To unsubscribe, e-mail: general-unsubscribe@incubator.apache.org
For additional commands, e-mail: general-help@incubator.apache.org


Re: Account requests for Incubator projects

Posted by "Alan D. Cabrera" <li...@toolazydogs.com>.
On 2/23/2006 9:16 AM, Upayavira wrote:

>Niclas Hedhman wrote:
>  
>
>>On Thursday 23 February 2006 15:46, Geir Magnusson Jr wrote:
>>    
>>
>>>Why not just modify incubator procedure to make it clear that
>>>
>>>1) Mentors make the requests and
>>>
>>>2) They sign the email w/ the title "$PODLING_NAME Mentor"
>>>
>>>Now #2 don't prevent someone from misrepresenting themselves - which
>>>would have to be dealt with - but rather it allows us to not act on but
>>>simply reply back to those that ask for accounts w/o representing
>>>themselves as mentors...
>>>      
>>>
>>Infra doesn't want emails with requests. They want JIRA issues for better 
>>tracking of progress et al.
>>
>>Make a list what the issue must contain, for instance;
>>
>> * Proper title according to some template.
>> * URL to VOTE SUMMARY,
>> * Name of Mentor
>> * Incubator General and/or PMC mailing list as a subscriber, so that someone
>>   can step in and hit the breaks if it wrong.
>> * List of Resources.
>>
>>and whatever else the Infra people like to see...
>>
>>Then keep a template somewhere, which the Mentor copy/paste into the Jira 
>>issue, fills in and off we go :o)
>>    
>>
>
>No. Account requests should go by mail to root@. That's their preferred
>route. Jira requests will likely be ignored.
>  
>

This strikes me as odd.  Jira can be setup so that only authorized 
people can post requests.  We can also create issue types that have the 
required data that needs to be suppiled.  It also allows us to track the 
outstanding requests.


Regards,
Alan



Re: Account requests for Incubator projects

Posted by Upayavira <uv...@odoko.co.uk>.
Niclas Hedhman wrote:
> On Thursday 23 February 2006 15:46, Geir Magnusson Jr wrote:
>> Why not just modify incubator procedure to make it clear that
>>
>> 1) Mentors make the requests and
>>
>> 2) They sign the email w/ the title "$PODLING_NAME Mentor"
>>
>> Now #2 don't prevent someone from misrepresenting themselves - which
>> would have to be dealt with - but rather it allows us to not act on but
>> simply reply back to those that ask for accounts w/o representing
>> themselves as mentors...
> 
> Infra doesn't want emails with requests. They want JIRA issues for better 
> tracking of progress et al.
> 
> Make a list what the issue must contain, for instance;
> 
>  * Proper title according to some template.
>  * URL to VOTE SUMMARY,
>  * Name of Mentor
>  * Incubator General and/or PMC mailing list as a subscriber, so that someone
>    can step in and hit the breaks if it wrong.
>  * List of Resources.
> 
> and whatever else the Infra people like to see...
> 
> Then keep a template somewhere, which the Mentor copy/paste into the Jira 
> issue, fills in and off we go :o)

No. Account requests should go by mail to root@. That's their preferred
route. Jira requests will likely be ignored.

Upayavira

---------------------------------------------------------------------
To unsubscribe, e-mail: general-unsubscribe@incubator.apache.org
For additional commands, e-mail: general-help@incubator.apache.org


Re: Account requests for Incubator projects

Posted by Niclas Hedhman <ni...@hedhman.org>.
On Thursday 23 February 2006 15:46, Geir Magnusson Jr wrote:
> Why not just modify incubator procedure to make it clear that
>
> 1) Mentors make the requests and
>
> 2) They sign the email w/ the title "$PODLING_NAME Mentor"
>
> Now #2 don't prevent someone from misrepresenting themselves - which
> would have to be dealt with - but rather it allows us to not act on but
> simply reply back to those that ask for accounts w/o representing
> themselves as mentors...

Infra doesn't want emails with requests. They want JIRA issues for better 
tracking of progress et al.

Make a list what the issue must contain, for instance;

 * Proper title according to some template.
 * URL to VOTE SUMMARY,
 * Name of Mentor
 * Incubator General and/or PMC mailing list as a subscriber, so that someone
   can step in and hit the breaks if it wrong.
 * List of Resources.

and whatever else the Infra people like to see...

Then keep a template somewhere, which the Mentor copy/paste into the Jira 
issue, fills in and off we go :o)


Cheers
Niclas

---------------------------------------------------------------------
To unsubscribe, e-mail: general-unsubscribe@incubator.apache.org
For additional commands, e-mail: general-help@incubator.apache.org


Re: Account requests for Incubator projects

Posted by Geir Magnusson Jr <ge...@pobox.com>.
Why not just modify incubator procedure to make it clear that

1) Mentors make the requests and

2) They sign the email w/ the title "$PODLING_NAME Mentor"

Now #2 don't prevent someone from misrepresenting themselves - which 
would have to be dealt with - but rather it allows us to not act on but 
simply reply back to those that ask for accounts w/o representing 
themselves as mentors...

geir


Erik Abele wrote:
> On 21.02.2006, at 21:18, Noel J. Bergman wrote:
> 
>> Infrastructure,
>>
>> All projects in the Incubator are managed by the Incubator PMC.  All 
>> Mentors
>> are Incubator PMC members (see committee info if in doubt).
>>
>> Requests for infrastructure and accounts should be coming from those
>> Mentors, and should be cc'd to the Incubator PMC, so that it can maintain
>> oversight.
> 
> Hmm, while this makes sense it also makes it very hard to recognize 
> valid requestors. The Incubator PMC membership is not always a long-term 
> relationship and so root@ (et al) will have to find out about new 
> mentors in some easy way.
> 
> For example there's this account request from Don Brown 
> <mr...@apache.org> from today - it's not easily possible to find out if 
> he is supposed to be in charge of that - there's nothing on the PMC list 
> and there's just one vote thread covering the proposal on the public 
> list, nothing else... so how are we supposed to find out if he is a 
> mentor for some poddling?
> 
> (And btw, I don't think it is efficient to dig mailing list archives on 
> every incubator request but that's the only possibilty right now, the 
> website isn't up2date in this regard.)
> 
> Cheers,
> Erik
> 

---------------------------------------------------------------------
To unsubscribe, e-mail: general-unsubscribe@incubator.apache.org
For additional commands, e-mail: general-help@incubator.apache.org


Re: Account requests for Incubator projects

Posted by Erik Abele <er...@codefaktor.de>.
On 21.02.2006, at 21:18, Noel J. Bergman wrote:

> Infrastructure,
>
> All projects in the Incubator are managed by the Incubator PMC.   
> All Mentors
> are Incubator PMC members (see committee info if in doubt).
>
> Requests for infrastructure and accounts should be coming from those
> Mentors, and should be cc'd to the Incubator PMC, so that it can  
> maintain
> oversight.

Hmm, while this makes sense it also makes it very hard to recognize  
valid requestors. The Incubator PMC membership is not always a long- 
term relationship and so root@ (et al) will have to find out about  
new mentors in some easy way.

For example there's this account request from Don Brown  
<mr...@apache.org> from today - it's not easily possible to find out  
if he is supposed to be in charge of that - there's nothing on the  
PMC list and there's just one vote thread covering the proposal on  
the public list, nothing else... so how are we supposed to find out  
if he is a mentor for some poddling?

(And btw, I don't think it is efficient to dig mailing list archives  
on every incubator request but that's the only possibilty right now,  
the website isn't up2date in this regard.)

Cheers,
Erik